Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people aren’t worried about this??

840 replies

Mummytotwonow · 25/01/2024 19:28

https://news.sky.com/story/time-to-think-the-unthinkable-and-consider-uk-conscription-says-britains-former-top-nato-commander-13056148

Sorry if I’ve missed any threads on this.

It’s not just sky news reporting this but for days now in the media this is being raised.

AIBU - to be extremely worried and concerned about this?

Is anyone else not worried?? Are we being prepared ready as “the higher up” know more and the threat is bigger than we’re told.

what age would it be from and to??

l‘m so scared for the world our children are growing up in 😢

Time to 'think the unthinkable' and consider UK conscription, says Britain's former top NATO commander

General Sir Richard Sherriff tells Sky News that even if Russia is defeated in the war against Ukraine, it is going to remain determined to rebuild another empire, subjugate Ukraine, and then move on to other ex-Soviet countries, like NATO members. Tha...

https://news.sky.com/story/time-to-think-the-unthinkable-and-consider-uk-conscription-says-britains-former-top-nato-commander-13056148

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
WinterMorn · 27/01/2024 17:38

Fair enough 🙂 it just seems to me to be an important way that non-Ukrainians can make the distinction. You will have seen earlier on in this post that not everyone grasps this.

zendeveloper · 27/01/2024 17:36

WinterMorn · 27/01/2024 17:26

Well, it would be nice if you were bothered as the Ukrainian people have specifically expressed their preference for this.

Well, I am also "Ukrainian people", we are allowed to have different opinions on the topic, kinda spoiled by the democracy and stuff. There is indeed a preference, but it is not a hill anyone would die on - what people say in this case is much more important than how they say it.

WinterMorn · 27/01/2024 17:26

zendeveloper · 27/01/2024 16:49

In Russian, the same effect is achieved by using a different preposition (referring to Ukraine as a territory and not a country). "The Ukraine" stems from exactly the same ideology, and roughly from the same time.
Having said that, I can't be really bothered much about anglophones using "the" or not, if otherwise they express a pro-Ukrainian sentiment, as it is an obscure technicality. It has always been a litmus test for Russians though.

Well, it would be nice if you were bothered as the Ukrainian people have specifically expressed their preference for this.

Wantthisfriend · 27/01/2024 17:11

Perturbed that most of this thread assumes conscription would be directed at males. Lets bring up 'strong' women and promote equality for women and transsexuals? Only when it suits us it seems....

SharonEllis · 27/01/2024 17:10

windowframer · 27/01/2024 16:13

There seems to be some misunderstanding here. I'm certainly not "shilling" for anyone. I think Putin is a vile piece of work, Russia's implementation of democracy a farce, the invasion of Ukraine completely unjustified and the western powers correct in opposing it. I hope that helps clarify things.

There are two different issues being conflated here: what political and electoral system a country has, in theory and on paper, and how transparently the processes of that system are followed to honestly deliver what it claims to deliver.

Russia is a multi-party representative democracy. That is just a fact. They hold elections and people vote for a choice of different candidates from different parties. Are the processes surrounding this fair, transparent and honourable enough for it to deliver what democracy is supposed to deliver? Hell no. (Although it must be remembered that Putin appears to be very popular within Russia. Sometimes democracy actually destroys itself - as it looks like it may also soon do in the USA.)

The UK is also a multi-party representative democracy. We hold elections and people vote for a choice of diffeent candidates from different parties. Are the processes surrounding this fair, transparent and honourable enough for it to deliver what democracy is supposed to deliver? Hell no.

OK, for the avoidance of doubt: Russia is worse. It's further down the road of authoritarianism than we are. And the British have always been peculiarly good at dressing up the exercise of raw power in civilised enough garb to make it look like something else. But this honestly just looks like a matter of degree to me, and not a large enough one to inspire me to go and fight to defend "British values" as though they're something different in kind and thereby sacred.

Gosh, this is silly. Of course Putin uses the veneer of democratic legitimacy to prop up his regime. Its absolutely essential to the way he holds onto power and controls dissent. But it is not 'worse' on a spectrum of more or less democracy that you can put alongside the UK. Here is just one example of a prisoner of conscience in Russia Russia: Fears of prisoner of conscience Aleksei Navalny forcibly disappeared - Amnesty International This just does not happen in the UK, even though we have and always have had miscarriages of justice. All democracies are imperfect, all governments try to overstep the mark in some way to achieve their ends, all citizens have to be alert to it, and democracy is not fixed - it is debated and reframed by every generation. I don't recall anyone talking about 'sacred' values. I certainly didn't mention it. I do think liberal democracies have values that are worth arguing about, holding onto, living and fighting for. They are contested every day, and that's the point. Just ask any of the refugees that risk their lives every day to come her. Just ask any of the Holocaust survivors and their descendants.

Russia: Fears of prisoner of conscience Aleksei Navalny forcibly disappeared

As if attempted poisoning, imprisonment and inhumane conditions of detention were not enough, Aleksei Navalny may now have been subjected to an enforced disappearance. In its resolve to suppress its critics, the Kremlin will stop at nothing

https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2023/12/russia-fears-of-prisoner-of-conscience-aleksei-navalny-forcibly-disappeared/

TempestTost · 27/01/2024 17:04

There is something very odd about people saying they'd just as soon be governed by Russia, because they can't stand the idea of the UK having conscription.

rainingsnoring · 27/01/2024 17:03

Naptrappedmummy · 27/01/2024 16:50

LBC are asking people to phone in and say whether they would comply with the conscription…

More scaremongering in the right wing media. The Telegraph is full of it in the last few days.

Naptrappedmummy · 27/01/2024 16:50

LBC are asking people to phone in and say whether they would comply with the conscription…

zendeveloper · 27/01/2024 16:49

raspberryjuiceandpompoms · 27/01/2024 13:56

Ukrainian wheat is 9% of world trade. China is 17%, followed by India followed by Russia. FYI. Actually in 2020 Ukrainian wheat was 3.1% of the global trade

and there can’t be Russian styling of THE Ukraine or Ukraine because Russians speak Russian and not English therefore they don’t have THE particle…

Edited

In Russian, the same effect is achieved by using a different preposition (referring to Ukraine as a territory and not a country). "The Ukraine" stems from exactly the same ideology, and roughly from the same time.
Having said that, I can't be really bothered much about anglophones using "the" or not, if otherwise they express a pro-Ukrainian sentiment, as it is an obscure technicality. It has always been a litmus test for Russians though.

windowframer · 27/01/2024 16:13

SharonEllis · 27/01/2024 14:34

It is. What does a person get out of shilling for an authoritarian regime and spreading such blatant, cynical misinformation? I wonder if its a school project or somethin ( I mean they are not very intelligent or sophisticated!) - to show how easy it is to disrupt an online conversation? I guess none of us are buying it, which is something.

There seems to be some misunderstanding here. I'm certainly not "shilling" for anyone. I think Putin is a vile piece of work, Russia's implementation of democracy a farce, the invasion of Ukraine completely unjustified and the western powers correct in opposing it. I hope that helps clarify things.

There are two different issues being conflated here: what political and electoral system a country has, in theory and on paper, and how transparently the processes of that system are followed to honestly deliver what it claims to deliver.

Russia is a multi-party representative democracy. That is just a fact. They hold elections and people vote for a choice of different candidates from different parties. Are the processes surrounding this fair, transparent and honourable enough for it to deliver what democracy is supposed to deliver? Hell no. (Although it must be remembered that Putin appears to be very popular within Russia. Sometimes democracy actually destroys itself - as it looks like it may also soon do in the USA.)

The UK is also a multi-party representative democracy. We hold elections and people vote for a choice of diffeent candidates from different parties. Are the processes surrounding this fair, transparent and honourable enough for it to deliver what democracy is supposed to deliver? Hell no.

OK, for the avoidance of doubt: Russia is worse. It's further down the road of authoritarianism than we are. And the British have always been peculiarly good at dressing up the exercise of raw power in civilised enough garb to make it look like something else. But this honestly just looks like a matter of degree to me, and not a large enough one to inspire me to go and fight to defend "British values" as though they're something different in kind and thereby sacred.

Justpontificating · 27/01/2024 15:47

Daisyislazy · 27/01/2024 13:10

If they can manage to get my 18 year old out of bed, washed, dressed in ironed uniform, wearing polished boots by 6 in the morning then they can have him

Love this!
crashing back down to reality here 🤣🤣

WinterMorn · 27/01/2024 14:38

I have just reported a multiple poster who is really whipping up fear

rainingsnoring · 27/01/2024 14:36

What is shameful is the amount of scaremongering rubbish in the press.

SharonEllis · 27/01/2024 14:34

WinterMorn · 27/01/2024 14:28

It’s shameful isn’t it?

It is. What does a person get out of shilling for an authoritarian regime and spreading such blatant, cynical misinformation? I wonder if its a school project or somethin ( I mean they are not very intelligent or sophisticated!) - to show how easy it is to disrupt an online conversation? I guess none of us are buying it, which is something.

WinterMorn · 27/01/2024 14:28

It’s shameful isn’t it?

SharonEllis · 27/01/2024 14:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Shadowsindarkplaces · 27/01/2024 14:20

Daisyislazy · 27/01/2024 13:10

If they can manage to get my 18 year old out of bed, washed, dressed in ironed uniform, wearing polished boots by 6 in the morning then they can have him

Grin
WinterMorn · 27/01/2024 14:02

@EasternStandard yes, I was. I agree that this has become the replacement drum to beat. It’s the same crowd all over again.

ProtectMotherNature · 27/01/2024 14:00

The thought of our nation not being able to defend itself terrifies me. What also puzzles me is that our government is really fond of trumpeting how vulnerable we are. In May 2023, there were questions regarding the detrimental affects to our RAF due to the of training Ukrainian pilots; at that time the government were still toying with the idea of more cuts to the armed forces, or increases due to growing security threats in Europe. The costs of maintaining our armed forces is immense; if our current government hadn't squandered so much money over this past 14 years, maybe we wouldn't be in such a mess now. Ukraine is - by default, fighting on our behalf and we cannot afford, in any way, shape or form to stop supporting them.

windowframer · 27/01/2024 13:59

SharonEllis · 27/01/2024 13:32

You are quite the joker aren't you?

You think that's a joke? I'm struggling to work out what's even questionable about it. We know what his policies are (to the extent that he has any) and his actions as Labour leader are a matter of public record, albeit not widely reported. This is just factual.

EasternStandard · 27/01/2024 13:59

WinterMorn · 27/01/2024 13:33

There are some very warped views on here

Were you on here for Covid?

I guess this is this version for now

raspberryjuiceandpompoms · 27/01/2024 13:56

Ukrainian wheat is 9% of world trade. China is 17%, followed by India followed by Russia. FYI. Actually in 2020 Ukrainian wheat was 3.1% of the global trade

and there can’t be Russian styling of THE Ukraine or Ukraine because Russians speak Russian and not English therefore they don’t have THE particle…

windowframer · 27/01/2024 13:44

Samamfia · 26/01/2024 19:13

The fact that Labour can get in is the difference

That's the thing. They can only get in because there is no difference.

And Russia is a multi-party electoral democracy. Their governments can be replaced just like ours.

windowframer · 27/01/2024 13:39

Runstothewater · 26/01/2024 19:00

This has been coming for quite a while so I'm wondering why people are expressing surprise. Considering our substantial military reduction and what's been going on in Ukraine, Belarus, Moscow, Finland or off the Scottish coastline daily, this issue was just a matter of time.

It's part of the mess which the current Gov have made, sure, and it's entirely on them, but we need to be talking about where this has left us and what needs to happen moving forward.

What's been comin? Once again: nothing has actually happened. Nobody in any position of power to make it happen has even suggested that it's going to happen.

windowframer · 27/01/2024 13:37

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 26/01/2024 18:50

We have gay marriage here. Russia doesn't. That's one respect in which we beat Russia.

If we don't have a democracy, how come we had a Brexit referendum?

Edited

The same reason we have anything. Because it served the interests of a certain section of the ruling class to take us out of the European Union.

If Russia is not a democracy, how come it has elections? I didn't say either country was "not a democracy". I said they were nominal ones that function more like oligarchies. There are certain procedures to make a show of democracy, with rules and restrictions and choices carefully devised to ensure they can't threaten the power or economic privilege of the establishment.

Sure, you have a point - we have gay marriage, and probably a few other things I could think of that are better than Russia. Pretty low bar though, for a country that considers itself a beacon of enlightened western democracy. I expect more. If the government wants my loyalty, it will need to give me more.