Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know it’s stealing….but…..

393 replies

VidalSass · 26/01/2024 00:32

Im going to be Annihilated here……

i took out a store card to pay for a large tech purchase, interest free, over 36months. This was four months ago

I set up a direct debit straight away for the monthly payment and then cut up the card.

I checked my account and noted direct debit not come out, so I logged on to the store card account and the charge is still ‘pending’ - therefore minimum payment is 0 as the charge has not been processed by the merchant.

would I be unreasonable to just ignore it and therefore avoid the repayments? Surely it would eventually just be cancelled? Although it’s already sat there for four months….

i don’t want to call the merchant as obviously they will then just process the charge…..

im worries that eventually it would just be charged but a part of me is excited at the thought that an error may have occurred resulting in me getting free stuff. I know it’s technically stealing but it’s a huge company (probably not paying corporation tax in the uk) and I’m not exactly rolling in it

AIBU - should call the merchant to process the charge and start paying it back

NBU - technically it’s stealing but fuck the man and ride the freebie wave

OP posts:
BusyMummyWrites01 · 26/01/2024 10:23

@diddle just realised I misread your post 🤦🏽‍♀️ you weren’t saying what I thought you were - sorry, can’t delete my reply!

Dotellhimpike · 26/01/2024 10:23

I'm just reminded of two times within the same year I was overpaid by the two different community care companies I was working for. One paid me a full month's salary after I'd already left the company, and the other overpaid me by about £800 one month. I mentioned to my manager I'd seemed to have been overpaid, his response was that I should give him the money back until the issue had been resolved. I told him I'd be happy to return the money once they'd given me a full breakdown of what hours I'd been paid for and what amount was an overpayment.

I never heard anything else about it.

BusyMummyWrites01 · 26/01/2024 10:22

diddl · 26/01/2024 10:21

If people don't check what is going out of their account, how do they know what is available to spend?

(Unless they have so much going in that this isn't a concern?)

No defence in law - your bank account, your legal responsibility. If you are negligent and do not check it, the risks are entirely on you.

diddl · 26/01/2024 10:21

If people don't check what is going out of their account, how do they know what is available to spend?

(Unless they have so much going in that this isn't a concern?)

kittylion2 · 26/01/2024 10:19

About a decade ago I took early redundancy from my job. I got paid my redundancy money as soon as I left, but there was still a month's salary to come. When that arrived into my account, it came with a duplicate payment of the £20k+ redundancy money. I rang them immediately - they apologised and asked me to send them a cheque, which I did.

When I told my ex-colleague, who had also taken redundancy, she checked her bank account and they had overpaid her too. She didn't say anything but a week or so later they contacted her. She then contacted 3 others who had been made redundant, and the same had happened to them - they hadn't noticed but had been contacted about a week after I had phoned.

To this day they all blame me for them not getting double bubble redundancy - they don't listen when I tell them it would have been fraud. Sigh.

Pusheen467 · 26/01/2024 10:17

gurnerandpooch · 26/01/2024 00:33

Ride the freebie wave but be prepared for it to come to light so save the money for if it does

This is what I'd do. It's their mistake.

Pookerrod · 26/01/2024 10:16

I would call them and sort it out. Not due to the morals or anything like that but to protect your finances.

At some point, the shop will likely reconcile their accounts and notice this “pending” payment. The deal you signed was for 36 months. So they could take via DD all the months that you’ve missed in one go. As you have set up a DD, they can just take it without your agreement. Can you really afford something like 6 or even 12 months worth of payments to come out of your account in one go? The longer this goes on, the worse it could get and I couldn’t have that over my head for 3 years.

Everyone saying that this is the merchants fault so you don’t need to worry are being naive. You took the goods and signed a credit agreement. They are entitled to be paid regardless of whether or not their admin is poor.

Whatdoy · 26/01/2024 10:15

saraclara · 26/01/2024 01:01

You've set up the direct debit. Most people wouldn't even check that the amount was going out.

This. Once I’d done the dd I would presume that they would actually do their job and not think about it again.

If I did notice then I would contact them though, but only because I would be concerned that it would get backed up and they would end up wanting a bulk payment which wouldn’t be convenient for me.

I wouldn’t do it through guilt about them not taking a payment I had tried to set up- that’s their failing not mine!

TheOccupier · 26/01/2024 10:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Are you a lawyer? There is an offence of "theft by finding" which you'd commit if you found money in the street and didn't try to get it back to its rightful owner - would be interesting to know whether this applies to situations like the OP's.

BusyMummyWrites01 · 26/01/2024 10:13

GintyMcGinty · 26/01/2024 09:58

I agree with this.

You haven't committed fraud. You have set it up to pay but they haven't processed it from their end.

As long as you are willing to pay if they ever get round to this.

After 36 months - 3 years - they will have long ago written this off as bad debt.

It was 4m ago. It will likely be picked up in the year end reconciliation that the finance company will carry out. Her contract is not with the merchant, but with a 3rd party finance company.

She has also signed a legal document in which she contracted to pay this amount - regardless of an admin error, she is committing fraud if she does nothing. The onus would be on her in court proceedings to prove that she did not know the DD was not being taken but, as it is reasonable to expect that a person would/should regularly review the bank accounts, she would still be liable for non payment and associated interest and costs.

She needs to contact them now and evidence her ‘willingness to pay’.

The advice on this thread encouraging the OP to commit fraud is risible. The PPs here are at no risk of the fall-out of OP being found out.

Malarandras · 26/01/2024 10:13

Tell them or don’t up to you OP. But be prepared to explain yourself when they catch up to you, because they will at some point.

Lemonyyellow · 26/01/2024 10:07

You can’t pay a charge that hasn’t been processed. I would wait and see. But have the money ready in case

Kittythecutest · 26/01/2024 10:06

If the bank accidentally deposited a million dollars into my account and I had the choice to keep it or send it back?

like 99% of people I would keep it.

I completely disagree with this, the percentage wouldn’t be that high. I think you’re judging too many people by your own standards!

NoOrdinaryMorning · 26/01/2024 10:05

Dotellhimpike · 26/01/2024 09:59

"she spent £71k of it before the bank realised, tried to contact her to no success and then got authorities involved. She served 4 months in prison in total."

£71K for four months in clink doesn't sound like the worst deal in the world to me if I'm being truthful

She had a fraud conviction on her record for the remainder of her life though which caused her no end of unexpected consequences. She was never ever accepted for private rentals, her marriage ended as a direct result and she lost her career and many friends. She also missed four months of her toddler's life too which then meant that he remained primarily with his father for good as he was, by then, very settled there.

NoOrdinaryMorning · 26/01/2024 10:02

Sillysausagedog · 26/01/2024 09:19

Its definitely not stealing.

You set up a direct debit and they failed to do their part.

I would just leave it as it is but be prepared it might come to light one day.

Unfortunately yes it is according to the law. It doesn't matter how the goods/money got to you or what the circumstances are/who made a mistake, intentionally depriving the company of payment is legally considered theft.

NonPlayerCharacter · 26/01/2024 10:02

Dotellhimpike · 26/01/2024 09:59

"she spent £71k of it before the bank realised, tried to contact her to no success and then got authorities involved. She served 4 months in prison in total."

£71K for four months in clink doesn't sound like the worst deal in the world to me if I'm being truthful

Depends what she spent it on. Was it cigarettes, whiskey and wild, wild women, or did she squander it?

Dotellhimpike · 26/01/2024 09:59

"she spent £71k of it before the bank realised, tried to contact her to no success and then got authorities involved. She served 4 months in prison in total."

£71K for four months in clink doesn't sound like the worst deal in the world to me if I'm being truthful

GintyMcGinty · 26/01/2024 09:58

Lavenderandbrown · 26/01/2024 00:50

It’s not your job to train their employees. Sit tight. Be prepared to pay. If they do figure it out and bill you deny all late charges saying you never received a statement/bill. It’s a bit opportunistic but I think it’s also a bit harsh for readers to comment on your morals.

I agree with this.

You haven't committed fraud. You have set it up to pay but they haven't processed it from their end.

As long as you are willing to pay if they ever get round to this.

After 36 months - 3 years - they will have long ago written this off as bad debt.

JohnMytton · 26/01/2024 09:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

NoOrdinaryMorning · 26/01/2024 09:56

@VidalSass I know somebody (my late SIL) who was given 6 months in prison after £550k was accidentally deposited into her account and she spent £71k of it before the bank realised, tried to contact her to no success and then got authorities involved. She served 4 months in prison in total.
So yeah, your example of 'a million dollars' along with other people on this thread giving incorrect info saying that it's their fault etc, is not helping as it's nonsense. Just like with HMRC, regardless of whether it's 'their fault' or not, if they incorrectly pay you any amount then you legally have to pay it back.

I once, many years ago, before online banking, I tried to purchase a three piece suite from George.com. I thought a cheque had cleared but it hadn't so the transaction declined. This was a Saturday so I had to wait until at least Monday before trying again. The cheque didn't clear Monday either as it happens but just as I was about to try again on Tuesday morning, my doorbell went. It was a delivery guy with the sofas!
I let them in obviously and presumed that they must've made a mistake and that the money had cleared after all 🤷🏼‍♀️ Wrong. Their system failed and dispatched the sofas anyway, despite payment failing. I'm ashamed to say I didn't contact them to make payment and they took 3 months to realise. I was threatened with legal action and long story short, after getting legal advice it became very clear that despite it being my mistake, if I didn't pay them then I could be criminally prosecuted and/or receive a CCJ through the county courts. Which they could then even escalate to the high court for a Writ of Execution which nobody wants as that permits High Court Sheriffs to forcibly gain access to your home (not bailiffs as they're not permitted to access your home but High Court Sheriffs with a Writ ARE!) However it's unlikely they would take it to the high court given the value of the claim but I wasn't taking that risk so I paid them and felt ashamed of myself

Moveoverdarlin · 26/01/2024 09:53

Just sit tight and see what happens, if they come after you, pay it, if not, happy days. I can’t believe people are using phrases like ‘could you live with this hanging over you?’ Bloody hell, she’s got a free telly because the sales person fucked up the sale. She hasn’t killed puppies!

RedRobyn2021 · 26/01/2024 09:52

I once had some joules wellingtons set to me in error and could have kept them, I don't think anyone would have ever realised.

I rang the company and they organised pick up.

Also, I once ordered a low value item to be delivered to work, it arrived whilst I was out and along with another item that was higher value item - a marquee tent (seriously)

We rang the company right away.

Anyway, it is stealing, most people wouldn't say anything and would take the freebie. I personally wouldn't.

berksandbeyond · 26/01/2024 09:51

I’d put the money you would have paid by direct debit away in an account, hopefully one where you can get a wee bit of interest (if such thing exists nowadays) and wait it out personally…

TheOccupier · 26/01/2024 09:51

Put the instalments into an interest-bearing (instant access) savings account. I think they will catch up with you at some point.

Nanny0gg · 26/01/2024 09:49

Snowdogsmitten · 26/01/2024 09:19

Jesus. These self righteous posters are hilarious. Must be exhausting being them. 😂

Do nothing. But be prepared to pay if it comes up.

What's 'self-righteous' about being honest?