Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get the children christened if DH doesn’t believe.

258 replies

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 10:09

AIBU to get the children christened if DH and his family don’t believe. DH believes religion causes war and suffering and is not supportive of same sex relationships and is basically a tool to suppress uprising in poverty stricken counties where citizens fear the church.

I was brought up RC and would attend Church around 10 times a year with family . I went a RC school . I am very open minded and feel religion ( in all its forms ) was something which I enjoyed learning about and have taken some comfort in.
I am really open minded and never felt that religion caused me to judge others or myself . I only attend church a few times a year - Christmas and Easter .

I would like my twins ( aged 18 months ) to be christened . After much discussion, DH will compromise and allow them to be christened COE but not RC.

I do not want a big fuss made and a party. I want a low key christening during service and that’s it. I have spoken to the COE and the Reverend is happy to christen the children .However - I just can’t help feel this doesn’t make sense if DH isn’t fully on board . DH is very supportive and usually very laid back however he and his family do not like religion. I respect DH and don’t want to bulldoze him.

I am tired as I have had two babies and i just don’t know if I should press on with the christening plan and cause ‘stress’ from the opposing views . Or if this is my wish for my children then I just make it simple, organize it and do it and anyone who doesn’t want to attend doesn’t need to come .

I want the children to have the option of attending the local faith school where I attended but the head teacher has explained I will need the children christened for them to stand a chance of getting in.
DH said he will look at all schools and of this is the best suited for us the children can attended.

AIBU to push ahead ? I don’t want to cause friction but I don’t want to just people please.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/01/2024 11:40

Very much agree about allowing them to make their own choice when they're old enough

In any case if your DH is anti and you only attend church a couple of times a year what's the point? It's not as if you'd be bringing them up in the faith community so there seems little reason for this

araiwa · 25/01/2024 11:39

For very obvious reasons, wild horses couldn't pull my kids anywhere a Catholic church

Caravaggiouch · 25/01/2024 11:36

For me it comes down to if it’s more important for you to have them christened or for him not to.

if he was just indifferent, I’d agree with you in a heartbeat. If he’s actively against it, it has to be weighed up about who cares more.

His family’s opinions don’t come into it. I’d also want something a bit more convincing than “cos religion causes wars”.

MrsRachelDanvers · 25/01/2024 11:36

My husband is an atheist and I totally get why he would tolerate c of e but not catholic. The fervour, shaming and cover ups, celibate priests telling people how to run their sex lives plus the scarring of his parents due to a strict catholic upbringing turned him off for life. If you’re religious but your other half doesn’t share your belief, a catholic upbringing is pretty hardcore. C of e seems a compromise everyone can live with.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/01/2024 11:34

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 11:21

Well, we weren’t married in a Church as we have different ideas . We of course discussed the matter of children and religion before even getting engaged.
DH wasn’t just going to go along with a church wedding for me as he felt it was wrong to do so. I wasn’t insistent we got married by god . I was just so happy to be married .
I don’t believe people who aren’t the same belief can’t get married ! I don’t think that is true. DH is amazing and respects me and I him. Hence the compromise of COE.

Oh, I'm not saying that people with different beliefs shouldn't get married at all. DH and I have different beliefs as it happens, and we rub along just fine! However, neither of us believes that the other is going to hell... and personally, I'm not sure that I would want to be with a partner who believed that about me, but I get that some people wouldn't really care.

As far as any kids are concerned, I would expect that, if faith (or lack of it) is important to either party, that these things would be discussed and agreed before marriage so that questions wouldn't arise later on.

Anyway, it sounds like you have reached a compromise that both you and your DH can live with, so that's good. If he is genuinely happy with the proposal to get them christened in a CofE church, and you're happy to accept that as an alternative to a Catholic baptism, what was it that made you doubt that decision/start this thread?

CoffeeatIKEA · 25/01/2024 11:34

OP, this is clearly important to you so I think you do it.
I don’t think you have to believe in every Christian doctrine and obey every rule to decide that this particular ritual is important to you.
I do Christmas stockings for my kids every year and feel very strongly about needing to do that even though it doesn’t fit in properly with how Christmas is celebrated here and how the Santa Claus story works here. I don’t care, I need to do the stocking to feel like Christmas has been properly celebrated. The ritual is important to me and I want to pass it on.
It’s not a facetious example. I know Santa Claus is just a story and that religious belief is not really comparable. But even with a ritual that everyone except young children accept as just a story, passing that ritual on to my kids is important to me. It’s ok to want to christen your child even if you can’t explain why in religious terms.

newusername2009 · 25/01/2024 11:32

Angrycat2768 · 25/01/2024 10:45

Original sin was done away with in the Catholic church ages ago!

What? No it wasn’t

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 11:21

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/01/2024 11:11

I totally respect the fact that religion is important to many people. We're all entitled to our beliefs and that's absoultely fair enough - who am I to say that my beliefs are right and yours are wrong when none of us can ever actually know for sure?

And if your faith is important to you, then it's completely natural to want to pass it on to your children. I get that.

What I don't really understand is why someone for whom religion is important would marry someone who not only doesn't share that religion but actually perceives it as a negative force in the world? And if someone did choose to marry someone in that situation, surely they would reach agreements on how any kids would be raised before they came along? If your faith truly matters to you, wouldn't this come up at a very early stage? Or is it a case of people thinking that they don't really care when they are at the stage of getting married and then suddenly finding that it is more important to them as they get older? I'm genuinely curious as to how these situations come about?

Well, we weren’t married in a Church as we have different ideas . We of course discussed the matter of children and religion before even getting engaged.
DH wasn’t just going to go along with a church wedding for me as he felt it was wrong to do so. I wasn’t insistent we got married by god . I was just so happy to be married .
I don’t believe people who aren’t the same belief can’t get married ! I don’t think that is true. DH is amazing and respects me and I him. Hence the compromise of COE.

OP posts:
user1469661475 · 25/01/2024 11:17

We recently decided to start attending mass at the local Catholic church. There were/are some difficulties in our marriage and we felt that it might help. I grew up CofE: my husband is RC, from a very different culture (misunderstandings and language issues are the cause of many of our problems TBH). We don't live in the UK so a CofE church is not an option, though that would have been my personal preference. Attending mass has actually helped a lot: it has brought us together. It has anchored us as a family. I feel as though my children, while they of course object to going to mass, are understanding how precious they are, and that they have talents and gifts it is their duty to develop. I am so worried about my kids becoming depressed and losing direction in the modern world. Sounds dramatic, but that is how we feel. Perhaps because we both live apart from our families and cultures.

So I would say go for it, if something is pulling you there. It will bring you comfort. I don't find the RC mass to be very different from the CofE services but if you would prefer RC since that is your background, definitely go with that. The sins of the Catholic church are perpetrated by corrupt individuals and are not the fault of millions of ordinary Catholics.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/01/2024 11:11

GreatGateauxsby · 25/01/2024 11:01

Look it's all good and well strangers on the internet having opinions but it’s your life….

I am a big believer in options.

not christening them takes away an option both in terms of lifestyle / “environmental values” and in terms of schooling

pretty much all our friends are Jewish or Christian and most are looking to send their children to faith schools and raise them in their culture.

it’s culturally important for us.
my DH and I are both catholic (RC v orthodox but still) but if my DH wasn’t I wouldn’t have given that up…

modern Catholicism (in fact even 80s Catholicism) in schools IME has been very much centred around love thy neighbour and do unto others vs burn the gays

Edited

I totally respect the fact that religion is important to many people. We're all entitled to our beliefs and that's absoultely fair enough - who am I to say that my beliefs are right and yours are wrong when none of us can ever actually know for sure?

And if your faith is important to you, then it's completely natural to want to pass it on to your children. I get that.

What I don't really understand is why someone for whom religion is important would marry someone who not only doesn't share that religion but actually perceives it as a negative force in the world? And if someone did choose to marry someone in that situation, surely they would reach agreements on how any kids would be raised before they came along? If your faith truly matters to you, wouldn't this come up at a very early stage? Or is it a case of people thinking that they don't really care when they are at the stage of getting married and then suddenly finding that it is more important to them as they get older? I'm genuinely curious as to how these situations come about?

Myotherdogsanoodle · 25/01/2024 11:04

I think if you really want them baptised and your husband doesn’t object you should just do it. No need to make it a big occasion. The children can make their own decisions about religion when they get older but there’s no harm in them being baptised and it will put your mind at rest.

shreknjumps · 25/01/2024 11:04

This sounds like it matters to you so much whereas your husband isn't actually arsed. He's heard something about the RC church not being very liberal and he's gone oh, I'm not bothered but not that one.

Honestly, I'd push for them to be christened the same as me. RC, not some compromise with someone who doesn't care anyway!

Floralnomad · 25/01/2024 11:02

It sounds to me like your religion is quite important to you and frankly I cannot understand how you’ve married a staunch atheist . WRT the children leave them to decide later in their lives .

GreatGateauxsby · 25/01/2024 11:01

Look it's all good and well strangers on the internet having opinions but it’s your life….

I am a big believer in options.

not christening them takes away an option both in terms of lifestyle / “environmental values” and in terms of schooling

pretty much all our friends are Jewish or Christian and most are looking to send their children to faith schools and raise them in their culture.

it’s culturally important for us.
my DH and I are both catholic (RC v orthodox but still) but if my DH wasn’t I wouldn’t have given that up…

modern Catholicism (in fact even 80s Catholicism) in schools IME has been very much centred around love thy neighbour and do unto others vs burn the gays

Ineedanewsofa · 25/01/2024 10:57

@x2boys mostly to do with the fire and brimstone, anti gay, oppression of women (by keeping them pregnant and beholden to men) that was the Catholic Church of my youth. COE, by contrast, was the New Testament, love thy neighbour, happy clappy version of religion. I appreciate both have probably changed beyond recognition now but I genuinely couldn’t allow DC in be induced into a system that, if they do turn out to be gay, infers that they will go to hell.

steppemum · 25/01/2024 10:54

I do think that unpicking your own beliefs would be helpful.
I don't know about RC church, but CofE do not believe that christening a child gives them access to heaven.

The best way of summarising would be something like - belief in Jesus gives you access to heaven. (not baptism). For those too young to understand or to make a decision, they would be considered innocent when they die, and so go to heaven. CofE is a broad church so there will be variations on that, but I think that is the basics.
there is no purgatory or limbo etc in CofE. YOu can't pray for people after they have died to go to heaven. It is about their choice to believe when alive.

I am not making a comment on those views, or on how they compare to RC, just trying to clarify what you might believe v. the church. But it would be good for you to examine and understand what your own view is.
I didn't think that the RC still held to the idea that an unbaptised child goes to hell? But I may be wrong.

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 10:53

Angrycat2768 · 25/01/2024 10:38

I was in the same position and did baptise my kids RC. My in laws didn't attend and DH said it didn't matter to him as it was just 'words said in a building ' I don't often go to church but felt that Catholicism was part of their cultural heritage which has become more important to me and them as they have got older. That may be my particular circumstances, as I married into an upper middle class white family and I am not White, they don't have my name ( which I regret) and DH's family are loud and vocal atheists. It just felt like it was a bit of my heritage that I wanted to pass on. I do take them to church occasionally. My older DS has got interested in it and likes going, even though he doesn't believe in God, but my younger doesnt. They didn't make their first holy communion and they haven't been confirmed, which they did decide themselves. I wouldn't have agreed to baptise them C of E as a compromise because I have no link to the C of E church. Fwiw they did go to Catholic school but we soon realised that the hothouse atmosphere of that particular school didn't suit DS do he moved to another school.

I am non white . I also feel that this is a part of me that I can pass to the children. I got shivers when I read your post. It’s abit about my heritage . My fathers family are Jamaican and devoted and my mother is Irish and still lives in ireland. I feel the RC is apart of my heritage . I feel up with it and I want DCs to have something of Me. COE is not RC though . But it is something. .

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/01/2024 10:51

Out of interest, do you worry about where your DH will end up in the afterlife?!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/01/2024 10:50

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 10:42

@AmeliaEarhart
Do you believe in original sin then OP? That your children won’t go to heaven if they’re not baptised? I’m not knocking it, just trying to unpick your reasoning.

I don’t want to turn this into a discussion which people will ridicule me but - I hate to say this - I think I do.
Dh thinks I am crazy and keeps saying -
you can’t believe in heaven and hell .

But I’ve always believed being christened means you can go to heaven which is where I hope I will be .

Wow.

It's amazing to me that people still hold onto this idea of such a heartless and capricious God.

Why on earth would a loving and all-powerful God choose to deny access to "heaven" to an innocent child, simply because their parents had failed to splash a bit of holy water on their head?

And why would anyone want to share eternity with a God that would choose to behave like that?

No disrespect to you and your beliefs, OP. I recognise that this is what you were brought up with, and I know from my own family's experience with Catholicism that it can be hard for people to shake these beliefs off. But from an outsider's point of view, they are truly incomprehensible.

luckylavender · 25/01/2024 10:49

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 10:09

AIBU to get the children christened if DH and his family don’t believe. DH believes religion causes war and suffering and is not supportive of same sex relationships and is basically a tool to suppress uprising in poverty stricken counties where citizens fear the church.

I was brought up RC and would attend Church around 10 times a year with family . I went a RC school . I am very open minded and feel religion ( in all its forms ) was something which I enjoyed learning about and have taken some comfort in.
I am really open minded and never felt that religion caused me to judge others or myself . I only attend church a few times a year - Christmas and Easter .

I would like my twins ( aged 18 months ) to be christened . After much discussion, DH will compromise and allow them to be christened COE but not RC.

I do not want a big fuss made and a party. I want a low key christening during service and that’s it. I have spoken to the COE and the Reverend is happy to christen the children .However - I just can’t help feel this doesn’t make sense if DH isn’t fully on board . DH is very supportive and usually very laid back however he and his family do not like religion. I respect DH and don’t want to bulldoze him.

I am tired as I have had two babies and i just don’t know if I should press on with the christening plan and cause ‘stress’ from the opposing views . Or if this is my wish for my children then I just make it simple, organize it and do it and anyone who doesn’t want to attend doesn’t need to come .

I want the children to have the option of attending the local faith school where I attended but the head teacher has explained I will need the children christened for them to stand a chance of getting in.
DH said he will look at all schools and of this is the best suited for us the children can attended.

AIBU to push ahead ? I don’t want to cause friction but I don’t want to just people please.

You should have agreed this a very long time ago

BoohooWoohoo · 25/01/2024 10:49

I think that there are people who do christenings for social rather than religious purposes (school, pressure from family…) so I don’t think that it’s a bad thing to do it without your husband being part of the process. I assume that you plan to take the child to church when you attend which is in the spirit of things.

x2boys · 25/01/2024 10:48

Ineedanewsofa · 25/01/2024 10:45

I’m a non believer, DH raised Catholic (severely lapsed 🤣) and we reached the same COE compromise you have OP, however DC was never christened because my stance was while I didn’t mind, I definitely was not going to organise it! Lo and behold it’s still on the to do list, 8 years later (much to MILs horror!)

Why CofE ?I'm not trying to start an argument just interested
I'm a very lapsed Catholic too and more agnostic now , although I did have my kids christened .

Gcsunnyside23 · 25/01/2024 10:47

Im christened, schooled and raised in the catholic religion. My family are very strong Catholics. I am on the fence with the whole thing, stopped going to church regularly years ago. My husband is a now athiest but was christened in church of Ireland. I opted to not have my kids christened as I felt a complete hypocrite that I don't actively follow the religion, disagree in quite a few views and my husband isn't religious also. I expose them to religious options through my family, school etc although school isn't a religious based school. I also don't believe in original sin, I believe that if people that murder can basically get into heaven them god will accept an innocent child. But I'm also from northern Ireland so the whole religion aspect requires heavy thought as my husband and I are from opposing religions.
But I feel strongly that unless you are baptising them as catholic as that's the religion you plan to follow then what's the point. If you're doing it to get into school then just say so. Let them decide as they get older

ActDottie · 25/01/2024 10:47

Let your children decide when they’re older.

I don’t really agree with christenings when the child is not old enough to know what is going on. You have no idea what religion the child will choose when older, they may not be religious at all when older.

BoohooWoohoo · 25/01/2024 10:46

Your husband has said yes so I would do it.

Personally I’m an atheist but can’t see why he’d want them christened CoE over Catholic like you. Will you feel disappointed if your kids don’t go through the later stages like confirmation ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread