Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wtf do we do? Forced to private educate DS (4)

234 replies

Thehonestbadger · 26/01/2024 05:48

DS is quite significantly disabled (ASD/PICA) he’s very well documented with lots of expert evidence and a strong EHCP and has been at a private nursery for over a year doing well with a 1:1.

Due to go to school this September but not legal school age till Easter/25 as that’s when he turns 5. I absoloutley cannot cope with him at home, I’m chronically unwell myself and had an actual breakdown before we found his current nursery. He’s lovely, but extremely hard work and the physical care is a lot and I also have a 2yo DD to consider.

Essentially every mainstream school we’ve consulted has now turned us down citing they cannot meet his need. Council say no recourse aren’t willing to work with schools RE funding…etc
All the specialist schools we consulted said no, some lower level said he was too high needs, higher level said not high needs enough and there’s over 100 kids for each space as is. We’ve been told he’ll be handed to some specialist team who can dump him anywhere in the region and won’t take our opinions/input into consideration and if we don’t like it we have to fight them legally (could be several hours away, could not place him at all as there’s no spaces anywhere)

At the moment our only option who might admit him is the local private school (a lot comes down to spaces they can offer/layout/staff ratio…etc) which our council worker is very ‘pro’ (their suggestion actually) and tbh everyone I’ve mentioned it to is adamant we should do as it’s ‘clearly the best option’ but WE CANNOT AFFORD IT! Council will pay for his 1:1 but not toward fees! It would be very tight and I would feel awful about sending DS but not DD and logistically wouldn’t be able to get them to two separate schools. We wouldn’t have gone private if DS weren’t disabled but it feels like we have no other option.

Ive invested so much time and energy over the last 2 years and I just want to cry now.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
myphoneisbroken · 26/01/2024 10:44

I don't have anything useful to add but just wanted to say how sorry I am that you are having to cope with this. It's absolutely heartbreaking.

Workworkandmoreworknow · 26/01/2024 10:40

Contact your MP. Make him/her aware of what is going on in his/her constituency and how it is affecting the people he/she represents. Demand education is properly funded and SEN children receive what they are entitled to without a fight. We have an election coming up - you and your child really matter.

WithoutACherryOnTheTop · 26/01/2024 10:39

If he's an Easter baby and so won't be CSA (compulsory school age) until the summer term you could seek to defer his entry to Reception until the September after he has turned 5. There's a Facebook group called Flexible Admission for Summer Borns. You should be able to find help and advice there. Good luck!

Zonder · 26/01/2024 10:32

The LA have to provide a place. Schools can be directed by the LA to take him and make his reasonable adjustments. If they can't provide a place they have to pay to cover private fees.

Trulyme · 26/01/2024 10:28

If you can’t afford it, then how will you pay for it?

Are you sure the private school is able to cope with his needs?

If you can find the money then perhaps try it for a year or 2, just to take some pressure off of you.

It may be that you use the next year or 2 to find a different setting for him or if he’s coping well, using the time to figure out how to pay his fees for the foreseeable and perhaps DDs too.

Some private schools have scholarships etc which may be useful for DD but I think you have enough to deal with right now.

So I would try and get DS into the private school for now and then go from there.

x2boys · 26/01/2024 10:24

The LEA is obliged to.find a school.that can meet your child s needs and fund it too.if necessary you need proper advice about this have you contacted the Sen Independent advisory service in your area ?

Updownleftandright · 26/01/2024 10:23

VerbenaGirl · 26/01/2024 09:31

The situation with SEND is really dire at the moment - our LA was rated inadequate in a recent inspection. I did read this today though: https://schoolsweek.co.uk/send-shoots-up-political-agenda-as-mps-reveal-woes/ - might be worth seeing if you can get your local MP engaged with this?

BCP LA?

SpeedyDrama · 26/01/2024 10:16

bryceQ · 26/01/2024 10:02

I'm not sure I really understand this, if he is very disabled by his autism, how is he going to cope in mainstream? He will require a tremendous amount of adjustments that I just can't imagine a private school could make. My son has pica too and he needs a constant 1:1 to stop him eating soil. Can you afford to speak to a sen solicitor? It feels like the local authority are leaving you very few options

Unfortunately this is the situation facing many autistic children and their parents. My own son is cognitively delayed with behaviour difficulties, he doesn’t meet the threshold for full SEN school at the moment. He could go to a mainstream primary with a SEN base but most of those focus on eventual full integration. That may be ok for children without GDD/LD but it’s simply political game playing with children who will need lifelong support for high needs. You have to put them in an unsustainable situation until either the LA crack and find them a suitable placement or you crack and homeschool (because some mainstream will usually try and reduce the timetable until you feel you have no choice).

At least an EHCP forces the hand of the LA to meet the child’s needs at mainstream, or at least to some degree. The higher the funding band, the more money the school can invest into additional sen provisions.

Fionaville · 26/01/2024 10:03

I wouldn't send him to the private school. It's really not a good idea to put a child into a school that they probably aren't going to flourish in, in the hope that they'll sink or swim. It could lead to all sorts of school related trauma and school refusal down the line. There are tens of thousands of people with SEN children at home, who can't go to school now, because they've had such a bad time in schools that have been unable to meet their needs.
You've gotten this far with the battle, I'd push on and refuse to pay.

bryceQ · 26/01/2024 10:02

I'm not sure I really understand this, if he is very disabled by his autism, how is he going to cope in mainstream? He will require a tremendous amount of adjustments that I just can't imagine a private school could make. My son has pica too and he needs a constant 1:1 to stop him eating soil. Can you afford to speak to a sen solicitor? It feels like the local authority are leaving you very few options

TeacupKitty · 26/01/2024 09:59

If the low needs special school says he is too high needs for them, then how on earth would he cope in a mainstream school even if it’s private?

GintyMcGinty · 26/01/2024 09:53

If you are in England get on to your MP about this.

Devonshiregal · 26/01/2024 09:52

This is probably the most useless suggestion but could you (until you find a suitable school) keep him at nursery - some round here keep kids longer if they’re not ready for school. and hopefully in the meantime a space would come up for him?

or some home schooling? Forest school where you aren’t actively involved so could get some mental rest? Or instead of spending on private a tutor but only a few days a week to save money but so the time you have alone is actually restorative rather than school runs etc? Again sorry probably just annoying ‘advice’ when it’s likely not workable.

but don’t agree to pay for private if you can’t whatever you do or you’ll be stuck forever.

also don’t feel bad re not sending your daughter if he does go private - he’s going to struggle because of his needs in a way she hopefully won’t. So it’s two different circumstances and if that’s what helps him that’s fine.

but on a side note, as others have mentioned, please be careful with private schools. Their marketing comes first so while they might look good on paper reality can be very different. And unless they have a good special needs departments where kids have differing levels of needs (ie more than needing a bit of help with reading or maths) I would agree with a pp that they are far less tolerant than state schools - remember they have parents paying them thousands to send their kids there and the school has to deal with their expectations. If someone is disruptive or whatever, they’re going to have a hard time convincing another kid’s parents that they should put up with their kid’s learning being impacted when they’re paying a tonne of money precisely to avoid things like disruptive behaviour.

zurala · 26/01/2024 09:51

Look into EOTAS, it's another option where the local authority pays for provision that you buy in, like tutors.

Ellie56 · 26/01/2024 09:50

Legoroses · 26/01/2024 07:12

None of their new bullshit process is lawful - all the legal obligations around provision in the ehcp still stand. Why aren't you naming the indie if that's what you want? You're in a v strong position if all other schools have said they can't meet need.

I agree entirely. If your child has an EHCP you shouldn't be paying. If the state schools are all saying they can't meet need, then name the private school as your chosen school.

Clearinguptheclutter · 26/01/2024 09:50

CurlsLDN · 26/01/2024 06:28

I don’t know what the answer is, but please don’t feel guilty about sending your son to private school and not your daughter. Fair isn’t everyone getting the same thing, fair is everyone getting what they need

this, definitely.
(but it doesn't mean that the private school is worth paying for - needs further investigation)

Sorry you find yourself in this position. There definitely are some private schools that deal brilliantly with specific needs. Even if it is, it's awful that no arrangement via the council can be made. It could save them money in the long term.

HerculesMulligan · 26/01/2024 09:41

OP, can I recommend that you spend a little money on talking to Adam Friel at Geldards solicitors? I went to a seminar he ran about a month ago and was extremely impressed (I'm a lawyer but of a different discipline). He also has some personal experience with the system and I am sure we'll be using him at some point fairly soon, to sort out provision for my autistic 9yo.

Jigglypuff87 · 26/01/2024 09:40

Legally the la have to find a suitable placement and pay for it. Much that you have been told is totally unlawful. Have you looked at independent specials schools? You are going to have to find a suitable school yourself that will take him and if they won't name it in section I you'll have to go to tribunal. Is it fair absolutely not! Unfortunately that's how us parents with special needs children are treated. If they can't find a school they still have to pay for and provide the provision is section F, whether that's at school, via a personal budget or Eatos.

Merryhobnobs · 26/01/2024 09:39

This is such a horrible situation and so wrong that a child's education is being completely undervalued by the authority (which I know will be down to a lack of money by the government).

My experiences have been that the private schools I know of are very academically focused and do not have the infrastructure or methods to cope with children with additional needs.

Have you written to your MP? Kick up a fuss. It's exhausting and it shouldn't be on you to do it.

VerbenaGirl · 26/01/2024 09:31

The situation with SEND is really dire at the moment - our LA was rated inadequate in a recent inspection. I did read this today though: https://schoolsweek.co.uk/send-shoots-up-political-agenda-as-mps-reveal-woes/ - might be worth seeing if you can get your local MP engaged with this?

SEND shoots up political agenda as MPs reveal woes

Dozens of MPs spoke of local problems with the special needs system

https://schoolsweek.co.uk/send-shoots-up-political-agenda-as-mps-reveal-woes

New2024 · 26/01/2024 09:22

HalfasleepChrisintheMorning · 26/01/2024 06:10

Don’t send him privately. School will talk the talk initially to get him in but with SEN like this, state is by far more able to meet needs.
Definitely don’t commit to school fees you can’t afford.

Council have to find a suitable school that will meet his needs for full time education from September.

Agree that unless it’s a specialist SEN school, you will probably find that they won’t offer the best support and may just change their minds about having him there. You could be paying for misery.

I’m so sorry you are having a tricky time with this

OwlWeiwei · 26/01/2024 09:21

What @Penguinfeetteal said. I'm pretty sure the council is legally obliged to find suitable schooling for him. (Thought he friend I know who had the exact same issue was an adoptive parent so they may have a higher duty of care to looked after children.) But I think if the only place they can find is private then they must pay the fees. Do some research on their legal obligation to you and be prepared to fight hard. My friend fought and fought and fought and would not back down to get her son the schooling he needed. The council had to cover it but they tried every trick in the book to get out of paying.

People who haven't been in your position might well tut at this, but given your breakdown and his needs, I would cut to the chase and threaten the council that you cannot cope, have medical evidence of your breakdown to support this and you are seriously considering having to have him fostered. (I know how shocking this sounds, but it might make them suddenly find the funds for his schooling because it will be cheaper than fostering and schooling which they'd be obliged to find if he became a looked-after child.)

Please bear in mind that unless they are specific SEN schools, private schools might be quick to expel him if his behaviour disturbs other pupils as they don't want other parents withdrawing their children. Fee-paying parents have very high expectations of class control and learning environment. The best bet would be for you and the council to continue to seek a suitable school (and transport btw, which they are also obliged to help with if the school is not within reasonable distance of your home).

Tracker1234 · 26/01/2024 09:21

I too am very surprised that a private school claims to be able to take your son.

He sounds like he needs significant support which if they have a small SEN team really wont be able to do. Both my children went to private boarding schools. A few SEN pupils did attend over the years but only seemed to attend for a term and then disappeared. I honestly dont know why the school pretended to be able to take them. It certainly didnt seem to position itself as one that could offer suitable support. A friend of mine had her son in a good private school and even paid for the 1-1. However she downplayed the extent of her sons needs to get him in and it ended in complete disaster. Also, I am afraid to say other parents complained about her son's behaviour and the fact that he was taking up far too much of the teacher's time.

We did speak about it before she decided to go down this route but she naively thought it would all sort itself out.

tara66 · 26/01/2024 09:19

Not read many PPs and do not have any experience but wanted to tell you I saw a ''feature'' on SKY news a few months ago about 2 ''disabled '' children -they were autistic who went to special state school some distance away and had daily taxi transport that was paid for by their council which cost £17.000 a year. They seemed very happy with this arrangement. Maybe you could have this sort of help?

Doireallyhavetopeopletoday · 26/01/2024 09:18

As parents we always have guilt but OP in Thais case I would happily put ds to private and not Dd. There is no comparison as you have limited choices and the outcome won’t be the same for both children.
Having support and stability for the family will help you and in turn will help your Dd too

If this is really your last option the. I would go with it .
I don’t have any other help regarding resources as like everything else in the UK now they are stretched and at breaking point.

Best of luck