Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people have no idea how little HLTAs/Teaching Assistants earn?

754 replies

LorlieS · 25/01/2024 22:58

Anybody want to hazard a guess at the average monthly income of a ft HLTA/TA?

It really is quite shocking!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
notyourmummy · 27/01/2024 12:30

happypillsareworking · 27/01/2024 12:18

Since when do we get that pay rise every year! I had not had a pay rise in years until this year!!

The TAs in my school get in on the dot of 9 and leave on the dot of 330. Totally understandable, they are not paid enough to hang around. They don't do any work at home.

Like has been mentioned before it's not a salary issue it's the number of hours you can work issue.

Wow, the TA's in your school wouldn't last 5 mins at my school - I do on average 10hrs work at home a week, rarely get a full dinner break and work well over my normal hours. Some don't and they're massively frowned upon!!

miniaturepixieonacid · 27/01/2024 12:29

I actually do think TAs are paid enough for what they should do - the problem is that so many are asked/made to do a lot more than that.

The qualifications point is a bit of a red herring - yes, lots of TAs are highly qualified. But because they don't need to be, the pay doesn't reflect the qualifications. People with high qualifications are choosing to apply for the jobs but the jobs aren't requring them to have those qualifications so don't pay in line with them.

One of our TAs has a PHD and is referred to as Dr Surname. Another of our TAs took her GCSE Maths and English exams last year in her early 30s. Before that she had no qualifications. They both get paid the same (I assume, I don't actually know) because they both do the same job.

Our TAs finish at 3pm when the school day doesn't finish till 4:30 or later. They are not required to attend staff meetings (they do have to do inset but get paid for it). They are not required to plan or mark. They are not required to teach a whole class. They would not be involved in IEPs, EHCPs or multi agency meetings unless a specificed 1:1 teacher (which comes with higher pay and a qualification requirement). They are not expected to do any work in the evenings, weekends or holidays. What they do do is work with individual children and small groups to help them to what the teacher has planned and taught, lots and lots of supervision and support of children and lots of displays, admin, setting up and clearing away. They are absolutely essential to our school but they don't need the high qualifications that some of them have to do those things. Our staff choose the job because they enjoy it, it's low stress and it's convenient for their families.

In other schools, I know the TAs would not recongise the expectations above. Instead, they are expected to act as teachers but for half the pay. That's what isn't ok.

Ace56 · 27/01/2024 12:29

@LorlieS You can’t complain about the low pay but then also scoff at anyone who suggests getting a better job 😂 and yes, you were complaining as you mentioned you and your husband struggling to make ends meet…You either love your low paid job and accept that the pay is shit, or can’t accept that the pay is shit so decide to leave.

TAs do get paid too little for what they do, yes, but that’s not going to change any time soon (if ever).

itispersonal · 27/01/2024 12:25

@happypillsareworking I also personally can't moan- my contracted hours are 8.35 til 3.55 but I'm paid a salary not a wage! But I know from other schools / friends in different they do the same as myself for a much less wage! Hence it being something I fight for, for others!

TheCircusOfLife · 27/01/2024 12:23

@itispersonal So what would your solution be? How much do you think a TA should be paid? The reason it is a low paid job is because it is PT and requires no qualifications, it has nothing to do with being 'women's work.'

itispersonal · 27/01/2024 12:22

@happypillsareworking
It is definitely a pay issue - £10.50ph for the duties and responsibilities we do is not right! Is it comparable to my dh who does actually work in a supermarket no!

happypillsareworking · 27/01/2024 12:21

itispersonal · 27/01/2024 12:19

@happypillsareworking I get an pay rise each year as my scale point on the grade goes up! Also in my LA the wages have gone up each year!

Wow I'm working in the wrong place but I am at the top of the scale. No pay rise here for years

LorlieS · 27/01/2024 12:21

@itispersonal They don't go up automatically each year here. And what happens when a teacher reaches M6?

OP posts:
itispersonal · 27/01/2024 12:19

@happypillsareworking I get an pay rise each year as my scale point on the grade goes up! Also in my LA the wages have gone up each year!

happypillsareworking · 27/01/2024 12:18

itispersonal · 27/01/2024 03:44

@Boomboom22 you don't think £1000 a month in take home pay is enough difference between an ups teacher and a TA!

TAs also don't have a nice teachers pension to retire on, nor will the our pay go up more than 2-3% per year. Even if we move up a grade we are talking what 50p an hour if that!

Since when do we get that pay rise every year! I had not had a pay rise in years until this year!!

The TAs in my school get in on the dot of 9 and leave on the dot of 330. Totally understandable, they are not paid enough to hang around. They don't do any work at home.

Like has been mentioned before it's not a salary issue it's the number of hours you can work issue.

itispersonal · 27/01/2024 12:16

TheCircusOfLife · 27/01/2024 12:04

@itispersonal that first paragraph is just completely off on a tangent and a another discussion altogether. No, not all people can just get better jobs! That is the whole premise of my argument.

No the OP is saying TAs are poorly paid which they are in the vast majority. You say she shouldn't moan as she could earn more! That doesn't address the poor wage for the sector does it!

Sunshine322 · 27/01/2024 12:05

LorlieS · 27/01/2024 11:31

@TheCircusOfLife I think I know you! Did you study Sculpture at Saint Martin's College? 😀

🤣🤣

TheCircusOfLife · 27/01/2024 12:04

@itispersonal that first paragraph is just completely off on a tangent and a another discussion altogether. No, not all people can just get better jobs! That is the whole premise of my argument.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 27/01/2024 12:03

Futb0l · 27/01/2024 11:08

But its a very part time role?

Its shorter hours than a normal 9-5.30. For many people it comes with very little commute as there are schools everywhere. You get 12 weeks off per year.

Its a minimum wage job, thats true. Its pointless talking about the annual income and comparing it to full time jobs when it works out at not much more than 50-60% of a full time job.

But that's one of the issues that we have.

It's pt therefore a women's = mother & wife job.

The wages are so low that only a cretin demographic of people are able and willing to do the job.
What does that teach our children?

Not lucky enough to have met a male teaching assistant that was willing to stick to it longer than 12 months!

itispersonal · 27/01/2024 11:54

TheCircusOfLife · 27/01/2024 11:23

@LorlieS Working class people don't just become 'high earners' they work extraordinarily hard for it. Both my husband and I were (still are) working class.
No, my kids were never privately educated. They are at uni now and work PT jobs.

No, I NEVER said your work is less valuable as you are a qualified teacher. The role is valuable regardless of who is doing it. My point was, you're not happy about your wages when you have the ability to do something about it... many people dont' have that choice.

Edited

So we shouldn't do anything about the rubbish wage of this job or other sectors which are primarily seen as women's work because we can get better jobs! Who does the TA roles then or the care work? And we all know the care sector is knackered because of the poor wages and conditions! I've also worked in that too.

School can't function without TAs because of the needs of children who are now attending mainstream school!

We can absolute moan about the rubbish wages, and the ever expanding list of duties and responsibilities we are expected to do when most are paid slightly more per hour than they would get at Aldi! Like others have said our role needs to be valued by parents, teacher and government more than as 'an assistant to the teacher' and actually reflect the new role to match the demands of the job and education as it is!

TheCircusOfLife · 27/01/2024 11:33

@LorlieS No. I'm in Chemical Engineering.

LorlieS · 27/01/2024 11:31

@TheCircusOfLife I think I know you! Did you study Sculpture at Saint Martin's College? 😀

OP posts:
TheCircusOfLife · 27/01/2024 11:29

@LorlieS 'Ah so that's why "working-class" people don't all work well-paid jobs...because they're lazy(!!)'

What on Earth? How have you come to that conclusion. My parents never earned high salaries, but they worked extremely hard and were fantastic parents. However, YOU are choosing to work PT hours though and with that comes PT wages.

LorlieS · 27/01/2024 11:25

@TheCircusOfLife Ah so that's why "working-class" people don't all work well-paid jobs...because they're lazy(!!)

OP posts:
TheCircusOfLife · 27/01/2024 11:23

@LorlieS Working class people don't just become 'high earners' they work extraordinarily hard for it. Both my husband and I were (still are) working class.
No, my kids were never privately educated. They are at uni now and work PT jobs.

No, I NEVER said your work is less valuable as you are a qualified teacher. The role is valuable regardless of who is doing it. My point was, you're not happy about your wages when you have the ability to do something about it... many people dont' have that choice.

LorlieS · 27/01/2024 11:19

@TheCircusOfLife WIth respect, you're both high earners with privately educated children(?) so how would you know how it is? You don't.

I lived your lifestyle once. It was far more miserable than the one I'm living now!

Yes my life isn't easy, and yes TAs should be paid more for the job they do. But clearly you think my work as a TA is less valuable because I'm a qualified teacher(!)

OP posts:
TheCircusOfLife · 27/01/2024 11:18

@LorlieS I don't think I've mentioned what my husband earns. But he is a higher earner yes. I earn well but that is because I worked toward a career that I knew would be a higher salary. I grew up very poor,(electric running out on the metre, bailiffs etc) I know what it is to struggle and it is absolutely miserable and stressful. At least it's within your power to earn more being qualified. It's the TAs who don't have any means to earn a higher wage that I feel sorry for as it is valuable work.

Futb0l · 27/01/2024 11:10

Notyourmummy why not do something else then? There are loads of other occupationa offering better pay

Futb0l · 27/01/2024 11:08

But its a very part time role?

Its shorter hours than a normal 9-5.30. For many people it comes with very little commute as there are schools everywhere. You get 12 weeks off per year.

Its a minimum wage job, thats true. Its pointless talking about the annual income and comparing it to full time jobs when it works out at not much more than 50-60% of a full time job.

TheCircusOfLife · 27/01/2024 11:05

'I struggle to pay the rent and provide for my 3 kids. I have a husband but he works ft in social care so doesn't earn a great salary.
Between us we come out with under £3k p/m with no other support. It's bloody difficult and I know we're by no means the worst off'

'As a HLTA with 3 kids, rent to pay and a low-earning husband, I wish I was in the position to be working for "fun" money. It's rough 😞'

Struggling financially in a job you love can be just as depressing as earning well in a job you hate.