Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get the children christened if DH doesn’t believe.

258 replies

Bonniebonchoco · 25/01/2024 10:09

AIBU to get the children christened if DH and his family don’t believe. DH believes religion causes war and suffering and is not supportive of same sex relationships and is basically a tool to suppress uprising in poverty stricken counties where citizens fear the church.

I was brought up RC and would attend Church around 10 times a year with family . I went a RC school . I am very open minded and feel religion ( in all its forms ) was something which I enjoyed learning about and have taken some comfort in.
I am really open minded and never felt that religion caused me to judge others or myself . I only attend church a few times a year - Christmas and Easter .

I would like my twins ( aged 18 months ) to be christened . After much discussion, DH will compromise and allow them to be christened COE but not RC.

I do not want a big fuss made and a party. I want a low key christening during service and that’s it. I have spoken to the COE and the Reverend is happy to christen the children .However - I just can’t help feel this doesn’t make sense if DH isn’t fully on board . DH is very supportive and usually very laid back however he and his family do not like religion. I respect DH and don’t want to bulldoze him.

I am tired as I have had two babies and i just don’t know if I should press on with the christening plan and cause ‘stress’ from the opposing views . Or if this is my wish for my children then I just make it simple, organize it and do it and anyone who doesn’t want to attend doesn’t need to come .

I want the children to have the option of attending the local faith school where I attended but the head teacher has explained I will need the children christened for them to stand a chance of getting in.
DH said he will look at all schools and of this is the best suited for us the children can attended.

AIBU to push ahead ? I don’t want to cause friction but I don’t want to just people please.

OP posts:
Blinkingmarvellous · 25/01/2024 22:40

I'm one of those c of e revs that does lots of christenings. A lot of the parents do not have a clear articulate faith. But they know that it matters to them to have the children baptised. And that's enough. It's like planting a seed of faith- it may blossom and grow or it may not.

freestarcollective · 25/01/2024 22:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Verdimillious · 25/01/2024 22:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sailingpasttheheadland · 25/01/2024 22:21

Interesting that the Church is considered to be close minded and unintellectual yet at the same time people are very keen to get their children into Catholic schools and they are often considered the best in an area 🙃

sixthvestibule · 25/01/2024 22:19

It’s not on to deliberately use the C of E as a second-best stepping stone with no further intention of engaging with its worship or teaching, just to appease the OP’s husband.

DillDanding · 25/01/2024 22:12

So it's OK to lie to get them into a good school? Hmm.

Our children were baptised as Catholics to get them into the best school in town. They went on to make their sacraments with their friends up to and including confirmation.

We have made many, many friends who were parents at that school. Are any of us believers or practicing Catholics? No.

Are all of those children now atheists? Almost exclusively, yes. 😂

Davros · 25/01/2024 22:11

I don't understand how this is so important to you, yet you married someone who is not religious...

Gobbolinothewitchscat · 25/01/2024 22:06

InAPickle12345 · 25/01/2024 21:51

While I agree with much of what you have said @Gobbolinothewitchscat despicable sexual, physical and emotional abuse was perpetrated by women within the church as well to a very significant level. And a lot of the sexual abuse perpetrated by men was covered up by women also. Women are not completely without blame here either.

Confirmation is also much younger than 16. Communion is normally around 8 years of age and confirmation around 12.

I quite agree with you re the women point too

First Holy Communion is around 8. At my church confirmation is around 14 - 16 but I attend an FSSP parish so it might be earlier at others

Strictly speaking, if you are baptised past the age of reason, you usually receive the sacraments of baptism, holy communion and confirmation at the same time if your baptised at the Easter vigil by the Bishop so you could be confirmed from age 7 onwards.

Circularargument · 25/01/2024 21:57

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 25/01/2024 10:26

Having some water splashed on their heads when they're babies won't make any difference, especially as it sounds like they won't be brought up in a particularly religious way.

I was christened, I'm not a Christian. Never pushed my beliefs on DS, for a while he decided all religions were true, at the moment, he's basically atheist - like his dad.

So it's OK to lie to get them into a good school? Hmm.

Sailingpasttheheadland · 25/01/2024 21:56

CurlewKate · 25/01/2024 20:18

@NoTouch "
It isn't a compromise, it is a blatant lie, with the intention to deceive (for a school place) and therefore in their RC book a sin.

I don't believe in any of this nonsense, but anyone who professes to have and actually believe in their religion could at least take it seriously."

I agree. Maybe I should have put compromise in inverted commas.

You clearly do not know Catholic teaching. It is not a sin for the OP to have a child baptised in a CoE church. The OP also explained very carefully that she is NOT having her child baptized for any reason other than she desires it.

As 2 or 3 of us have already explained, if a child was baptised CoE, the Catholic Church considers that a valid Christian baptism. The child is not a member of the Catholic Church at that point however, and if the child wishes to join the Church and receive other Sacraments they will need to receive catechisis (teaching) and the permission of the Priest. So I agree that the OP may want to have a discussion with her Parish Priest before deciding where the parents should have their baby baptised.

As to her husband's wishes that is obviously a discussion between them.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/01/2024 21:51

There is a difference between faith and organised religion. Faith can be a beautiful thing and bring comfort to many and you can encourage your children to have faith without aligning them with such vicious, money and power hungry people

Absolutely perfectly put, InAPickle12345

InAPickle12345 · 25/01/2024 21:51

While I agree with much of what you have said @Gobbolinothewitchscat despicable sexual, physical and emotional abuse was perpetrated by women within the church as well to a very significant level. And a lot of the sexual abuse perpetrated by men was covered up by women also. Women are not completely without blame here either.

Confirmation is also much younger than 16. Communion is normally around 8 years of age and confirmation around 12.

acatcalledjohn · 25/01/2024 21:44

Sexual abuse occurred in the church and other institutions because of predatory men. Let's be under no illusions of that.

I agree. However, the age mentioned does suggest it was an easy way for them to help justify it to themselves.

The "let your children chose" bit is contrary to Christian teaching generally as the main purpose of baptism is salvation so not something to be delayed. The choice bit comes later - when the child is perfectly free to say I'm not being confirmed and/or carrying on going to Mass or whatever because I don't believe or I want to become a Sikh or whatever.

I have two issues with that. Christian teaching clearly is about winning souls, and what is better than getting them young or when they are vulnerable/impressionable? Also, the notion that the child is perfectly free to make a decision is hardly true in stricter families/churches.

CurlewKate · 25/01/2024 21:32

@Wooloohooloo "And I also think any state funded schools should be allowed to have a faith requirement."
Why?

Gobbolinothewitchscat · 25/01/2024 21:29

acatcalledjohn · 25/01/2024 21:04

A baby is too young to decide whether to be baptised so their parents make that decision. When the child is attained the age of reason (7) in the Catholic Church, they can chose to be confirmed - normally as a teenager. That is because the church recognises that they have not made an active decision to be baptised or not as an infant and to continue their membership of the church.

That's a bit chilling. If 7 is considered the age of reason in the RC church it explains a lot of the sexual abuse that happened within its walls.

I think it is far too big a choice for any child to make such a big and personal decision. Up until the age of 18 they should be allowed (not forced) to explore what faith means to them. But deciding to actively be a member of a church is an adult decision.

IF there is a God then I doubt non-baptised children will go straight to hell by virtue of their parents having decided to not have a priest/pastor/minister/reverend chuck some water over their heads whilst saying a few words.

Sexual abuse occurred in the church and other institutions because of predatory men. Let's be under no illusions of that. Even if the age of reason was 16, children and vulnerable people would still have been abused by them. It is the age of reason with regards to being able to have a basic understanding of whether they wish to participate in membership of the church and receive sacraments - including baptism or reception into the church if they are not baptised RCs. It is nothing more than that. Confirmation is around 16 years of age usually.

The "let your children chose" bit is contrary to Christian teaching generally as the main purpose of baptism is salvation so not something to be delayed. The choice bit comes later - when the child is perfectly free to say I'm not being confirmed and/or carrying on going to Mass or whatever because I don't believe or I want to become a Sikh or whatever.

InAPickle12345 · 25/01/2024 21:10

Unless you're both on board I would really just wait and let the children decide for themselves when they are older.

But then, I chose not to christen my DC and have allowed him to make his own mind up so that's obviously going to sway my answer.

I am agnostic and absolutely abhor the Catholic Church (and most other organised religions) for the destruction they have caused to the human race. There's no way I would willingly align my child with an organisation who have raped, starved, stolen and waged war and destruction against millions, if not billions, of people the world over for centuries.

There is a difference between faith and organised religion. Faith can be a beautiful thing and bring comfort to many and you can encourage your children to have faith without aligning them with such vicious, money and power hungry people.

MrsRachelDanvers · 25/01/2024 21:09

@Mumsfishnets I mentioned the term indoctrinate in referring to RC. Indoctrination means teaching people to accept things uncritically-the RC church absolutely does this. You are not allowed to question your priest. You are not allowed to say some of the things taught are wrong. I have catholic family-and rather than question whether being on the pill is wrong-they just do it without saying anything and would lie about it. Of course, not all Catholics do that and many follow teachings to the letter but it’s not acceptable to have debate and criticism which is accepted in other denominations. It’s not disrespectful to use indoctrinate because they obey the exact definition of it.

CoffeeatIKEA · 25/01/2024 21:07

acatcalledjohn · 25/01/2024 21:04

A baby is too young to decide whether to be baptised so their parents make that decision. When the child is attained the age of reason (7) in the Catholic Church, they can chose to be confirmed - normally as a teenager. That is because the church recognises that they have not made an active decision to be baptised or not as an infant and to continue their membership of the church.

That's a bit chilling. If 7 is considered the age of reason in the RC church it explains a lot of the sexual abuse that happened within its walls.

I think it is far too big a choice for any child to make such a big and personal decision. Up until the age of 18 they should be allowed (not forced) to explore what faith means to them. But deciding to actively be a member of a church is an adult decision.

IF there is a God then I doubt non-baptised children will go straight to hell by virtue of their parents having decided to not have a priest/pastor/minister/reverend chuck some water over their heads whilst saying a few words.

I think unbaptised infants who died were said to have gone to limbo.

acatcalledjohn · 25/01/2024 21:04

A baby is too young to decide whether to be baptised so their parents make that decision. When the child is attained the age of reason (7) in the Catholic Church, they can chose to be confirmed - normally as a teenager. That is because the church recognises that they have not made an active decision to be baptised or not as an infant and to continue their membership of the church.

That's a bit chilling. If 7 is considered the age of reason in the RC church it explains a lot of the sexual abuse that happened within its walls.

I think it is far too big a choice for any child to make such a big and personal decision. Up until the age of 18 they should be allowed (not forced) to explore what faith means to them. But deciding to actively be a member of a church is an adult decision.

IF there is a God then I doubt non-baptised children will go straight to hell by virtue of their parents having decided to not have a priest/pastor/minister/reverend chuck some water over their heads whilst saying a few words.

Wooloohooloo · 25/01/2024 20:26

And I also think any state funded schools should be allowed to have a faith requirement.

Wooloohooloo · 25/01/2024 20:24

Ex DP is a Christian and I am an atheist. He wanted to get DD christened. I had no objection but said I couldn't be a part of it. I'm not a hypocrite and find it odd that any atheist would participate in such a religious ritual. He chose not to get her christened as he felt he couldn't do it without me (again his choice).

CurlewKate · 25/01/2024 20:18

@NoTouch "
It isn't a compromise, it is a blatant lie, with the intention to deceive (for a school place) and therefore in their RC book a sin.

I don't believe in any of this nonsense, but anyone who professes to have and actually believe in their religion could at least take it seriously."

I agree. Maybe I should have put compromise in inverted commas.

Gobbolinothewitchscat · 25/01/2024 20:15

I think there’s some confusion here between baptism and confirmation.

The reason for baptism in the Roman Catholic Church is for entry into the church but it is primarily to remove original sin and for salvation. A baby is too young to decide whether to be baptised so their parents make that decision. When the child is attained the age of reason (7) in the Catholic Church, they can chose to be confirmed - normally as a teenager. That is because the church recognises that they have not made an active decision to be baptised or not as an infant and to continue their membership of the church. If you do believe in Catholic teachings then you can’t wait for your child to make a decision as to whether to be baptised as your decision is essentially operating as an insurance policy for them on the basis that if they think it’s a load of nonsense then no harm done. However, if they do believe in the teachings of the church, they will have wanted to be baptised as soon as possible

Re: the point that the Catholic Church will accept another Christian baptism so long as it is Trinitarian and the child can then go onto receive the sacraments, that’s correct but only up to a certain point. The baptism will be recognised as valid. However there will a long period of catechism at the discretion of the priest as a child has to be received into the Catholic Church before they can receive the sacraments.

You can’t just rock up with an 8 year old and say they have been baptised CofE, that’s an acceptable Christian denomination so they have a right of entry onto a first Holy communion prep class and to access sacraments. They are not a member of the Catholic Church. The first thing the priest will want to see is a baptism certificate to ensure the child is baptised Roman Catholic - not just a baptised Christian. If the children are being prepped at school, a letter is normally sent out saying only children who have been baptised in the Roman Catholic faith can start preparations. Anyone else must speak to the priest about preparing their child for reception into the church first. That is normally by way of the RCIC course. To receive a sacrament (particularly the Eucharist) without being a member of the Catholic Church can be deemed to be a mortal sin and would certainly cause grave offence.

To be received into the Catholic Church (after another Christian denomination baptism), a priest must be sure that the child will be supported in their Catholic faith - who will take them to Mass etc? The priest will want to understand why the child (with one Catholic parent) has been baptised in the Church of England. Presenting it and some kind of “middle ground” is a bit odd to be honest and would probably mean that the priest would want to have a period of discernment with the parents. I would strongly recommend you speak to priest before you go down this route as it could have unintended consequences.

separately, most catholic schools will always prioritise children who are baptised Catholics over any other Christian baptism in over subscription categories. It maybe the school is under subscribed now but they could change. However, if you do want your children to be educated at a Catholic school, the best way to do that, is to have them baptised in the Catholic faith.

mathanxiety · 25/01/2024 20:10

ConfusedBear · 25/01/2024 18:43

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I wouldn't suggest that no. Have a conversation with him to discuss why he is happy with CoE but not RC. And explain why they're not interchangeable so it isn't a compromise. Then they can decide between RC Christening or no Christening.

The visit to grandma was a suggestion of how it could still be special for the op without her DH having to get involved (or even be in the same country).

They absolutely are interchangeable as far as the RC church is concerned.

Christian baptism in the name of the Trinity, using natural water, is valid baptism, in the eyes of the RC church.

NoTouch · 25/01/2024 19:48

CurlewKate · 25/01/2024 18:51

@NoTouch "COE is not a compromise if it is not your religion."

It is if, to repeat, you're doing it for school places.

Never read any of your posts.

It isn't a compromise, it is a blatant lie, with the intention to deceive (for a school place) and therefore in their RC book a sin.

I don't believe in any of this nonsense, but anyone who professes to have and actually believe in their religion could at least take it seriously.