Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wtf do we do? Forced to private educate DS (4)

234 replies

Thehonestbadger · 26/01/2024 05:48

DS is quite significantly disabled (ASD/PICA) he’s very well documented with lots of expert evidence and a strong EHCP and has been at a private nursery for over a year doing well with a 1:1.

Due to go to school this September but not legal school age till Easter/25 as that’s when he turns 5. I absoloutley cannot cope with him at home, I’m chronically unwell myself and had an actual breakdown before we found his current nursery. He’s lovely, but extremely hard work and the physical care is a lot and I also have a 2yo DD to consider.

Essentially every mainstream school we’ve consulted has now turned us down citing they cannot meet his need. Council say no recourse aren’t willing to work with schools RE funding…etc
All the specialist schools we consulted said no, some lower level said he was too high needs, higher level said not high needs enough and there’s over 100 kids for each space as is. We’ve been told he’ll be handed to some specialist team who can dump him anywhere in the region and won’t take our opinions/input into consideration and if we don’t like it we have to fight them legally (could be several hours away, could not place him at all as there’s no spaces anywhere)

At the moment our only option who might admit him is the local private school (a lot comes down to spaces they can offer/layout/staff ratio…etc) which our council worker is very ‘pro’ (their suggestion actually) and tbh everyone I’ve mentioned it to is adamant we should do as it’s ‘clearly the best option’ but WE CANNOT AFFORD IT! Council will pay for his 1:1 but not toward fees! It would be very tight and I would feel awful about sending DS but not DD and logistically wouldn’t be able to get them to two separate schools. We wouldn’t have gone private if DS weren’t disabled but it feels like we have no other option.

Ive invested so much time and energy over the last 2 years and I just want to cry now.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
MumTeacherofMany · 27/01/2024 18:51

Speak to SENDIAS. There must be a special school close by to you? They normally offer to collect & drop back. There are 4 additional needs schools where we live, one for behavioural needs, 2 for ASD and one for complex medical needs. Do you need have these in your county?

Startyabastard · 27/01/2024 18:46

This is 100% not good enough!!! I'm so sorry you're not getting what you need. I hope you receive the right help soon xxx

CatkinToadflax · 27/01/2024 18:42

Hello OP, just wanted to say that I wish you well. Flowers

My DS1 thrived at a mainstream private school with full-time 1:1 support for several years until his needs became visibly significant enough that our (extremely unpleasant bunch of liars) LA eventually agreed to fund independent specialist. At the mainstream private his 1:1 support was funded by the LA. We paid his fees because we were so emotionally battered and bruised by then that we wanted the easiest fight possible. Three other students that I knew of in the school had their full fees as well as 1:1 paid for by the LA. In all cases, these pupils had ASD and assorted extras but were quiet, withdrawn young people who didn’t have obvious ‘behavioural’ issues. They all benefited from the smaller class sizes. In every case the LA had to agree that there was nowhere else suitable. It was a mainstream school but, at the time, had a fabulously well resourced SEN department with access to a sensory room and a brilliant full-time senco. Unfortunately I gather that the SEN provision there is now less good than it was. It saved our LA a lot of money though, as was significantly cheaper than all of the special schools in the county, independent and state.

I hope you are able to secure the the provision that you are happiest with for your DS.

Lifethroughlenses · 27/01/2024 18:34

Please please don’t send him privately. My school has several kids with SEN who were told by private schools that they could meet needs only for them to kick the kids out after a few years. It will be much worse in the long run.

HelenaTranscart · 27/01/2024 18:26

Agree with others that private schools, unless specialist, won't take/keep him. I talk from bitter experience after my son (who's moderately dyslexic) was turfed out of a sh*t private school in Newbridge near Edinburgh in the middle of his NAT5s. It was a horrible experience, and it could have had serious consequences, but thanks to an excellent state school, my son thrived and was far happier. I wish you luck but I'd defo explore state options first.

Anisette · 27/01/2024 18:26

The tribunal is a specialist court.

Sort of, and technically. According to the MoJ, "Tribunals are specialist judicial bodies which decide disputes in particular areas of law. " More materially, on a site for non-lawyers, tribunals are considerably less formal than the courts and more accessible to lay people. Therefore it's helpful to talk about the remedy being via a tribunal, not least to distinguish it from other remedies which may only be available via courts.

However, the general principle from the Education Act 1996 that pupils should be educated in accordance with the wishes of their parents also applies.

Which is exactly what I said.

It isn't easy for LAs to ignore a parental preference for an independent school, especially where, as appears to be the case here, there are no state schools able to meet the child's needs.

As anyone with experience in SEN will tell you, LAs find it all too easy to ignore this. Because of the lack of accountability in the relevant law, there is a growing chasm between what LAs should do and what they do do. I hope it won't be the case for OP, but what is all too likely to happen is that they twist some maintained school's arm into changing their minds and agreeing to take the child in question, often with promises of support which are strangely slow to materialise. Or they'll follow up on what OP says, and make arrangements for him to be placed in a specialist school which may or may not suitable and may well be a long way away. Yes, OP will have a right of appeal, but that may well take a very long time to resolve.

Meredithmama · 27/01/2024 17:57

Does your DS have an EHCP which I am assuming he has because of the council offering to pay for the 1-1. If this is the case and no borough schools are agreeing to having him then the council should fun the placement at the independent school.

Also if the independent school is mainstream what do they offer different to your local school. Also SEN schools cannot say they aren’t disabled enough that is discrimination.

i would definitely look at getting an advocate as they will know the law and be willing to remind the council of it.

Im not sure where you live but check out Talking sense. Ken the owner is incredible and a parent of adults now with SEN needs but he knows the law inside and out and will tell you what the council are required to do.

Flamme · 27/01/2024 15:16

prh47bridge · 26/01/2024 21:33

The LA cannot refuse to name a school that says it can meet the child's needs just because they claim to believe the school is incorrect. They need to justify that belief and offer a school that can meet the child's needs. Equally, they cannot refuse to name the independent school just because another school is cheaper.

If this goes to the SEND tribunal and both the parents' choice of independent school and the LA's choice of school can meet the child's needs, the tribunal will look at whether the additional expense of the independent school is justified by any advantages that attending would offer the child. They can consider any wider health and social care benefits as part of that. I can quote case references if necessary.

Obviously they have to be able to justify a refusal to name the school and name a school that can meet needs. However, anyone with any experience of working in the SEN field will tell you that that certainly does not stop LAs doing just that. Time after time they are happy to take the risk on the basis that (1) only a relatively small proportion of parents challenge them, (2) if they do appeal, it may well be 10 months or more till a hearing takes place and they hope to have cobbled together some sort of evidence by then, and (3) if they lose the appeal at least they've saved themselves a year's worth of school fees.

Yes, if the costs of an independent school and a maintained school or academy are not too far apart, the tribunal may do a balancing act and decide in favour of the more expensive school. But the difference in costs cannot be too great, and cases where this happens are relatively unusual. In most cases if the tribunal decides the LA school can meet needs and is cheaper than the parental choice, it will name the LA school.

prh47bridge · 26/01/2024 21:45

Anisette · 26/01/2024 21:24

I think you may have confused this with the situation where the private school in question is on the Department for Education's section 41 list, which is extremely unlikely for a non-specialist school. For the vast majority of independent schools, the only applicable law states that the LA should "have regard to the general principle that pupils are to be educated in accordance with the wishes of their parents, so far as that is compatible with the provision of efficient instruction and training and the avoidance of unreasonable public expenditure" which is obviously a weaker duty.

Parents don't apply to the courts if they want to challenge school placement, they appeal to the specialist tribunal.

The tribunal is a specialist court.

Yes, the law for a non-section 41 school is as you say. However, the general principle from the Education Act 1996 that pupils should be educated in accordance with the wishes of their parents also applies. And, as per my last post, the courts (or tribunals if you prefer) have been clear that it isn't easy for LAs to ignore a parental preference for an independent school, especially where, as appears to be the case here, there are no state schools able to meet the child's needs.

forcedfun · 26/01/2024 21:37

@Thehonestbadger it might be worth researching whether any charities would provide a grant to help.

Try https://www.turn2us.org.uk/get-support/apply-for-grants for starters. And there may be charities that aren't on there too. It's definitely worth a bit of a search. I am a trustee of a small charity on there and I know we have paid for things like educational equipment etc

Apply for Grants

The Turn2us Grants Search has over 1,400 grants to support individuals looking for financial help. Turn2us also offers a small number of its own grants.

https://www.turn2us.org.uk/get-support/apply-for-grants

prh47bridge · 26/01/2024 21:33

Anisette · 26/01/2024 21:07

LAs and tribunals don't name schools on the footing that they are the best option. They simply have to name a school that is able to meet the child's needs as set out in the EHCP. If they identify another school that is able to meet needs and is cheaper, it can and will name that school; equally, even if the private school was the only one claiming to be able to meet needs, the LA could refuse to name it if it believed the school was incorrect in that.

The LA cannot refuse to name a school that says it can meet the child's needs just because they claim to believe the school is incorrect. They need to justify that belief and offer a school that can meet the child's needs. Equally, they cannot refuse to name the independent school just because another school is cheaper.

If this goes to the SEND tribunal and both the parents' choice of independent school and the LA's choice of school can meet the child's needs, the tribunal will look at whether the additional expense of the independent school is justified by any advantages that attending would offer the child. They can consider any wider health and social care benefits as part of that. I can quote case references if necessary.

motchapudding · 26/01/2024 21:27

Is him staying in nursery for another year an option? I know a couple high needs children coped well with a mainstream after one year delay.

Anisette · 26/01/2024 21:24

prh47bridge · 26/01/2024 14:12

I can think that is how it works because that is what the law says and, indeed, how it works in practise.

When the parents choose which school they want named on an EHCP, there are only limited grounds on which the LA can refuse to comply. If the parents choose an independent school and the LA refuses to name it, the parents can apply to the courts. Unless the LA can show that one of the limited grounds applies, the courts will force the LA to name the school.

If an independent school is named on an EHCP, the LA must pay the school fees.

In 2022/23 there were 389,171 pupils with an EHCP. Of these, 28,372 were at independent schools with their fees being paid by the LA. Breaking these down further, 21,943 were at independent special schools, 6,789 were at ordinary independent schools.

I think you may have confused this with the situation where the private school in question is on the Department for Education's section 41 list, which is extremely unlikely for a non-specialist school. For the vast majority of independent schools, the only applicable law states that the LA should "have regard to the general principle that pupils are to be educated in accordance with the wishes of their parents, so far as that is compatible with the provision of efficient instruction and training and the avoidance of unreasonable public expenditure" which is obviously a weaker duty.

Parents don't apply to the courts if they want to challenge school placement, they appeal to the specialist tribunal.

Chichimcgee · 26/01/2024 21:19

You should be able to name a school on his ehcp. Does it say ‘mainstream’ or ‘specialist’ or an actual named school? If it doesn’t say anything you need to speak to the ehcp coordinator about naming a school on the ehcp.

don’t send him private, tell ehcp coordinator that they need to work quickly as he starts in September. Any issue contact your local authority and ask what provision they’re going to put in place come September while you’re waiting for a named school. They should provide a short stay school or tutor or force a place at the local mainstream.

Anisette · 26/01/2024 21:07

prh47bridge · 26/01/2024 13:51

No, I haven't read those posts. Yes, the private school can refuse the child. However, if the private school is the right school and is willing to accept the child, my post stands. If OP is right that it is clearly the best option and the school will take her son, she should go for it.

LAs and tribunals don't name schools on the footing that they are the best option. They simply have to name a school that is able to meet the child's needs as set out in the EHCP. If they identify another school that is able to meet needs and is cheaper, it can and will name that school; equally, even if the private school was the only one claiming to be able to meet needs, the LA could refuse to name it if it believed the school was incorrect in that.

Anisette · 26/01/2024 21:03

Needmoresleep · 26/01/2024 13:49

I would add that prh47bridge is a genuine expert who has helped many MN parents over the years.

I don't think s/he claims to be an expert in SEN law, however.

Anisette · 26/01/2024 20:56

HerculesMulligan · 26/01/2024 09:41

OP, can I recommend that you spend a little money on talking to Adam Friel at Geldards solicitors? I went to a seminar he ran about a month ago and was extremely impressed (I'm a lawyer but of a different discipline). He also has some personal experience with the system and I am sure we'll be using him at some point fairly soon, to sort out provision for my autistic 9yo.

I know someone who spent a hell of a lot of money with this firm only to be advised by them after several months to withdraw the appeal. Think carefully.

SearchingForSolitude · 26/01/2024 19:48

If it is inappropriate for the provision to be made in a school there is EOTAS. EOTAS packages are completely bespoke. The whole point is the package is designed to meet the pupil’s individual needs and provision required. It can be whatever is suitable.

AnneValentine · 26/01/2024 19:35

SummitOfMountWashmore · 26/01/2024 19:32

I mean there will be more options than the LA will be telling OP about - section 41 schools, independent specialists etc. They are hardly transparent. And if there isn't a suitable physical school for this child, then they still have a duty to provide an education, whether that's EOTAS or hospital education or whatever else is required.

It doesn’t mean there is something suitable. This is known.

SummitOfMountWashmore · 26/01/2024 19:32

AnneValentine · 26/01/2024 18:13

I have literally no idea what your point is. You stated “there will be somewhere suitable for him”. That’s literally not always true.

I mean there will be more options than the LA will be telling OP about - section 41 schools, independent specialists etc. They are hardly transparent. And if there isn't a suitable physical school for this child, then they still have a duty to provide an education, whether that's EOTAS or hospital education or whatever else is required.

AnneValentine · 26/01/2024 18:13

SummitOfMountWashmore · 26/01/2024 11:32

It's not a lawful reason for the LA not to facilitate it though. When we were going through this process we were told of 2 specialist schools we could look at. LA maintained, the cheapest option for them after mainstream. Neither were appropriate and we're currently going through court to appeal for a place at an independent specialist school. For the LA it's all about money, they're fighting us on this due to the cost despite it being the only school in the county that is appropriate.

95% (I think that may recently have gone up to 98%) of tribunals rule in favour of the child/parent.

I have literally no idea what your point is. You stated “there will be somewhere suitable for him”. That’s literally not always true.

Zonder · 26/01/2024 18:02

Felicia19 · 26/01/2024 14:54

Sorry, just seen it.

And then I saw this 😂

Zonder · 26/01/2024 18:02

Felicia19 · 26/01/2024 14:53

Where did the OP say that the local private school is known for its SEND support? Have I missed something?

It's here.

Wtf do we do? Forced to private educate DS (4)
Naptrappedmummy · 26/01/2024 17:51

I really feel for you, Badger. Nothing to suggest as no SEN knowledge here but I’ve seen a couple of your threads and just wanted to send some virtual support 💐 I hope something presents itself, I really do xx

SussexLass87 · 26/01/2024 16:52

Updownleftandright · 26/01/2024 08:58

Can I ask what she did? I have a child similar to OP except he is in a mainstream school and we are trying to get a specialist and are doing a section I appeal. It is going to take a year to get to hearing 😫its a fucking mess. This country is a shambles. We wrote our own appeal and the SENDIAS lady said it was very thorough with 23 pieces of evidence, so I'm hoping when it comes to them submitting their evidence they realise they don't really have anything to counter it. They agreed he needed specialist at panel, but did not name a specialist school. I'm not quite sure how they can fight that. Their only defence is no specialist have said they have spaces, but that's not really a robust reason not to name specialist.

Your situation sounds so similar to my own. The lawyer was recommended by a friend and she initially read through the initial EHCP for us. She changed wording, added arguments for longer hours of TA support etc. Then helped us through the tribunal process when fighting to get into a specialist school. The council didn't even show up to the hearing (a well known tactic that they use) and we won.

Good luck! Wishing you and your boy all the best.