Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not bother with swimming lessons for DS yet?

63 replies

ThreadLasso · 25/01/2024 21:35

DS has just turned 4. Had a couple of swimming lessons a few months ago but the teacher left and we couldn't make the alternative time offered (too late in evening).

He's been on a waiting list for weekend lessons since. He's now been offered a place but it's for the 8am class. Sometimes he's awake really early but sometimes he's still asleep at 7, so feel like it would often be a battle and a rush to get there. I also have a baby DD so me or DH would have to take DS, and the other entertain DD at home, meaning neither adult could have a lie in.

But he's 4 and can't swim, so don't know if I should be concerned about this and do whatever it takes to get him into lessons?

Or is it ok not to bother until a more convenient time comes up? Or maybe when he's in school just do some intensive courses? And in the interim just take him swimming for fun?

AIBU to say no to the 8am lesson?

OP posts:
LadyMinerva · 26/01/2024 03:25

I'll be the one to go against the grain.

Children can drown in as little as 5cm of water. They should be in lessons of some sort from when they are babies.

I would make the effort to take the class that I can get until another became available. I wouldn't choose lazing around in bed over my childs life.

I'm not saying this to be dramatic or shame you, i've just seen first hand the consequences of children not being water smart. It's harrowing.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 26/01/2024 03:08

Id happily wait a year, you're still closely supervising at that age. My DD learnt to swim really well at 7 within a year, her brother was 4 years old when we started and has barely progressed.

AgentJohnson · 26/01/2024 03:06

DD learnt to swim when she was eight because of waiting lists but it worked out in the end because she accelerated through her badges because of her age. Many of her peers who started much earlier, also took longer to become proficient. I started swimming at 4 and hated it, I just wasn’t ready and never got pleasure from doing it because it was such a chore.

Swimming is an important skill to learn but it shouldn’t be a chore, every child is different.

Winterstars · 26/01/2024 02:53

I know different places have different setups but at ours parents go in the pool with the child. So taking the baby wouldn’t work!

Kokeshi123 · 26/01/2024 00:02

We blitzed it with an intensive course of 1-1 lessons at 7; each lesson was pricy, but we needed few of them, so it cost the same as 2 years of slowly-progressing group lessons and produced the same amount of progress in a very short amount of time. We didn't want every weekend sacrificed to swimming lessons for years on end, so this was an efficient way for us to do things.

Other people, though, enjoy doing the pool each week and meeting the other parents for a chat, so it's fine to start early and do things gradually too if you prefer.

Moier · 25/01/2024 23:56

Can't you all go as a family?. My Mum took us.. l took my daughters from six weeks old.. they take their sons.. we still go every week now.. they all were swimming without armbands age 3 and under water.. they need to learn the survival float on back like a starfish..

NewName24 · 25/01/2024 23:22

I would take it.

Don't get me wrong, I love a lie in. I am definitely not a morning person, but getting up early just goes with the territory of having small dc.
Even I wouldn't (well, didn't) prioritise lying in over taking my dc to activities.
Learning to swim is really important in my book, and plenty of children learn well at 4 yrs old.

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 25/01/2024 22:59

I would take it, but also alternate which parent takes him each week. That parent can take the baby too quite easily. Take him swim ready, strip off and into pool while you sit on the side with the baby in pushchair or sling, then quick change into clothes in changing room and home for shower/bath etc

We've done early morming lessons and we do just a banana or something on the way then proper breakfast at home afterwards

Essie274 · 25/01/2024 22:55

FoxtrotSkarloey · 25/01/2024 22:42

I think it's fine to wait a year if needs be.

I would take hike yourselves so he enjoys the water.

ROFL at the expectation of a lie in then you have a four year old and a younger one.

I don't understand the ROFL if the children have two parents. I have a 4yo and 1yo and one parent has a lie in every Saturday here, other parent supervises Saturday morning Bluey viewing then takes 4yo to dance class (with 1yo - we go for a coffee). Lie in parent is expected to have cooked something yummy for lunch on our return at midday.

Essie274 · 25/01/2024 22:51

My eldest is just turned 4yo and has been in swimming lessons for 6 months. His confidence has improved, but his actual level of swimming hasn't really since the second week (when he learned to actually kick). The lessons are partially council funded so work out at only £3.20 a week, which is considerably cheaper than DH or me taking him each week so we will continue with it (and take him swimming ourselves when we can!). I wouldn't personally see any value in the same style of group lessons where you pay £8+ a week for such slow progression.

8am on a Saturday is an awful time. I'd hold out for a better slot, honestly - and in the mean time take him yourself!

FoxtrotSkarloey · 25/01/2024 22:43

*take him not hike!!

FoxtrotSkarloey · 25/01/2024 22:42

I think it's fine to wait a year if needs be.

I would take hike yourselves so he enjoys the water.

ROFL at the expectation of a lie in then you have a four year old and a younger one.

PercyPigInAWig · 25/01/2024 22:33

There is no way I would book an 8am slot, DC don’t wake up until after that and on a Saturday neither do I if I can help it.

I would bring the child swimming for fun and join a list for a class at a more civilised time.

Mandarinaduck · 25/01/2024 22:22

Definitely not worth disrupting sleep and routine for swimming lessons for an only just 4 year old in my view.

SkankingWombat · 25/01/2024 22:21

Could the parent going swimming take the baby too, giving the other parent a lie in? Alternate who gets the lie in each week.

I would stick with the 8am session whilst being on the waiting list for a later one.
PPs have given anecdotes about their DCs being late to start but who have progressed quickly and caught up. I have also seen plenty of DCs start later and be very slow to progress because they lack water confidence. It can be a much harder barrier to overcome the older you get - the extreme end of this is the adult beginners' class, where it can take a really really long time for them to even put their faces in the water.
IME starting young didn't equate to a prolonged period of little progress and hours wasted. DD1 completed the learn to swim program at 8yo (everything but fly was passed at 7.5yo, but it took another 6 months to get the strength to consistently swim 25m of 'Swim England Standard' butterfly, as judged by a very strict teacher). She's 9.5yo now, and about to compete at Counties this weekend for the first time. DD2 is 7.5yo and on the cusp of finishing level 7 (just the synchronised swim routine to go!), so DD1 wasn't a complete fluke!

PerfectTravelTote · 25/01/2024 22:18

You've got time to wait for a more convenient slot. Anytime in the next year or two is fine.

Unicornpuzzle · 25/01/2024 22:14

Same. Saturday morning first activity with DC1 is at 8am, second activity with DC2 at 10am , third activity with DC2 at 10.30am.

Sunday morning DC1 activity at 9am and DC2 different activity at 9am.

We devide and conquer and no lie ins...

And both DCs go for swimming, it's a life skill after all.

Gloriousgardener11 · 25/01/2024 22:13

I don’t think you should worry too much about having proper lessons until he is 5 or 6. You could just take him to the swimming baths for fun and to gain confidence.
However I very firmly believe that learning to swim is an important life skill and could one day save his life.

BogRollBOGOF · 25/01/2024 22:13

At 4, it's nice to have lessons for fun and water confidence, but a lot of children aren't ready to learn to swim properly at that age and progress can be slow.

I've got a 10 & 13 yo in stage 7... they've both been going since Foundation at age 4. I've viewed it as weekly exercise anyway, but it wasn't the most efficient route.

If the lesson time is going to be an aggro, I'd hold out for something more convenient. 6-7 are ages where most children have more co-ordination to learn more efficiently.

Rewis · 25/01/2024 22:09

You don't need formal lessons (at least yet). You can just go swimming and later enroll them in a class if you want/need

MissAtomicBomb1 · 25/01/2024 22:09

Wouldn't worry too much about starting yet but I think I'd def be looking to have lessons in place between age 5-6.
If you start them too early it seems to just be a year or two of blowing bubbles and building confidence which frankly you probably don't need. It also depends on your child. I'm gobsmacked by the posters that have said they didn't bother with lessons. Neither of mine have been natural swimmers and it's been a long slog of 1:1 and group lessons to get them to be half decent swimmers.
My eldest has stopped lessons now but we still take him for regular swims as he forgets! Thankfully his school have a pool and also offer lessons.

aynsleyredder · 25/01/2024 22:07

Can you not take the 8am lessons and ask to be put on a waiting list for a more convenient time?
My son is 4 and almost swimming without armbands (had lessons for a year), so I’d be inclined to keep them going. Unless you intend to take him swimming yourself regularly to keep his up his confidence in the water.

hotginbottle · 25/01/2024 22:07

Could you not wake him up rather than rely on his natural waking time?

I'd take the 8am. Gets it over with and doesn't screw up the rest of the weekend. If he is not at school, you will be grateful for freeer Saturdays.

NewName24 · 25/01/2024 22:04

Generally speaking, the beginners lessons do tend to be the first lesson in the morning, as there is a correlation -
Beginners tend to be youngest children.
Youngest children tend to be the early risers.

So the odds are that all the beginners lessons are going to be the early starts.

Nevermind31 · 25/01/2024 21:59

I would go but stay on the wait list. But also, parent who goes can take baby along too, so other parent can get a lie in.
at 4, my DC could float, and swim about 5-10 m - that would get you out of a pool if you fell in.