Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I told DD I wish I had never had her

272 replies

user9009887 · 25/01/2024 17:41

I feel terrible obviously I never meant it but life is just stressful at the moment.

In August my husband and father of my two children DS 20 and DD 16 left. He had been having an affair for 5 years and when I found out he went to live with the other woman.

He has no contact with DD but does see DS occasionally as they both work near each other.

DD doesn't talk about her Dad she started college in September and has made new friends and doesn't speak about her home life to them. She doesn't see any old school friends anymore I don't know if that is just a part of growing up or if it is to avoid talking about her Dad.

I'm in the middle of a messy divorce and was going over bits this afternoon and I snapped at DD and told her I wish I had never had her.

Her Dad has abandoned her and now I have said this to her I can't imagine what is going on in her head right now.

OP posts:
MuckyEyebrows · 25/01/2024 19:07

I overheard my mum telling my step dad that she wished she hadn’t had me and it was just those two and their new child.

I was 16. I’m 42 now and still not over it.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 25/01/2024 19:06

Hereinthismoment · 25/01/2024 17:46

You know MN will probably be more unforgiving and harsh than your DD ever will (unless she is a Victorian judge.)

It’s a form of self punishment. I would just apologise sincerely and move on.

My mother said this to me years ago when I was a teenager. You may forgive, you don't forget.

wellhello24 · 25/01/2024 19:04

I feel like someone punched me in the gut just reading this and it’s not even about me. Add in the surrounding hurt re absent father and brother getting car & driving lessons & her not.

You must go to the ends of the earth to make her understand you didn’t mean it you must put her no1 until she believes you anything less than this then you will never to repair The damage you’ve caused. When I was 16 my mum told me she loved me but didn’t like me & Iv never forgotten that it was excruciating and felt like the worse kind of rejection. What you said is so much worse. I know you feel bad that’s why you’re posting but you have got to get this across to her & how much you didn’t mean it or else your relationship will never be the same and she will always be scarred. You are supposed to be her guardian. Please do the right thing and also get yourself some support at the same time.

TheFairyCaravan · 25/01/2024 19:04

My mum said this too me, too. More than once however she really meant it and I’m not entirely sure you do. I don’t have a proper relationship with my parents anymore, mainly because of how cruel she is and because my dad refused to accept it and won’t accept the truth.

What you said won’t leave her. She’s going to be feeling so hurt. You’ve got a lot of apologising to do.

thefallen · 25/01/2024 19:04

Well, whatever happens she won't forget it. I haven't.

sprigatito · 25/01/2024 19:03

ZoeCM · 25/01/2024 18:53

OP, you need to prepare yourself for the possibility that your relationship with your daughter will never be the same again. As MN shows, people cut contact with their mothers for far less than this.

Do they really? I don't think so. There's a huge difference between a loving parent who says a terrible thing once - followed by lots of remorse, love and reassurance - and one who says this stuff and means it.

My mother said things like this constantly. "You've never brought me anything but heartache", "I wish to God I'd never had any of you", etc. She said it so often that by the time I was OP's DD's age I would eye roll and mutter "me too". Moreover she proved in the way she treated me that she absolutely meant it. No surprise that we have no contact now.

OP isn't anywhere near that situation. There's every chance of pulling this round and while her DD will remember that she said it and it hurt, it doesn't have to define their relationship.

I think some people just love to put the boot in, tbh. It's sick.

ManchesterLu · 25/01/2024 19:03

My mum said this to me once. Even though she apologised later, I'm far too aware that we tend to say what we really mean in the heat of the moment, and it's quite likely she means it, and would have preferred not to have children.

I'm child-free myself, by choice, so can completely understand, and feel quite guilty that she spent the best years of her life looking after us.

OodlesPoodle · 25/01/2024 19:03

user9009887 · 25/01/2024 18:55

I said it in the context - sometimes I wish i had never had kids. I didn't mean it for one moment but just that divorce would be much easier without them.

She is desperate for driving lessons when she turns 17 and we bought them for DS and a car for his 17th and she knows that it isn't going to happen for her.
Her dad hasn't been around for her the past 4 years, never came to any of her parents evenings or helped with homework like he did with DS.

Before Christmas there were plans for them (DD and DS) to meet up with their dad but DS couldn't make it as he had plans with his girlfriend and husband said there was no point in meeting that weekend then, so she already feels unwanted by her dad and now I have gone and said this.

Wow, I now hope this isn't a genuine post because this context about her dad changes everything. She IS unwanted, and has been since before her dad left. That's the only thing you should be caring about frankly, so there is no cause for what you said. You took the thing that makes her most vulnerable as a child and used it against her.

Also the fact you stayed with her dad knowing how he treated her?? You're complicit in her feelings of abandonment, so I really don't see any way of her moving past this. It's not just one comment, it's a lifetime of feeling this way that you have now confirmed.

Incogg · 25/01/2024 19:02

What an infuriating thread. What do you even want from it? I find it difficult to imagine anyone genuinely doing this and then posting about it in such a vague manner.

Snugglemonkey · 25/01/2024 19:01

Newbutoldfather · 25/01/2024 17:49

I don’t think it is just about apologising, although you definitely need to do that.

It is as bad as it gets, really, as it will make her wonder about the value of her entire existence.

You need to address how you came to say it and how you can become a proper parent to your daughter. Will counselling or family therapy help? Maybe a teenage parenting course?

You need to make sure you never ever say anything like it again and become a consistent supportive parent, but still maintain appropriate boundaries, The worst you can do is oscillate between this type of comment and over effusive displays of love and affection.

This. Also, do not attempt to justify it in any way.

Peachpicklepie · 25/01/2024 19:01

Hereinthismoment · 25/01/2024 17:46

You know MN will probably be more unforgiving and harsh than your DD ever will (unless she is a Victorian judge.)

It’s a form of self punishment. I would just apologise sincerely and move on.

Quite obviously not true. MN will read, comment, and move on. Her daughter has to live with this for life and won't forget.

booh1276 · 25/01/2024 19:00

I was told this once and never forgot it.

CustardySergeant · 25/01/2024 18:59

How did she react and have you apologised?

CaptainMyCaptain · 25/01/2024 18:58

Hoardasurass · 25/01/2024 17:45

Sorry op but as someone who's mum said similar to me in a similar situation I can honestly tell you that she will never forget what you've said, all you can do is try to repair the damage you've done asap

I had similar and I didn't ever forget it.

Roselilly36 · 25/01/2024 18:57

@ZoeCM adult children don’t cut contact with their parents, unless they have very good reason to do so. It’s never a decision taken lightly.

DaffodilsAlready · 25/01/2024 18:57

Sorry, cross post

DaffodilsAlready · 25/01/2024 18:56

user9009887 · 25/01/2024 17:41

I feel terrible obviously I never meant it but life is just stressful at the moment.

In August my husband and father of my two children DS 20 and DD 16 left. He had been having an affair for 5 years and when I found out he went to live with the other woman.

He has no contact with DD but does see DS occasionally as they both work near each other.

DD doesn't talk about her Dad she started college in September and has made new friends and doesn't speak about her home life to them. She doesn't see any old school friends anymore I don't know if that is just a part of growing up or if it is to avoid talking about her Dad.

I'm in the middle of a messy divorce and was going over bits this afternoon and I snapped at DD and told her I wish I had never had her.

Her Dad has abandoned her and now I have said this to her I can't imagine what is going on in her head right now.

How did going over bits in the middle of a messy divorce lead to the comment that you wish you had never had your DD? There is no clear connection - I can sort of understand if you got married when you were pregnant with her (my mum got married when she was pregnant with my sister and then got pregnant with me when she was breastfeeding and said she then felt she had to stay and it ruined her life - I do think that was not too far from she wished she never had me, but not actually that far). But you were four years into a marriage and your DD was eleven when your husband started an affair, and that is of course not your DD’s fault. So it is difficult to see where it came from.

It is also not easy to see the relevance of your DD’s new friendship group. It is not unusual to get caught up with new friends when you start college or Uni - my DD’s best friend went AWOL in the first semester, which DD was upset/concerned about, and I ended up just dropping DD’s gift for her off at her house in January and texting the friend’s mum could DD visit before she left to go back to Uni. And now things are back to normal with their communication and friendship. It’s a big adjustment. It’s also not unusual for DC to have separated parents but it is unusual for their father not to have any communication. Surely you need here to step in and tell her dad he still has responsibilities? If you have not done so already. No divorce is so messy that parents should stop thinking what their DC need.

user9009887 · 25/01/2024 18:55

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 25/01/2024 18:24

If you explained the context, perhaps posters could help you through this.

Did you say and mean DD specifically? Or a generic “kids ruin your life, they’re so stressful, wish I’d never had them”? What was the conversation about when you said this?

Did you mean her, or her and her brother?

You’ll know all the things, including about seeing her life from her perspective. I think getting over this could be a matter of months and years, not days and weeks. What you do immediately will matter. Don’t let her stew with the idea that you wish she didn’t exist/hadn’t been born.

I said it in the context - sometimes I wish i had never had kids. I didn't mean it for one moment but just that divorce would be much easier without them.

She is desperate for driving lessons when she turns 17 and we bought them for DS and a car for his 17th and she knows that it isn't going to happen for her.
Her dad hasn't been around for her the past 4 years, never came to any of her parents evenings or helped with homework like he did with DS.

Before Christmas there were plans for them (DD and DS) to meet up with their dad but DS couldn't make it as he had plans with his girlfriend and husband said there was no point in meeting that weekend then, so she already feels unwanted by her dad and now I have gone and said this.

OP posts:
Roselilly36 · 25/01/2024 18:55

What a terrible thing to say to your child. Very damaging. You will have a lot of making up to do OP.

Scottishskifun · 25/01/2024 18:54

You need to correct this and quickly. Take her out for a meal (neutral ground), explain yourself that you didn't mean it at all, she was and is wanted and that you're sorry for snapping in the stress of the moment. That you will give her space but hope that you can both move past it in time.

Basically you need to get grovelling and quickly.

ZoeCM · 25/01/2024 18:53

OP, you need to prepare yourself for the possibility that your relationship with your daughter will never be the same again. As MN shows, people cut contact with their mothers for far less than this.

Hoardasurass · 25/01/2024 18:50

@LightSwerve yes she did eventually but by then it was far to little far to late. I have never forgotten nor forgiven her it basically destroyed our relationship well that plus the "you've been nothing but trouble since you were conceived" (when in therapy trying to fix things). I haven't spoken to her in more than a decade and have zero intention to ever do so again

Patrickiscrazy · 25/01/2024 18:50

Somepeoplearesnippy · 25/01/2024 18:23

My mum used to say this to me. It damaged me and our relationship. She died earlier this month. I have been a dutiful daughter all my life and took care of her in her old age but there was never really any genuine affection there. She killed it stone dead long ago.

however your situation is different I think. First of all I heard it repeatedly and it was reflected in her treatment of me so I knew it was true. Also my mum never apologised or retracted it. In your case it doesn't seem to be true - it was a momentary lashing out set against a lifetime of love and support. It doesn't make it ok but she probably knows deep down you didn't mean it. You have to opportunity to apologise and tell her you know it was a cruel and untrue thing to say and ask her to let you start afresh.

I'm very, very sorry. My mother is a narcissistic bully (I'm a 44yo) but even she didn't manage this. May I ask, why have you been a dutiful daughter?? I effed off to another country, married and wouldn't dream of "caretaking".

OodlesPoodle · 25/01/2024 18:46

If life were normal for her, then I think a heartfelt apology and re-assurance you didn't mean it would be enough. But her dad has just abandoned her in the worst way possible, and avoiding her while still seeing her brother. So it's going to cut her much deeper than normal. This is a formative time for her because it's so traumatic and she's so young.

Do you wish you'd never had her? Do you blame her for your DH leaving? Because it's a very extreme comment to make even under stress. I don't think there's smoke without fire, unless you just really wanted to hurt her? I personally think she has started checking out of home already, given you said she doesn't discuss her home life with friends (can you blame her?). So you've got a limited period to fix things with her or you'll likely not see her again as soon as she finishes college and moves out. Take her out for a meal and have a proper conversation and apology with her.

LightSwerve · 25/01/2024 18:41

Mariposistaaa · 25/01/2024 18:34

I honest don’t know what you can do or say to undo this. She will never forget it. She might forgive you but in that one lapse of judgement‘ because life is stressful’ you will have done irreparable damage. Poor, poor girl. I hope she has good friends and kind teachers.

Edited

I feel this is too dramatic, errors can be repaired with genuine apologies.