Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people aren’t worried about this??

840 replies

Mummytotwonow · 25/01/2024 19:28

https://news.sky.com/story/time-to-think-the-unthinkable-and-consider-uk-conscription-says-britains-former-top-nato-commander-13056148

Sorry if I’ve missed any threads on this.

It’s not just sky news reporting this but for days now in the media this is being raised.

AIBU - to be extremely worried and concerned about this?

Is anyone else not worried?? Are we being prepared ready as “the higher up” know more and the threat is bigger than we’re told.

what age would it be from and to??

l‘m so scared for the world our children are growing up in 😢

Time to 'think the unthinkable' and consider UK conscription, says Britain's former top NATO commander

General Sir Richard Sherriff tells Sky News that even if Russia is defeated in the war against Ukraine, it is going to remain determined to rebuild another empire, subjugate Ukraine, and then move on to other ex-Soviet countries, like NATO members. Tha...

https://news.sky.com/story/time-to-think-the-unthinkable-and-consider-uk-conscription-says-britains-former-top-nato-commander-13056148

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Daisybuttercup12345 · 26/01/2024 00:16

TooOldForThisNonsense · 25/01/2024 19:58

Agreed

They can fuck right off

the days of people or let’s face it men being asked to lay down their lives for “king and country” are over. No way are my boys being sacrificed while the fucking idiots who cause wars remain protected.

If it came to it you would get no say at all. Just like mothers in other countries have no say.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 26/01/2024 00:15

CoatRack · 25/01/2024 20:49

Equality and equity etc. is for times of peace and luxury. Those policies will disappear very quickly once there is an actual need for meat shields.

Not least because we have known for millennia that sending the womb-holders away to be killed is irretrievably stupid.

we have known for millennia that sending the womb-holders away to be killed is irretrievably stupid.

I came to this thread to say this.

As a class, women's most important job for their country is to bear the next generation of citizens.

You could have 90% or even more of all men die and still have a replacement birth rate, by having each surviving man father children on multiple women concurrently and keeping careful records to make sure that half-siblings conceived this way don't marry each other.

If 90% of women die, you will have a massive population crash. If 50% of women die, you will have a massive population crash. A country cannot afford to risk mass death or mass reproductive incapacitation of its women.

Ukraine ordered the women to flee and the men to stay and fight for good reasons. Russian soldiers have mass raped Ukrainian women with the stated intent of traumatising them into asexual behaviour so that they cannot bear Ukrainian children. Rape works as genocide by a) forcing women to birth the enemy's babies and b) preventing future births. Rape can cause injuries that prevent future pregnancies too. Russian soldiers have murdered Ukrainian women. Dead women bear no children. The Ukrainian government has been very wise.

Catpuss66 · 26/01/2024 00:14

gnarlynarwhal · 25/01/2024 20:53

My DH thinks if Trump wins the US election he will withdraw aid from the Ukraine which would massively increase Russia's chance of advancing.

I think if Trump wins he will hand over the US to Putin anyway & he’ll get paid for his efforts.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 26/01/2024 00:12

berksandbeyond · 25/01/2024 19:49

People saying ‘oh my kids won’t be fighting’ are kidding themselves, that’s not how conscription works funnily enough. If it comes to it- they’ll be going. Mothers didn’t want their kids to fight in any other war either, that’s kinda the whole point in conscription

This is correct.

WinterMorn · 26/01/2024 00:10

@Carthag you obviously haven’t read much of this thread. In fact, it’s unlikely you have read much at all, judging by some of the inaccuracies in your post.

ChedderGorgeous · 26/01/2024 00:08

CoatRack · 26/01/2024 00:06

I never said the lockdowns were UK only, and it doesn't make them right. Not everyone did them either - Sweden being a close example.

Throwing mountains of bodies at conflicts is the Russian standard MO, and has been for centuries.
Again, criticising one does not mean support of the other, and I do not believe we are that special. How many people at the Somme really knew what they were fighting for?

I have to say, this patriotism is inspiring in the face of my disdain for our political establishment. One wonders how we're falling short of recruitment numbers.

Isn't there a tin foil hat that's missing a head ? Back you go !

CoatRack · 26/01/2024 00:06

HenndigoOZ · 25/01/2024 23:49

one of my closest friends is Russian and her brother was conscripted. He thought he was just going to have some training for a year and then leave. He was taken to Ukraine and not told what was happening. It was a shock to him to be fighting the Ukrainians, who to Russians are like Welsh or Scottish to us. Honestly, the UK government as bad (as it is)is not the same. Russia really treat their male population as fodder to be thrown in the meat grinder and jail the opposition leaders.

re Covid, virtually every country around the world regardless of politics all had scientists who were agreed on the reality of the virus and proposed similar measures to reduce deaths. It wasn’t a UK government only exercise while the rest of us overseas watched on in disbelief. We all had lockdowns!

Edited

I never said the lockdowns were UK only, and it doesn't make them right. Not everyone did them either - Sweden being a close example.

Throwing mountains of bodies at conflicts is the Russian standard MO, and has been for centuries.
Again, criticising one does not mean support of the other, and I do not believe we are that special. How many people at the Somme really knew what they were fighting for?

I have to say, this patriotism is inspiring in the face of my disdain for our political establishment. One wonders how we're falling short of recruitment numbers.

Carthag · 26/01/2024 00:05

UnderratedGenius · 25/01/2024 22:49

Interesting so many people say that they wouldn’t let their children fight for this country, and that they would rather live under whatever regime the invading force imposed.

Have you any idea what invasion involves?

Imagine you’re the leader of an invading army. When you arrive on the shore of the target country you want to advance as far as possible with as little resistance as possible. You’ve heard that the locals don’t want to fight, that they have publicly stated they will submit, but can you be really sure that’s true? Is it worth the risk to go in without a plan? What if they change their minds?

Who is most likely to put up a viable resistance? Due to size, weight and strength differences that’s generally young men. So, who are you going to target first? Round up some of the local men where you land, kill or torture them and ensure that no one is tempted to put up any form of resistance. Do this in every town you reach.

Rape the women and girls, it’s a terror tactic of war as old as time itself. If the husbands, partners or fathers try to intervene kill them. And then kill the women they were defending.

Impose restrictions on movement and ban freedom of assembly, at least until everyone has given up all hope of being free. Make the demands for compliance onerous, that way when you loosen your grip people are fooled into thinking that they have their liberty back.

Ban discussions about life before invasion unless it follows the party line - life was bad before, but now we love our new society. If access to communications poses a risk to successful compliance by the locals then deny them access to it. Elderly people can be dangerous, they remember the time before complacency, when people helped their neighbours and believed in being proud of the freedoms accorded to them by their country. Make it known that reminiscing can lead to imprisonment. If no one can remember the Before time, then no one can reliably judge whether things are better or worse.

The last country-wide invasion of England was in 1066. For the last thousand years the citizens have generally considered invasion to be undesirable and understood that in order to repel invaders it was necessary to maintain a trained force of fighting age men in sufficient numbers to make a difference.

Apathy to defend against invaders, coupled with insiders trying to overthrow the existing system gave us William of Orange.

Not really comparable to Putin, was he?

Your post has many truths, however I would answer it as simply as this:-

Nuclear war = Dead earth

Nothing is worth this.

Dead or maimed children.

Nothing is worth this.

Sanctioned murder of ordinary people dressed up as soldiers? No thanks.

Nogg · 26/01/2024 00:04

War is young men dying and old men talking

theduchessofspork · 26/01/2024 00:03

cerisepanther73 · 25/01/2024 21:56

No chance would i allow my son willing to fight in the name of this country
I would be doing whatever is humanely to discourage him

especially after the Windrush scandal in more recent times ect,

I come from ethnic heritage background

It’s not going to happen, but if it did, it wouldn’t be your choice.

Nogg · 26/01/2024 00:01

The old Lie: Dulce et decorum est
Pro patria mori.

Carthag · 25/01/2024 23:59

WinterMorn · 25/01/2024 23:49

You are completely and utterly wrong.

What a reasoned and intelligent argument that wasn't.

Reminds me of the fools in Threads screaming in rage at the public speaker who was telling them of the insanity of nuclear war.

Carthag · 25/01/2024 23:54

What a reasoned and intelligent argument that wasn't.

Reminds me of the fools in Threads screaming in rage at the public speaker who was telling them of the insanity of nuclear war.

WinterMorn · 25/01/2024 23:53

CoatRack · 25/01/2024 23:52

'Free' is certainly an appropriate measure of value in this case.

I eagerly await any kind of tangible contribution from you, though I'm not holding my breath.

I really don’t expect you to. Next!

Drosera · 25/01/2024 23:53

HenndigoOZ · 25/01/2024 23:49

one of my closest friends is Russian and her brother was conscripted. He thought he was just going to have some training for a year and then leave. He was taken to Ukraine and not told what was happening. It was a shock to him to be fighting the Ukrainians, who to Russians are like Welsh or Scottish to us. Honestly, the UK government as bad (as it is)is not the same. Russia really treat their male population as fodder to be thrown in the meat grinder and jail the opposition leaders.

re Covid, virtually every country around the world regardless of politics all had scientists who were agreed on the reality of the virus and proposed similar measures to reduce deaths. It wasn’t a UK government only exercise while the rest of us overseas watched on in disbelief. We all had lockdowns!

Edited

Quite!

People that think covid was like living under a true dictatorship would be in for a really rude awakening I feel.

CoatRack · 25/01/2024 23:52

WinterMorn · 25/01/2024 23:45

No problem CoatRack, it’s a free one just for you.

Edited

'Free' is certainly an appropriate measure of value in this case.

I eagerly await any kind of tangible contribution from you, though I'm not holding my breath.

Carthag · 25/01/2024 23:50

Indeed correct, people are sheep, unfortunately and will go along with it. Ordinary Britain's have nothing to gain or lose from stupid wars, only death, grief, mutilation, mental and emotional trauma, etc. Those who have everything to win or lose will be nowhere near a battlefield.
It's like me arguing with a neighbour over a border, then threatening them with my Dad and older brother, so the neighbour threatens me with his Dad and his brother's and cousins. If it's so important, fight your own fights, because I won't.

Drosera · 25/01/2024 23:49

For me, it's not the possibility of war that's interesting (as I think it's unlikely in the manner discussed here) but how people are claiming they'd react if it did.

(Although of course we don't really know what we'd do until it actually did happen).

It crazy to see people saying they'd just roll over and also those with the "why should I fight for my freedom" attitudes.

HenndigoOZ · 25/01/2024 23:49

CoatRack · 25/01/2024 22:42

not a dictatorship
You weren't here for 2020 were you?

Emergency powers go a very long way when they have to, and we have seen what they did in response to a fancy version of the flu.
If they want something to happen, then it happens.

How do I know? They did it in Canada a couple years ago when some truckers were protesting in the cities. The government seized their bank accounts until they gave up.

Make no mistake: "Democracy" means the square root of fuck all when push comes to shove. They are all as bad as each other.

one of my closest friends is Russian and her brother was conscripted. He thought he was just going to have some training for a year and then leave. He was taken to Ukraine and not told what was happening. It was a shock to him to be fighting the Ukrainians, who to Russians are like Welsh or Scottish to us. Honestly, the UK government as bad (as it is)is not the same. Russia really treat their male population as fodder to be thrown in the meat grinder and jail the opposition leaders.

re Covid, virtually every country around the world regardless of politics all had scientists who were agreed on the reality of the virus and proposed similar measures to reduce deaths. It wasn’t a UK government only exercise while the rest of us overseas watched on in disbelief. We all had lockdowns!

WinterMorn · 25/01/2024 23:49

Carthag · 25/01/2024 23:42

You are quite correct to be worried and I have already started teaching my children the absurdity of war and why under no circumstances should they consider submitting to conscription.

It's funny how, when the elites of two nations can't agree, how it falls to ordinary people, who have nothing to gain or lose from the outcome of a war are the ones who have to do the murdering or be murdered isn't it? I wonder if this blithering idiot "General Sir Richard Sherriff" (the one demanding that ordinary people will be made to fight) ever fought on the front line himself? I doubt it, despite being a "professional soldier".

We are not a world power and have not been for decades - Britain needs to accept this fact, get over it and stop interfering. Take a leaf out Switzerland's book - they stayed out of both world wars and is a richer and happier place for it.

There is no reason for Britain to go to war - we are under no threat whatsoever. Don't get me wrong, I feel for the Ukrainians, but up until 1991, they were part of the USSR (largely unwilling) and we weren't considering armed conflict to free them before that, were we?
No doubt someone will start ranting about Hitler and the Nazis and how we had to stop them.
News flash: we didn't have to stop them, they would have fallen all by themselves.
Want some proof? Joseph Stalin, another dictator responsible for the slaughter of millions - who stopped him?

No one. He died. In bed.

I remember watching Threads on the BBC as a child and was terrified of nuclear war and the utter destruction it would wreak. There is no cause, no ideal, no belief on earth worth that.

You are completely and utterly wrong.

WinterMorn · 25/01/2024 23:45

No problem CoatRack, it’s a free one just for you.

raspberryjuiceandpompoms · 25/01/2024 23:45

I still can’t believe that there are people who believe that Russia wants to invade Britain 🤦🏻‍♀️ y’all getting conscribed so that US & NATO can annihilate a threat to the balance of power. Putin asked to join NATO when he first came to power, the answer was clear “we don’t want you here”. Russia has been purposefully excluded from international deals because no one wanted to deal with it. It found new allies. The balance started tipping. Why can’t anyone see a bigger picture? Russia and China alliance is a threat to the current balance of power… of influence. Russia doesn’t want or need British land.

CoatRack · 25/01/2024 23:45

WinterMorn · 25/01/2024 23:31

What a charmer Coatrack is

You've argued me to an utter standstill there. Bravo.

BurkeWalter · 25/01/2024 23:44

CS Lewis's quote raises important considerations about the potential dangers of well-intentioned tyranny. Let's delve into the meaning and implications of this quote.

Lewis begins by highlighting the concept of a tyranny that is sincerely exercised for the supposed benefit of its victims. This idea challenges the commonly held belief that intentions alone are sufficient to justify actions. Lewis suggests that even with good intentions, a tyranny can be exceptionally oppressive. This assertion prompts us to question whether the end justifies the means, particularly when the means involve a form of control or interference in the lives of individuals.

The comparison drawn between a tyranny for the supposed good and the rule of "robber barons" adds depth to Lewis's argument. The term "robber baron" typically refers to powerful, unscrupulous individuals who accumulate wealth and power through ruthless and exploitative means. Lewis implies that, despite the cruelty of the robber baron, there may be a certain degree of respite – a temporary cessation of cruelty when compared to a tyranny that is supposedly driven by moral considerations.

The essence of Lewis's argument lies in the notion that those who seek to impose their version of morality on others may become relentless in their pursuit. The "omnipotent moral busybodies" are portrayed as individuals who, fueled by the belief in their moral superiority, will continue to torment people endlessly. The term "busybodies" suggests not just a concern for morality but an intrusive and meddlesome nature, further emphasizing the intrusive aspect of the tyranny.

The phrase "torment us without end" underscores the perpetual nature of the oppression inflicted by those who claim to act in the name of morality. The conscience approval aspect adds a layer of complexity. The tormentors believe they are justified in their actions, and this self-righteousness can make them immune to the suffering they cause. This raises profound questions about the subjective nature of morality and the potential for abuse when moral convictions become the basis for wielding power over others.

In contemporary contexts, this quote can be applied to various scenarios, such as government interventions, paternalistic policies, or even social and cultural movements that seek to enforce certain moral standards. The warning about the dangers of unchecked moral authority serves as a reminder to critically assess the actions of those in power, even when their intentions are ostensibly benevolent.

In conclusion, CS Lewis's quote serves as a thought-provoking commentary on the potential perils of well-intentioned tyranny. It encourages us to question the legitimacy of authority that claims moral superiority and highlights the enduring torment that may result from such tyranny. The quote prompts reflection on the delicate balance between individual freedom and the pursuit of collective well-being, urging us to be vigilant against the encroachment of those who would oppress under the guise of benevolence.

CoatRack · 25/01/2024 23:43

EasternStandard · 25/01/2024 23:30

You’d get your robber’s cruelty from your quote, which you seem keen on

Have you lived under an actual dictatorship? not stuff about U.K. gov but elsewhere?

I've given zero indication that I'm keen on anything in particular. The quote is an alternative to the "road to hell is paved with good intentions" phrase.
Sorry for trying to insert a bit of culture.

Regarding dictatorships, are you one of those people who thinks that criticising one thing means that you are automatically fully in favour of the other?
The world is not black and white, and we are not necessarily the 'good guys', even if we are the 'better guys', for now.
I fail to see how that is an objectionable position.