Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Are the majority of men assholes?

240 replies

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 25/01/2024 09:29

Firstly I'm not a man hater - I've been married twice and am still married. But increasingly I'm starting to think that the vast majority of men are arseholes or display some kind of arsehole behaviour. Example this morning, but there are lots more.

Swimming at the gym, all lanes empty except the one I'm swimming in. Bloke gets into my lane and does splashy front crawl, almost whacking me in the face with his big meaty arm every time he passes me. So I move lanes, because obvs he's more important than me and should have his favourite lane to himself. 🙄

After my swim I go for a quick jacuzzi - this is a 10 person jacuzzi with three men already in there taking up every available space with their arms stretched across the back of the jacuzzi as far as possible. So I approach thinking one of them will make space for me. Erm no - I have to force myself in and get dirty looks for daring to go into their 'man space.'

Contrast this with the very polite behaviour of MOST of the women who use my gym.

I'm happy to say my DH is in the small minority of men who aren't aresholes (although he's by no means perfect - who is?) But if anything happens to him I will happily remain single and sexless for the rest of my days rather than try to find another decent man. (Also worth saying my first husband was a narcissist and I wouldn't piss on him if he were on fire!)

OP posts:
JadziaD · 26/01/2024 15:29

MNUse · 26/01/2024 14:32

A similar, but different issue for our own times is how often we're now seeing historical women being pitched as trans. The assumption being that the roles of men and women were so defined that if a woman did it, it was because she thought she was a man.

Have you got specific examples of this? Its not something I’ve come across myself.

I don't follow this closely, but for example, I have seen reports where a female body (identified by female characteristics/bones etc) is buried with what is assumed to be "male" items. There is some speculation now that this means the woman was non binary. Instead of, you know, a woman who had weapons. Or that the society may not have had any issues with female warriers and so on. This idea that anyone who does not conform to modern gender expectations must therefore be non binary is bizarre. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/non-binary-medieval-warrior-burial-b1899832.html

There's also been quite a lot of talk about Joan of Arc off the back of a theatre performance last year or the year before?

There's also a Dr James Barry. As I understand it - she presented as a man in order to be a doctor. It's not clear that whether she truly believed she was a man or whether it was just a woman trying to be more than her society would allow her to be at that time. But many people now claim she was trans.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Barry_(surgeon)

Medieval warrior given lavish burial 1,000 years ago was likely non-binary

The person was given an elaborate burial in a ‘female-type dress’ with furs, feathers, and a sword

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/non-binary-medieval-warrior-burial-b1899832.html

slug · 26/01/2024 15:00

FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 12:46

It’s certainly true that women wouldn’t be available for hunting during periods around childbirth.

I think there’s the big problem here that with prehistoric (and some more recent societies) we don’t really know what they did or didn’t do.

We are extrapolating from very limited evidence, and historically that evidence was not necessarily interpreted by experts (by which I mean the Victorian amateur “archaeologist” - who has the money to finance investigations but doesn’t have an training or standards to adhere to).

So a lot of what we believe, as a society, about ancient cultures, has been largely made up from limited evidence, interpreted by people who are very much a product of their own time (as we all are). So Victorian man sees evidence of hunting paraphernalia in a grave of a male and female and he presumed the male is a hunter and the woman stays home, because that’s what he’s conditioned to see.

And because of how academic circles worked at that time, his interpretation is largely accepted and disseminated as fact. Now we are a century and a half on and that’s the paradigm we are still trying to shift…

In a lot of ways, popular historical beliefs tell us more about the patriarchal nature of the 19th C than the cultures they are supposedly about.

I remember seeing a tweet from a female archeologiest about this once.

Male archeologist "The knive/sword is on a shelf in the one room of the house. This is an alter, the knife/sword is a sacred object"
Female archeologist "The knife/sword is extemely sharp. Possibly it was put high up to keep it out of small hands"
Male archeologist "The hands in spray paintings in caves are small. This means their creation was part of the initiation ritual of young hunters"
Female archeologist "Womens hands are smaller than males. Could this be part of a female ritual?"

MNUse · 26/01/2024 14:32

A similar, but different issue for our own times is how often we're now seeing historical women being pitched as trans. The assumption being that the roles of men and women were so defined that if a woman did it, it was because she thought she was a man.

Have you got specific examples of this? Its not something I’ve come across myself.

Thisistyresome · 26/01/2024 14:24

misskatamari · 25/01/2024 10:12

Yanbu. I become more and more aware of it every day, especially now my TikTok algorithm seems to want to show me feminist content, which has opened my eyes to so much. My new favourite podcast is the “f the nice guy” podcast (and her TikTok content is fab too). Many people arseholes but many men really do take it to the next level

Yes TicToc, that is a great way to judge the world…

anothernamitynamenamechange · 26/01/2024 13:39

The thing about hunting is that almost all animals (including mammals) show some difference in behaviour between the males and females. Sometimes its very drastic sometimes subtle. But I can't find ANY examples where only the males hunted. Including animals that live in packs of males/females (even were the strength/size differences are much larger than in humans). There might sometimes be a difference in the tactics used/prey hunted and in some cased male chimpanzees tend to do more hunting than females (who are much better at using tools and therefore do more termite gathering). But not one example where the females don't hunt at all.
So its weird that people assume that humans were the only species ever to exist were the males did all/the vast majority of hunting. You would think there was some really compelling evidence for this but there isn't. Its just what people reckon must have been the case.

TheCadoganArms · 26/01/2024 13:38

Personally I find the tactics and concepts of successful hunting fascinating. Which is odd for someone who else wouldn’t hunt by choice 😂

You should have been born 12,000 years ago, you would have been good at project managing the hunting of a wooly mamouth.

anothernamitynamenamechange · 26/01/2024 13:32

spicedlemonpie · 25/01/2024 10:30

If war starts we wont have to worry over men as they will all be signed up.
Problem solved.

If WW3 starts we will rapidly achieve equality of opportunity AND equality of outcome for all but the uppermost echelons

doctor strangelove GIF
deragod · 26/01/2024 13:29

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 25/01/2024 10:07

Maybe it's also because I'm a 'woman of a certain age' and not deemed worth of their attention.

I fucking hate splashy loud male swimmers with their arms flapping everywhere. Gives me the absolute rage.

I do concede that there are also arsehole women though.

Every time I have to stop myself from pausing and telling them that the only thing they are showing off, while making everyone else life difficult, is lack of skills.

Pools and gyms are like magnet for this kind of men.

FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 13:25

TheCadoganArms · 26/01/2024 13:08

Dunno about you but I would rather not be hit by spear thrown from 30m away or 50m away! In both instances the spear is going to carry enough force to fuck you up. I agree that one spear, unless you are very lucky, is not going to take down some bison or mammoth but as I alluded to above I imagine hunting such sized prey would require a group effort where lobbing multiple spears at range would increase your chances of mortally injuring the animal while keeping the risks to your self at minimum. I am not trying to frame this as a 'men are better hunters' narrative, more a case that within a group of hunters there will be a raft of different skill sets at their disposal that are used as when the situation demands it. Some people can throw further (mostly men) and others can throw more accurately at shorter distances (men and women).

Have to confess I did not expect to be debating spear chucking ranges / accuracy of Mesolithic period hunter gathers when I work up this morning.

Edited

Sure, I can see what you’re saying. I think my point is that in general numbers are more important than distances. So the extra 10 spears of taking the women are likely to be more valuable going out hunting than the extra 20 yards a man might throw his spear. So there isn’t a lot of value in a “male only” hunting party.

Personally I find the tactics and concepts of successful hunting fascinating. Which is odd for someone who else wouldn’t hunt by choice 😂

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 26/01/2024 13:12

@user1497207191 woah, you're saying that women who swim are usually fat and slow??

OP posts:
TheCadoganArms · 26/01/2024 13:08

FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 12:50

But at the extremes of range, you aren’t hitting with enough force to really wound an animal, even if you’re hoping for a slow death. I’d argue that greater accuracy minus the 20m extra range is probably more useful.

And with large game, one spear is very unlikely to do enough damage on its own, unless extremely well placed. You’d be better to take all available spears, including the women, get in close and kill it.

Dunno about you but I would rather not be hit by spear thrown from 30m away or 50m away! In both instances the spear is going to carry enough force to fuck you up. I agree that one spear, unless you are very lucky, is not going to take down some bison or mammoth but as I alluded to above I imagine hunting such sized prey would require a group effort where lobbing multiple spears at range would increase your chances of mortally injuring the animal while keeping the risks to your self at minimum. I am not trying to frame this as a 'men are better hunters' narrative, more a case that within a group of hunters there will be a raft of different skill sets at their disposal that are used as when the situation demands it. Some people can throw further (mostly men) and others can throw more accurately at shorter distances (men and women).

Have to confess I did not expect to be debating spear chucking ranges / accuracy of Mesolithic period hunter gathers when I work up this morning.

NotLactoseFree · 26/01/2024 13:06

Deathbyfluffy · 26/01/2024 13:00

As for men being arseholes, people that genuinely believe this must walk around with their eyes shut.

Every day I see examples of both genders behaving awfully, depressing but that’s the world we live in.

Some feckless woman had a go at me for holding the door open for her ‘because it isn’t 1950 anymore and I can do it myself‘ 🙄

Are you a man or a woman? I think this might impact things here. DH probably sees men and women being dickheads about equal amounts of the time. But lots of men are only dickheads around women, so women probably tend to see men being dicks more often than they see women being dicks.

As for the door holding thing - I am a woman. I hold doors for other women and politely thank someone (man or woman) who hold doors for me.

user1497207191 · 26/01/2024 13:06

YABU.

"Some" people of both sexes are assholes, they're just assholes in different ways.

Men are more likely to be neanderthal, knuckle-draggers, taking up too much space, being deliberately clumsy, loud, untidy, etc. Take workmen, why put down their toolbox or materials slowly, carefully and quietly, when they can just drop them on the floor, causing the entire house to shake? Instead of wearing earbuds to listen to music/radio, they have to bring a huge ghetto blaster so that the entire neighbourhood can hear it! Too important to wear shoe covers or wipe their feet, so they just trample dog shit all over your new carpet!

But women can be pretty inconsiderate too. I.e. on my daily canal side walks, it's more likely to be women walking/jogging side by side who don't pull into single file to pass other people. It's mostly women with dogs on extendable leads who have no control whatsoever as their dogs zig zag from side to side tripping people up. It's mostly women who park on double yellows, zig zags, over junctions, etc., when dropping off or picking up their little lazy darlings from school, etc., causing traffic chaos.

As for swimming, at least men usually actually make progress and swim. When I was a member of gyms, there always seemed to be a couple of huge women doing a single length at a snail's pace and then talked blocking the lane end for half an hour, before they did another length!

So, no, it's "people" of both sexes that can be inconsiderate assholes.

Deathbyfluffy · 26/01/2024 13:00

As for men being arseholes, people that genuinely believe this must walk around with their eyes shut.

Every day I see examples of both genders behaving awfully, depressing but that’s the world we live in.

Some feckless woman had a go at me for holding the door open for her ‘because it isn’t 1950 anymore and I can do it myself‘ 🙄

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 12:58

Yeah, I'm not convinced that extra strength is THAT compelling an argument for men apparently doing more hunting. It's a bit like that section in Invisible Women where she's talking about people saying things like, "Well, it's harder for women to be builders or firefighters because there's a lot of heavy lifting" and she points out that we've created standard sizing and weights etc to meet men's strengths. That bricks didn't HAVE to be that size. That equipment was made a certain size but that doesn't mean it's the ONLY size it could be made etc.

If a spear was smaller/lighter, would the difference in distance be the same? if a bunch of people are hunting would there be any intrinsic issue in say 3 people working together to bring it down/haul it home than 4?

Re the victorian times assumptions, so true. It was interesting at the Natural History Museum a little while ago to see how they're trying to highlight some women's efforts more where before they were ignored. I think it's newish anyway.

A similar, but different issue for our own times is how often we're now seeing historical women being pitched as trans. The assumption being that the roles of men and women were so defined that if a woman did it, it was because she thought she was a man.

Gettingbysomehow · 26/01/2024 12:58

Obviously you will get maximum grief for posting in AIBU but in my opinion a lot of men are arseholes. Certainly every single man in my life, father, stepfather, husbands have been.
I've given up and have lived on my own for years. My male friends are all gay and we get on like a house on fire. But men on the whole are like untrained puppies.
My DS is ok but then I brought him up so he would be.

Deathbyfluffy · 26/01/2024 12:58

spicedlemonpie · 25/01/2024 10:30

If war starts we wont have to worry over men as they will all be signed up.
Problem solved.

Hopefully due to ‘equality’ both men and women will be - or does equality only work one way?

SwimmingWorrier · 26/01/2024 12:53

Lentilweaver · 25/01/2024 11:11

I don't disagree with you @SweetBirdsong. I didn't mean my comment to imply that I don't believe in the patriarchy, because I do. But I can guarantee this thread will only go one way: posters will rush to say "Not my Nigel" and tell us how wonderful their husbands or sons are.

I wondered how long it would be before Nigel was mentioned.

FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 12:50

TheCadoganArms · 26/01/2024 12:43

I'm absolutely speculating on the last bit of my post but I don't think it is necessarily a controversial idea. A cursory look at the javelin world records show men throwing about 20m further then their elite women counterparts. An additional 20m range is a huge distance in the context of hunting prey. Sure, accuracy reduces the further you are trying to throw but if you are hunting as a group you just need that one 'hit' to disable an animal and then wait for it to sufficiently weaken from blood loss before going for the kill.

Hopefully an anthropologist will be along soon to set the record straight.

But at the extremes of range, you aren’t hitting with enough force to really wound an animal, even if you’re hoping for a slow death. I’d argue that greater accuracy minus the 20m extra range is probably more useful.

And with large game, one spear is very unlikely to do enough damage on its own, unless extremely well placed. You’d be better to take all available spears, including the women, get in close and kill it.

SwimmingWorrier · 26/01/2024 12:47

spicedlemonpie · 25/01/2024 10:30

If war starts we wont have to worry over men as they will all be signed up.
Problem solved.

WTF?

FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 12:46

It’s certainly true that women wouldn’t be available for hunting during periods around childbirth.

I think there’s the big problem here that with prehistoric (and some more recent societies) we don’t really know what they did or didn’t do.

We are extrapolating from very limited evidence, and historically that evidence was not necessarily interpreted by experts (by which I mean the Victorian amateur “archaeologist” - who has the money to finance investigations but doesn’t have an training or standards to adhere to).

So a lot of what we believe, as a society, about ancient cultures, has been largely made up from limited evidence, interpreted by people who are very much a product of their own time (as we all are). So Victorian man sees evidence of hunting paraphernalia in a grave of a male and female and he presumed the male is a hunter and the woman stays home, because that’s what he’s conditioned to see.

And because of how academic circles worked at that time, his interpretation is largely accepted and disseminated as fact. Now we are a century and a half on and that’s the paradigm we are still trying to shift…

In a lot of ways, popular historical beliefs tell us more about the patriarchal nature of the 19th C than the cultures they are supposedly about.

TheCadoganArms · 26/01/2024 12:43

FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 12:29

I don’t think there is even sufficient evidence to support the last statement - men might be able to throw slightly further than women, on average, but not necessarily with similar accuracy, and how far a distance throw is really helpful when hunting game is debatable. Particularly when there is access to atatls…

The whole reason the “man hunter” thing is so widely believed is because it plays into the patriarchal prejudices of modern (and early modern / European medieval) society.

I'm absolutely speculating on the last bit of my post but I don't think it is necessarily a controversial idea. A cursory look at the javelin world records show men throwing about 20m further then their elite women counterparts. An additional 20m range is a huge distance in the context of hunting prey. Sure, accuracy reduces the further you are trying to throw but if you are hunting as a group you just need that one 'hit' to disable an animal and then wait for it to sufficiently weaken from blood loss before going for the kill.

Hopefully an anthropologist will be along soon to set the record straight.

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 12:35

FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 12:29

I don’t think there is even sufficient evidence to support the last statement - men might be able to throw slightly further than women, on average, but not necessarily with similar accuracy, and how far a distance throw is really helpful when hunting game is debatable. Particularly when there is access to atatls…

The whole reason the “man hunter” thing is so widely believed is because it plays into the patriarchal prejudices of modern (and early modern / European medieval) society.

I suspect this is one of those things where practicalities or unconscious things societies do leads to things being seen as "fact".

So, 100% yes re women hunters and we're seeing more evidence of that and it's actually being properly studied, finally!

But, practically speaking, it's not unreasonable to assume that many women were NOT hunting as a result of pregnancy, childbirth and breastfeeding. So the narrative should be that men took this on because they couldn't do the childcare needed pre-and post-birth so this was the thing they could do. Arguably, they were LESS competent because they could ONLY do this thing, while women could do the children thing AND, if not encumbered by children, ALSO do the hunting thing.

But instead, the narrative shifted to be all about men hunting becuase they're bigger, stronger, more aggressive, more decisive, can measure distance better (argh)etc. And then, as you say, that completely feeds into a longer term patriarchal view of men as "protectors" and "aggressive" and all that bollocks.

FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 12:29

I don’t think there is even sufficient evidence to support the last statement - men might be able to throw slightly further than women, on average, but not necessarily with similar accuracy, and how far a distance throw is really helpful when hunting game is debatable. Particularly when there is access to atatls…

The whole reason the “man hunter” thing is so widely believed is because it plays into the patriarchal prejudices of modern (and early modern / European medieval) society.

TheCadoganArms · 26/01/2024 12:04

FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 11:44

I believe the “man hunts, woman stays home” theory isn’t nearly as accurate as it’s believed to be. There’s plenty of evidence of women hunting in prehistoric societies. The whole thing is a patriarchal myth, or at least a wild extrapolation.

Yep, more evidence around that women were accomplished hunters too. I think the simple hardship of hunter gather survival back then required everyone pitched in as it were, be it lighting fires, foraging for plants, fruit, eggs, honey etc or trapping and killing animals. I imagine on the odd occasion where a much larger or particularly dangerous prey was being hunted men might have taken a more prominent role purely on the basis that they could maintain a safe distance due to the ability to throw a spear/stone a greater distance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread