Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Are the majority of men assholes?

240 replies

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 25/01/2024 09:29

Firstly I'm not a man hater - I've been married twice and am still married. But increasingly I'm starting to think that the vast majority of men are arseholes or display some kind of arsehole behaviour. Example this morning, but there are lots more.

Swimming at the gym, all lanes empty except the one I'm swimming in. Bloke gets into my lane and does splashy front crawl, almost whacking me in the face with his big meaty arm every time he passes me. So I move lanes, because obvs he's more important than me and should have his favourite lane to himself. 🙄

After my swim I go for a quick jacuzzi - this is a 10 person jacuzzi with three men already in there taking up every available space with their arms stretched across the back of the jacuzzi as far as possible. So I approach thinking one of them will make space for me. Erm no - I have to force myself in and get dirty looks for daring to go into their 'man space.'

Contrast this with the very polite behaviour of MOST of the women who use my gym.

I'm happy to say my DH is in the small minority of men who aren't aresholes (although he's by no means perfect - who is?) But if anything happens to him I will happily remain single and sexless for the rest of my days rather than try to find another decent man. (Also worth saying my first husband was a narcissist and I wouldn't piss on him if he were on fire!)

OP posts:
FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 11:44

I believe the “man hunts, woman stays home” theory isn’t nearly as accurate as it’s believed to be. There’s plenty of evidence of women hunting in prehistoric societies. The whole thing is a patriarchal myth, or at least a wild extrapolation.

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 11:19

@TheCadoganArms No, my theory is that women are not taught to drive well. That's my theory. And then my theory goes on to say that as a result, there are certain errors women are more likely to make when driving which may make them less good drivers and/or more irritating drivers etc.

In my original statement, perhaps I should have said, "but they come down to...." as I'd said "theories about driving". An incorrect use of a verb may have confused things slightly there.

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 26/01/2024 11:18

I'm a great driver. Just saying..

OP posts:
JadziaD · 26/01/2024 11:17

@C1N1C I'll only respond once more as we're derailing! Grin. But, "Humans were originally hunter gatherers. Men went out, had to judge distance, speed, space etc when hunting prey. Women were more organised and methodical planners, cooking, looking after kids etc. These qualities don't lend themselves to driving. (Don't hate me for saying this!!!)"

I'd say... bollocks. Society made it so that men would do the majority of hunting. In many cases, most likely for practical reasons - women pregnant, breastfeeding etc. Not because men were better at distance/speed/space judging by nature. This is a classic nature/nurture question. Also, organisation, planning etc would have been important for community wide hunting. Preparing the meet for transport and storage, ditto so men had these skills or could learn them.

TheCadoganArms · 26/01/2024 11:14

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 10:50

@TheCadoganArms I think it's pretty clear in the "I have theories" part of my statement? It's MY personal theory. Based on my own observed experience. Which, of course, is absolutely not in any way particularly scientific or genuinely extensive enough to count as fact. Hence why I said, "theory".

If I do ever get around to doing a post graduate degree in gender studies or sociology or something (which I've toyed with off and on for a long time) I'd be interested in actually conducting some real research on this theory of mine.

I think it's pretty clear in the "I have theories" part of my statement? It's MY personal theory. Based on my own observed experience. Which, of course, is absolutely not in any way particularly scientific or genuinely extensive enough to count as fact. Hence why I said, "theory".

You claim to have theories based on the assertion that 'women are actually not taught to drive as well as men', the latter point you have presented above as a fact, which is why I questioned it.

Interestingly, statistically men are more likely to pass their practical driving test whereas women are more likely to pass the theory test.

C1N1C · 26/01/2024 11:11

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 10:58

Aaaa, @C1N1C But now, this is exactly why I'd be doing this research. In the context of driving, my feeling is that this is an example where, if I am right, women have been actively taught in a certain way as a result of various societal/patriachal norms. I feel like this is one that could actually be properly researched, with facts and statistics that would allow us to either prove/disprove my theory and make some deductions as a result.

And then, I imagine, we could then start to extrapolate. So, are boys genuinely just more willing to blag it, be risk takers etc? Or is it that as a society we are unconsciously teaching them this from day 1? Are there some lessons we can learn from my driving hypothesis (assuming it's proved true) that we could apply to other aspects of how we bring up and teach girls and boy?

Honestly, I feel I could revolutionise the whole issue of how the patriarchy is continued if I did this research! Grin

I'd imagine the presumed justification that men are genetically predisposed to be risk takers will be slammed, but I'd argue this is perhaps the most likely reason. Humans were originally hunter gatherers. Men went out, had to judge distance, speed, space etc when hunting prey. Women were more organised and methodical planners, cooking, looking after kids etc. These qualities don't lend themselves to driving. (Don't hate me for saying this!!!)

More testing is required :)

I'm sure if this is true, we could 'engineer' progressively over successive generations these traits 'out' (or into) their respective genders... or maybe simply accept that these differences confer advantageous traits, and encourage them? Better to have one very good individual and use them for a particular task, than to have many 'average individuals?
...but that last suggestion flies in the face of traditional feminism.

Thinking out loud, not my actual suggestion for society!

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 10:58

Aaaa, @C1N1C But now, this is exactly why I'd be doing this research. In the context of driving, my feeling is that this is an example where, if I am right, women have been actively taught in a certain way as a result of various societal/patriachal norms. I feel like this is one that could actually be properly researched, with facts and statistics that would allow us to either prove/disprove my theory and make some deductions as a result.

And then, I imagine, we could then start to extrapolate. So, are boys genuinely just more willing to blag it, be risk takers etc? Or is it that as a society we are unconsciously teaching them this from day 1? Are there some lessons we can learn from my driving hypothesis (assuming it's proved true) that we could apply to other aspects of how we bring up and teach girls and boy?

Honestly, I feel I could revolutionise the whole issue of how the patriarchy is continued if I did this research! Grin

C1N1C · 26/01/2024 10:53

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 10:36

I have theories about driving but it comes down to the fact that women are actually not taught to drive as well as men and as a result tend to be more nervous, less able to adapt. Absolutely not a definitive statement, but overall, I think it's likely that women are not as confident/don't learn properly MORE often than men. The lane hogging, for example, is often not selfishness, but a lack of confidence in lane changing and/or a misguided belief that changing lane unless you are needing to turn is dangerous and/or lack of awareness of the road around you .

Valid hypotheses, which seems to agree with the 'typical' presumption about women. Men tend to be more reckless, risk-takers. Women stereotypically tend to be more methodical planners. I read this is true for certain ages at school where boys perform better because they'll 'guess' and blag, often securing higher scores in tests, whereas girls tend to only write what they know.

I've no idea if any of that is true!

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 10:50

@TheCadoganArms I think it's pretty clear in the "I have theories" part of my statement? It's MY personal theory. Based on my own observed experience. Which, of course, is absolutely not in any way particularly scientific or genuinely extensive enough to count as fact. Hence why I said, "theory".

If I do ever get around to doing a post graduate degree in gender studies or sociology or something (which I've toyed with off and on for a long time) I'd be interested in actually conducting some real research on this theory of mine.

TheCadoganArms · 26/01/2024 10:38

I have theories about driving but it comes down to the fact that women are actually not taught to drive as well as men and as a result tend to be more nervous, less able to adapt.

Is this really a 'fact' or just an unsubstantiated claim?

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 10:36

C1N1C · 26/01/2024 09:52

I think a large part of this is statistics. If 10% are 'bad', there will be a proportion of society who never encounter them, and there will be others who just have the bad luck of only encountering them.

I've noticed (around here) women are far less considerate on the road, rare 'thank you's, lane hogging, 'owning' the road when dripping off kids etc. I'd imagine not all, just perhaps a local subset.

I have theories about driving but it comes down to the fact that women are actually not taught to drive as well as men and as a result tend to be more nervous, less able to adapt. Absolutely not a definitive statement, but overall, I think it's likely that women are not as confident/don't learn properly MORE often than men. The lane hogging, for example, is often not selfishness, but a lack of confidence in lane changing and/or a misguided belief that changing lane unless you are needing to turn is dangerous and/or lack of awareness of the road around you .

superplumb · 26/01/2024 10:34

Yeah I agree op. Most are bellends. I've said the same, if I split from my husband, I wouldn't bother again. By the time you cut all all the criminals, perverts, liars and cheaters, ain't many left really.
Agree about the comments from middle aged men too. It's worse if i put my actual profile photo on Facebook rather than a dog ( which it currently is). The comments are much more rude.

TheCircusOfLife · 26/01/2024 09:59

No more so than arsehole women.

C1N1C · 26/01/2024 09:52

I think a large part of this is statistics. If 10% are 'bad', there will be a proportion of society who never encounter them, and there will be others who just have the bad luck of only encountering them.

I've noticed (around here) women are far less considerate on the road, rare 'thank you's, lane hogging, 'owning' the road when dripping off kids etc. I'd imagine not all, just perhaps a local subset.

BIossomtoes · 26/01/2024 09:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 26/01/2024 06:19

Slightly off topic but if/when conscription happens again it probably won't be just men that are called up. Women have been "allowed" to perform all army combat roles since 2018 so presumably it would be applied equally now. Shudder.

Icouldseetinsel · 26/01/2024 03:52

I don't think so. I've been lucky to have some truly wonderful men in my life.
However I've been raped, beaten been in an horrifically violent relationship with and been consistently lied to by men also...
I think there are arseholes everywhere of every gender but when you meet this shit men they are often more likely to be dangerous and seriously harm you as a woman.
I'd not say these men are the majority of men though. The majority of men I've met are decent people.
However I do think we live in a society that kind of covers up the horrific behaviour of the minority of men
Even now days.
None of the men who've serious hurt me physically actually faced any consequences for it either under the law or even in their social lives.
It makes you very scared to think sometimes how some men are just getting away with this stuff.
And even amongst decent men you sometimes see a downplaying of male violence towards women..

kisstheblarney · 26/01/2024 03:14

@EBearhug you took it wrongly then.

Nevertouchakoala · 26/01/2024 02:03

Men are always really nice to me 🤷🏻‍♀️?

EBearhug · 26/01/2024 01:42

Aptique · 25/01/2024 12:48

The more men that get killed, the safer the world is for women.

What a disgusting comment and don't try to cover yourself under the 'safe' reason. I'm guessing you include your own son, father, husband and male relatives too?

I took this to mean, not that we should go round killing men, but it is men being killed in accidents at work, or on the road, in medicine, etc, which is more likely to result in a proper review of why it happened and an improvement in safety practices, than if the same things happened to women.

rainbowbee · 26/01/2024 00:34

A man who comes into my office for a few afternoons a month demanded my desk. Yes he is significantly senior and it was the best desk but he would not have demanded it if I were male. And a woman wouldn't have had the lack of respect. I'm still cross about it. Once you open your eyes to male entitlement, it is everywhere. Everywhere. I have played patriarchy chicken for years (pick your battles though) and some of them react like outraged little toddlers. I go to a yoga centre and without fail, it is men who assume possession of communal space. Women share. It is a man who walks over your mat with his dirty feet. Women walk around it. It is a man who flings his arms and legs around and anyone in his way can just get out of it. And don't start me on the stenches, and performative grunting that they do. No-one says that women are perfect all the time but we just don't have the entitled audacity of straight white men.

LorlieS · 26/01/2024 00:28

@KimberleyClark I can see why there is objection from some to being called actresses; why should there be a differentiation needed? Most other jobs don't have a gender-specific word.
But then again, I don't believe anybody's marital status should be reflected in their title so I'm probably bound to think along these lines 😀

Pliskin · 26/01/2024 00:11

JadziaD · 25/01/2024 23:36

WHAAAAAT? I thought inhad read all and every John Wyndham story or novel.

<scuttles off to.find this asap>

"Consider Her Ways" is not a short story written by John Wyndham; rather, it is a novella. Published in 1956 as part of a collection titled "Consider Her Ways and Others," this speculative fiction piece is one of Wyndham's notable works.

JadziaD · 25/01/2024 23:36

KimberleyClark · 25/01/2024 19:49

There is also a very interesting short story by John Wyndham called Consider Her Ways which explores a world without men.

WHAAAAAT? I thought inhad read all and every John Wyndham story or novel.

<scuttles off to.find this asap>

spookehtooth · 25/01/2024 22:30

From your perspective that makes sense @Vegandiva otherwise you'd end up being suspicious of all decent behaviour by men