Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not bother with swimming lessons for DS yet?

63 replies

ThreadLasso · 25/01/2024 21:35

DS has just turned 4. Had a couple of swimming lessons a few months ago but the teacher left and we couldn't make the alternative time offered (too late in evening).

He's been on a waiting list for weekend lessons since. He's now been offered a place but it's for the 8am class. Sometimes he's awake really early but sometimes he's still asleep at 7, so feel like it would often be a battle and a rush to get there. I also have a baby DD so me or DH would have to take DS, and the other entertain DD at home, meaning neither adult could have a lie in.

But he's 4 and can't swim, so don't know if I should be concerned about this and do whatever it takes to get him into lessons?

Or is it ok not to bother until a more convenient time comes up? Or maybe when he's in school just do some intensive courses? And in the interim just take him swimming for fun?

AIBU to say no to the 8am lesson?

OP posts:
Ginandjuice57884 · 25/01/2024 21:57

Just take him swimming yourself when it's convenient?

CuriousMoe · 25/01/2024 21:56

I think it probably depends on how likely you think you are to need it. I was a later swimmer (9yo) but my mum put me in 1-1 classes for a few months and within a year I was an excellent swimmer and was taking part in school galas. We hardly ever went on holiday though and didn’t live near the water. That being said I’ve literally just today started Water Babies with my 7 month old, but my in laws have 2 holiday homes, both with swimming pools with no barriers and no shallow end and we spend a lot of time there in the summer so we want him to be confident in the water as soon as possible for peace of mind.

Catsandcuddles · 25/01/2024 21:55

We took our son swimming when he was nearly 3 for about 9 months. I saw no progress at all and my son was just stubborn about it and didn't want to do it. Pulled him out of it, he wasn't enjoying it and the instructor wasn't right and it was a waste of money.

He will be 5 this year and I've just booked him on a 1 to 1 intensive swimming course over the Feb half term. Its expensive at £30 a lesson but the instructor reckons at his age she will get him to swim in about 10 lessons. So we will book again for April holidays and see how that goes!

I wouldn't fancy a lesson at 8am though, I think that is too early

confusedlots · 25/01/2024 21:51

I'm not sure I'd be rushing to get to an 8am lesson! Mine did water babies when they were very small, then stopped altogether for a few years due to Covid and a few other life stressors. They started again about 6 months ago, 2 children to 1 teacher. My 7 year old has really come on in the past few weeks, and although clearly not as good as other younger children I see swimming, she's definitely getting there. The younger one has a bit further to go, but I'm sure they will get there too.

Sonora25 · 25/01/2024 21:50

4 is a good age to start lessons and the more confident and able a child is in swimming the better. You will have more fun on holidays, at pools and of course of course it’s safer! 8am is a bad time I agree, maybe try it for a bit. Or find a different school.

but no sport or hobby is as crucial as swimming and believe me that you will be so relieved when you have a confident swimmer.

hernandee · 25/01/2024 21:49

We do an 8am swimming lesson for DD aged 5. It's early for her, she wakes at 7am and eats breakfast on the way. But we chose that time because we spend time as a family at weekends so we often book theatre show or concerts (which start at 10.30/11am), travel to a museum or some other attractions which is far enough and interesting enough to fill the day. Sometimes we'll have a birthday party too- it's guaranteed never to clash (I know some other dcs in her class have had to turn down party invites because of weekend classes they have booked for the term). So it works really well for us.

We do a family leisure swim as well on a Sunday - but she would not have made the kind of progress she has just splashing for fun. Her lessons are 1:1 or 2:1 - and it's far more detailed than simple water confidence and blowing bubbles.

NoTouch · 25/01/2024 21:48

Start saving the money now you would be spending on years of group lessons and spend it on 1-1 lessons when he is 7-8.

Thats what we did. Just under year of swimming lessons then rookie life guard was more than enough, dont know how parents manage to sit through them for years and years on end with little progression and keep their sanity.

Anahenzaris · 25/01/2024 21:47

It really depends whether there’s water around you or not. Swimming is an essential skill. I live in a coastal community, backyard pools are common, creeks and rivers are everywhere. If you’re somewhere without pools/creeks/ etc it’s not as time critical - still important as when kids don’t learn they often don’t as adults.

Kids drown. Adults drown. Non-swimmers drown far more often than good swimmers. Kids drown quickly and quietly. Always keeping your eyes on the kid is good in theory - works less well in practice. We’ve had at least 2 child drownings in my community recently. You don’t hear about the near drownings that can have life-long consequences.

I’d say take the lessons. 8am is a horrible time, but swimming is essential. Your kids will likely be in lessons for years. But if they fall into water they need to know how to float / get to the side until there is help. They need to not panic. They need lessons to get there - and 8am is what is on offer.

I’d keep looking for later classes though and switch if something comes up.

NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 25/01/2024 21:42

As someone who can't swim because my mum fell out with the teacher and pulled me out of the classes 6 weeks in, I think swimming is very important and I was upset when DS was a baby that I couldn't get him into baby swim due to Covid closures.

However, DS is 4 now and doing lessons. They basically get pulled up and down the water while wearing a pool noodle and about once a lesson they float like a starfish, blow bubbles in the water, and jump in the pool from the side. It seems to be more about building confidence than actual swimming skills.

So I don't think they're missing much at this age that you couldn't do by just going to public swim at a time that suits you.

Boomarang · 25/01/2024 21:42

Mine are 8 and 11.

Oldest started lessons in a good swimming school aged 6, small classes, excellent teachers. Completed all stages and extremely competent by 10 (competing).

8 year old started at 6 and a half. Following a similar trajectory.

I’m a shit swimmer (sort of Bob about)…

I firmly believe the quality of the lessons/ small class sizes is more important than the age they start. I’d rather save my pennies when they are very very little (thus progress more slowly) and put the money into good quality classes once they can really get going, they understand and can put instruction into practice so much easier. The

s4usagefingers · 25/01/2024 21:41

Just do swim for fun. I never had lessons growing up but learned to swim around age 5 and always had confidence in water. I couldn’t swim in any competitions though!

JinglePringle · 25/01/2024 21:39

Ds has been able to do life saving swimming (roll over, float and kick to the side) since he was 2, swimming is really important to me.

However 9 times out of 10 I wouldn't make it to an 8am lesson because ds would be too sleepy/crabby. So I would wait for a better time.

Winterstars · 25/01/2024 21:38

We are in a similar boat, it’s a bit of a pain but we all go. I do the lesson with DS and DH takes baby DD and goes to get a sausage sandwich. DS is 3 and we used to go on a Friday morning but can’t now due to the baby. I miss those days, it felt so much more relaxed!

Swipe left for the next trending thread