Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wtf do we do? Forced to private educate DS (4)

234 replies

Thehonestbadger · 26/01/2024 05:48

DS is quite significantly disabled (ASD/PICA) he’s very well documented with lots of expert evidence and a strong EHCP and has been at a private nursery for over a year doing well with a 1:1.

Due to go to school this September but not legal school age till Easter/25 as that’s when he turns 5. I absoloutley cannot cope with him at home, I’m chronically unwell myself and had an actual breakdown before we found his current nursery. He’s lovely, but extremely hard work and the physical care is a lot and I also have a 2yo DD to consider.

Essentially every mainstream school we’ve consulted has now turned us down citing they cannot meet his need. Council say no recourse aren’t willing to work with schools RE funding…etc
All the specialist schools we consulted said no, some lower level said he was too high needs, higher level said not high needs enough and there’s over 100 kids for each space as is. We’ve been told he’ll be handed to some specialist team who can dump him anywhere in the region and won’t take our opinions/input into consideration and if we don’t like it we have to fight them legally (could be several hours away, could not place him at all as there’s no spaces anywhere)

At the moment our only option who might admit him is the local private school (a lot comes down to spaces they can offer/layout/staff ratio…etc) which our council worker is very ‘pro’ (their suggestion actually) and tbh everyone I’ve mentioned it to is adamant we should do as it’s ‘clearly the best option’ but WE CANNOT AFFORD IT! Council will pay for his 1:1 but not toward fees! It would be very tight and I would feel awful about sending DS but not DD and logistically wouldn’t be able to get them to two separate schools. We wouldn’t have gone private if DS weren’t disabled but it feels like we have no other option.

Ive invested so much time and energy over the last 2 years and I just want to cry now.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Needmoresleep · 26/01/2024 13:48

Felicia, I have read the whole thread and am pretty sure the private school think they can do something for this child.

A lot of SEN children end up in the private sector and many do very well. Smaller classes, often easier discipline and a calmer environment. Better sports and other facilities. In our experience school don't take kids if they don't think that child will settle/stay.

Sdpbody · 26/01/2024 13:46

prh47bridge · 26/01/2024 13:29

I have not read the whole thread.

Your son has an EHCP. You can therefore choose what school should be named. There are only limited grounds under which they can refuse to name your chosen school. If the local private school is named, the council must pay all his school fees. They cannot just pay for 1:1 support and leave you to pay the fees. The law requires them to pay his fees.

Tell them that you want to name the local private school and stick to your guns.

You can't just choose a private school, and then say "Now you have to pay my school fees".

You cannot possibly think that is how it works.

Felicia19 · 26/01/2024 13:43

prh47bridge · 26/01/2024 13:29

I have not read the whole thread.

Your son has an EHCP. You can therefore choose what school should be named. There are only limited grounds under which they can refuse to name your chosen school. If the local private school is named, the council must pay all his school fees. They cannot just pay for 1:1 support and leave you to pay the fees. The law requires them to pay his fees.

Tell them that you want to name the local private school and stick to your guns.

Have you not read the posts which say that the local private school is under no obligation to accept the child? The local authority cannot force this.

There is also the fact that most private schools are prep schools - they prepare children for the exams they need to enter the private secondaries. They are usually very focused on high academic standards, and they don't usually have provision for sen children.

The state system, even though it isn't functioning as it should in this respect, is better equipped to deal with sen issues than the private system.

Soontobe60 · 26/01/2024 13:36

In my local authority, any children applying for admission to Reception / Year 7 who have EHCPs already are asked to have an early Annual Review where the choice of schools are made. We have 3 children in reception whose nurseries did this. we have 4 in Year 6 who’s ARs I held in October and all parents selected Special schools. The school choices were named at the review and those schools were put on the application forms.
All applications which name special schools are taken to panel before notifying the admissions team. Where a child with an EHCP has put down a mainstream school choice, those schools are consulted with to see if they can meet the child’s needs.
The protocol isn’t for schools to tell parents that they can / cannot meet a child’s needs.

OP, what did you put on your DCs Reception admissions application form?

prh47bridge · 26/01/2024 13:29

I have not read the whole thread.

Your son has an EHCP. You can therefore choose what school should be named. There are only limited grounds under which they can refuse to name your chosen school. If the local private school is named, the council must pay all his school fees. They cannot just pay for 1:1 support and leave you to pay the fees. The law requires them to pay his fees.

Tell them that you want to name the local private school and stick to your guns.

Felicia19 · 26/01/2024 13:07

Sdpbody · 26/01/2024 12:54

A lot of people on here are assuming the local private school would accept this child. Private schools are notoriously selective.

One boy in my child's year 1 class was asked to leave (he had been given lots of chances) as 6 parents threatened to move schools if this boy was not expelled. The school have now implemented a 3 taster session minimum plus an assessment with the head of Pre-Prep. It gives them multiple chances to not accept children.

This. It can be difficult for some children to get into a private school. There will be some kind of assessment, and the school can choose to either accept or reject an application. It isn't simply a matter of paying the fees.
Private schools are businesses and the local authority has no influence to make them accept a child.

Sdpbody · 26/01/2024 12:54

A lot of people on here are assuming the local private school would accept this child. Private schools are notoriously selective.

One boy in my child's year 1 class was asked to leave (he had been given lots of chances) as 6 parents threatened to move schools if this boy was not expelled. The school have now implemented a 3 taster session minimum plus an assessment with the head of Pre-Prep. It gives them multiple chances to not accept children.

Fraaahnces · 26/01/2024 12:34

Contact your newspapers and your MP. Explain where this leaves you and your child. It is bonkers to believe that you should be financially penalized even MORE for having a child with special needs.

coatonthewashingline · 26/01/2024 12:33

You’ll win a tribunal. It’ll be horrible but you will win - 97% of times parents win in full or part.

loads of useful advice here: https://www.specialneedsjungle.com/

If a private school can meet needs and nowhere else can, then the LA will have to pay.

Special Needs Jungle

Special Needs Jungle provides parent-centred information, news, resources and informed opinion about SEN, disability, children's health and SEN politics

https://www.specialneedsjungle.com/

Jaxhog · 26/01/2024 12:28

Does the private school have any kind of bursary scheme? It might not pay all your fees, but it might be enough to make it feasible.

BusyMummyWrites01 · 26/01/2024 12:24

if you have an EHCP I think the LEA is required to ensure provision, aren’t they? This can involve they paying the fees at a private school or giving the funds to a state school to support your son. I would contact one of the organisations above and find a solicitor/advocate to help you through this process.

A school local to me specialises in Boys with SEN - from dyslexia to ASD, ADHD to sensory issues. Mixed academic ability. It’s a large school of over 500 now and at least 50% are funded by the LEA. One of the organisations above should be able to flag ideal schools in your area with a good reputation for support, making the search easier for you.

lookwhatyoudidthere · 26/01/2024 12:15

Thehonestbadger · 26/01/2024 05:48

DS is quite significantly disabled (ASD/PICA) he’s very well documented with lots of expert evidence and a strong EHCP and has been at a private nursery for over a year doing well with a 1:1.

Due to go to school this September but not legal school age till Easter/25 as that’s when he turns 5. I absoloutley cannot cope with him at home, I’m chronically unwell myself and had an actual breakdown before we found his current nursery. He’s lovely, but extremely hard work and the physical care is a lot and I also have a 2yo DD to consider.

Essentially every mainstream school we’ve consulted has now turned us down citing they cannot meet his need. Council say no recourse aren’t willing to work with schools RE funding…etc
All the specialist schools we consulted said no, some lower level said he was too high needs, higher level said not high needs enough and there’s over 100 kids for each space as is. We’ve been told he’ll be handed to some specialist team who can dump him anywhere in the region and won’t take our opinions/input into consideration and if we don’t like it we have to fight them legally (could be several hours away, could not place him at all as there’s no spaces anywhere)

At the moment our only option who might admit him is the local private school (a lot comes down to spaces they can offer/layout/staff ratio…etc) which our council worker is very ‘pro’ (their suggestion actually) and tbh everyone I’ve mentioned it to is adamant we should do as it’s ‘clearly the best option’ but WE CANNOT AFFORD IT! Council will pay for his 1:1 but not toward fees! It would be very tight and I would feel awful about sending DS but not DD and logistically wouldn’t be able to get them to two separate schools. We wouldn’t have gone private if DS weren’t disabled but it feels like we have no other option.

Ive invested so much time and energy over the last 2 years and I just want to cry now.

Did you know that if there is a preschool attached to the private school and you child doesn't turn five until '25, you would be able to apply you 30 hours free to the private school fees - until the end of term in which the birthday appears? We were absolutely gobsmacked when we were given the first term almost free, because they take it from the date the school year starts, so if your child turns 5 years old, 3 days after term starts, the hours can be applied to the rest of the term. Not a magic solution or answer to the long-term burden that is school fees.

VerbenaGirl · 26/01/2024 12:05

Updownleftandright · 26/01/2024 10:23

BCP LA?

No - looks like there might be a few LAs now rated like this :-(

Needmoresleep · 26/01/2024 12:04

I thought I would try and summon the experts. @admission and @prh47bridge

In terms of paying for one not the other, children are very different. Its about addressing each one's need, not about paying equal amounts. One day you might be contributing to your DD's Universities fees. Hopefully DS' as well, obviously but hopefully you get my point. Or helping pay for a wedding for one, but not the other.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 26/01/2024 11:52

Speak to the National Autistic Society education rights service and they will be able to advise on whether the council can pay the fees. I am in Scotland so don’t want to give wrong advice.

SummitOfMountWashmore · 26/01/2024 11:32

AnneValentine · 26/01/2024 07:37

There is a massive shortage of Sen placements. Don’t assume there is somewhere.

It's not a lawful reason for the LA not to facilitate it though. When we were going through this process we were told of 2 specialist schools we could look at. LA maintained, the cheapest option for them after mainstream. Neither were appropriate and we're currently going through court to appeal for a place at an independent specialist school. For the LA it's all about money, they're fighting us on this due to the cost despite it being the only school in the county that is appropriate.

95% (I think that may recently have gone up to 98%) of tribunals rule in favour of the child/parent.

Sdpbody · 26/01/2024 11:11

I would be hugely surprised if you were accepted to the local private school.

Grimbelina · 26/01/2024 10:58

Will also add that - as another PP says - the wrong setting could lead to school trauma and then you can end up with a child who can't go to any school, ever, at all. We are in this situation and my health condition is consequently taking a downturn due to the unrelenting stress and having no chance to rest etc.

BettyBakesCakes · 26/01/2024 10:57

I never use my local sendiass they're as helpful as a chocolate teapot.

Assume everything the LA tells you is a lie.

Phineyj · 26/01/2024 10:57

I put in a refuse to issue appeal in November 23 and was given a tribunal date in early Sept 24 so 9 month wait. I then did a SEND7 form to ask for an.earlier date as DD starts year 7 in Sept 24. They've given me June 24 and it could be earlier if it's done "on the papers" (e.g. they just look at evidence). So the tribunal wait could be 6 or 7 months for a change of phase (which yours is too). So basically the tribunal can rule well before your child turns 5 with luck. The tribunal are clear (if bureaucratic) in their communications and seem fair. Parents win well over 90% of appeals.

Don't despair.

I was recommended Talking SENse as an advocate. Much cheaper than a solicitor.

BettyBakesCakes · 26/01/2024 10:56

Your LA are talking bollucks. They have to work with you they MUST provide suitable full time education under section 19 of the education act 1996. If a school can't be found they will have to provide education other than at school which should be full time.

Unfortunately OP you will have to appeal, it's like it's just part of the process unfortunately because LAs are so horrific when it comes to send.

Schools can't deny space because 'they're full' they must evidence to tribunal why taking your child would cause the inefficient education of others.

If theres no education space come Sep you can get a solicitor to issue a pre action letter to the council (if you are entitled to legal aid this may be funded). This usually shifts them sharpish.

Unfortunately tribunal is often the only way to get a suitable space for a Sen child. If the local independent school is the only place that can meets and are willing to offer a space, as said above the LA should fund it and you can go to tribunal for this.

They will run rings around you until you start tribunal/legal action. It's what they do in the hope you shuffle off and they save ££££

Get on Ipsea, sossen, coram child law education advice sites and they all have helplines. Use them.

Grimbelina · 26/01/2024 10:56

Don’t send him privately. School will talk the talk initially to get him in but with SEN like this, state is by far more able to meet needs.

I was also going to say this and also have experience of being chronically ill and this being impacted by having my child at home.

It will get harder and harder to get a more suitable SEN placement as your DC ages as all the places fill up in the early years. You are saying the private school might work for 2-3 years (might not...) but you could then find yourself in a worse position and it could be very upsetting for him.

You need support and need to work hard with SENDIASS, IPSEA etc. join all the amazing Facebook groups supporting children trying to get EHCPs and the right settings etc. and find a good advocate (if you can afford it) to help you navigate this (especially if you have limited energy etc.). You really need to become an expert on the law around this (very sadly).

Time and money spent now getting him in the right setting (which might not be nearby) will both be well spent.

kitsuneghost · 26/01/2024 10:55

The issue is - if you send him to private school would the council then take it as he is sorted and take him off the council school list?

Timeisallwehave · 26/01/2024 10:46

I would highly recommend you do not send your SEN child with high need to private school.

If you can, go find a SEND solicitor who will explain the process. The local authority often do this. We had the same exact scenario, in the end we found a school and a nursery agreed to educate my daughter for a year. She started school age five instead and they pay for everything. Her placement is really expensive for them, we had to put in a lot of money initially legally but haven’t had to do anything since.

Ilovechocolatelimesandsherbertlemons · 26/01/2024 10:45

The local authority have a statutory duty to meet his needs, provide schooling and find an appropriate school. It shouldn't be up to you, although obv you have the final say. The problem with mainstream schools is that they are already underresourced and generally unsupported by the LA, who have no money either. I wouldn't recommend a private school unless it is for special needs, they're unlikely to cope. If the LA can't provide state education, then they may have to fund the private.

https://www.gov.uk/courts-tribunals/first-tier-tribunal-special-educational-needs-and-disability

You could try going to tribunal. Have a look at this page, the government explains what it is for.

Also agree about going to your MP or local Borough Councillor. I do have experience of this, was a SEND specialist and have disabled son myself.

First-tier Tribunal (Special Educational Needs and Disability)

We’re responsible for handling appeals against local authority decisions regarding special educational needs, including a refusal to: assess a child or young person’s educational, health and care (EHC) needs reassess their EHC needs issue an EHC plan c...

https://www.gov.uk/courts-tribunals/first-tier-tribunal-special-educational-needs-and-disability