Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people aren’t worried about this??

840 replies

Mummytotwonow · 25/01/2024 19:28

https://news.sky.com/story/time-to-think-the-unthinkable-and-consider-uk-conscription-says-britains-former-top-nato-commander-13056148

Sorry if I’ve missed any threads on this.

It’s not just sky news reporting this but for days now in the media this is being raised.

AIBU - to be extremely worried and concerned about this?

Is anyone else not worried?? Are we being prepared ready as “the higher up” know more and the threat is bigger than we’re told.

what age would it be from and to??

l‘m so scared for the world our children are growing up in 😢

Time to 'think the unthinkable' and consider UK conscription, says Britain's former top NATO commander

General Sir Richard Sherriff tells Sky News that even if Russia is defeated in the war against Ukraine, it is going to remain determined to rebuild another empire, subjugate Ukraine, and then move on to other ex-Soviet countries, like NATO members. Tha...

https://news.sky.com/story/time-to-think-the-unthinkable-and-consider-uk-conscription-says-britains-former-top-nato-commander-13056148

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 28/01/2024 15:03

@llizzie There are no innocent Palestinians.

This same rhetoric was used by the Russian soldiers to justify their rape of little girls during the Rape Of Berlin. In their eyes, there were no innocent Germans.

There are innocent Palestinians. Even if every adult is complicit (which they aren't BTW), there are Palestinian children. Children cannot consent to war. Children cannot consent to the perpetration of terrorist acts.

You should be ashamed of your inflammatory rhetoric.

Yasai · 28/01/2024 15:03

Do you remember when we illegally invaded Iraq and we didn’t provide our servicemen with the appropriate equipment.

I find it hilarious when people assume that anyone in opposition of war is somehow a sheltered mouse who hasn’t heard of terrorism. I have several friends and family members in the armed forces and it is my cousin who fought in Iraq who has reinforced my belief that we entered illegally.

Yasai · 28/01/2024 14:59

This reply has been deleted

We've now deleted this as it refers to a deleted post.

llizzie · 28/01/2024 14:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 28/01/2024 14:42

windowframer · 28/01/2024 12:00

There must be some mistake here.

The UK is a democracy, so its government could never engage in human rights abuses against its own citizens.

Hahahahahaha

The citizen can apply for legal remedy against government abuse through the courts.

All govts are corrupt to some extent, whether democracies or not. This is why an independent judiciary is so important to keep the bastards in check.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 28/01/2024 14:36

Megifer · 28/01/2024 11:32

Imagine getting all sneery about mothers saying their kids aren't going to fight. The alternative is "yea ill be dead happy about it"

Stop being fucking dickheads. have the day off.

Edited

It's not a matter of being sneery, but of being realistic. Conscription, by definition, is not a choice. If the govt says your sons fight, they fight.

I don't think anyone on this thread has expressed pleasure at the thought of conscripts going into combat.

Also, this is distracting you from the Coalition Government's complicity in the Horizon scandal, which is far more important right now.

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 14:24

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 28/01/2024 14:21

Says who?
I don't think the folk on this thread would beaking the rules...

Says virtually every military in the world since time began. Women in frontline roles is actively damaging to the war effort. A tiny number of female professional soldiers may have combat roles, but conscripting women for it would be a disaster and would never happen.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 28/01/2024 14:21

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 14:18

We’ve been over this.

Women would likely be conscripted for background roles, but not combat.

Says who?
I don't think the folk on this thread would beaking the rules...

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 14:18

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 28/01/2024 14:07

Husbands and children... I don't imagine women would be exempt in this day and age.

We’ve been over this.

Women would likely be conscripted for background roles, but not combat.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 28/01/2024 14:07

Mummytotwonow · 25/01/2024 19:42

The difficulty is we don’t want our children or husbands to go and fight if there was conscription - but would it be more horrendous allowing Russian soldiers terrorising us all??

It horrendous to think these things, but one day this might happen.

Edited

Husbands and children... I don't imagine women would be exempt in this day and age.

Yasai · 28/01/2024 13:58

llizzie · 28/01/2024 13:41

''We are told that the risk comes from Russia primarily. Why did you use Gaza and UNWRA as a reason to support your pro-conscription viewpoint? ''

So says Yasai reply to my latest post.

The fact is that were it not for the invasion of Israel on 7/10/23 we would not have been aware of just how wicked Hamas and Jihads actually are, and the implications of the invasion are so serious. We now have evidence to show how far reaching this invasion actually is. I asked what alternatives there are to conscription. You have not answered that. Instead, like a 'good'un' you divert attention away from the topic. You and countless others have condemned the withdrawal of aid. It should be withdrawn. Don't you know that in most countries IF YOU GIVE MONEY TO CHARITY AND THEY USE IT FOR SOMETHING ELSE it is illegal and donors have a right to stop the flow. Why should the world pay hard earned money to support terrorism? The League of Nations made a law which says civilians should not be targeted by war. How does that make you feel knowing that Hamas is actually hiding in civilian institutions for protection? Who would have known that terrorists would be that devious, that they would use that law to their advantage, a law passed in all innocence, following the Holocaust.

I am shocked at your comment about the cutting off of funds to the UNWRA and the sufferings of the Palestinians because of that. Countries have been giving taxpayers hard earned money to the Palestinians in good faith, for decades, only to discover that the Palestinians were not receiving it at all: it was all going to pay for the digging of tunnels, payments to Hamas and Jihadi armies and rockets fired into Israel, and that is WICKED and if the Palestinians are suffering, it is their own fault. There are no innocent Palestinians: we found that out for sure in the past 100+ days. The Palestinian medics knew where the hostages were and did nothing. The medics deliberately kept patients in hospital, deliberately aided and abetted the invasion on 7/10/23, deliberately put pregnant women and their families AT RISK after they signed THE HIPPOCRATIC OATH which begins 'FIRST DO NO HARM'.

For that they deserve all they get. If they are suffering, then that will tell them how criminally responsible they are, not just to the Israelis, but to the Palestinian people themselves.

The saddest thing, though, is that the ordinary Muslims of the world just want to get on with their lives and live in faith as their ancestors did. Now Islamist terrorists are destroying their world too.

I am not sure that I actually came out completely in support of conscription, but it is not just the invasion of Israel on 7/10/23, is it? We know what happened that day. That was an act of genicide against Jews, because the justification for that attack was from Hamas itself: ''We will kill all Jews, all over the world, no matter where they are''. Since that date, Hamas and Iran, and Islamic Jihad have openly admitted that they knew about the invasion weeks before it happened. The IDF warned Hamas of their entry into Gaza to take back the hostages. Every country in the world condemns kidnapping. In some, it is a capital offence. Did you expect the IDF not to do that? If Hamas health ministry knew about the invasion in September, why were there still patients in the hospitals? Why were pregnant women not evacuated? There should not have been premature births. There should not have been any births in North Gaza: there should not have been any patients either. I had a tinge of resentment when I heard that so many patients were kept in hospitals so long. The NHS kicks them out after a day or so.

Justify cutting aid to hundreds of thousands of innocent people all you like. You’re getting what you want anyhow - they continue to be trapped behind a wall just as generations before them always have 🤷🏽‍♀️ they’ll continue to die in their thousands each month. Belittle those who try to amplify the voices of these people all you like by labelling them “Hamas sympathisers” all you like. Just don’t expect people with long memories (Iraq invasion) to be falling over themselves to die for King Charles and the UK foreign policy.

llizzie · 28/01/2024 13:41

''We are told that the risk comes from Russia primarily. Why did you use Gaza and UNWRA as a reason to support your pro-conscription viewpoint? ''

So says Yasai reply to my latest post.

The fact is that were it not for the invasion of Israel on 7/10/23 we would not have been aware of just how wicked Hamas and Jihads actually are, and the implications of the invasion are so serious. We now have evidence to show how far reaching this invasion actually is. I asked what alternatives there are to conscription. You have not answered that. Instead, like a 'good'un' you divert attention away from the topic. You and countless others have condemned the withdrawal of aid. It should be withdrawn. Don't you know that in most countries IF YOU GIVE MONEY TO CHARITY AND THEY USE IT FOR SOMETHING ELSE it is illegal and donors have a right to stop the flow. Why should the world pay hard earned money to support terrorism? The League of Nations made a law which says civilians should not be targeted by war. How does that make you feel knowing that Hamas is actually hiding in civilian institutions for protection? Who would have known that terrorists would be that devious, that they would use that law to their advantage, a law passed in all innocence, following the Holocaust.

I am shocked at your comment about the cutting off of funds to the UNWRA and the sufferings of the Palestinians because of that. Countries have been giving taxpayers hard earned money to the Palestinians in good faith, for decades, only to discover that the Palestinians were not receiving it at all: it was all going to pay for the digging of tunnels, payments to Hamas and Jihadi armies and rockets fired into Israel, and that is WICKED and if the Palestinians are suffering, it is their own fault. There are no innocent Palestinians: we found that out for sure in the past 100+ days. The Palestinian medics knew where the hostages were and did nothing. The medics deliberately kept patients in hospital, deliberately aided and abetted the invasion on 7/10/23, deliberately put pregnant women and their families AT RISK after they signed THE HIPPOCRATIC OATH which begins 'FIRST DO NO HARM'.

For that they deserve all they get. If they are suffering, then that will tell them how criminally responsible they are, not just to the Israelis, but to the Palestinian people themselves.

The saddest thing, though, is that the ordinary Muslims of the world just want to get on with their lives and live in faith as their ancestors did. Now Islamist terrorists are destroying their world too.

I am not sure that I actually came out completely in support of conscription, but it is not just the invasion of Israel on 7/10/23, is it? We know what happened that day. That was an act of genicide against Jews, because the justification for that attack was from Hamas itself: ''We will kill all Jews, all over the world, no matter where they are''. Since that date, Hamas and Iran, and Islamic Jihad have openly admitted that they knew about the invasion weeks before it happened. The IDF warned Hamas of their entry into Gaza to take back the hostages. Every country in the world condemns kidnapping. In some, it is a capital offence. Did you expect the IDF not to do that? If Hamas health ministry knew about the invasion in September, why were there still patients in the hospitals? Why were pregnant women not evacuated? There should not have been premature births. There should not have been any births in North Gaza: there should not have been any patients either. I had a tinge of resentment when I heard that so many patients were kept in hospitals so long. The NHS kicks them out after a day or so.

Justpontificating · 28/01/2024 12:49

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 12:37

DP also just made the very good point that if women were conscripted men would feel they had nothing to fight for. The biggest driver to fight would be protecting their girlfriends/wives/families back home. If women were ordered to the frontline and they knew their spouse was at high risk of being killed, what’s the motive to keep fighting? Nothing to protect back at home.

I agree
Keeping moral up is key
Although on the basis in ww2 single men with kids didn’t have to fight then if a couple have kids one of them wouldn’t have to ‘go to war’.

Obviously those with adult children wouldn’t necessarily be exempt, unless they’re over the age bracket etc.

I thought the ( current ) figures for conscripting women were interesting to note though.
Those figures would be very different though in reality.

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 12:37

DP also just made the very good point that if women were conscripted men would feel they had nothing to fight for. The biggest driver to fight would be protecting their girlfriends/wives/families back home. If women were ordered to the frontline and they knew their spouse was at high risk of being killed, what’s the motive to keep fighting? Nothing to protect back at home.

Hillsmakeyoustrong · 28/01/2024 12:36

@Justpontificating depends how long the war lasted. Depends how long your frontliens are. So many variables...

Two years in and Russia has lost around 350,000 soldiers to date. That doesnt include casualties. You need also need to rotate the soldiers, if possible, although many on Ukraine's frontlines have been so for two years. A million is not so many in Ukraine's invasion.

Justpontificating · 28/01/2024 12:33

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 12:28

@Justpontificating possibly because like you said many would be ineligible for reasons they’re not aware. They would also be looking to conscript people with useful skills that would mean they would need less training - mechanics, medics, pilots, seafarers etc. Plus I would hazard a guess that a third of people who claim they would volunteer would think twice if it actually happened.

Especially after
they have exhausted the volunteers
bodies start arriving home

This is not the same as previous wars as we are more likely, as the general public, to see the realities of war in the media.

llizzie · 28/01/2024 12:33

Crackoncrackerjack · Today 08:58

Do they involve Putin’s attempt to subjugate the west ?

Is Putin attempting to subjugate the west? How would he do that? He can control world shipping - world trade - without even firing a pistol. He finances terrorism to do that for him. Look at the map of the Black Sea: the Ukraine is losing control of it's coastline, unless the world wakes up. The Russian Federation controls the Russian coastline, and a whole lot of the Ukraine, and Turkey controls a good bit of it too, and the route into the Mediterranean Sea. The only reason why the Palestinians and those who control them want Israel is to control the south and east coasts of the Med, and particularly the Suez Canal.

Already world shipping trade is compromised, and the cost of goods - including essential goods - will rise: if it isn't already. Putin does not even supply the weapons the Houthis are using to attack shipping in the Red Sea, which last year was blocked. Putin and the Ayatollah whatshisname are in bed together, and with different agendas. Look at the maps of Black Sea, Mediterranean Sea, Suez Canal and Red Sea, and you can add the North Sea to that if Putin invades Scandinavian countries, and Erdogan opposed Sweden for a long time, and still is not happy. Putin and Erdogan got together to allow the Ukraine to export it's grain last year. In the Great War, it was the assassination of Archduke Ferdinand: in this, when the shipping is diverted away from Suez, an attack on Gibraltar will be out Franz Ferdinand moment. and for that we need a navy, marines, airforce and boots on the ground. Have we been keeping our eyes on the coastline from Egypt to the Atlantic? What need of nuclear weapons? Kim Ung has showed the world just how far reaching his rockets are. Is it all to defend itself, or is he showing Putin how far away the Russians need their base to be to shock the world?

All this is financed with crypto currency, which was almost done until 7th October 2023, and suddenly the value has risen.

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 12:28

@Justpontificating possibly because like you said many would be ineligible for reasons they’re not aware. They would also be looking to conscript people with useful skills that would mean they would need less training - mechanics, medics, pilots, seafarers etc. Plus I would hazard a guess that a third of people who claim they would volunteer would think twice if it actually happened.

Justpontificating · 28/01/2024 12:25

So.
Because I’m in a bit of a maths mood.
Based on the above surveys

With 30% of UK pop ( as of 2021 ) in the 18-40 age bracket
assuming same % in that age bracket now
Taking a pop of 66million
7% would volunteer ( takes account of those who know they would be unfit to fight but of course not those who may be unaware )

The total number of 18-40 yr olds who would volunteer = 1,407,000people
The total number who agree to go to war if conscripted @ 21% = 4,221,000ppl

Based on these numbers ( very basic I know and in the face of war im sure the reality of fighting would lower the %s however ) would the call up be needed

BorgQueen · 28/01/2024 12:23

Half of you would probably turn traitor in any case, should we be invaded, in the vain hope that you and your families would be treated a little better in the work camps.
We saw how people liked the idea of snitching during lockdown.
I know I would rather die on my feet trying to free my country rather than grovel in the dirt for whatever scraps are offered.
I KNOW how it feels to have a loved one go to war because I’ve lived it when I also had a six month old baby.
DH, although technically too old for conscription, would be rounded up and shot by an invading army because his name is probably on a list somewhere. The enemy wouldn’t want ex-military in the population, able to mount a resistance, they would be the first to go.

Hillsmakeyoustrong · 28/01/2024 12:17

I assume conscription is more likely when its an invasion on your soil. Or you are the invader. Professional soldiers in Ukraine have said that they have been significantly put at risk by conscripts who are not trained in handling weaponry, battle comms (radios etc) and overall resilience amongst other things. I say all of this to emphasise how last resort conscription is even in the highly unlikely event that war is declared. This brings us back full circle as to why we need to ensure defence spending is increased and our professionals are trained and equipped.

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 12:05

Justpontificating · 28/01/2024 12:02

I’m fully aware of that
This however shows how the general public view the issue. Which is all I was intending to highlight given MN is also a part of that general public
The Govn will be interested, also, in these sort of surveys in formulating a way forward should they ever need to.
Just as they considered attitudes about lockdowns

I don’t think Yougov polls will determine how the military approach a war, or even feature. After all the polls would indicate the public don’t want war at all.

Justpontificating · 28/01/2024 12:02

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 11:57

It wouldn’t be down to public vote, it would be down to military strategy. No military strategy suggests equal numbers of women on the frontline would be successful in any way. It’s never happened, in any country, ever.

I’m fully aware of that
This however shows how the general public view the issue. Which is all I was intending to highlight given MN is also a part of that general public
The Govn will be interested, also, in these sort of surveys in formulating a way forward should they ever need to.
Just as they considered attitudes about lockdowns

windowframer · 28/01/2024 12:00

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 27/01/2024 19:48

And the Coalition Govt of David Cameron knew.

There must be some mistake here.

The UK is a democracy, so its government could never engage in human rights abuses against its own citizens.

Naptrappedmummy · 28/01/2024 11:57

Justpontificating · 28/01/2024 11:55

Here’s more survey results regarding conscripting women also yougovn

A very low % believe women should not be conscripted

It wouldn’t be down to public vote, it would be down to military strategy. No military strategy suggests equal numbers of women on the frontline would be successful in any way. It’s never happened, in any country, ever.