Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know it’s stealing….but…..

393 replies

VidalSass · 26/01/2024 00:32

Im going to be Annihilated here……

i took out a store card to pay for a large tech purchase, interest free, over 36months. This was four months ago

I set up a direct debit straight away for the monthly payment and then cut up the card.

I checked my account and noted direct debit not come out, so I logged on to the store card account and the charge is still ‘pending’ - therefore minimum payment is 0 as the charge has not been processed by the merchant.

would I be unreasonable to just ignore it and therefore avoid the repayments? Surely it would eventually just be cancelled? Although it’s already sat there for four months….

i don’t want to call the merchant as obviously they will then just process the charge…..

im worries that eventually it would just be charged but a part of me is excited at the thought that an error may have occurred resulting in me getting free stuff. I know it’s technically stealing but it’s a huge company (probably not paying corporation tax in the uk) and I’m not exactly rolling in it

AIBU - should call the merchant to process the charge and start paying it back

NBU - technically it’s stealing but fuck the man and ride the freebie wave

OP posts:
VidalSass · 26/01/2024 01:50

mirax · 26/01/2024 01:27

Don't worry Op, they will charge you the full amount in 36 months. To those who think there is nothing legally wrong about this, what would you do with say a million wrongly deposited into your account? Sure it is the bank's mistake but there is a firm legal precedent that you have zero rights to the money and are liable to return it. Some very ill-considered advice is being given to OP who seems to have little sense themself.

If the bank accidentally deposited a million dollars into my account and I had the choice to keep it or send it back?

like 99% of people I would keep it.
imight have the odd pang of guilt after umming and aaahing about it for a little while, but ultimately it would change my kids lives so therefore I wouldn’t feel bad about it.

would I take a million quid knowingly, in exchange for making a family homeless, no probably not. Morals aren’t black and white and anyone who thinks so has far less sense than you presume I have.

OP posts:
Abouttoblow · 26/01/2024 01:50

OvxvO · 26/01/2024 00:46

I'd be annoyed at myself but I'd have to phone up. 😩. I like to think of myself as a normal decent person with morals so not paying someone when I know I owe them money wouldn't sit with that.

I think it's scummy, dishonest and cheap not to do anything. I've been sent things by mistake by companies before and have always let the companies know. It's not a dilemma for me as i don't consider keeping stuff that's not mine for a moment.

Amazon once sent and expensive special edition games system, I can't remember which one now but it was worth nearly £500 instead of a set of pans. I let them know and they arranged someone to collect it. It would have been nice if they had let me keep it.

Cam you explain what all these "things companies sent you by mistake" were. Did you order something and receive something else? Or did companies just send you random stuff? Do you think someone else is entering your address by mistake?
What happened when you told them? Did they find out how or why you were sent things.
I'd be really concerned about random people entering my address details.

PyongyangKipperbang · 26/01/2024 01:49

If she saves until she has the full amount the item costs then she has it there if/when they contact her. It is interest free.

After 6 years (prepared to be corrected) as long as the debt isnt acknowledged, then it cannot be legally pursued. But in that 6 years, the interest accruing is in her account, not theirs.

Moro93 · 26/01/2024 01:47

I’m genuinely curious, how long would people recommend saving the money for in a situation like this? Theoretically, they could contact for the money at any point during the 3 years or even afterwards if the mistake is realised.

If the OP saves every payment for 3 years, is she supposed to hold on to it, potentially forever, on the off chance they might realise? Presuming she won’t have the money to pay the cost of the item upfront without saving, otherwise she wouldn’t have taken the credit agreement.
If this is the case then she may as well contact and start making payments…

Namemchangeforthispostonly101 · 26/01/2024 01:40

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns, so we've agreed to take this down now.

PyongyangKipperbang · 26/01/2024 01:39

I dont think that this is fraud or indeed stealing.

The OP can prove that the DD was set up and on what date, she can prove that is it still active on her account. The whole point of a DD over a standing order is that it is claimed by the company taking the money, not pushed by the debtor (as in a standing order). They have the information and the means to take the payments, that they havent is NOT on the OP.

As long as the OP saves the money just in case and argues any late fees on the basis that the payments are late due to their fuck up not her refusal to pay, I think she is morally in the clear and I would certainly argue it legally too.

Youremylobster87 · 26/01/2024 01:32

No way would I chase this up....you've given your DD details. I'd be more than happy to pay if they realised the error but I'd play stupid until then.

Icedlatteplease · 26/01/2024 01:32

Charliecatpaws · 26/01/2024 00:58

Fraud by failing to disclose information (section 3) of the fraud act 2006

How is that relevant,?

As I understand it that covers for example an insurance company not telling you they don't cover something specific or you not saying you have a serious condition to a travel insurance.

I think actually, if you present the item for purchase and the company fails to put through the sale it isnt classed as theft.

That said I'm not sure I'd be comfortable with a large purchase that could go through my credit card at any potentially inconvenient moment.

mirax · 26/01/2024 01:29

I don’t think I would even put the money aside tbh. If it’s a 36 month credit agreement and they’ve failed to process it properly, then the 36 months should start from when they eventually realise. If they do contact you then I’d just start making the monthly payments from scratch and wouldn’t backdate them, it was their mistake. Just feign innocence and say you didn’t realise the payements weren’t going out.

Like I said, this is shite advice.

ActDottie · 26/01/2024 01:28

gurnerandpooch · 26/01/2024 00:33

Ride the freebie wave but be prepared for it to come to light so save the money for if it does

This. If the transaction is pending I have a feeling eventually you’ll have to pay up though.

mirax · 26/01/2024 01:27

Don't worry Op, they will charge you the full amount in 36 months. To those who think there is nothing legally wrong about this, what would you do with say a million wrongly deposited into your account? Sure it is the bank's mistake but there is a firm legal precedent that you have zero rights to the money and are liable to return it. Some very ill-considered advice is being given to OP who seems to have little sense themself.

Moro93 · 26/01/2024 01:23

I agree with what the majority are saying. Don’t do anything. It’s their mistake to fix. If they eventually contact you then start paying.

I don’t think I would even put the money aside tbh. If it’s a 36 month credit agreement and they’ve failed to process it properly, then the 36 months should start from when they eventually realise. If they do contact you then I’d just start making the monthly payments from scratch and wouldn’t backdate them, it was their mistake. Just feign innocence and say you didn’t realise the payements weren’t going out.

People on here can act all holier than thou but the truth is that the majority of people wouldn’t dare contact in a situation like this. Unless they’ve got plenty of money and if that was the case, they wouldn’t be taking out a credit agreement in the first place.

Bringing up morals is ridiculous, she’s not stealing from her own mother or her elderly neighbour!

liveforsummer · 26/01/2024 01:23

@Isittimeformynapyet bit the card numbers etc will still be available via the account- it's rare you need a physical card these days!

moomoomoo27 · 26/01/2024 01:19

They are just going to charge you the full amount in 36 months.

Isittimeformynapyet · 26/01/2024 01:19

Isittimeformynapyet · 26/01/2024 01:16

"Maybe don't use the card again"

This is from the original post, which you have presumably JUST READ...

"I set up a direct debit straight away for the monthly payment and then cut up the card."

Sorry, this was @liveforsummer

Isittimeformynapyet · 26/01/2024 01:16

"Maybe don't use the card again"

This is from the original post, which you have presumably JUST READ...

"I set up a direct debit straight away for the monthly payment and then cut up the card."

Growlybear83 · 26/01/2024 01:16

I expect they will catch up with you eventually and I would set the money aside in case they do. But if you don't hear anything there's no way I would contact them. whatever people on here say, I don't believe the vast majority would do anything other than be delighted that they had possibly got a free item and be a bit jealous that this has happened to you and not them.

gurnerandpooch · 26/01/2024 01:15

It's not fraud . It's not theft. Legally.

See what happens . Be prepared to pay if they ask . If they don't ......it's their issue

penjil · 26/01/2024 01:14

OP, ignore all the bashing comments about morals.

Just sit right and see what happens. It's not your problem to sort.

Put some money aside for if the direct debit does ever get sorted their end.

penjil · 26/01/2024 01:12

You've kept up your end of it.

Whatever the problem is, it's their end and they must deal with it.

Don't do their job for them.

gurnerandpooch · 26/01/2024 01:11

Mn is mean , nasty , vindictive, yet everyone is a moral saviour according to these threads ! Makes me laugh .

Like fuck would everyone own up to this . Sanctimonious shite .

HollyKnight · 26/01/2024 01:10

I would probably call tbh just so it looks like I tried to address the issue in case they try to charge you interest or something. It will be easier to argue against paying extra if you can show you actively tried to sort this.

AnnieSnap · 26/01/2024 01:10

VidalSass · 26/01/2024 00:47

Is it fraud though? I entered a contract with the merchant, they have processed their end of the contract therefore I can’t process mine? It’s not like I have false information with the intention of getting free equipment? I don’t know I’m processing all the options

No it’s not fraud at all. You signed your DD agreement (in person, or virtually), it’s down to the company to request the money from your bank. The error here is theirs, not yours. If they come back to you with any extra charges, or interest, you should challenge them. Plenty of people (foolishly) don’t check their bank account transactions. They would never be guilty of fraud when they believed a DD was being paid until the company in question wrote to them to highlight a problem.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 26/01/2024 01:07

You are still acting with intent to defraud them in the moral sense if not the legal one. No matter what excuses you want to wrap this up in it's still theft and it's still wrong. Our morals aren't the things we do in public they are how we act when no one is watching or will know what we've done or said. If you do this you're a thief whether you want to admit it to yourself or not.

liveforsummer · 26/01/2024 01:06

You're probably asking I the wrong place because on MN if you forget to scan your Asda carrier bag and don't make the 10 mile journey back to pay for it you're a theif nowhere in real life most of us would sit tight and see what I occurred. Maybe don't use the card again