Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Are the majority of men assholes?

240 replies

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 25/01/2024 09:29

Firstly I'm not a man hater - I've been married twice and am still married. But increasingly I'm starting to think that the vast majority of men are arseholes or display some kind of arsehole behaviour. Example this morning, but there are lots more.

Swimming at the gym, all lanes empty except the one I'm swimming in. Bloke gets into my lane and does splashy front crawl, almost whacking me in the face with his big meaty arm every time he passes me. So I move lanes, because obvs he's more important than me and should have his favourite lane to himself. 🙄

After my swim I go for a quick jacuzzi - this is a 10 person jacuzzi with three men already in there taking up every available space with their arms stretched across the back of the jacuzzi as far as possible. So I approach thinking one of them will make space for me. Erm no - I have to force myself in and get dirty looks for daring to go into their 'man space.'

Contrast this with the very polite behaviour of MOST of the women who use my gym.

I'm happy to say my DH is in the small minority of men who aren't aresholes (although he's by no means perfect - who is?) But if anything happens to him I will happily remain single and sexless for the rest of my days rather than try to find another decent man. (Also worth saying my first husband was a narcissist and I wouldn't piss on him if he were on fire!)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
chocolatesaltyballs22 · 28/01/2024 18:56

@spookehtooth was only joking 😀

OP posts:
spookehtooth · 28/01/2024 17:09

I was trying to be supportive @chocolatesaltyballs22 I guess something lost in translation 🤣

Definitely not a splashy swimmer type bloke, I'll leave it at that because self praise is no praise right?

SweetBirdsong · 28/01/2024 13:39

CurlewKate · 28/01/2024 06:28

"Some feckless woman had a go at me for holding the door open for her ‘because it isn’t 1950 anymore and I can do it myself‘"

And today in things that never happened.....

Yep this. ^ Exactly what I thought.

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 28/01/2024 11:55

spookehtooth · 27/01/2024 17:33

This is a massive detour of the OPs post anyways 🤣🤣 I think people have taken the original post far too seriously and literally. She's pissed off by men, and it's how she feels. I'm a bloke, and I couldn't care less 🤷‍♂️ whatever the percentage of men who are horrible, it's true that bad experiences are common & it's fine to feel that way & want to talk about it

Are you splashy front crawl swimmer guy? 😂

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 28/01/2024 07:22

Sorry-wrong thread.

CurlewKate · 28/01/2024 06:29

Can I ask- do your children witness this behaviour?

CurlewKate · 28/01/2024 06:28

"Some feckless woman had a go at me for holding the door open for her ‘because it isn’t 1950 anymore and I can do it myself‘"

And today in things that never happened.....

RantyAnty · 27/01/2024 22:12

Deathbyfluffy · 26/01/2024 13:00

As for men being arseholes, people that genuinely believe this must walk around with their eyes shut.

Every day I see examples of both genders behaving awfully, depressing but that’s the world we live in.

Some feckless woman had a go at me for holding the door open for her ‘because it isn’t 1950 anymore and I can do it myself‘ 🙄

Lol how tragic. She hurt your little feelers. Come back when you've been groped, followed, slammed into, etc. etc.

You have no clue.

spookehtooth · 27/01/2024 22:08

I hear you @goneaway2 I have a lovely foot & cycling path from my house to the city centre in Norwich and periodically come across those creatures. The noise & pollution isn't good for the wildlife living there

I'm starting to make a point of hogging the middle of the path to block them, and slowing down to frustrate their progress as much as possible 🤷‍♂️ I'm not afraid of being Mr difficult. If they got difficult, I'd just get my phone out and start recording them.

Now you mention it I'm gonna complain to my councillor. It's an argument for seriously considering a cycle camera to try and capture the number plates so I can report them

goneaway2 · 27/01/2024 18:55

The illegal dirt bikers riding on the nature reserves (no helmets), footpaths and roads where I live - all men. Mostly in their 40's and 50's too! These eejets don't even try to avoid people.

spookehtooth · 27/01/2024 17:33

This is a massive detour of the OPs post anyways 🤣🤣 I think people have taken the original post far too seriously and literally. She's pissed off by men, and it's how she feels. I'm a bloke, and I couldn't care less 🤷‍♂️ whatever the percentage of men who are horrible, it's true that bad experiences are common & it's fine to feel that way & want to talk about it

spookehtooth · 27/01/2024 17:27

These arguments about "facts" and "truth" are interesting.

Archeology to this day routinely builds a story around a limited amount of evidence. They often have to, because the solid evidence alone leaves so much unanswered that they have to, essentially, make bits up to knit together the evidence into a story. Our entire culture is rooted in storytelling, advertiser's and politicians both essentially sell stories or dreams about a lifestyle or how society should be.

Periods closer to our own have more evidence to hand, but still gaps remain and academics do much the same to fill in gaps or try to explain what's going on with individuals and societies. Even that is, to some extent quite a modern phenomena. The Greek historian Herodotus, covering the Peloponnesian war was unique in the Greco Roman world for his reliance on evidence. It was much more of a blurred line between story and history, untill that point.

Everyone is to some extent affected by the culture they grow up in, we can't help it
In this context, trying to reinterpret history wrt gender & identity is nothing new. It's just another debate about evidence and what people think it might suggest. It would be dangerous to shut it down, and disallow questioning of the evidence .. because where does that stop? What else might you not be allowed to disagree with? None of us have to agree with anyone else's interpretation of the evidence

anothernamitynamenamechange · 27/01/2024 13:32

Re Florence Nightingale and James Barry. Both were women who ended up doing things in medicine that fell outside the expected remit for women at the time
Florence Nightingales route was nurse (female profession) but she effectively expanded that role to include being a statistician etc. This within the context of war a time when women's expected roles tend to expand. But what she did was unconventional/ground breaking for men AND women.
James Barry's route was in a way more straightforward- everything she did as a doctor fell within the role of doctor. But she had to identify as a man to do so.

They are different answers to a similar problem. But I don't think the route James Barry chose means she was necessarily trans.

I also don't think its fair to say because Elizabeth Garett Anderson's life overlapped with James Barry they had similar options. Barry died the same year Anderson finally got a license to practice medicine. Its like saying an old woman who died this year had the same options/life experiences as a young person who just graduated this year. 1813 was not 1865.

I'm not saying Barry didn't have issues with their identity as female/male. There is literally no way of knowing. But I don't think you can say they likely did either. There is no "evidence" either way.

MNUse · 26/01/2024 22:40

Here’s info about the first women to qualify for medical degrees in the UK and US. Both of their lifetimes overlapped with that of Dr James Barry. No openly declared woman had qualified as a doctor at the time they set out to do so. They had to fight to do it. But they persevered and fought as women and they didn’t present themselves as male. Because they weren’t trans. It’s not true to say Barry had no other option and all of Barry’s choices can be explained by the fact that there were no female doctors yet.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Garrett_Anderson

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Blackwell

Elizabeth Garrett Anderson - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Garrett_Anderson

MNUse · 26/01/2024 22:26

CurlewKate · 26/01/2024 17:31

@JadziaD Re Dr James Barry, I know there’s been debate about this, and of course we can’t know for sure, but the argument that this was a historical trans person seems pretty strong to me. Compare that with someone like Florence Nightingale who was also doing things that hadn’t really been done before by women in her society, but she didn’t present herself as male in order to do that".

She didn't need to present herself as a man. She was a nurse-women were allowed to be nurses. In fact, it would have been incredibly unusual (I don't say impossible because I'm not sure) for a man to do what she did. She took her nursing in unprecedented directions- but her being a nurse was unremarkable. James Barry could ONLY have been a doctor by pretending to be a man. It would have been impossible as a woman. So I think we have no evidence to suggest that she was trans. Ditto Jean d'Arc.

And the suggestion that if she had been a woman she would have wanted to be a trail blazer for other women shows a fundamental misunderstanding of the historical context. She wanted to be a doctor. And she wanted the freedoms that being a man gave her. Simple as that.

Ok I don’t share your confidence in your ability to read the mind of a person who died nearly 160 years ago and know for sure why they did what they did, so again, we’ll have to agree to disagree. Claiming there’s no evidence Barry was trans is risible. Presenting as a man in private as well as public life until death is evidence. It’s the claim that Barry wasn’t trans that needs justifying. Yes it’s possible, but the evidence points the other way.

Florence Nightingale wasn’t primarily a nurse, that’s a common misconception due to the way the Victorian press tried to feminise her image, precisely because her actual activities were very unusual if not unprecedented for a woman of that time. Wikipedia isn’t a brilliant source but you’ll see they describe her as a social reformer, statistician and a manager and trainer of nurses, not primarily a nurse herself. That’s backed up by Mark Bostridge’s biography which is the best current source on her life. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/FlorenceNightingale. But she didn’t call herself Frank and present herself as male to the world to do those things. James Barry died in 1865 so contrary to claims above it’s not a completely different social period to Florence Nightingale, who was born in 1820. If you’d like an earlier example, Jane Austen was very unusual in being a female professional author but although she published anonymously the one thing she did publicise was her sex, her novels were published as ‘by a lady’. So saying that Barry had no choice but to present as male in order to do things women hadn’t done before is not supported by the evidence. And it’s true to say Jane Austen in the late 18th/early 19th century wanted to make sure the world knew her work was done by a woman. You’re showing your ignorance of the historical context to claim otherwise.

Florence Nightingale - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florence_Nightingale

SheerLucks · 26/01/2024 21:59

I just think a huge proportion of the population are very selfish and couldn't care less about anyone but immediate family. It's just that males are more aggressive and obvious about it.

But you can spot these people a mile off and avoid them. A huge proportion are also lovely.

FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 20:53

Not only am I the dog’s bollocks at reverse parking, I can reverse trailers (big agricultural trailers and tiny, annoying ones you can’t see behind you) like an absolute pro.

But, I really struggled with this stuff when learning / under test conditions because, like a lot of women, I was conditioned to be insecure and not confident with practical tasks, and I had been taught that mistakes were a sign you were no good at something, not a learning experience.

This wasn’t something wrong with my driving tuition (although it probably could’ve been better), but more to do with how I was treated in schools, by family, and society at large, and how women were generally portrayed in the media at the time. I’d like to think this is changing, but it’s slow progress for sure.

TheCadoganArms · 26/01/2024 19:38

superplumb · 26/01/2024 16:38

Women are taught to drive as well as men. The tests are the same.
I do think that many women are worse drivers ( risk of getting flammed). More likely to block off a junction, rarely say thank you and still tailgate. Not sure why maybe more going on in our minds..

In my experience women are crap at saying thank you, reverse parking and are more responsible general low level road based annoying fuckwittery. Men on the other hand are way more likely to drive at speed, drive aggressively, more prone to road rage and are responsible for way more fatal catastrophic accidents. On that basis give me the minor inconvenience of someone not saying thank you or waiting a bit longer for someone to complete a parking manoeuvre every day of the week.

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 17:35

A full 100 years later than Dr Barry, Laura Ingalls Wilder was bemoaning the restrictions of being a girl. And she was talking about riding horses, and not having to do the sewing. So yes, as @CurlewKate points out, thinking that Dr Barry might have wanted to be a trailblazer completely misses the historical context and the reality of women's lives in that time.

CurlewKate · 26/01/2024 17:31

@JadziaD Re Dr James Barry, I know there’s been debate about this, and of course we can’t know for sure, but the argument that this was a historical trans person seems pretty strong to me. Compare that with someone like Florence Nightingale who was also doing things that hadn’t really been done before by women in her society, but she didn’t present herself as male in order to do that".

She didn't need to present herself as a man. She was a nurse-women were allowed to be nurses. In fact, it would have been incredibly unusual (I don't say impossible because I'm not sure) for a man to do what she did. She took her nursing in unprecedented directions- but her being a nurse was unremarkable. James Barry could ONLY have been a doctor by pretending to be a man. It would have been impossible as a woman. So I think we have no evidence to suggest that she was trans. Ditto Jean d'Arc.

And the suggestion that if she had been a woman she would have wanted to be a trail blazer for other women shows a fundamental misunderstanding of the historical context. She wanted to be a doctor. And she wanted the freedoms that being a man gave her. Simple as that.

FourLeggedBuckers · 26/01/2024 17:31

Sandi Toksvig has a book about women doing unusual things throughout history and she discusses exactly this in the introduction - that it’s not really possible to know which of the women pretending to be men were doing so because the cultural norms for women were so restrictive, or because they actually identified as male. It’s quiet a nice, light and humorous general interest book.

MNUse · 26/01/2024 17:27

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 17:18

@MNUse that independent article is just one article - there were loads. It's also very clearly stated the amount of DNA is tiny. As for Dr Barry vs Florence Nightingale, there are a million differences, not least being the time periods in which they were alive. As for How many women who identified as women would really be willing to live their whole life as the other sex, no matter how much you wanted to be a doctor? They would want to be visible as women to make the point that women could do it as well.

I'm amazed you can write this about a woman in the 18th century. for a start, you're right, most would NOT be willing to do it, which is probably why female doctors were pretty rare. As for wanting to be "visible?... at that time, in that place when women weren't allowed to do these things and, one assumes, in an army camp filled with men would NOT have been safe? Come on.

Either way, my point is that a historical character presenting as a man/woman or having artefacts we consider to be linked to the other sex doesn't mean they're transgender. we shouldn't be applying our standards to history. I am sure there WERE trans people in history, of course, but that doesn't mean that every female body buried with weapons was transgender or that every woman who pretended to be a man to do things or have a life that women weren't allowed was transgender. ie we shouldn't assume they believed they'd been born in the "wrong body."

Yeah re independent article I edited my post because actually the academic article that was the source seemingly did use the term non-binary, so my bad, the journalist didn’t just pull it out of nowhere.

i don’t think we’re particularly in disagreement for the most part, I also think there were trans people in history and I also don’t think ‘woman with a sword’ automatically equals trans. Re Dr James Barry I think we’ll just have to agree to disagree.

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 17:18

@MNUse that independent article is just one article - there were loads. It's also very clearly stated the amount of DNA is tiny. As for Dr Barry vs Florence Nightingale, there are a million differences, not least being the time periods in which they were alive. As for How many women who identified as women would really be willing to live their whole life as the other sex, no matter how much you wanted to be a doctor? They would want to be visible as women to make the point that women could do it as well.

I'm amazed you can write this about a woman in the 18th century. for a start, you're right, most would NOT be willing to do it, which is probably why female doctors were pretty rare. As for wanting to be "visible?... at that time, in that place when women weren't allowed to do these things and, one assumes, in an army camp filled with men would NOT have been safe? Come on.

Either way, my point is that a historical character presenting as a man/woman or having artefacts we consider to be linked to the other sex doesn't mean they're transgender. we shouldn't be applying our standards to history. I am sure there WERE trans people in history, of course, but that doesn't mean that every female body buried with weapons was transgender or that every woman who pretended to be a man to do things or have a life that women weren't allowed was transgender. ie we shouldn't assume they believed they'd been born in the "wrong body."

MNUse · 26/01/2024 17:09

JadziaD · 26/01/2024 15:29

I don't follow this closely, but for example, I have seen reports where a female body (identified by female characteristics/bones etc) is buried with what is assumed to be "male" items. There is some speculation now that this means the woman was non binary. Instead of, you know, a woman who had weapons. Or that the society may not have had any issues with female warriers and so on. This idea that anyone who does not conform to modern gender expectations must therefore be non binary is bizarre. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/non-binary-medieval-warrior-burial-b1899832.html

There's also been quite a lot of talk about Joan of Arc off the back of a theatre performance last year or the year before?

There's also a Dr James Barry. As I understand it - she presented as a man in order to be a doctor. It's not clear that whether she truly believed she was a man or whether it was just a woman trying to be more than her society would allow her to be at that time. But many people now claim she was trans.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Barry_(surgeon)

Thanks for your reply.
Re Dr James Barry, I know there’s been debate about this, and of course we can’t know for sure, but the argument that this was a historical trans person seems pretty strong to me. Compare that with someone like Florence Nightingale who was also doing things that hadn’t really been done before by women in her society, but she didn’t present herself as male in order to do that. How many women who identified as women would really be willing to live their whole life as the other sex, no matter how much you wanted to be a doctor? They would want to be visible as women to make the point that women could do it as well. When you’ve got someone presenting their whole life as male, including wanting to be buried at death under a male name, it’s not just about career opportunities imo.

superplumb · 26/01/2024 16:38

Women are taught to drive as well as men. The tests are the same.
I do think that many women are worse drivers ( risk of getting flammed). More likely to block off a junction, rarely say thank you and still tailgate. Not sure why maybe more going on in our minds..

Swipe left for the next trending thread