Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people aren’t worried about this??

840 replies

Mummytotwonow · 25/01/2024 19:28

https://news.sky.com/story/time-to-think-the-unthinkable-and-consider-uk-conscription-says-britains-former-top-nato-commander-13056148

Sorry if I’ve missed any threads on this.

It’s not just sky news reporting this but for days now in the media this is being raised.

AIBU - to be extremely worried and concerned about this?

Is anyone else not worried?? Are we being prepared ready as “the higher up” know more and the threat is bigger than we’re told.

what age would it be from and to??

l‘m so scared for the world our children are growing up in 😢

Time to 'think the unthinkable' and consider UK conscription, says Britain's former top NATO commander

General Sir Richard Sherriff tells Sky News that even if Russia is defeated in the war against Ukraine, it is going to remain determined to rebuild another empire, subjugate Ukraine, and then move on to other ex-Soviet countries, like NATO members. Tha...

https://news.sky.com/story/time-to-think-the-unthinkable-and-consider-uk-conscription-says-britains-former-top-nato-commander-13056148

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
BurkeWalter · 25/01/2024 23:43

Analysis of the original article

The question of conscription in the United Kingdom has gained attention from various military officials and experts, including General Sir Richard Sherriff, Britain's former top NATO commander. Sherriff, in a recent statement, emphasized the need to "think the unthinkable" and consider conscription as a measure to address potential threats, especially in the context of the current global situation and defense funding cuts.

Background and Context:
Sir Richard Sherriff's remarks come in the wake of the ongoing conflict between Russia and Ukraine. He highlighted concerns that even if Russia were to be defeated in the war against Ukraine, there remains a significant risk of Russia attempting to rebuild another empire and potentially engaging in conflicts with other former Soviet countries, including NATO members. This, he argues, necessitates a robust and well-prepared military force to deter potential threats and maintain peace in the Euro-Atlantic region.

Current State of UK Armed Forces:
Sherriff expressed concern about the current state of the UK armed forces, pointing out that troop numbers are in "freefall" and stand at around 74,000, with forecasts suggesting a further decline. He argued that the existing armed forces may not be sufficient to respond effectively to high-intensity conflicts. Moreover, he emphasized the need for effective military deterrence, including both conventional and nuclear capabilities.

Budgetary Constraints and Volunteer Army:
One of the central points raised by Sherriff is the limitation of the UK defense budget. He argued that the budget is not large enough to support the expansion of the armed forces solely through professional volunteer soldiers. He acknowledged the cultural and historical reliance on long-service volunteer professionals in the British armed forces but stressed the necessity to overcome cultural hang-ups and consider alternative measures.

Conscription as a Controversial Option:
While acknowledging that conscription is traditionally viewed as anathema by professional soldiers, Sherriff argued that it might be necessary to "think the unthinkable" given the current circumstances. He referenced the Chief of the General Staff, General Sir Patrick Sanders, who suggested the possibility of conscription in the event of a war with Russia. Sherriff suggested that the UK should explore conscription as a means to bolster troop numbers and readiness.

Reference to Finland's Model:
Sherriff pointed to Finland as a potential model for conscription. He highlighted Finland's practice of universal male conscription starting at the age of 18, with varying service durations for different roles. He emphasized the success of Finland's approach in maintaining a small professional army that can be expanded through mobilization, with a reserve commitment for individuals up to a certain age.

Military Analyst's Perspective:
Major General Charlie Herbert, a military analyst, supported the idea that the UK needs to invest in a capable military to deter potential threats. He echoed the warning that failing to invest in defense now may lead to consequences in the future. Herbert suggested that General Sanders and others are advocating for increased spending to ensure the UK is adequately prepared for emerging threats.

Political Perspectives and Wider Concerns:
The debate around conscription has also entered the political arena, with senior Tory MP Tobias Ellwood expressing concerns about the current global situation and warning of a "1939 feel to the world." He emphasized the need for increased military spending and preparation for the challenges ahead.

Government's Stance and Future Considerations:
While there is a growing call to consider conscription, Downing Street has, at least for now, ruled out any move towards a conscription model, maintaining that army service will remain voluntary. The government's position suggests that conscription remains a controversial and challenging option that requires careful consideration.

Conclusion:
The discussions around conscription in the UK highlight the complex challenges and threats facing the nation, particularly in light of the evolving global geopolitical landscape. General Sir Richard Sherriff's call to "think the unthinkable" reflects the gravity of the situation and the need for a comprehensive reassessment of defense strategies. Whether conscription becomes a viable option will likely depend on ongoing evaluations of the military's capabilities, budget considerations, and the perceived level of threat to national security. As the debate continues, it is crucial for policymakers, military officials, and the public to engage in informed discussions about the potential paths forward in ensuring the country's defense and security.

Carthag · 25/01/2024 23:42

You are quite correct to be worried and I have already started teaching my children the absurdity of war and why under no circumstances should they consider submitting to conscription.

It's funny how, when the elites of two nations can't agree, how it falls to ordinary people, who have nothing to gain or lose from the outcome of a war are the ones who have to do the murdering or be murdered isn't it? I wonder if this blithering idiot "General Sir Richard Sherriff" (the one demanding that ordinary people will be made to fight) ever fought on the front line himself? I doubt it, despite being a "professional soldier".

We are not a world power and have not been for decades - Britain needs to accept this fact, get over it and stop interfering. Take a leaf out Switzerland's book - they stayed out of both world wars and is a richer and happier place for it.

There is no reason for Britain to go to war - we are under no threat whatsoever. Don't get me wrong, I feel for the Ukrainians, but up until 1991, they were part of the USSR (largely unwilling) and we weren't considering armed conflict to free them before that, were we?
No doubt someone will start ranting about Hitler and the Nazis and how we had to stop them.
News flash: we didn't have to stop them, they would have fallen all by themselves.
Want some proof? Joseph Stalin, another dictator responsible for the slaughter of millions - who stopped him?

No one. He died. In bed.

I remember watching Threads on the BBC as a child and was terrified of nuclear war and the utter destruction it would wreak. There is no cause, no ideal, no belief on earth worth that.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 25/01/2024 23:40

Hillsmakeyoustrong · 25/01/2024 23:17

A huge proportion of the Ukrainian frontlines are made up of civvies well as professionals. Men and women, many in the younger age bracket (20 to 45) and who were living lives much like our own young people, who had never held a gun, are now frontliners. They are fighting because they know what living under a Russian regime would entail for the people. There isn't a choice in such matters. Putin cannot be allowed to succeed and he will not succeed.

I worry about the possibility of war. And I realise that if it comes we'll have to fight.

A comparison with Ukraine isn't a very good one though. They are fighting off an invader on their home soil.

We'll have to fight a war on someone else's soil. It's going to take a lot more to convince the British public that a war in the Baltic states, just for example, is just as important to us as the war in Ukraine is to them.

I get frustrated with the "but the government" whinging. A war is so much bigger than a this, and if it comes, they government will be a different one.

WinterMorn · 25/01/2024 23:33

Owl55 · 25/01/2024 23:32

I fear there is a real possibility of a war in the future, the situation in the Middle East is very concerning as it could draw in Iran and Russia arming other countries too, a world war would be very different now with nuclear weapons and the vast distance they could reach, I wonder if we are being prepared for the possibility of a war in the future, a terrifying thought!

The idea is that preparing for war prevents it.

Owl55 · 25/01/2024 23:32

I fear there is a real possibility of a war in the future, the situation in the Middle East is very concerning as it could draw in Iran and Russia arming other countries too, a world war would be very different now with nuclear weapons and the vast distance they could reach, I wonder if we are being prepared for the possibility of a war in the future, a terrifying thought!

WinterMorn · 25/01/2024 23:31

What a charmer Coatrack is

EasternStandard · 25/01/2024 23:30

CoatRack · 25/01/2024 23:27

No, I couldn't give a toss about Ukraine.

Why do you ask?

You’d get your robber’s cruelty from your quote, which you seem keen on

Have you lived under an actual dictatorship? not stuff about U.K. gov but elsewhere?

leighanneJ · 25/01/2024 23:28

It wont happen

LuluBlakey1 · 25/01/2024 23:28

bellamountain · 25/01/2024 23:08

Absolutely!

People did not take that view in the first and second world wars - many parents wanted to but the propaganda battle won. It would happen again. The propaganda battle across Europe would win out in terms of people signing up. They'd start with volunteers and the public's reaction to that- turning them into heroes- would influence more to sign up. By the time conscription came it would be seen as a duty. The right-wing Press would support it all with nationalistic fervour. The male dominated influences like football and other sports would support it because that's what men do when the opportunity arises to look like they are tough and they'd all join up. And all those who are influenced to follow things and believe things by idiots like Daily Mail, social influencers, celebs social media accounts, SCD, IACGMOOH, Twitter, Facebook etc would believe this propaganda too. You might think you wouldn't but you would. Before you knew it you'd be worried but proud and waving them off on their training.

CoatRack · 25/01/2024 23:27

EasternStandard · 25/01/2024 23:25

@CoatRack would you rather be in Ukraine fighting than here?

No, I couldn't give a toss about Ukraine.

Why do you ask?

EasternStandard · 25/01/2024 23:25

CoatRack · 25/01/2024 23:19

I don't do social media.

5G
They locked us down and took away our right to stand in a field well before any vaccines were released.

your government tried to save your life

Spoken like a true dictator.
The mid-century moustache man just wanted to protect Germans from being exploited and to regain stolen territory, don't you know. (@Justpontificating before you say anything, this is rhetorical; I am not actually a socialist).

Even if good intentions weren't a complete lie, I think CS Lewis put it quite well:
"Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience."

@CoatRack would you rather be in Ukraine fighting than here?

katem98 · 25/01/2024 23:25

Hillsmakeyoustrong · 25/01/2024 23:22

I also don't believe we need to worry about a conventional war or a nuclear war but it is wise to prepared for all eventualities because that is a safeguard in itself. Please go to the Ukriane threads and ask the incredibe main contributers any questions because they will be honest, sober and give you an informed answer.

Yes! Please read the Ukraine threads. They have been a godsend for me and so informative/ well balanced.

CoatRack · 25/01/2024 23:25

Justpontificating · 25/01/2024 22:37

‘Menfolk could just do the right thing’
That's an extremely old fashioned and sexist turn of phrase and attitude

No, you said I had an old fashioned and sexist attitude. See above.

And I've backtracked on nothing. Feel free to show me otherwise.

bellamountain · 25/01/2024 23:23

Oneofthesurvivors · 25/01/2024 22:44

Why would Putin attack us? What do we have that Russia wants?

To be fair a lot of Russians like the UK, we have many Russian students in our private schools.

Hillsmakeyoustrong · 25/01/2024 23:22

I also don't believe we need to worry about a conventional war or a nuclear war but it is wise to prepared for all eventualities because that is a safeguard in itself. Please go to the Ukriane threads and ask the incredibe main contributers any questions because they will be honest, sober and give you an informed answer.

CoatRack · 25/01/2024 23:19

LastTrainEast · 25/01/2024 22:53

Coatrack you'd be one of those getting a shock if you actually found yourself under a dictatorship. There's a real world out there that facebook hasn't prepared you for.

Your government tried to save your life. Even if we agreed they could have done a better job that was the point. They faced resistance in the form of people who think viruses are a myth and vaccines contain computer chips.

Shortly there will be an election and you can vote for a different government. Because this is a democracy.

I don't do social media.

5G
They locked us down and took away our right to stand in a field well before any vaccines were released.

your government tried to save your life

Spoken like a true dictator.
The mid-century moustache man just wanted to protect Germans from being exploited and to regain stolen territory, don't you know. (@Justpontificating before you say anything, this is rhetorical; I am not actually a socialist).

Even if good intentions weren't a complete lie, I think CS Lewis put it quite well:
"Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience."

Hillsmakeyoustrong · 25/01/2024 23:17

A huge proportion of the Ukrainian frontlines are made up of civvies well as professionals. Men and women, many in the younger age bracket (20 to 45) and who were living lives much like our own young people, who had never held a gun, are now frontliners. They are fighting because they know what living under a Russian regime would entail for the people. There isn't a choice in such matters. Putin cannot be allowed to succeed and he will not succeed.

Wackadaywideawake · 25/01/2024 23:17

StopTheBusINeedAWeeWeeAWeeWeeBagOChips · 25/01/2024 19:33

Its a scaremongering tactic to highlight the lack of budget for armed forces rather than anything that will happen in reality.

It would be totally unworkable and unrealistic to do it these days.

Yep. This.

He wants the government to spend more money on defence. Scaring the public is the most effective way of achieving this.

SammyScrounge · 25/01/2024 23:13

BoohooWoohoo · 25/01/2024 19:38

It won’t happen because people will refuse. There aren’t enough jail cells or capacity in the law courts to try everyone plus it’s an election year.

Why are you so sure people would refuse? If the provocation were enough men would come forward.

lljkk · 25/01/2024 23:10

MNers are always scaremongering.

Josette77 · 25/01/2024 23:10

UnderratedGenius · 25/01/2024 23:03

During WW2 many hundreds of people across Europe risked their lives by hiding Jewish people. If found out they risked being killed.

The Jews were hated by Hitler.

Gay people are hated by Putin.

How many of you would risk your lives to hide your gay friends?

Would you expect your friends to hide your gay children?

Or is it better to accept the inevitable, keep your head down and not get involved? They may be your friends and family, but they’re not worth fighting over, right?

Oh my gosh this. So much this.

An American model Rain Dove Assembled a team and went to Ukraine to rescue lgbtq people. I'm still amazed at their bravery.

They recently went to Gaza to help as well.

That kind of bravery and selfishness is so needed in this world.

I hope I would do the same in similar circumstances for my country.

Justpontificating · 25/01/2024 23:08

Livelovebehappy · 25/01/2024 23:05

Tbh, this generation are totally unequipped to cope with conscription. A lot of our young are emotionally stunted compared to previous generations, if we have to rely on them to defend our country we’re screwed. So we need to accept that we will absolutely not do well in a conventional war.

We are far more unfit aswell
A More sedentary lifestyle hasn’t exactly made people super fit.

bellamountain · 25/01/2024 23:08

Theothersideofthefence · 25/01/2024 19:33

My boys will not be spilling blood for a government that would otherwise watch them starve.

Please just be mindful of all the scaremongering that happened with covid. We are weak if in a constant state of fear.

Absolutely!

EasternStandard · 25/01/2024 23:07

Livelovebehappy · 25/01/2024 23:05

Tbh, this generation are totally unequipped to cope with conscription. A lot of our young are emotionally stunted compared to previous generations, if we have to rely on them to defend our country we’re screwed. So we need to accept that we will absolutely not do well in a conventional war.

Do you think your generation is better placed

I’m not sure why anyone bar armed forces thinks they can judge

Catpuss66 · 25/01/2024 23:07

Terrrence · 25/01/2024 19:32

They can fuck off if they think my children are fighting in any land war. I don't think anybody else's children should either. I would rather Russia just took over than a generation were sacrificed to prevent it.

So all those who gave their lives their sons their husbands & brothers, for nothing so you can be ruled by Russia.