Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get the children christened if DH doesn’t believe.

258 replies

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 10:09

AIBU to get the children christened if DH and his family don’t believe. DH believes religion causes war and suffering and is not supportive of same sex relationships and is basically a tool to suppress uprising in poverty stricken counties where citizens fear the church.

I was brought up RC and would attend Church around 10 times a year with family . I went a RC school . I am very open minded and feel religion ( in all its forms ) was something which I enjoyed learning about and have taken some comfort in.
I am really open minded and never felt that religion caused me to judge others or myself . I only attend church a few times a year - Christmas and Easter .

I would like my twins ( aged 18 months ) to be christened . After much discussion, DH will compromise and allow them to be christened COE but not RC.

I do not want a big fuss made and a party. I want a low key christening during service and that’s it. I have spoken to the COE and the Reverend is happy to christen the children .However - I just can’t help feel this doesn’t make sense if DH isn’t fully on board . DH is very supportive and usually very laid back however he and his family do not like religion. I respect DH and don’t want to bulldoze him.

I am tired as I have had two babies and i just don’t know if I should press on with the christening plan and cause ‘stress’ from the opposing views . Or if this is my wish for my children then I just make it simple, organize it and do it and anyone who doesn’t want to attend doesn’t need to come .

I want the children to have the option of attending the local faith school where I attended but the head teacher has explained I will need the children christened for them to stand a chance of getting in.
DH said he will look at all schools and of this is the best suited for us the children can attended.

AIBU to push ahead ? I don’t want to cause friction but I don’t want to just people please.

OP posts:
idrinkandiknowthings · 25/01/2024 12:44

EndOfIt · 25/01/2024 10:14

I would let your children decide when they’re old enough to understand. I don’t agree with faith schools so I’d send them to a different one.

I wanted to give my child the very same option. They're* 17 now and don't follow any particular faith but if they wanted to I would support them in their choice.

For many people I think a Christening is simply an expected part of child-raising when in reality the parent and godparents have no interest whatsoever in bringing the child up according to the chosen faith.

*they are agender.

whyhere · 25/01/2024 12:43

lanthanum · 25/01/2024 10:27

Here are the promises you have to make. I presume your husband could sit them out.

Parents and godparents, the Church receives these children with joy.
Today we are trusting God for their growth in faith.
Will you pray for them,
draw them by your example into the community of faith
and walk with them in the way of Christ?
With the help of God, we will.
In baptism these children begin their journey in faith.
You speak for them today.
Will you care for them,
and help them to take their place
within the life and worship of Christ’s Church?
With the help of God, we will.

Are you happy to make those promises? And is your husband happy for you to do so?

Oh, and if the school you're hoping they will attend is Catholic, do they have to be baptised Catholic?

Exactly so.

I've previously baptised the child of a Christian mother and a Jewish father - he simply stayed silent for the vows that he could not, in all conscience, make.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 25/01/2024 12:41

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 12:39

For me - it is either COE or nothing . I am sad to have nothing. So I thought COE was the compromise.

COE would also mean my children could go to the Catholic School- this has been confirmed by the Head. Currently due to low birth rates they are now accepting children of other faiths to fill spaces.

If you're happy with it that's totally fair enough. I wouldn't personally have liked his framing of the issue.

resi4 · 25/01/2024 12:41

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 12:39

For me - it is either COE or nothing . I am sad to have nothing. So I thought COE was the compromise.

COE would also mean my children could go to the Catholic School- this has been confirmed by the Head. Currently due to low birth rates they are now accepting children of other faiths to fill spaces.

If he's opposed to the teachings of the Catholic Church how does he feel about them going to a Catholic school?

NotAnotherPylon · 25/01/2024 12:41

The views of both you and your DH are equally valid. It sounds as though your DH is willing to compromise, so you need to stop worrying and have the courage of your convictions. Unless, of course, you are hesitating because your own convictions aren't particularly strong, in which case it might be best to leave it.

DP and I are atheists, but he is from an RC background. One of the first things his dad said when DS1 was born was 'Right, we need to see about getting this wean baptised'. Um, hold on there matey! There was nearly all out war when we said we weren't having him christened. DP suggested that we do it to keep them happy and I understood the pressure he was under, but there was just no way that was happening. It would have been completely different if DP had still been Catholic and wanted to have DS baptised in keeping with his own beliefs, but that wasn't the case.

resi4 · 25/01/2024 12:40

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 25/01/2024 11:45

Because atheists are a bit dog in the manger about religious faith, because they don’t have it, they don’t want anyone else to enjoy its manifold benefits either.

More vocal about the faults of Christianity, though…..

What a horrible, hateful thing to say.

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 12:39

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 25/01/2024 12:37

As a Catholic of Irish heritage like you OP, the idea that C of E represents some kind of compromise middle ground is rather culturally insensitive.

For me - it is either COE or nothing . I am sad to have nothing. So I thought COE was the compromise.

COE would also mean my children could go to the Catholic School- this has been confirmed by the Head. Currently due to low birth rates they are now accepting children of other faiths to fill spaces.

OP posts:
Abouttimemum · 25/01/2024 12:39

Your children can decide if they want to be christened when they’re older, so they have a choice in the matter, rather than enforcing it on them when they have no say.

It makes zero difference to their life at the current time.

OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 25/01/2024 12:37

As a Catholic of Irish heritage like you OP, the idea that C of E represents some kind of compromise middle ground is rather culturally insensitive.

Nanny0gg · 25/01/2024 12:35

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 12:34

I’ve already answered this.

Well, we weren’t married in a Church as we have different ideas . We of course discussed the matter of children and religion before even getting engaged.
DH wasn’t just going to go along with a church wedding for me as he felt it was wrong to do so. I wasn’t insistent we got married by god . I was just so happy to be married .
I don’t believe people who aren’t the same belief can’t get married ! I don’t think that is true. DH is amazing and respects me and I him. Hence the compromise of COE.

We aren’t having huge arguments. He isn’t saying I can’t . I’m trying to work out if I should.

How is CofE a compromise?

There's still differences in belief

Why not Baptists or Methodists?

Makes as much sense

Gobbolinothewitchscat · 25/01/2024 12:34

ThursdayTomorrow · 25/01/2024 12:22

Being Christened has nothing to do with going to heaven! Being Christened is saying you will teach the children your views on Christ and bring them up in faith.

Being baptised in the Catholic Church has everything to do with going to heaven; particularly if you have a Catholic parent who knows the relevance and importance of the sacrament or baptism.

Rightly or wrongly, the Catholic faith is very prescriptive on these matters and the faith is strongly structured around sacraments - baptism is essentially a gateway to these. It’s not the case that anyone can take holy communion as maybe the case in other denominations.

I would strongly advise speaking to a Catholic priest regarding all of these matters so you and and your husband can make an informed decision about what you want to do based on a through understanding of the Catholic faith and the ramifications of not being baptised into the faith. They you can decide what to do. There is not a “halfway house” in that your child will be a Christian if they are baptised CofE but they will not be a member of the Catholic Church

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 12:34

Bumblebeestiltskin · 25/01/2024 12:30

Why on earth didn't you discuss this before you got married and had children? I'm vegan, my daughter's dad isn't, but I made it very clear any children I had would be raised vegan and he agreed (we've been split up 3 years and he's still happy she's vegan 😁).

I’ve already answered this.

Well, we weren’t married in a Church as we have different ideas . We of course discussed the matter of children and religion before even getting engaged.
DH wasn’t just going to go along with a church wedding for me as he felt it was wrong to do so. I wasn’t insistent we got married by god . I was just so happy to be married .
I don’t believe people who aren’t the same belief can’t get married ! I don’t think that is true. DH is amazing and respects me and I him. Hence the compromise of COE.

We aren’t having huge arguments. He isn’t saying I can’t . I’m trying to work out if I should.

OP posts:
WipeYourFeet · 25/01/2024 12:32

OP I think your husband is being petty to be honest. The thinking being "I'm not getting what I what (for the kids to be atheist) so you're not getting what you want either (for them to be RC)"

Why would you want them to be baptised into a different faith? You won't have the understanding of that faith like you do of RC, are you going to forgo attending your church and ceremonies to teach them CofE by attending CofE church? And as rightly pointed out by PP, you feel RC is part of your family history and heritage.
It makes no sense to go CofE unless you intend to convert too.

Bumblebeestiltskin · 25/01/2024 12:30

Why on earth didn't you discuss this before you got married and had children? I'm vegan, my daughter's dad isn't, but I made it very clear any children I had would be raised vegan and he agreed (we've been split up 3 years and he's still happy she's vegan 😁).

TeabySea · 25/01/2024 12:30

Let the children decide when they're old enough. It's ultimately their choice which faith (or none) they want to follow.

I have alway wondered if you can get 'unbaptised' - as I probably would do that myself.

chaos76 · 25/01/2024 12:26

Why not take them to Ireland to visit your mum and have the christening there in her chapel. I’m RC and so is my DH I know how important it is even when you think you are a lasped RC the guilt never goes away and if it gives you peace of mind then do it but i wouldn’t compromise on it being in Coe that makes no sense

HollaHolla · 25/01/2024 12:26

We weren't christened as kids, for similar reasons. My Mum was a church-goer/involved in the church; my Dad very anti-religion. They came to the decision that we could decide, when we were old enough to understand. My sister was christened at age 12; my brother and I have never been christened. I am the only non church-goer from the three of us now.
I would leave it, and let them decide when they're old enough to understand what it really means.

Nanny0gg · 25/01/2024 12:23

ThursdayTomorrow · 25/01/2024 12:20

Religion doesn’t cause wars. Men wanting power and land causes wars.
Those men might try and hide their power lust behind other reasons such as religion but the reality is , it’s men and their power lust that causes war.
All the Christians I know are in favour of same sex marriages. Plenty of vicars in the CofE are in same sex relationships.

They can't marry though...

ThursdayTomorrow · 25/01/2024 12:22

Being Christened has nothing to do with going to heaven! Being Christened is saying you will teach the children your views on Christ and bring them up in faith.

Nanny0gg · 25/01/2024 12:22

caringcarer · 25/01/2024 12:09

If you believe and will take the DC to church with you then I don't think it's your DH place to stop it being done. He does not have to attend the christening or the church.

If he thinks his child is being brought up to believe in what he thinks is a total, possibly corrupt fiction, I think he does get a say

ThursdayTomorrow · 25/01/2024 12:20

Religion doesn’t cause wars. Men wanting power and land causes wars.
Those men might try and hide their power lust behind other reasons such as religion but the reality is , it’s men and their power lust that causes war.
All the Christians I know are in favour of same sex marriages. Plenty of vicars in the CofE are in same sex relationships.

Nanny0gg · 25/01/2024 12:20

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 10:42

@AmeliaEarhart
Do you believe in original sin then OP? That your children won’t go to heaven if they’re not baptised? I’m not knocking it, just trying to unpick your reasoning.

I don’t want to turn this into a discussion which people will ridicule me but - I hate to say this - I think I do.
Dh thinks I am crazy and keeps saying -
you can’t believe in heaven and hell .

But I’ve always believed being christened means you can go to heaven which is where I hope I will be .

Well to be fair I'm not entirely on board with his views either...

Do you view same sex relationships the same way?

I'm trying to see where you two actually have common views?

Didn't you talk about this before children?

Ponderingwindow · 25/01/2024 12:20

Respect your children enough to let this be their decision.

applepiesain · 25/01/2024 12:19

MammaTo · 25/01/2024 11:41

I don’t understand why he’s agreed to COE when he doesn’t believe/agree anyway? Why not just christen them the same religion as you?

Probably because Cof E is a sort of neutral/ bland religion where to be honest I wouldn't be surprised if the majority of its members were in it for the traditional and cultural aspects rather than actually believing in the miracles afterlife etc.
I personally don't see this as a bad thing.

RC is different. Its sunday school teachers come out with stuff like you shouldn't read Harry Potter because it's the work of the devil and the like. Baptism is one thing, but as soon as the indoctrination starts it will be difficult for an atheist to deal with.
He probably thinks that Cpf E You s harmless, but RC isn't.

pizzaHeart · 25/01/2024 12:19

I think you shouldn’t go with CoE, no. You are RC, your faith means a lot for you: it’s your cultural heritage and identity you shouldn’t give up on this. What kind of decision would it be ? Neither of you are CoE , it would look purely for school tbh, it’s not for your heart.
Your DH is not religious, fine, just do everything in a simple way. Don’t ask him to be overjoyed, respectful is enough. He is a bit too serious imo. RC schools are good , everyone knows that, it’s reality. It might change in your place. You are not going to drag the whole family every Sunday to the church? I think not.
If you have fundamentally different values it will go out and affect you regardless of christening. If not, you will just have some difference in your views and it’s not a big deal.
In reality most of couples have different level of faith and they cope with this ok. I wouldn’t go into RC school if both parents are strong atheists but it’s not the case here.