Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know it’s stealing….but…..

393 replies

VidalSass · 26/01/2024 00:32

Im going to be Annihilated here……

i took out a store card to pay for a large tech purchase, interest free, over 36months. This was four months ago

I set up a direct debit straight away for the monthly payment and then cut up the card.

I checked my account and noted direct debit not come out, so I logged on to the store card account and the charge is still ‘pending’ - therefore minimum payment is 0 as the charge has not been processed by the merchant.

would I be unreasonable to just ignore it and therefore avoid the repayments? Surely it would eventually just be cancelled? Although it’s already sat there for four months….

i don’t want to call the merchant as obviously they will then just process the charge…..

im worries that eventually it would just be charged but a part of me is excited at the thought that an error may have occurred resulting in me getting free stuff. I know it’s technically stealing but it’s a huge company (probably not paying corporation tax in the uk) and I’m not exactly rolling in it

AIBU - should call the merchant to process the charge and start paying it back

NBU - technically it’s stealing but fuck the man and ride the freebie wave

OP posts:
BobnLen · 27/01/2024 14:51

If they update the account in the future obviously OP will just have to make the minimum payment for that month if its a storecard, there won't be arrears if that is paid as needed

Lillush · 27/01/2024 14:39

It's not fraud as it stands. I would be more inclined to do some research on your rights if it does come to light but you could play dumb, like you say the debit is set up, it's up to the merchant to collect it monthly, if they don't that's on them not you.

notjustthe · 27/01/2024 14:36

potential credit history arrears i

nothing is going to go in to arrears because no payment is being asked from the Op so she’s not “going on to arrears”!

notjustthe · 27/01/2024 14:35

the op hasn’t “defaulted” on any payment

i think it would be best if you read the thread!

Mumtofourandnomore · 27/01/2024 14:30

Yes exactly - the OP has bought something, clicked at checkout for a store card (this is a credit agreement) and now hasn’t paid, because they can’t (because it hasn’t been processed correctly). However the terms and conditions of the store credit card will include penalties and interest if the OP defaults.

The OP can just leave it and hope that the company doesn’t notice and keep the item. That might happen - fingers crossed.

But equally the company could easily realise, update the account and consider that legally OP has defaulted (because they haven’t made any payments in line with the store credit agreement or tried to resolve it). The OP could easily end up with a default - that’s a pain for six years in the future.

And so the OP has to decide whether the risk of potential credit history arrears is worth taking, for the free item, it’s not the same as a duplicate order or delivery error or similar cock up 🤷‍♀️.

Coconutter24 · 27/01/2024 14:21

VidalSass · 27/01/2024 10:59

I can’t make a payment on a zero balance, as far as the credit card is concerned there’s a pre-authorisation on the account that hasn’t been finalised.

I have a receipt for the purchase from the supplier. I’ve actually been in and exchanged one of the items as faulty using the receipt - obviously prior to discovering they haven’t actually charged me…

I agree that yes it could be classed as stealing but on paper I haven’t done anything wrong… I once transferred a large sum of money overseas and the bank teller processed one of the digits wrong, the money ended up being returned but I was still charged a processing fee. The bank refused to refund it. That’s technically stealing too….

Ok so if there’s no balance the morally correct thing to do would be to phone the credit or store card and explain the situation see what they say? No you on paper haven’t done anything wrong the error was not made by you but how you deal with it would determine if you end up doing wrong or not.
The last part of your comment about the bank and processing fees is totally irrelevant, that’s a different situation. Just because someone wrongs you it doesn’t make it ok for you to wrong someone else

notjustthe · 27/01/2024 14:14

Mumtofourandnomore · 27/01/2024 13:45

I have Read Enough of the Thread to know the contractual position - thanks for the advice.

OP has bought an expensive tech item, signed a credit agreement at checkout and the company hasn’t processed it correctly onto her account so it shows as pending, and hence she’s not paying it back (or able to pay it back).

It doesn’t matter how it shows on her online account, just because it shows as pending, they can still easily chase her for payment - even in many years time. The company aren’t going to care about processing errors on their side - she’s taken delivery of an item and signed a credit agreement at checkout so if she defaults, she’s in trouble.

Most likely, the company will realise - so definitely best to set aside the money, but the consequences of defaulting on the credit agreement are serious.

but in your previous post you state **
If you default on your contractual obligation to make payments, i**

the op has made no payments. that is the point of the thread

ChiChiChiChi · 27/01/2024 13:54

Stuff like this happens to me all the time, as I do alot of online shopping. Duplicates sent in error.
Got a free TV once as I ordered and cancelled but they still sent it. Was never charged. Never heard from them again.
It's not your fault they didn't process it properly

If the account is showing as 0 I'd try and close the account before they realise 😂

Mumtofourandnomore · 27/01/2024 13:45

I have Read Enough of the Thread to know the contractual position - thanks for the advice.

OP has bought an expensive tech item, signed a credit agreement at checkout and the company hasn’t processed it correctly onto her account so it shows as pending, and hence she’s not paying it back (or able to pay it back).

It doesn’t matter how it shows on her online account, just because it shows as pending, they can still easily chase her for payment - even in many years time. The company aren’t going to care about processing errors on their side - she’s taken delivery of an item and signed a credit agreement at checkout so if she defaults, she’s in trouble.

Most likely, the company will realise - so definitely best to set aside the money, but the consequences of defaulting on the credit agreement are serious.

Wouldyouguess · 27/01/2024 13:28

gurnerandpooch · 26/01/2024 01:11

Mn is mean , nasty , vindictive, yet everyone is a moral saviour according to these threads ! Makes me laugh .

Like fuck would everyone own up to this . Sanctimonious shite .

I would and many people would too, not everyone is a scumbag.

tiredmama23 · 27/01/2024 13:21

I wouldn't feel guilty if this happened or morally driven to call them and be honest. Their error after all. HOWEVER- and this is a huge however for me- I'd literally be unable to sleep at night for worry the error would be discovered and I'd be penalised. So I'd own up to rid myself of that anticipatory anxiety, not because I'm a moral saint or anything.

KentLife01 · 27/01/2024 12:53

It will catch up with you eventually. If you could/can afford the monthly payments in the first place then what is the issue with calling the company and telling of the mistake? If it does catch up with you later and you've spent the money or find your financial position changes for the worst then you could end up in small claims court and you and your kids will be worse off as a result. Just call them and rectify it then you won't have to worry about whether you and others thing you're a thief or fraudster.

notjustthe · 27/01/2024 12:45

Mumtofourandnomore · 27/01/2024 12:09

I have not RTFT but I think you need to be careful here. You have purchased at item and owe the company the money for it - you have a contractual obligation to pay for it.

To settle the obligation, you have no doubt signed a credit agreement agreeing to pay the amount in instalments. As part of that credit agreement there are likely to be contractual penalties for late payments which will likely result in interest charges and perhaps admin fees.

Just because the mechanical setting up of the DD in terms of a cash settlement process hasn’t worked, the actual contractual obligation to settle the credit agreement will still exist. You have a legal liability to pay for the item and will ultimately be responsible for it. It’s a hassle and a pain if they haven’t set up the DD correctly, but this doesn’t mean you have been ‘let off’ your legal obligation to pay.

If you default on your contractual obligation to make payments, it will really hurt your credit score for many years and you will have to meet the penalties for default - is it really worth it ?

Of course there’s a chance they might not notice, but I think it’s unlikely - I think you’re being a fool, it would perhaps be different if you hadn’t signed a legally enforceable credit agreement.

to go to the effort of a very lengthy post but not to read the thread 😐

BobnLen · 27/01/2024 12:14

Mumtofourandnomore · 27/01/2024 12:09

I have not RTFT but I think you need to be careful here. You have purchased at item and owe the company the money for it - you have a contractual obligation to pay for it.

To settle the obligation, you have no doubt signed a credit agreement agreeing to pay the amount in instalments. As part of that credit agreement there are likely to be contractual penalties for late payments which will likely result in interest charges and perhaps admin fees.

Just because the mechanical setting up of the DD in terms of a cash settlement process hasn’t worked, the actual contractual obligation to settle the credit agreement will still exist. You have a legal liability to pay for the item and will ultimately be responsible for it. It’s a hassle and a pain if they haven’t set up the DD correctly, but this doesn’t mean you have been ‘let off’ your legal obligation to pay.

If you default on your contractual obligation to make payments, it will really hurt your credit score for many years and you will have to meet the penalties for default - is it really worth it ?

Of course there’s a chance they might not notice, but I think it’s unlikely - I think you’re being a fool, it would perhaps be different if you hadn’t signed a legally enforceable credit agreement.

Maybe you should RTFT because it's nothing to do with the direct debit

Mumtofourandnomore · 27/01/2024 12:09

I have not RTFT but I think you need to be careful here. You have purchased at item and owe the company the money for it - you have a contractual obligation to pay for it.

To settle the obligation, you have no doubt signed a credit agreement agreeing to pay the amount in instalments. As part of that credit agreement there are likely to be contractual penalties for late payments which will likely result in interest charges and perhaps admin fees.

Just because the mechanical setting up of the DD in terms of a cash settlement process hasn’t worked, the actual contractual obligation to settle the credit agreement will still exist. You have a legal liability to pay for the item and will ultimately be responsible for it. It’s a hassle and a pain if they haven’t set up the DD correctly, but this doesn’t mean you have been ‘let off’ your legal obligation to pay.

If you default on your contractual obligation to make payments, it will really hurt your credit score for many years and you will have to meet the penalties for default - is it really worth it ?

Of course there’s a chance they might not notice, but I think it’s unlikely - I think you’re being a fool, it would perhaps be different if you hadn’t signed a legally enforceable credit agreement.

StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 27/01/2024 12:01

@HollyKnight Ah ok I see what you mean.

HollyKnight · 27/01/2024 11:59

StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 27/01/2024 11:50

I was always under the impression that if you used a credit card, it is the credit card company you owe. They pay the company for the goods and then you have to pay the credit card company back with interest.

Yes, but in this case the credit card hasn't been used. The charge wasn't put on the card. As far as the seller is concerned, they haven't yet received payment from the OP. And as far as the CC company is concerned, it has nothing to do with them. The debt is between the seller and the OP.

Crunchymum · 27/01/2024 11:58

Just to clarify, are you saying you took the store card to pay for a purchase (how much are we talking?) but the item has never been charged to the card so you can't make a payment as the card is at zero?

I assume you had to be credit checked? Are you sure they didn't charge the card you used as ID?

It will most likely catch up with you at some point so at the very least I'd be putting money aside to be able to make the payment if they ever come back to you. However I wouldn't be in a hurry to ring them up and point out the mistake.

StopTheQtipWhenTheresResistance · 27/01/2024 11:50

HollyKnight · 27/01/2024 10:49

You are in possession of item(s) you have not paid. This means either you have stolen said items or you still owe money for those items.

If you take the view that you still owe money for those items, then your debt is with the company you got the items from, not the credit card company. That company has every right to take action against you to recover the money you owe them. They might just ask for immediate payment. Or they could pass the debt on to a debt recovery agency. Or take legal action against you. The latter will affect your credit rating.

Your sit and wait approach is very risky.

I was always under the impression that if you used a credit card, it is the credit card company you owe. They pay the company for the goods and then you have to pay the credit card company back with interest.

Pleiades2020 · 27/01/2024 11:19

Was the offer something like buy now pay in 6 months as well as interest free? In which case the pending charge might be just be that, pending, and appear later.

Puddingpieplum · 27/01/2024 11:15

It could really fcuk up your credit rating, is it worth it?

EBearhug · 27/01/2024 11:06

I wouldn't voluntarily send a payment while the balance says £0 - I suspect that would lead to all sorts of "computer says no" confusion. If you wanted to do that, then you probably would need to speak to them to get the pending stuff sorted first. But keeping the money aside and waiting for them, rather than doing their admin for them, seems fine to me. After all, you've set the DD up, so they could see you're intending to pay.

<Vaguely wonders if something similar has happened with ISP, as they appear to have successfully cancelled the old DD, but not yet taken anything for the new one, but they got the old kit back and the new is installed and working...>

BobnLen · 27/01/2024 11:02

Do people not understand how store cards work, you can only pay what is on there, it only affects your credit score if you don't pay the minimum payment on there, there is £0 on there to pay as of yet. No point in OP making a random payment to a credit card with £0 to pay.

Growlybear83 · 27/01/2024 11:00

Of course you've not done anything wrong, OP. I suspect the vast majority of people who are criticising you are really just jealous that this hasn't happened to them!

VidalSass · 27/01/2024 10:59

Coconutter24 · 27/01/2024 10:49

Normally you can go on your online banking and enter the card details to make a payment to the credit card company. Could you not do that? Or You could sit on it and wait to see what happens but I don’t think I could cope with the wondering. People always seem to assume it’s ok to steal from big companies like that makes it any better than stealing from a small business, it’s still stealing

I can’t make a payment on a zero balance, as far as the credit card is concerned there’s a pre-authorisation on the account that hasn’t been finalised.

I have a receipt for the purchase from the supplier. I’ve actually been in and exchanged one of the items as faulty using the receipt - obviously prior to discovering they haven’t actually charged me…

I agree that yes it could be classed as stealing but on paper I haven’t done anything wrong… I once transferred a large sum of money overseas and the bank teller processed one of the digits wrong, the money ended up being returned but I was still charged a processing fee. The bank refused to refund it. That’s technically stealing too….

OP posts: