Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she should look for work?

259 replies

Daisydoodo · 24/01/2024 23:35

my sister is on the migration from tax credits to universal credit. Her husband works and earns around £25k a year and does not aspire to earn anymore she has 6 children 3 over 16 and 3 5-16years she was complaining today that she may be expected to start looking for work when she migrates and how she thinks it’s unfair as she is only just getting her life back now the 5yo is in full time school. AIBU to tell her to get a grip and get a job? I feel awful for saying it but it’s getting on my nerves as I was expected to return after 6 months mat leave. Should the UC system force her to look for work

OP posts:
Luxell934 · 25/01/2024 13:55

I don’t get posts like these. It’s your sister, not some random woman down the road.
Why make a thread for people to bash her call her lazy, entitled, benefit bashing etc

If she needs to look for work to get her full UC amount then that’s what she will do or she will lose some money. Her business, her choice, her life.

Don’t compare yourself to her, you make your own choices. She’s probably terrified about going back to work after so long out the work force, maybe a little support wouldn’t go amiss.

Twins3007 · 25/01/2024 13:53

Mariposistaaa · 25/01/2024 04:27

This is MN - no doubt they all cosleep (although she and DP still make time for plenty of sex to produce more), breast feed until secondary school and at least 3 will have SN. Hahahahaha
OP is right - get off your arse and get a job!

exactly this

Oliotya · 25/01/2024 13:52

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

So what do you think that support should like? How long should it last? How much should it cost? What happens if someone never gets over said "apprehension"? Why would they take advantage of this new support having avoided any previous support?

Spirallingdownwards · 25/01/2024 13:48

SaladDays2024 · 25/01/2024 03:32

Her children will end up contributing to society, we need more children for all the expected elderly in care.

Maybe. Or maybe they will se their parents taking full advantage of a welfare state supporting their family and think that would be options for them too.

Let's hope it is the former.

JohnMytton · 25/01/2024 13:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Oliotya · 25/01/2024 13:47

aname1234 · 25/01/2024 13:45

She has work. She has 6 kids!

Popping out kids that everyone else has to support isn't a job. Not everything that takes up time is work.

aname1234 · 25/01/2024 13:45

She has work. She has 6 kids!

Oliotya · 25/01/2024 13:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I don't really understand this. What kind of support do people who have been unemployed through choice need? They'd soon get over the lack of support if benefits were stopped. They should never have been supported through unemployment in the first place. Personal responsibility.

Maray1967 · 25/01/2024 13:37

SaladDays2024 · 25/01/2024 04:07

I didn't mean they will work as carers, the society needs more children to generate taxes to raise funding fot public services..particularly as we're out of the EU.

No it doesn’t, it needs to welcome migrants who can and will work. Why on earth should we be encouraging large families?

JohnMytton · 25/01/2024 13:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LadyBird1973 · 25/01/2024 12:43

Part of the problem here is that jobs are so badly paid, that people need to be topped up with benefits. And housing/general cost of living isn't proportional to what people can earn in many jobs.

That said, I do understand the resentment people feel towards working full time and cutting their own mat leave short or having fewer kids than they'd ideally like, and then seeing people be supported by the state when those people have clearly had more children than they can reasonably afford.

It's also a problem that the people who work hardest aren't always the best paid - it's so often luck of the draw whether you end up earning well or not and is nothing to do with working harder or being more capable or making wiser choices.

kisstheblarney · 25/01/2024 12:41

SaladDays2024 · 25/01/2024 10:05

Even if she worked, most of it will be on childcare as the older children need to study for A levels abd GCSEs.

There is a deep disdain of SAHP even when they don't claim benefits they are looked down for letting feminism down and relying on a man, for not being a good role model ...etc
But it's 100x worse when they are claiming benefits.

I bet none of those posters mind middle class sports injuries costing the NHS or the environmental impact their frequent holidays, home swimming pools and 4x4s cause. It's only when a poorer family wants to exercise their HUMAN RIGHT to have a family and put it first within government rules that posters love to judge.

If you don't like the rules of the system, use your votes or campaign for change.

And the comment on the children ending up just like their parents, that is not necessarily true and if it were true or most likely then isn't the sister a victim, a product of her own circumstances and deserves kindness and support to break the cycle? No, it's more fun to demonise and name call her. 6 kids and lazy? Sure ok.

we all know or have heard of rich spoilt children born to self made parents, if the rich kids success that's mostly down to nepotism. The problem is that this society looks down on family values and the importance of a solid family unit and absolutely worships money.

It's part of the system to demonise SAHP and shame benefits users to coerce them back into
Meanwhile our children are raised by strangers, getting obese, lonely and cyber bullied because both parents are run ragged by a job who will toss you out any minute.

Lastly, dogs issues are absolutely not the same. Dangerous dogs kill and maim. They are bred for tossers who gloat in having a danger dog. I hope the law gets even stricter on dogs and their owners.

It's not a HUMAM RIGHT to have six children you can't afford! You reckon these kids are so well looked after......

Yeah loads of time to parent six kids! But they decided it was their right to have someone 6 kids, so if they're working all day, either in or out of the home.... it's a life choice that they chose.

Oliotya · 25/01/2024 12:40

SaladDays2024 · 25/01/2024 10:05

Even if she worked, most of it will be on childcare as the older children need to study for A levels abd GCSEs.

There is a deep disdain of SAHP even when they don't claim benefits they are looked down for letting feminism down and relying on a man, for not being a good role model ...etc
But it's 100x worse when they are claiming benefits.

I bet none of those posters mind middle class sports injuries costing the NHS or the environmental impact their frequent holidays, home swimming pools and 4x4s cause. It's only when a poorer family wants to exercise their HUMAN RIGHT to have a family and put it first within government rules that posters love to judge.

If you don't like the rules of the system, use your votes or campaign for change.

And the comment on the children ending up just like their parents, that is not necessarily true and if it were true or most likely then isn't the sister a victim, a product of her own circumstances and deserves kindness and support to break the cycle? No, it's more fun to demonise and name call her. 6 kids and lazy? Sure ok.

we all know or have heard of rich spoilt children born to self made parents, if the rich kids success that's mostly down to nepotism. The problem is that this society looks down on family values and the importance of a solid family unit and absolutely worships money.

It's part of the system to demonise SAHP and shame benefits users to coerce them back into
Meanwhile our children are raised by strangers, getting obese, lonely and cyber bullied because both parents are run ragged by a job who will toss you out any minute.

Lastly, dogs issues are absolutely not the same. Dangerous dogs kill and maim. They are bred for tossers who gloat in having a danger dog. I hope the law gets even stricter on dogs and their owners.

Lol at middle classes having frequent holidays and home swimming pools.
There is no "human right" that states you must be able to have 6 kids at other people's expense.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/01/2024 12:27

LovesFood1987 · 25/01/2024 03:40

Exactly this.

Yes, these ‘lifestyles’ often run to 2 or 3 generations.

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 12:13

lostincakes · 25/01/2024 11:25

She won't be getting benefits for the youngest child as assuming they are 5 by the age description in first post which means they were born after the 2 child limit. The older 3 who are 16+ will be approaching the cut off age for child benefits in the next few years. So, quite soon they will have 3 children/young adults who they cannot claim for. What will they do then? I suppose they will tell them to claim jobseekers element of UC or whatever young people can get and contribute to the household costs if they stay at home, or are they likely to get jobs considering the examples they have been set?

Why would they not be likely to get jobs? Their father works and their mother is a SAHM. Do you think that all children with a SAHP don't get jobs?

KreedKafer · 25/01/2024 11:26

It's not really your business whether she looks for work - I don't think it's up to anyone else to say what she 'should' do. But she shouldn't be moaning about it to you and she sounds pretty lacking in self-awareness if she doesn't realise how badly she's coming across! So I can see why you're annoyed at her going on about it.

lostincakes · 25/01/2024 11:25

She won't be getting benefits for the youngest child as assuming they are 5 by the age description in first post which means they were born after the 2 child limit. The older 3 who are 16+ will be approaching the cut off age for child benefits in the next few years. So, quite soon they will have 3 children/young adults who they cannot claim for. What will they do then? I suppose they will tell them to claim jobseekers element of UC or whatever young people can get and contribute to the household costs if they stay at home, or are they likely to get jobs considering the examples they have been set?

CrispsnDips · 25/01/2024 11:02

When I had five children under 11 at home I still managed to work weekend evenings and earn some money

RampantIvy · 25/01/2024 11:02

@ElevenSeven having a child is not a human right.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/01/2024 10:59

There is no human right to have a child. Otherwise, us infertile women who aren't eligible for adoption could sue someone for breach of our human rights.

Even setting aside the law, nobody has a right to bring another human being into the world. If you're not able to adequately care for (emotionally, financially, or otherwise) a vulnerable human being then you have no right to produce one.

You have the freedom to have a child and nobody can stop you from doing it even if the child is likely looking forward to 18 years of abuse or neglect, but that isn't the same thing.

Kendodd · 25/01/2024 10:55

And to all the people criticising the husband for doing low paid work. Requiring people to 'get a better, high paid job' this attitude is part of the problem with society. People doing low paid work are almost always doing essential and hard work to keep society running. They deserve respect and recognition for this and to be able to afford a decent standard of living not a life on top up benefits and poverty. As a society we would miss bin men and supermarket shelf stackers a lot more than brain surgeons and astronauts. The point is we need them all though. The solution isn't paying people more benefits, it's to get the 0.01% to stop hoarding all the profits, that their workers make for them, for themselves.

MRSMTO · 25/01/2024 10:54

SaladDays2024 · 25/01/2024 10:05

Even if she worked, most of it will be on childcare as the older children need to study for A levels abd GCSEs.

There is a deep disdain of SAHP even when they don't claim benefits they are looked down for letting feminism down and relying on a man, for not being a good role model ...etc
But it's 100x worse when they are claiming benefits.

I bet none of those posters mind middle class sports injuries costing the NHS or the environmental impact their frequent holidays, home swimming pools and 4x4s cause. It's only when a poorer family wants to exercise their HUMAN RIGHT to have a family and put it first within government rules that posters love to judge.

If you don't like the rules of the system, use your votes or campaign for change.

And the comment on the children ending up just like their parents, that is not necessarily true and if it were true or most likely then isn't the sister a victim, a product of her own circumstances and deserves kindness and support to break the cycle? No, it's more fun to demonise and name call her. 6 kids and lazy? Sure ok.

we all know or have heard of rich spoilt children born to self made parents, if the rich kids success that's mostly down to nepotism. The problem is that this society looks down on family values and the importance of a solid family unit and absolutely worships money.

It's part of the system to demonise SAHP and shame benefits users to coerce them back into
Meanwhile our children are raised by strangers, getting obese, lonely and cyber bullied because both parents are run ragged by a job who will toss you out any minute.

Lastly, dogs issues are absolutely not the same. Dangerous dogs kill and maim. They are bred for tossers who gloat in having a danger dog. I hope the law gets even stricter on dogs and their owners.

Nah, you're looking at this too deeply.

I just don't agree with people having children they can't afford. We're not talking about people whose lives have changed beyond recognition due to circumstances outside of their control, we're talking about a woman who has chosen to have 6 kids who cannot afford to care for them without claiming benefits. That's a lifestyle choice. A responsible adult would not choose to have 6 children if she knew she would have to use tax money to feed & clothe them. It's the very definition of irresponsible.

ElevenSeven · 25/01/2024 10:44

It's only when a poorer family wants to exercise their HUMAN RIGHT to have a family and put it first within government rules that posters love to judge.

It’s everyone’s human right to have a family. It’s not your human right to want taxpayers to fund it so you can not work. If you want to stay home; fine, just don’t expect working people to fund it forever.

cadburyegg · 25/01/2024 10:10

She is being unreasonable. Being a SAHP with school aged children is a luxury, and the state will not fund this.

That being said, I don't believe she is lazy. But maybe a little out of touch which perhaps isn't unusual with being out of the workplace for so long.

kittensinthekitchen · 25/01/2024 10:06

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 08:44

No, some just haven't migrated yet. I'd still be on working tax credits myself but I chose to migrate last year after doing the sums and realising I'd get more on UC. There's not many left now but a few. My colleague still gets tax credits.

Ah thank you for clarifying (and another poster who responded)

Would be nice for the OP to confirm whether the person is question is in receipt of anything like that, but I think this thread is just for creating froth.