Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get the children christened if DH doesn’t believe.

258 replies

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 10:09

AIBU to get the children christened if DH and his family don’t believe. DH believes religion causes war and suffering and is not supportive of same sex relationships and is basically a tool to suppress uprising in poverty stricken counties where citizens fear the church.

I was brought up RC and would attend Church around 10 times a year with family . I went a RC school . I am very open minded and feel religion ( in all its forms ) was something which I enjoyed learning about and have taken some comfort in.
I am really open minded and never felt that religion caused me to judge others or myself . I only attend church a few times a year - Christmas and Easter .

I would like my twins ( aged 18 months ) to be christened . After much discussion, DH will compromise and allow them to be christened COE but not RC.

I do not want a big fuss made and a party. I want a low key christening during service and that’s it. I have spoken to the COE and the Reverend is happy to christen the children .However - I just can’t help feel this doesn’t make sense if DH isn’t fully on board . DH is very supportive and usually very laid back however he and his family do not like religion. I respect DH and don’t want to bulldoze him.

I am tired as I have had two babies and i just don’t know if I should press on with the christening plan and cause ‘stress’ from the opposing views . Or if this is my wish for my children then I just make it simple, organize it and do it and anyone who doesn’t want to attend doesn’t need to come .

I want the children to have the option of attending the local faith school where I attended but the head teacher has explained I will need the children christened for them to stand a chance of getting in.
DH said he will look at all schools and of this is the best suited for us the children can attended.

AIBU to push ahead ? I don’t want to cause friction but I don’t want to just people please.

OP posts:
Beastlylittleparasite · 25/01/2024 12:17

It doesn’t matter what DH and his family think. If they’re atheists then you can’t offend their faith because they don’t have any. It’s a harmless ritual that will have no effect on their lives whatsoever, so if you and your family want to do it then just book it. Go low key and don’t drag the other family along so you’ve not inconvenienced anyone. I can’t see why anyone would take issue with it.
dedicated atheist here and if my DH family wanted to bless my kids or baptise them or whatever I wouldn’t be bothered at all.
So long as they don’t expect me to do any work or planning I’d be delighted for them.

HelpMeGetThrough · 25/01/2024 12:16
  • Because atheists are a bit dog in the manger about religious faith, because they don’t have it, they don’t want anyone else to enjoy its manifold benefits either.

More vocal about the faults of Christianity, though…..*

I couldn't give a bugger about the different religions or if people have faith or not., it's none of my business, just like me being an atheist is none of theirs.

My OH isn't an atheist, it's not an issue, as we don't talk about religion. It doesn't interest me.

Bundeena · 25/01/2024 12:15

If you are Catholic and plan to bring them up in that faith then have them baptised in a Catholic church.

I don't see how it makes any sense to have them Christened in a CofE church if neither parent is of that religion. And they wouldn't turn make their first communion, confirmation - are these sacraments important to you?

What is your husband's aversion to Catholic baptism specifically?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/01/2024 12:15

DillDanding · 25/01/2024 12:11

Ours were baptised. This was to please my religious parents, get them into the Catholic school and have a family do.

Didn’t overthink it.

This is why faith schools are such a nonsense, and shouldn't be state funded!

Whatevershallidowithmylife · 25/01/2024 12:14

Well you see your husband is right - you are doing this for the school intake, not because you are religious. This isn’t what religion should be about but it has become a tool to get what people want. Either do it or don’t but if you do you should be entering into their christening as bringing them up in the faith, not a couple of times a year to make it look right. I say this as someone who isn’t christened and doesn’t particularly believe in any god.

MrsRachelDanvers · 25/01/2024 12:14

sensationalsally · 25/01/2024 12:07

Can't understand why he's bothered at all if he's an atheist. If you are RC, then that's where they should be baptised. Why bring CoE into it at all?

Because to an atheist, the CofE has beliefs and practices that appear more rational while still being Christian. So they don’t believe in transubstantiation unlike Catholics. They allow their religious leaders normal family lives unlike the Ca5olic church which preaches a lot about family while insisting its employees can’t have one. They don’t indoctrinate young children to the same extent. They don’t preach against artificial birth control. So there are lots of reasons why someone can agree to their kids being raised Christian while being adamantly anti Catholic.

RaraRachael · 25/01/2024 12:14

Mine had a dedication service as that's what the church I went to at the time, did. My daughter chose to be baptised as an adult but my don didn't. I've been to too many christenings where it was just an excuse to have a knees/booze up with the parents having no intention of encouraging their children to have any religious experience.
My XMiL was horrified that we weren't having them christened - this from somebody who had had XH and his brothers christened purely so they could attend a C of E school.

OrlandointheWilderness · 25/01/2024 12:13

There is a process for children coming to their own belief - it is called confirmation which normally happens when they are teenagers and have chosen to reaffirm faith. Christenings happen for the parents. I would have them done.

DillDanding · 25/01/2024 12:11

Ours were baptised. This was to please my religious parents, get them into the Catholic school and have a family do.

Didn’t overthink it.

SardineSarnie · 25/01/2024 12:11

I'm an atheist from a CoE family. My cousin (also CoE) married into a RC family. Based on what I've observed from how that has worked out, I think you should baptise your children RC. They may choose to be atheists later, that's fine, but there is a large amount of difference between CoE and RC in terms of beliefs and practices, honestly. Your DH should respect your beliefs and your culture. I think if you aren't RC you don't really appreciate how much of it is culture outside church as well as religious services inside church (from what I've seen).

bryceQ · 25/01/2024 12:11

I'm not religious i have a different spiritual and ethical belief system but my husband is devout Roman Catholic. It was important for him to have our son christened. My family didn't attend, I saw it as something for his family. He went out with his family for lunch after and I looked after our son (he has additional needs). The christening was very low key, but it made my husband so happy. It's fine that it doesn't matter to me

FanFckingTastic · 25/01/2024 12:10

A CofE Baptism is more a celebration of the child and an opportunity for the parents and Godparents to agree to raise them in a Christian way. The child then gets to make this decision for themselves when it comes to Confirmation.

Just a note on CofE Baptisms, most Godparents are required by
the Church to be at least baptised themselves (ideally confirmed) so this might
be a consideration for you OP.

My faith is important to me as it obviously is to you OP. My DH is less religious however he understood that the Church and religion were important to me so was happy that our kids were baptised and introduced to Christianity. What they choose to do after this is down to them and they have all made their own minds up on whether to be confirmed or not – that piece is down to them.

GreatGateauxsby · 25/01/2024 12:09

sixthvestibule · 25/01/2024 11:42

The C of E is not a watered down, slightly more palatable version of Roman Catholicism. The priest you spoke to is not doing his own church, or your beliefs, justice if he offers you a baptism date without any preparation or further conversation, knowing that neither you nor your husband are committed to Anglicanism.

This.

its quite an odd “compromise”

caringcarer · 25/01/2024 12:09

If you believe and will take the DC to church with you then I don't think it's your DH place to stop it being done. He does not have to attend the christening or the church.

sensationalsally · 25/01/2024 12:07

Can't understand why he's bothered at all if he's an atheist. If you are RC, then that's where they should be baptised. Why bring CoE into it at all?

Brefugee · 25/01/2024 12:06

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 25/01/2024 11:45

Because atheists are a bit dog in the manger about religious faith, because they don’t have it, they don’t want anyone else to enjoy its manifold benefits either.

More vocal about the faults of Christianity, though…..

no. Many many atheists used to belong to a church. Most of the ones i know would probably, gritted teeth, go along with a CofE christening because we have seen the cover ups of the sexual abuse and protection of priests over children, and we read about the shaming of women (mother and baby homes etc).

Given the choice, if my (catholic as it happens, severely lapsed) DH had insisted on a baptism and i had the choice between catholic and pretty much anything else, i'd have taken the anything else.

And in common with many atheists, i don't have a problem with the religion as such, but the way it is performed.

romdowa · 25/01/2024 12:01

I'm a rc and my husband is an atheist and had no problem with me christening our dc but I'm in ireland where its a very cultural thing

Brefugee · 25/01/2024 11:59

i am constantly baffled by any religion that baptises (or whatever) children before they can make an independent, informed decision.

I am particularly baffled when it is a religion that is anti women and has a lot of issues around abuse by religious leaders.

YMMV.

(but in your husband's shoes? i would be very very unhappy about this. Very much so)

Gobbolinothewitchscat · 25/01/2024 11:57

anarchicparadise · 25/01/2024 10:26

If neither of you are C of E then I wouldn’t baptise them.

for me (and I’m Catholic) I’d want my DC to follow the same faith as me if I were to baptise them.

as it happens, my DH is atheist and didn’t want the children baptised into any faith because he thinks it’s a load of nonsense.

This. I'm a Catholic so I believe that baptism is a sacrament and I therefore had my children baptised into the same faith. The CofE is a Protestant church and there are material differences in belief. I couldn't have my children baptised as CofE as I don't believe in all of their teachings so how could I raise them in that faith? If I'm not raising them in that faith, why would I have them baptised in it?

If the children are not baptised as Catholic, this is going to have a knock on effect with other sacraments. Will they make their first Holy Communion? If so, that will be over the age of 6. The church will recognise their baptism (so long as baptised in the name of the father, son and Holy Spirit) as valid but they won't be members of the Catholic Church so won't be able to join prep classes. Instead they will need to prepare to be received into the Catholic Church and then have first Holy Communion.

Over the age of 7, they are essentially treated as adults and have to go through a long preparation process. If they are not at a Catholic school, this is a huge amount of work for parents to undertake at home and with regular meetings with a priest or someone who can catechise them nominated by the priest.

I would consider most sincerely why you went your child baptised. CofE baptism is not going to help them get into an oversubscribed Catholic school. A Catholic school is going to be infused with Catholic teaching and culture. What is your husband's position on that if he doesn't even want them baptised as Catholics?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/01/2024 11:56

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 25/01/2024 11:45

Because atheists are a bit dog in the manger about religious faith, because they don’t have it, they don’t want anyone else to enjoy its manifold benefits either.

More vocal about the faults of Christianity, though…..

That's nonsense.

It isn't anything to do with not wanting other people to enjoy the benefits of their faith. I'm genuinely happy for anyone who finds a faith that helps them in their daily lives, but I also know that that isn't everyone's experience of being part of an organised religion.

If my dc finds a faith when she is older, and it makes her happy, then I will absolutely respect and celebrate that. However, I wouldn't have wanted to bring her up to believe in something that I don't personally think is true. What would be the point of that?

ginasevern · 25/01/2024 11:53

I don't see the point in having them Christened C of E if you are RC. I find that a strange "compromise" to be honest. If you're going to have them baptised it might as well be in the faith you follow.

Neither church has covered themselves in glory. The RC church with its historic sex abuse and the C of E is essentially the Tory party at prayer.

Most people I've known who have had their children christened have done so more out of tradition than a burning urge to follow in the footsteps of Jesus Christ anyway.

Sprig1 · 25/01/2024 11:48

I would not be at all happy about them being christened if I was your husband. In fact it would become a show stopper for the relationship.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 25/01/2024 11:45

x2boys · 25/01/2024 10:39

If your Dh,is an atheist why does it matter to him,wether they are christened in a RC or a C of E church.?

Because atheists are a bit dog in the manger about religious faith, because they don’t have it, they don’t want anyone else to enjoy its manifold benefits either.

More vocal about the faults of Christianity, though…..

sixthvestibule · 25/01/2024 11:42

The C of E is not a watered down, slightly more palatable version of Roman Catholicism. The priest you spoke to is not doing his own church, or your beliefs, justice if he offers you a baptism date without any preparation or further conversation, knowing that neither you nor your husband are committed to Anglicanism.

MammaTo · 25/01/2024 11:41

I don’t understand why he’s agreed to COE when he doesn’t believe/agree anyway? Why not just christen them the same religion as you?

Swipe left for the next trending thread