Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This is a terrible pension position isn’t it?!

135 replies

haengry · 25/01/2024 15:38

I’m 38. I just got a letter from my private pension with the annual update and it says my pension value is currently 28k. For context I have been paying in since I was 25 and my employer makes a contribution too. We each pay it 4% a year so 8% in total. My starting salary was 30k and I’ve been on 60k the last two years and then in the fifties a few years prior to that. Surely it should be more? Does that literally mean I have 28k to my name if I was to retire tomorrow?!

OP posts:
Flatulence · 26/01/2024 15:57

Yes, sorry, your pension pot is very low but you can act now to improve it and you'll have another 30yrs in the workplace to help you out. Don't panic.
For context, I'm a bit older than you and on about the same pay. I didn't really get my arse in gear for a pension til I was 30, and didn't start earning over 50k til about 5 or 6yrs ago. Yet my pot is a lot bigger (not megabucks, but not terrible either) but only because my contributions are a fair bit more than yours, and my employer contributions are very generous.
If you work for a large(ish) employer they should run pension events via HR, or the company that provides your workplace pension may send you info about events. Otherwise get advice from organisations like Pensionwise. Martin Lewis also has good advice on his website.
There are things you can do to increase your contributions without significantly affecting your take home pay.
You could also look at having a private pension. I set one up a couple of years back, and while it's only very small and I don't put in very much at all it is worth having it to diversify where the money is invested. I use Scottish Widows.
I know you're a single parent, which affects how much you can realistically afford to put in. But as your child/children grow you'll have to fork out less for extortionate childcare - and that will allow you to save more.
In addition, I set up a Lifetime ISA (LISA) before I turned 40. This is absolutely worth doing as the Government will top it up by (I think) 20pc if you don't touch it til you're over 60.
I use Hargreaves Lansdowne for my LISA and a stocks and shares ISA - the latter only has about a grand in it as I know fuck all about investing 🤣
I'd not worry too much, but you do need to act now. £10 saved now will be able to grow so much more than £20 invested in a decade's time.
Good luck. It is confusing but you're doing the right thing by thinking about the future.

5thCommandment · 26/01/2024 15:21

Genuinely baffles me that people don't prioritise pensions. Teach children at school age and get them paying in 10% from 18. Also set up a junior ISA for them. The state pension age will rise and rise and is peanuts.

I pay in 28% currently plus bonuses, my employer 10%. For tax efficiency alone it's a no brainer. I'd put in more if I could.

ACynicalDad · 26/01/2024 15:05

Some pensions are limited to qualifying earnings, rather than them paying 5% of 60k they pay 5% of that band which is about 5-45k so 5% of 40, meaning you get about 1/3 less in your pension than you would expect.

Ilovemybike88 · 26/01/2024 14:45

Best thing I have done is contribute to my work pension so I get the ‘free money’ from my employer. But every so often, once or twice a year, I transfer the balance to my SIPP so i can manage the money myself. Transferring money to the SIPP is very easy, an online form which take 2 minutes. I like being in charge of my money and get a much better rate of return than I would with the work pension but I’m still getting the ‘free money’

Makeitmakesensetoday · 26/01/2024 14:07

KnottyKnitting · 25/01/2024 22:17

Look at your statements online- it should show if the indexation has been applied.

Good luck if it hasn't- they are bloody useless. I think there is a flag on my account so when someone sees my name flash up their call centre operatives have a script for the same old flannel, pretend to speak to "someone from billing" go and make a cup of tea and then come back with lies about someone looking into it.

" it's being expedited, someone will call you within 48 hours..." yadayadayada- total bullshit- not once has the situation been dealt with within 10working days and not once has anyone ever called me back following 15 calls during the two years this has been going on.

They took nearly £5k of extra money to cover the shortfall and 18 months later the account is inaccessible and the projection letters they have sent me still don't reflect the indexation. As far as I am concerned they have stolen from me. Even the CEO hasn't expedited anything despite a letter assuring she would.

For those of you considering any dealings with Aviva - don't- they are a bunch of clowns.

Thank you sorry to be dense but what would it look like on a statement? Would it literally say indexation? And do you mean indexation I.e increasing in line with inflation? Thanks

WolfFoxHare · 26/01/2024 09:55

CatusFlatus · 26/01/2024 09:46

I think the rule of thumb is based on the age you are when you start to pay into a pension, not the age you are now.

E.g. If you start paying in at age 20 then 10% is what you should pay in for the rest of your working life, but if you don't start till age 40 then you need to pay in 20%.

Ah ok. Hmmm. I started a bit late and wasn’t putting enough in at the start but for the last few years I’ve been putting much more in than half my age… Thanks for the clarification.

CatusFlatus · 26/01/2024 09:54

Anyone wanting to understand more about saving for retirement or personal finance in general I'd recommend the Meaningful Money podcasts and YouTube videos.

CatusFlatus · 26/01/2024 09:52

ohididntrealise · 26/01/2024 09:36

@Moreorlessmentallystable

Two points:

  1. yes, you are correct, you will pay tax when you draw your pension. However, the tax relief on the way in will have had the benefit of compounding. Therefore the tax on the way out will have less of an effect due to the compounding effect.

Also, with things such as flexiaccess drawdown, you can manage how much you take to do it in a tax advantaged manner.

Also, the funds within the wrapper grow free of capital gains tax.

Finally, they do not form part of your estate and therefore are free from inheritance tax .

  1. you say you are good at saving, not investing. Well yes, this is why I said you can invest in money market funds if this is your preference.

Over the long term equity markets have significantly outperformed cash. But nobody is forcing you to invest. You can save into cash funds if you'd rather.

However, the tax efficiency of pensions isn't really a matter of opinion. It's a fact. And the tax benefits are so good that subsequent governments may change the rules on this. So it really makes sense to use them while you can.

More sound advice 😊

CatusFlatus · 26/01/2024 09:49

ohididntrealise · 25/01/2024 18:54

You've misunderstood.

Pensions are just a wrapper. A very advantageous tax wrapper.

Within the wrapper, you can do what you want. And achieve tax relief.

You say you are good at investing. Well, do it. You can invest and manage your own pension. It's no different to any other investment. Except it receives tax relief, is not liable to CGT or IHT.

You don't need to let any "crooks" manage your money; you can do it yourself.

This is good advice.

CatusFlatus · 26/01/2024 09:46

WolfFoxHare · 25/01/2024 16:48

Oh, that’s good to know. I haven’t heard that before.

I think the rule of thumb is based on the age you are when you start to pay into a pension, not the age you are now.

E.g. If you start paying in at age 20 then 10% is what you should pay in for the rest of your working life, but if you don't start till age 40 then you need to pay in 20%.

ohididntrealise · 26/01/2024 09:36

@Moreorlessmentallystable

Two points:

  1. yes, you are correct, you will pay tax when you draw your pension. However, the tax relief on the way in will have had the benefit of compounding. Therefore the tax on the way out will have less of an effect due to the compounding effect.

Also, with things such as flexiaccess drawdown, you can manage how much you take to do it in a tax advantaged manner.

Also, the funds within the wrapper grow free of capital gains tax.

Finally, they do not form part of your estate and therefore are free from inheritance tax .

  1. you say you are good at saving, not investing. Well yes, this is why I said you can invest in money market funds if this is your preference.

Over the long term equity markets have significantly outperformed cash. But nobody is forcing you to invest. You can save into cash funds if you'd rather.

However, the tax efficiency of pensions isn't really a matter of opinion. It's a fact. And the tax benefits are so good that subsequent governments may change the rules on this. So it really makes sense to use them while you can.

Bigwig1 · 25/01/2024 22:49

For the people commenting that they'll only receive £20k p/a if they were to purchase an annuity with their fund, I think this is pretty decent is it not?! I mean, assuming you don't have a mortgage to pay come retirement, that seems plenty...? Am I missing something here?

EasterIssland · 25/01/2024 22:47

Woaluka · 25/01/2024 22:39

Up your pension salary sacrifice to get your taxable pay under 50k and then claim child benefit!

Saying this reminded me have you done self assessment? It’s compulsory for those earning over 50k if they receive child benefit

Woaluka · 25/01/2024 22:39

Up your pension salary sacrifice to get your taxable pay under 50k and then claim child benefit!

Didimum · 25/01/2024 22:33

forcedfun · 25/01/2024 22:28

Ah ok the bit about the high salary confused me

Yes, I’m hoping to grow it much more now because of the jump! You know, if world war and global pandemics can hold off 🙄

forcedfun · 25/01/2024 22:28

Didimum · 25/01/2024 22:17

I was on a very low salary for the most part of that - lower than national average. It’s only shot up in the last 2-3 years. Plus, as another PP mentioned had happened to her, my pot absolutely tanked in the covid/post covid years. Lost a good 20% and that’s only now slowly recovering.

Ah ok the bit about the high salary confused me

EasterIssland · 25/01/2024 22:27

Can you make a bit more your invest ? I once read a comment saying you should put %50 of your age (tho it wasn’t like that but that’s what stuck in my mind :)). I’m 38 and I’m close to that 50%. 10% myself and 7% the company. I earn a bit more than you tho not by much and I think I’m paying £700 only myself. Which at the end of the year it’s around £12k(and as someone has said I do it by tax relief so it helps a bit more as well)

any chance you can increase your % a bit higher ?

InAMess2023 · 25/01/2024 22:23

I'm 38. My pension value is 0

So no

OddityOddityOdd · 25/01/2024 22:22

You need to pay in far more, about 15%, more if your scheme permits it and you can afford it.

KnottyKnitting · 25/01/2024 22:17

Look at your statements online- it should show if the indexation has been applied.

Good luck if it hasn't- they are bloody useless. I think there is a flag on my account so when someone sees my name flash up their call centre operatives have a script for the same old flannel, pretend to speak to "someone from billing" go and make a cup of tea and then come back with lies about someone looking into it.

" it's being expedited, someone will call you within 48 hours..." yadayadayada- total bullshit- not once has the situation been dealt with within 10working days and not once has anyone ever called me back following 15 calls during the two years this has been going on.

They took nearly £5k of extra money to cover the shortfall and 18 months later the account is inaccessible and the projection letters they have sent me still don't reflect the indexation. As far as I am concerned they have stolen from me. Even the CEO hasn't expedited anything despite a letter assuring she would.

For those of you considering any dealings with Aviva - don't- they are a bunch of clowns.

Didimum · 25/01/2024 22:17

forcedfun · 25/01/2024 22:09

You've paid in for 14 years and only have a pot of £25k?

I was on a very low salary for the most part of that - lower than national average. It’s only shot up in the last 2-3 years. Plus, as another PP mentioned had happened to her, my pot absolutely tanked in the covid/post covid years. Lost a good 20% and that’s only now slowly recovering.

forcedfun · 25/01/2024 22:09

Didimum · 25/01/2024 20:47

I’m not relying it. I have my own pension which I have paid into for 14yrs without a break + a high salary, and having a well-off spouse helps.

You've paid in for 14 years and only have a pot of £25k?

Makeitmakesensetoday · 25/01/2024 21:40

KnottyKnitting · 25/01/2024 16:02

Who is the provider? Taken over by Aviva in 2009/10?

If so check the indexation has been applied- mine wasn't ( absolutely their fault which they admitted) and 15 calls, endless letters and emails over nearly 2 years and despite having paid the extra to bring it up to date it's still not sorted. They are laughably, blindingly incompetent and I wouldn't recommend touching them with a 10 foot barge pole.

How to check this please? I have 3 aviva pensions.

Singlespies · 25/01/2024 21:30

People slag off pensions, but they have great tax benefits, especially if you are a higher rate tax payer. Nowadays, you don't have to buy an annuity but can do income draw down. So, even a modest amount can make the difference between retiring at 65 or having to wait til 67. Perhaps this is the opportunity for the OP to do some research. And, if you can't put in half your age, don't then put in zero. Even modest contributions can help.

LewishamMumNow · 25/01/2024 20:57

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 25/01/2024 16:04

I'll make you feel better... i only have £2k in my old one that i had wirh work. I never paid into any when I was working during my 20s or 30s (the company was very small so didn't offer pension schemes).

I've not been working since I had my 2 DC from 2017, and before that i worked for 13 years in publishing before i had a head injury and post concussion syndrome 9 years ago.

My DH has several good pension pots which he has paid into since his early 20s. He's now 53, I'm 42.

So I am pretty buggered really, unless I get a big inheritance or win the lottery.

There are always plenty of people worse off than you, OP. You might not think your pension is much, but it's £35k more than mine. ✨️

Don't agree. I'm 42 in less than a month, and didn't start saving for a pension until I was 40 1/2. I work for a trade union - not great pay, but great benefits, including pension. After 12 months in the job my defined benefit provision was £1,500 ie at retirement age I'll get £1,500 per year (well a bit extra, bc of inflation etc). If I stayed in the job 10 years, then that would be £15,000 per year (obviously more because my pay will increase, although still will inflation, but you get my general point).
People don't check out pensions much when they look for jobs, but seriously for local councils, civil service, NHS and a lot of the third sector, especially trade unions, there are still good options, including final salary schemes. You are not "pretty buggered", but you should get a job where the pension is the goal, and not the salary (which will be lower).