Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This is a terrible pension position isn’t it?!

135 replies

haengry · 25/01/2024 15:38

I’m 38. I just got a letter from my private pension with the annual update and it says my pension value is currently 28k. For context I have been paying in since I was 25 and my employer makes a contribution too. We each pay it 4% a year so 8% in total. My starting salary was 30k and I’ve been on 60k the last two years and then in the fifties a few years prior to that. Surely it should be more? Does that literally mean I have 28k to my name if I was to retire tomorrow?!

OP posts:
Didimum · 25/01/2024 18:40

Moreorlessmentallystable · 25/01/2024 18:35

It's rubbish. I have like £12k ...and I am 40! Seems like pensions do not make money anymore. They always stay the same or go down after fees. It pisses me off that they make it a legal requirement to contribute. I am good at saving and would much rather invest it myself then give it to these crooks, the only ones benefiting are the people that get to play with our money and loose it while they get big bonuses. At this point even putting the money into a high interest rate account would give me better returns

Definitely. Having other investments of your own is a very wise move.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 25/01/2024 18:35

It's rubbish. I have like £12k ...and I am 40! Seems like pensions do not make money anymore. They always stay the same or go down after fees. It pisses me off that they make it a legal requirement to contribute. I am good at saving and would much rather invest it myself then give it to these crooks, the only ones benefiting are the people that get to play with our money and loose it while they get big bonuses. At this point even putting the money into a high interest rate account would give me better returns

KT8282 · 25/01/2024 18:30

The half your age thing is the % you pay in when you start saving. OP started at 25yo so should aim for 12.5% salary every year to retirement. This is not supposed to then increase by 0.5% every year you age. If you start saving at 40yo you need 20% salary every year until retirement and so on.

Didimum · 25/01/2024 18:17

leftoverss · 25/01/2024 18:09

I think this is risky, I would always want to have my own healthy pension too.

Personal choice though, isn’t it. If we get divorced then I get half his pension anyway.

ConsistentlyElectrifiedElves · 25/01/2024 18:12

JustBeach · 25/01/2024 16:07

Contact Scottish Widows- you probably have a pot of money sat in there too. My workplace pension is split between providers from different jobs and I'm planning on moving them into the same one.

This.

Also, can you afford to pay more? You can add voluntary contributions out of your net pay in to your workplace pension - if you have an Aviva account, it should allow you to set this up. The 8% total is a minimum payment - you can always pay more.

Alternatively, talk to your employer about whether you can do a "salary sacrifice" and pay in to your pension scheme gross (i.e. rather than pay £100 out of your net salary, you pay it out of your gross, saving you income tax and NI on it) -
Info

As others have said, you can transfer old pensions in to your new ones - you'd need to speak with the previous pension provider about transferring it to the new one.

The Chancellor announced in the Autumn Statement that it would be possible in the future to request that you keep the same pension when you change jobs, to avoid people having lots of pots all over the place.

Finally, on your Aviva login, you may find you can adjust how you want your pension saved. You may be able to choose your risk levels, so a higher risk might bring a higher return.

I am 44 and have less than you in my pot. It's something I'm working towards resolving, but I do have some other investments elsewhere.

Have a look at this website too - https://www.pensionbee.com/pension-calculator

PropertyManager · 25/01/2024 18:11

28K is better than mine, I'm 44 and have a grand total of £4.77 in a Black Rock scheme, thats it!!, thats retirement planning for you!!

leftoverss · 25/01/2024 18:09

Didimum · 25/01/2024 18:05

Mine is only 25k and I’m on similar salary to you, OP. I refuse to make larger contributions right now with a young family to bring up. My husband does have a large NHS pension though, so I have that to even it out.

I think this is risky, I would always want to have my own healthy pension too.

leftoverss · 25/01/2024 18:07

That is quite low. My sister has a similar contribution over a similar number of years and has double that. It's still not great, as her pension portal says by the time she retires she will get £5k pa.

Overthebow · 25/01/2024 18:07

You need to pay in more than 4%. Even an extra 2% would make a difference as you’re on a good salary.

Didimum · 25/01/2024 18:05

Mine is only 25k and I’m on similar salary to you, OP. I refuse to make larger contributions right now with a young family to bring up. My husband does have a large NHS pension though, so I have that to even it out.

haengry · 25/01/2024 18:03

Thanks everyone!

im never going to be able to pay in 20%, single parent to a young child. I am hoping inheritances will pay off my mortgage and if not I will be very poor!

I will check Scottish windows as suggested, thank you

OP posts:
CKL987 · 25/01/2024 17:37

Also, people keep commenting on certain providers not performing well but it doesn't work like that. There will be a range of funds you can invest, some in house with your provider and some external. Your performance will depend on where it is invested so people can't just say Aviva or scottish widows perform badly, it is nowhere near as simple as that.

CKL987 · 25/01/2024 17:34

A few things to consider before you even start thinking about how it has been invested.

  1. have you always been with the same employer? You mention a Scottish widows one too so could that be with a different employer? Your contributions won't go to the same pot with different employers.
  2. as a higher rate tax payer you won't automatically get the higher rate tax relief that you qualify for. If you pay your contributions by a method called salary sacrifice (your payroll can confirm this) then you will be getting the relief. If you don't do salary sacrifice then you need to claim the relief via a tax return and I think you can claim up to 5 years back.
  3. ask your provider for your full contribution history to make sure the correct contributions have been paid.
  4. once you've got everything sorted and know where all your pension money is you can start looking at where it is invested.
CoffeeMachineNewbie · 25/01/2024 17:32

Have you been working part time or had unpaid maternity leave?

GreatGateauxsby · 25/01/2024 17:27

I think main issue is your contributions are really rather low.

You should be paying in half your age.
ie 20%+
I am your age and pay in 30% of my gross or more! I am still concerned mine is low as I have always had shit private pension schemes defined contributions not a defined benefit. (My employer contributions have been between 3!!! And 8 %)

Agree with pp that Aviva are a bit shit though so your yield might be poor too...but that's a secondary issue.

I'd look at setting up a SIPP (vanguard AJ Bell etc all do them.... Takes 30 mins to set one up) and making private contributions

ActDottie · 25/01/2024 17:13

My guess is they changed provider and you have another find somewhere as that seems very low.

I’ve been working 8 years and had similar salary progression to you although now on £75k and have about £90k in mine.

BreakingAndBroke · 25/01/2024 17:05

Mine is lower than that sadly 😔 I have a much lower salary than you, but I upped my pension contributions by 1% with every annual pay rise I've received over the last few years and now pay 12% (+ employer contribution). It is unlikely you can go from 4% to 50% overnight, but try upping to 6% this year, 7% next year an so on. Good luck 🍀

Augustus40 · 25/01/2024 16:55

Shouldn't your employers be paying 8 per cent?

My son just got a permanent job after a temporary contract there first. He will be paying 4 % the employers 8%. It is with Fidelity. I think they are good as I used to have them as part of a private pension which did quite well.

Figment1982 · 25/01/2024 16:54

I suspect that your employer transferred from a different pension fund at some point previously and therefore you have another one elsewhere.

ohididntrealise · 25/01/2024 16:51

KnottyKnitting · 25/01/2024 16:29

Indexation is an increasing amount that you pay towards your pension depending on stuff like inflation.

Mine was not applied when it was taken over 12 years previous (can't remember who from) We have paid an additional amount to cover this short fall but that was 18 months ago and it's still wrong!
If you look on your pension online you will be able to see if the indexation was applied since it was taken over.

We have complained to the ombudsman about it but they are pretty useless too or at least take ages to investigate and I have come to the conclusion that Aviva know this hence the inaction.

We have actually written to the CEO but this was three weeks ago and still nothing has been done.

We are about to go to watchdog about it and suspect that Aviva are going to be in deep deep shit over it as lots of other people are going to be coming up against the issues we have had with them which is going to cost them an absolute fortune to put right!

Indexation refers to pensions in payment.

This is different to the OP's scenario.

The OP's position is that her pot isn't big enough.

OP, you need to increase your contributions. And also track down previous pensions. It sounds like you have another pot with Scottish Widows.

This isn't disastrous, you have time to turn it around.

WolfFoxHare · 25/01/2024 16:48

Hetty2507 · 25/01/2024 16:26

The rough rule is to put away half of your age as a %. So if you are 38 you should be paying 19% (you+employer) into your pension. I don't think you've been paying enough.

Oh, that’s good to know. I haven’t heard that before.

Tooolde · 25/01/2024 16:48

I dont think scottish widows tends to perform well on pensions. My work one was predicting £5k if i carried on contributing the same. So low i havent even bothered looking at it.

You can also put in sipps. And get the tax added.

But more in work one maybe better if they match it??

Or theres LISAs. Up to 4k and get 25% extra added. However can only start before 40 and pay in to 50.
downside of LISA is it will count as saving for UC so could affect if you lose a job............

my shares have all dropped since i bought them - however i invested in ones with high dividend %.

you can pay into pension lower of 40k or full earnings. and get tax added. So you could build up pretty quickly.

forcedfun · 25/01/2024 16:43

I have a 10k pot from just two years work at a £35 k salary 15 years ago, so that sounds v low. I think you should do some more digging.

Public sector work is good if you want to boost your pension.

Hillarious · 25/01/2024 16:33

Your contributions sound low. I pay 9% of my salary, and the employer pays 18%. I don't look at the amount I "lose" each month, just the bottom line once all deductions have been made. I've only had my current job/pension for 17 years, but for a previous private pension my employer match funded my contributions. Will your employer match your payments if you increase yours?

Stickthatupyourdojo · 25/01/2024 16:31

I'm a similar age and salary OP and don't have a huge fund, mines around £50k at last check, but it lost £10k in one year a couple of years ago, could that have happened to you?