Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this ok instead of saving into a pension?

34 replies

avslp11 · 25/01/2024 19:10

Inspired by the thread on pensions that I read just now, I have no pension that i save into despite working on 45k and have been on around that since I was 26, I’m now 33.

My family own four homes and gift money every year around 10k. I save this and so far have 80k in savings and 220k left on my mortgage.

I know it’s not ideal to rely on inheritance but I have always thought that I would PROBABLY be fine. Is this wildly idiotic?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Savourycrepe · 25/01/2024 22:25

Agree with all the others. YABU - you are turning down free money. If you put the 10k into a pension, you would get at least £1.5k from your employer (their employer contribution) and £2k extra from the govt (tax relief). You are turning down £3.5k free money each year by not having a workplace pension.

Flossflower · 25/01/2024 21:46

Don’t count your chickens. I am well into my retirement and I don’t expect to get any inheritance from my parents or as it will probably be gone on care home fees. Even if I do get anything it will probably be too late. I am not in the slightest bit bothered about this as I made my own provisions as everyone should try to do.
You need to save into something tax efficient like a pension or shares ISA. It is silly not to take advantage of a work place pension.

ALunchbox · 25/01/2024 20:38

You may be fine but you never know. The houses could be needed to pay for care homes etc. I personally wouldn't rely on it and just think of it as a 'nice bonus' if it works out.

Allergictoironing · 25/01/2024 20:29

You do have to remember that any money that goes into your pension (up to an annual limit) is tax free, so to save £10k a year you only need to put £8k in. Plus as others have said, if you put 5% of your salary into a pension you get an additional 3% (minimum) from your employer and again for every £80 the both of you put in then £100 goes into the "pot". AS this is invested, there's likely to be a decent bit of growth plus the income, which is reinvested so the pot grows even more every year.

Currently the interest you get paid on your savings is very likely to be lower than the interest you're paying on your mortgage, so paying the mortgage off would be better for you. Plus the growth and income of any pension investments, even with the fees allowed for, is likely to be significantly higher than the interest you're earning on these savings.

Find yourself a good Financial Advisor. The initial consultation should be free and fees should only be payable on investments you make through them for pensions. I'm pretty sure they will tell you that having a pension and/or paying off the mortgage will be much more beneficial for your retirement. BTW I was a paraplanner in a previous life, so spent all my working days preparing reports along these lines for clients.

CuriousGeorge80 · 25/01/2024 20:24

You should definitely start a pension OP, regardless of the rest of it. Tax efficient and free money from your employer.

GreatGateauxsby · 25/01/2024 20:22

I’m not against this in principle…

how many siblings and what’s the value?

there is a big diff between 1 sibling and 4 London houses worth 6-7m

vs

3 siblings and 4 houses in the sticks worth £1-1.5m

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 25/01/2024 20:20

Apparently the rule of thumb is that if you want to retire at the standard age, and maintain the same standard of living, you need 10x your final salary saved in a pension. Obviously this will vary depending on other sources of income and outgoings, but might give you some idea of how far adrift you are

jm9138 · 25/01/2024 20:18

IcedupTulip · 25/01/2024 20:12

But you don’t take into account that if those properties were sold it means there’s less rental properties for people who really want them. Not everyone wants to own. Not everyone can own. What if your children aren’t in a position to own and NEED to rent and there are no landlords left?

i also really don’t believe that you wouldn’t take the money - maybe you would for your children if you don’t need it. Perhaps for a deposit for them for the future!

And that is why we need proper social housing.

Part of the problem we are in the sorry mess we are in this country with property (and elsewhere) is the ‘so long as I’m alright’ approach to everything.

No. I really would not take the money for me or my children. It is not mine. My values just differ from yours. I can understand the perspective of other people and I know I am in a minority with my views but I see a society that has become less fair since I was a child and part of that is because people just don’t question where the money is coming from

ObliviousCoalmine · 25/01/2024 20:13

I am in a similar situation to you.

Realistically, I shouldn't need a pension. But out of common sense and generally not wanting to count my chickens before the hatch, I've got a workplace pension. I only started it when I was 34 because I was a stay at home mum until that point.

Why wouldn't you set up a workplace pension? It's calculated pre-tax and your employer contributes, you're turning down 'free' money.

Any financial advisor will tell you similar.

avslp11 · 25/01/2024 20:13

jm9138 · 25/01/2024 20:06

It might surprise you to know that not everyone is the same. I wouldn’t take the money no. I didn’t earn it and it’s not mine. I would tell my parents if they really don’t need the money then they should sell the houses to people who can own them and invest properly and not rent seek. Or put the money in trust to actually help people who need it.

if you want one reason why my children - like many others - will struggle to get on the property ladder look no further than the OPs four homes they own. Still, my children can rent one of those homes to enable the OP to not have to worry about saving for a pension - that my children will still have to do - so so long as she is ok all is well.

@Jk987 your post is so contradictory, can’t you see that? You want your children to have a home, then they need a house deposit. But in your hypothetical world you’d reject money offered from you own parents which would then help your own children? And you’ll remain bitter that they can’t get on the property ladder.

Let me know if you want some salt with that chip.

OP posts:
IcedupTulip · 25/01/2024 20:12

jm9138 · 25/01/2024 20:06

It might surprise you to know that not everyone is the same. I wouldn’t take the money no. I didn’t earn it and it’s not mine. I would tell my parents if they really don’t need the money then they should sell the houses to people who can own them and invest properly and not rent seek. Or put the money in trust to actually help people who need it.

if you want one reason why my children - like many others - will struggle to get on the property ladder look no further than the OPs four homes they own. Still, my children can rent one of those homes to enable the OP to not have to worry about saving for a pension - that my children will still have to do - so so long as she is ok all is well.

But you don’t take into account that if those properties were sold it means there’s less rental properties for people who really want them. Not everyone wants to own. Not everyone can own. What if your children aren’t in a position to own and NEED to rent and there are no landlords left?

i also really don’t believe that you wouldn’t take the money - maybe you would for your children if you don’t need it. Perhaps for a deposit for them for the future!

Jean24601Valjean · 25/01/2024 20:09

Sorry but the employer contributions are the least of what you're missing out on with this set-up. You need to put the £10k each year into a Self-Invested Pension (SIPP) and invested in index tracked funds. Sounds scary I know but it's actually really easy if you do it using Hargreaves Lansdown or similar. I just did a quick compound interest calculation and if you started at only £10k (it sounds like you must have more than this) and continued at that rate for 35 years, at an estimated interest rate of 5% (which is very conservative, you'd have a pension fund of around £700k. Which is far more than enough to live on. And that's not even taking into account the tax you'd get back on the savings.

jm9138 · 25/01/2024 20:06

IcedupTulip · 25/01/2024 19:54

So if that was your parents properties, what would you do? Refuse the money? Give the houses to charity when you come to inherit them? Hardly. It’s pure jealousy. You would do exactly the same as the OP, as would I.

It might surprise you to know that not everyone is the same. I wouldn’t take the money no. I didn’t earn it and it’s not mine. I would tell my parents if they really don’t need the money then they should sell the houses to people who can own them and invest properly and not rent seek. Or put the money in trust to actually help people who need it.

if you want one reason why my children - like many others - will struggle to get on the property ladder look no further than the OPs four homes they own. Still, my children can rent one of those homes to enable the OP to not have to worry about saving for a pension - that my children will still have to do - so so long as she is ok all is well.

EdgarsTale · 25/01/2024 19:54

Well, you’re missing out on your employer’s contributions. Pensions are also tax efficient so it’s strange not to pay into your work pension.

I wouldn’t rely on inheritance. You never know what will happen-care needs, family fall out etc.

IcedupTulip · 25/01/2024 19:54

jm9138 · 25/01/2024 19:46

Technically it would be ‘envious’ and no. Suspect it is a perspective the OP had not considered. That £10k a year she gets is from (potentially) hard working people. She does not lift a finger to get this. I imagine if instead of saying she gets £10k from her parents rentals each year so did not want to save for her pension she instead said she received £10k in benefits allowing her to do the same you would vilify her. Sure the arguments will now come ‘but that is not the same’ they would both be unearned income for the OP.

Edited

So if that was your parents properties, what would you do? Refuse the money? Give the houses to charity when you come to inherit them? Hardly. It’s pure jealousy. You would do exactly the same as the OP, as would I.

jm9138 · 25/01/2024 19:46

IcedupTulip · 25/01/2024 19:34

What’s wrong with that? Jealous much?

Technically it would be ‘envious’ and no. Suspect it is a perspective the OP had not considered. That £10k a year she gets is from (potentially) hard working people. She does not lift a finger to get this. I imagine if instead of saying she gets £10k from her parents rentals each year so did not want to save for her pension she instead said she received £10k in benefits allowing her to do the same you would vilify her. Sure the arguments will now come ‘but that is not the same’ they would both be unearned income for the OP.

HousePlantNeglect · 25/01/2024 19:37

I think it's always worth it to get the free employer contributions and the tax relief. Even if you pay in a small amount it's worth it to diversify. I'm keen never to have all my eggs in one basket.

WantOutOfRatRace · 25/01/2024 19:35

Definitely look into joining your workplace pension, as the bit the employer pays in is basically free money. I'd also play around with a salary calculator for different % contributions from yourself too as often increasing your contribution doesn't decrease your take home as much as you expect (due to tax savings, etc)

IcedupTulip · 25/01/2024 19:34

jm9138 · 25/01/2024 19:30

‘I am relying on people who rent my parents properties to subsidise my lifestyle now and in my old age’. I think your picture should be in the dictionary under ‘entitled’ and exemplifies one of the things wrong with our society and economy.

What’s wrong with that? Jealous much?

avslp11 · 25/01/2024 19:31

@jm9138 thanks for your input

OP posts:
jm9138 · 25/01/2024 19:30

‘I am relying on people who rent my parents properties to subsidise my lifestyle now and in my old age’. I think your picture should be in the dictionary under ‘entitled’ and exemplifies one of the things wrong with our society and economy.

IcedupTulip · 25/01/2024 19:30

I don’t know to be honest but I don’t have much of a pension at 47 but we are becoming landlords to a small property that we won’t have a mortgage on and are planning to use the rental income as our pension in the future. Hopefully we will be ok.

NewYearNewCalendar · 25/01/2024 19:30

Do you mean you don’t have a workplace pension at all? Yes frankly that is wildly idiotic if so - you’re missing out on the tax benefits and the employer contributions. Start one, tomorrow!

How old are the people involved? I suspect I may want to retire before I receive any inheritance! What if the people involved marry a gambler, or suddenly need expensive care, etc etc. Do not put all your eggs in that basket.

If you actually mean you have one, but you don’t pay any extra in, that’s a bit different. I think it’s a good idea to have some diversity in your income/savings.

avslp11 · 25/01/2024 19:30

Yes I opted out as my salary wasn’t that high initially. Thanks I’m going to look into it a bit more! I’m single and likely to always be (terrible luck with men!) so it will likely just be me on my own in future.

OP posts:
Zoomerang · 25/01/2024 19:28

Jk987 · 25/01/2024 19:26

I thought it was a legal requirement for all employers to pay into a staff pension. Why haven't you got one through work?

It’s a legal requirement for most employers to offer one to most staff, but you can opt out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread