Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know it’s stealing….but…..

393 replies

VidalSass · 26/01/2024 00:32

Im going to be Annihilated here……

i took out a store card to pay for a large tech purchase, interest free, over 36months. This was four months ago

I set up a direct debit straight away for the monthly payment and then cut up the card.

I checked my account and noted direct debit not come out, so I logged on to the store card account and the charge is still ‘pending’ - therefore minimum payment is 0 as the charge has not been processed by the merchant.

would I be unreasonable to just ignore it and therefore avoid the repayments? Surely it would eventually just be cancelled? Although it’s already sat there for four months….

i don’t want to call the merchant as obviously they will then just process the charge…..

im worries that eventually it would just be charged but a part of me is excited at the thought that an error may have occurred resulting in me getting free stuff. I know it’s technically stealing but it’s a huge company (probably not paying corporation tax in the uk) and I’m not exactly rolling in it

AIBU - should call the merchant to process the charge and start paying it back

NBU - technically it’s stealing but fuck the man and ride the freebie wave

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 26/01/2024 09:48

VidalSass · 26/01/2024 01:50

If the bank accidentally deposited a million dollars into my account and I had the choice to keep it or send it back?

like 99% of people I would keep it.
imight have the odd pang of guilt after umming and aaahing about it for a little while, but ultimately it would change my kids lives so therefore I wouldn’t feel bad about it.

would I take a million quid knowingly, in exchange for making a family homeless, no probably not. Morals aren’t black and white and anyone who thinks so has far less sense than you presume I have.

You might think you can keep it but at any time they can come after you for it.

And if you've spent any of it it's theft.

And in this case it would be theft. You are knowingly keeping something you haven't paid for.

But you think that's ok, so crack on

And the more people steal, the more prices go up...

Galatine · 26/01/2024 09:45

It's OK. When you endup in court just explain to the judge that folk on MumsNet said it was fine to ignore it. I'm sure that he'll take a lenient view.

Dotellhimpike · 26/01/2024 09:45

"Anyone who works in retail would because they know that it’s this sort of thing that, big picture, gives a chance of layoffs due to losses caused by fraud and theft"

Most business fraud and theft is commited by employees.

BusyMummyWrites01 · 26/01/2024 09:43

Pretty sure under contract law that it will be deemed that you have taken goods and not provided consideration (payment) for them, having contracted to do so. That there is a vendor admin error is unlikely to be deemed sufficient excuse as the legal responsibility for monitoring the outgoings of your bank account or that you have met the terms of your financial agreement (ie made the payments) is yours alone.

Ie, when it is noted (and it very likely will be) that you have not paid, the merchant may simply write advising you of the error and request immediate settlement; but if the debt is actually held by a 3rd party finance company (ie the company through which you have set up the DD/finance agreement, such as Klarna etc), their credit controllers may not take the same view and seek a county court judgment for the arrears, plus interest and costs. At the very list it will have a significant impact upon your credit rating and take years to clear.

You’ve not stated what your job is - or that of any live-in partner - but a CCJ would impact your ability to get future finance, a mortgage and impact employment - my husband, for instance, works in finance, so any CCJ that I get would have to be declared to his employer. The fall-out can be immense.

You need to contact the company you have set the DD with and query this now. Better to pay this than risk the fall-out.

IfYouDontAsk · 26/01/2024 09:42

How is this even a question? You either know it’s not ok to steal or you don’t. You clearly do know but want to justify it.

If you’re “not exactly rolling in it”, the smart thing to do would be to not make large, expensive tech purchases in the first place rather than tying yourself in knots trying to justify stealing it.

Etoile41 · 26/01/2024 09:42

If you kept money that was wrong deposited in your account, it would be theft. Lawyer here

stayathomer · 26/01/2024 09:40

Big company, i wouldnt chase, but would be putting the amount away each month

Little company - I would chase
Why? We had two branches of the shop I work for closed down because of losses, that’s loads of jobs gone, loads of local businesses losing out too, all the while we STILL hear ‘oh they’re a big company, they can take the hit’ when people want money off.

OvxvO · 26/01/2024 09:39

@Snowdogsmitten
Jesus. These self righteous posters are hilarious. Must be exhausting being them. 😂

The OP is on AIBU and is asking opinions so people are giving their opinions. 🤷🏻‍♀️
I think it a bit pathetic to be trying to justify keeping something when you know you shouldn't. It's the scrabbling around looking for reasons why it's ok that's the most pathetic. I've almost more respect for people that don't give a shit and are happy to be dishonest.

As for it being 'exhausting' being honest I disagree. I think it's the easiest option. It's not something I give any thought to.

PabloPawcasso · 26/01/2024 09:39

chiwowowa · 26/01/2024 09:26

I would contact them yes with a view to paying, but would be prepared that it might be a hassle. No good deed goes unpunished and you may find that it's actually a bit of a job to get them to sort it.
I once had two large items instead of one - worth about £100 each - delivered by mistake by a major retailer. Because it was a duplicate I had a bit of trouble actually getting them to take the extra one back as it wasn't on their system or paperwork. I did feel morally good after though!

Nonplayercharacter above is probably correct - it will probably show up in some sort of audit - it sounds like quite a high value item, not just an extra bag of chips on your supermarket delivery. 😁

it’s not the recipient’s responsibility to return unsolicited goods. So you weren’t under any obligation to chase or arrange a return

BobnLen · 26/01/2024 09:37

It's a purchase on a store card not one of those interest free deals similar to what DFS do, the store card is interest free for 36 months not just the item

stayathomer · 26/01/2024 09:36

Mn is mean , nasty , vindictive, yet everyone is a moral saviour according to these threads ! Makes me laugh

Like fuck would everyone own up to this . Sanctimonious shite
Anyone who works in retail would because they know that it’s this sort of thing that, big picture, gives a chance of layoffs due to losses caused by fraud and theft. I hate the ‘fuck the man’ attitude- op, the man is a person who started a business to earn a living, employs people and provides a service. At what point in this process does it mean they’re fine to be stolen from?

MyUsernameIsBetterThanYours · 26/01/2024 09:35

I agree that this is on the retailer but taking aside the moral issue I’d probably pay up for practical reasons.

If I wasn’t going to follow up with them I’d feel like I’d need that money ring-fenced in case they ever came asking, and if I can’t spend it anyway then tbh I may as well just pay it and not have the niggle of unfinished business.

Bundtbake · 26/01/2024 09:34

Are you sure it isn't an interest free purchase with no payments and you pay the full amount at the end of the 36mths?

twnety · 26/01/2024 09:34

Ghentsummer · 26/01/2024 01:04

I would consider theft of a something frivolous to be immoral and the OP wants to get away with not paying for such an item. She asked if she is being unreasonable and I responded. It wouldn't even be a dilemma if she had decent morals.

decent morals....

Big company, i wouldnt chase, but would be putting the amount away each month

Little company - I would chase

DocOck · 26/01/2024 09:33

It's not stealing, you've held up your part of the deal. It's not your fault if they make a fuck up. I wouldn't be pointing it out but like other posters have said, I'd make sure I was keeping the cash to one side to pay it if it ever does come to light.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 26/01/2024 09:27

At some point over the 6 years (?) they are bound to get in touch with you. Whether that's to recoup all the payments or not, unsure. But you signed an agreement with them, even though they haven't fulfilled their side.

chiwowowa · 26/01/2024 09:26

I would contact them yes with a view to paying, but would be prepared that it might be a hassle. No good deed goes unpunished and you may find that it's actually a bit of a job to get them to sort it.
I once had two large items instead of one - worth about £100 each - delivered by mistake by a major retailer. Because it was a duplicate I had a bit of trouble actually getting them to take the extra one back as it wasn't on their system or paperwork. I did feel morally good after though!

Nonplayercharacter above is probably correct - it will probably show up in some sort of audit - it sounds like quite a high value item, not just an extra bag of chips on your supermarket delivery. 😁

Appleofmyeye2023 · 26/01/2024 09:26

misssunshine4040 · 26/01/2024 02:34

Grin a free coffee!!

Hmmm, habitat were better. Somehow got two lights sent, told them, could keep both . Have a nice matching pair 😊

BobnLen · 26/01/2024 09:24

It will probably just appear at some stage if it says pending on the store card statement

Sillysausagedog · 26/01/2024 09:19

Its definitely not stealing.

You set up a direct debit and they failed to do their part.

I would just leave it as it is but be prepared it might come to light one day.

Snowdogsmitten · 26/01/2024 09:19

VidalSass · 26/01/2024 00:54

Scummy, dishonest and cheap. Tell me what you really think 😂😂😂😂😂

Jesus. These self righteous posters are hilarious. Must be exhausting being them. 😂

Do nothing. But be prepared to pay if it comes up.

Madamlulu · 26/01/2024 09:18

gurnerandpooch · 26/01/2024 01:11

Mn is mean , nasty , vindictive, yet everyone is a moral saviour according to these threads ! Makes me laugh .

Like fuck would everyone own up to this . Sanctimonious shite .

This!!!

StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 26/01/2024 09:11

@Abi86 Ok fair point, if that's how it would be viewed then I would probably mention it at my next shop and offer the 20p. No big deal. What I meant was I wouldn't go out of my way (as in drive to the shop specifically) to pay back the 20p.

BobnLen · 26/01/2024 09:08

How much was it?

StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 26/01/2024 09:08

beverlytun · 26/01/2024 09:05

@Charliecatpaws it's not fraud. It's theft. It's an ongoing misappropriation of goods. Your definition of fraud would involve a statement, not an omission. (Am a lawyer)

I agree. Would it go along the lines of 'unjust enrichment' or does that normally apply to when a sum of money gets deposited into a bank account when it shouldn't have been? (Like the million £ example upthread).