Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she should look for work?

259 replies

Daisydoodo · 24/01/2024 23:35

my sister is on the migration from tax credits to universal credit. Her husband works and earns around £25k a year and does not aspire to earn anymore she has 6 children 3 over 16 and 3 5-16years she was complaining today that she may be expected to start looking for work when she migrates and how she thinks it’s unfair as she is only just getting her life back now the 5yo is in full time school. AIBU to tell her to get a grip and get a job? I feel awful for saying it but it’s getting on my nerves as I was expected to return after 6 months mat leave. Should the UC system force her to look for work

OP posts:
chickenriceorspud · 25/01/2024 17:52

People should be turfed out to work when their own children reach school age. If not paid work they should be forced to do community work. There is always someone to contribute to society in exchange for benefits. Makes me mad when i see lazy friggers not working / playing the system when they are more than capable! For some reason it annoys me more when I see herds of them hitting the local Asda for a fry up after the kids are farmed out to school.

. I mean I can see my 12 hour days far enough many days!

Goldbar · 25/01/2024 17:52

lostincakes · 25/01/2024 17:36

Totally agree. I find it odd that MNers who advocate strongly against climate change are also the ones that don't want to discourage large families and don't see the contradiction. More people = bigger carbon footprint and it all adds towards climate change.

Perhaps we need to penalise people who have more than the replacement rate of children rather than pay them more in benefits, as each new person adds so much to the carbon footprint of the planet.

There isn't a problem with people having too many children.

ElevenSeven · 25/01/2024 17:39

BreakingAndBroke · 25/01/2024 16:57

No more responses from the OP. Think this is a DM journalist looking for a few outraged quotes to copy and paste into an article about benefit scroungers.

Doubt it, they don’t have to go looking very hard for these stories, plenty of it about

lostincakes · 25/01/2024 17:36

lookwhatyoudidthere · 25/01/2024 14:46

Im afraid the reality is that services are so overstretched- if everyone had 6 kids - there would be no doctor’s/surgeons appointments. That’s before we even discuss whether morally, with the planet in the state its in, adding 6 more humans is a worthwhile endeavour.

Totally agree. I find it odd that MNers who advocate strongly against climate change are also the ones that don't want to discourage large families and don't see the contradiction. More people = bigger carbon footprint and it all adds towards climate change.

Perhaps we need to penalise people who have more than the replacement rate of children rather than pay them more in benefits, as each new person adds so much to the carbon footprint of the planet.

BreakingAndBroke · 25/01/2024 16:57

No more responses from the OP. Think this is a DM journalist looking for a few outraged quotes to copy and paste into an article about benefit scroungers.

Umidontknow · 25/01/2024 16:50

And it's noone else's fault she chose to have 6 kids, so it shouldn't be up to the government to fund her staying at home now all the children are in full time education. Lots of women would love to be stay at home mums but can't afford too, so they have to work instead. That's life.

lookwhatyoudidthere · 25/01/2024 15:42

Goldbar · 25/01/2024 14:56

But the whole point is that very, very few people are having or want to have 6 children. No need to demonise those who are.

Our family structure (inverse pyramid) is much more common. My PIL and parents have 9 siblings between them. DH and I have 4 siblings between us. Yet there are only three children in the whole extended family and very unlikely to be more.

I’m sure all families are very charming, yours included. The UK is already very densely populated, a family of such a size, depending on an income of 25k is being bank rolled by the tax payer via tax credits or universal credit. I’m not telling anyone to NOT have children, I’m saying whoever has them should expect to pay their way to a greater degree. That’s the job description as far as I can make out, along with a load of other super fun and hard things. Benefits should be for people on really hard times, not career layabouts who don’t wish to earn.

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 15:19

Funny how OP hasn't been back. Almost as if the thread has done what it needs to do. And people fall for it every time.

Shadowsindarkplaces · 25/01/2024 15:05

I'd froth more at companies paying piss poor wages. Taxpayers subsidise Tesco/ Sainsbury/ B&Q/Homebase type companies and all lower waged employers and all the ilk while raking massive profits.
Some people will never have more than NLW earning power, saying get a better job is futile, who would employ them?

Pride doesn't pay bills, hard cash does that.
It's easier to have a go at peoples life choices but it often bites at a later age, when friends are taking early retirement and they will still be working because the safety net is no longer there as DC have left and they have to work.

Goldbar · 25/01/2024 14:56

lookwhatyoudidthere · 25/01/2024 14:46

Im afraid the reality is that services are so overstretched- if everyone had 6 kids - there would be no doctor’s/surgeons appointments. That’s before we even discuss whether morally, with the planet in the state its in, adding 6 more humans is a worthwhile endeavour.

But the whole point is that very, very few people are having or want to have 6 children. No need to demonise those who are.

Our family structure (inverse pyramid) is much more common. My PIL and parents have 9 siblings between them. DH and I have 4 siblings between us. Yet there are only three children in the whole extended family and very unlikely to be more.

AILeaveMeAlone · 25/01/2024 14:51

SaladDays2024 · 25/01/2024 10:05

Even if she worked, most of it will be on childcare as the older children need to study for A levels abd GCSEs.

There is a deep disdain of SAHP even when they don't claim benefits they are looked down for letting feminism down and relying on a man, for not being a good role model ...etc
But it's 100x worse when they are claiming benefits.

I bet none of those posters mind middle class sports injuries costing the NHS or the environmental impact their frequent holidays, home swimming pools and 4x4s cause. It's only when a poorer family wants to exercise their HUMAN RIGHT to have a family and put it first within government rules that posters love to judge.

If you don't like the rules of the system, use your votes or campaign for change.

And the comment on the children ending up just like their parents, that is not necessarily true and if it were true or most likely then isn't the sister a victim, a product of her own circumstances and deserves kindness and support to break the cycle? No, it's more fun to demonise and name call her. 6 kids and lazy? Sure ok.

we all know or have heard of rich spoilt children born to self made parents, if the rich kids success that's mostly down to nepotism. The problem is that this society looks down on family values and the importance of a solid family unit and absolutely worships money.

It's part of the system to demonise SAHP and shame benefits users to coerce them back into
Meanwhile our children are raised by strangers, getting obese, lonely and cyber bullied because both parents are run ragged by a job who will toss you out any minute.

Lastly, dogs issues are absolutely not the same. Dangerous dogs kill and maim. They are bred for tossers who gloat in having a danger dog. I hope the law gets even stricter on dogs and their owners.

‘Meanwhile our children are raised by strangers, getting obese, lonely and cyber bullied because both parents are run ragged by a job who will toss you out any minute.’

I just need to correct you there. I don’t benefits-bash and I support vulnerable people at work. But despite utilising the help of ‘strangers’ to care for my kids as I worked as an NHS doctor, it was me that raised them. Oh, and they are slim and have friends, if you were wondering.

In your support of stay at home mums, you don’t need to cite the usual trope of working parents not raising their own children. There is a place for both working and sahms.

WithACatLikeTread · 25/01/2024 14:47

'Pelt' kids out? What a weird turn of phrase.

lookwhatyoudidthere · 25/01/2024 14:46

Goldbar · 25/01/2024 14:39

In reality, the birthrate is through the floor. The tiny number of women who have large families is not really an issue - many more women only want one child or no children at all. There are ongoing discussions about how people can be encouraged to have more children.

Im afraid the reality is that services are so overstretched- if everyone had 6 kids - there would be no doctor’s/surgeons appointments. That’s before we even discuss whether morally, with the planet in the state its in, adding 6 more humans is a worthwhile endeavour.

CagneyAndLazy · 25/01/2024 14:45

Maray1967 · 25/01/2024 13:37

No it doesn’t, it needs to welcome migrants who can and will work. Why on earth should we be encouraging large families?

It's a load of bollocks anyway.

@SaladDays2024 has zero clue about public finances and the average personal contribution (or lack of) to them.

username268 · 25/01/2024 14:41

I don't see why it is any of your business.

Goldbar · 25/01/2024 14:39

lookwhatyoudidthere · 25/01/2024 14:33

Do you know why your sister chose to have so many children - without funds to adequately support them? I’m genuinely aghast that the state bankrolls such poor decision making. This ‘let the tax payer pay me’ seems to be a prevailing and widespread attitude. Your sister should get a job immediately. Do people who pelt out 6 kids not understand that they are piling more pressure on a system that is quaking under the demands - with not enough high tax payers propping it up. As someone pointed out on a similar thread yesterday, unless you’re earnings are in excess of 55k, you are costing the state more than you are contributing.

In reality, the birthrate is through the floor. The tiny number of women who have large families is not really an issue - many more women only want one child or no children at all. There are ongoing discussions about how people can be encouraged to have more children.

Sunshine322 · 25/01/2024 14:38

Six kids on a 25k salary, how on earth do they manage financially, even with top ups and child benefit. Plus once the kids are all at school full time she’ll be bored stiff.

Goldbar · 25/01/2024 14:36

Change is difficult. So she's probably apprehensive about having to push herself out of her comfort zone. I'd think you'd have a bit more sympathy and give a little more emotional support to your sister.

Also you must know that having 6 children living at home (and the youngest fairly young) must generate a significant amount of unpaid labour.

Do her partner and the older kids pull their weight? Or does he come home and put his feet up because "he's been at work".

If the latter, I can understand her dread at the prospect of potentially having to combine full-time work with all the daily unpaid drudgery for a family of 8. Personally it would send me running for the hills.

lookwhatyoudidthere · 25/01/2024 14:33

Daisydoodo · 24/01/2024 23:35

my sister is on the migration from tax credits to universal credit. Her husband works and earns around £25k a year and does not aspire to earn anymore she has 6 children 3 over 16 and 3 5-16years she was complaining today that she may be expected to start looking for work when she migrates and how she thinks it’s unfair as she is only just getting her life back now the 5yo is in full time school. AIBU to tell her to get a grip and get a job? I feel awful for saying it but it’s getting on my nerves as I was expected to return after 6 months mat leave. Should the UC system force her to look for work

Do you know why your sister chose to have so many children - without funds to adequately support them? I’m genuinely aghast that the state bankrolls such poor decision making. This ‘let the tax payer pay me’ seems to be a prevailing and widespread attitude. Your sister should get a job immediately. Do people who pelt out 6 kids not understand that they are piling more pressure on a system that is quaking under the demands - with not enough high tax payers propping it up. As someone pointed out on a similar thread yesterday, unless you’re earnings are in excess of 55k, you are costing the state more than you are contributing.

Oliotya · 25/01/2024 14:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Yes, because 16 year of support so far hasn't been enough.

JohnMytton · 25/01/2024 14:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Oliotya · 25/01/2024 14:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

That basic support has always been available for those inclined to seek it out. Surely someone choosing not to work, and still bemoaning being expected to even look for work is the very definition of a scrounger? Whether or not there are hordes of them is irrelevant.

Robinbuildsbears · 25/01/2024 14:17

SaladDays2024 · 25/01/2024 10:05

Even if she worked, most of it will be on childcare as the older children need to study for A levels abd GCSEs.

There is a deep disdain of SAHP even when they don't claim benefits they are looked down for letting feminism down and relying on a man, for not being a good role model ...etc
But it's 100x worse when they are claiming benefits.

I bet none of those posters mind middle class sports injuries costing the NHS or the environmental impact their frequent holidays, home swimming pools and 4x4s cause. It's only when a poorer family wants to exercise their HUMAN RIGHT to have a family and put it first within government rules that posters love to judge.

If you don't like the rules of the system, use your votes or campaign for change.

And the comment on the children ending up just like their parents, that is not necessarily true and if it were true or most likely then isn't the sister a victim, a product of her own circumstances and deserves kindness and support to break the cycle? No, it's more fun to demonise and name call her. 6 kids and lazy? Sure ok.

we all know or have heard of rich spoilt children born to self made parents, if the rich kids success that's mostly down to nepotism. The problem is that this society looks down on family values and the importance of a solid family unit and absolutely worships money.

It's part of the system to demonise SAHP and shame benefits users to coerce them back into
Meanwhile our children are raised by strangers, getting obese, lonely and cyber bullied because both parents are run ragged by a job who will toss you out any minute.

Lastly, dogs issues are absolutely not the same. Dangerous dogs kill and maim. They are bred for tossers who gloat in having a danger dog. I hope the law gets even stricter on dogs and their owners.

A perfect response, completely agree with all of this.

JohnMytton · 25/01/2024 14:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Gcsunnyside23 · 25/01/2024 13:56

It's her fault she's 'only getting her life back' as noone forced her to have 6 kids that she can't afford. Thats the reason most done have more than one or two. She needs to get a job like everyone else