Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she should look for work?

259 replies

Daisydoodo · 24/01/2024 23:35

my sister is on the migration from tax credits to universal credit. Her husband works and earns around £25k a year and does not aspire to earn anymore she has 6 children 3 over 16 and 3 5-16years she was complaining today that she may be expected to start looking for work when she migrates and how she thinks it’s unfair as she is only just getting her life back now the 5yo is in full time school. AIBU to tell her to get a grip and get a job? I feel awful for saying it but it’s getting on my nerves as I was expected to return after 6 months mat leave. Should the UC system force her to look for work

OP posts:
greengreengrass25 · 25/01/2024 20:28

But I don't think they are necessarily

I was one when my dc were young

I

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 20:26

greengreengrass25 · 25/01/2024 19:41

Yes because she's receiving benefits and now needs to get a job or stop claiming

Fair enough you can be a SAHP if you don't need to depend on the state

A slightly different scenario

That's not what I said though. Either being a SAHP is lazy, or it isn't, regardless of where the income is from. So if you think she's lazy, you think all SAHPs are lazy too.

Kalevala · 25/01/2024 20:24

AmethystSparkles · 25/01/2024 20:17

Does this mean that almost all of you disagreed with tax credits?

Do you not realise how much easier women’s lives were with tax credits? Why do you all want women’s lives to be hectic and for there to be no effective safety net?

I thank God that my migration letter arrived a couple of weeks before my tax credits ended! And I wish that they still existed for everyone else.

I hope that the people who don’t agree with benefits done become ill or disabled. It could happen to any of you. And there will be no help.

Women who were single parents had to work on TC.

Oliotya · 25/01/2024 20:21

AmethystSparkles · 25/01/2024 20:17

Does this mean that almost all of you disagreed with tax credits?

Do you not realise how much easier women’s lives were with tax credits? Why do you all want women’s lives to be hectic and for there to be no effective safety net?

I thank God that my migration letter arrived a couple of weeks before my tax credits ended! And I wish that they still existed for everyone else.

I hope that the people who don’t agree with benefits done become ill or disabled. It could happen to any of you. And there will be no help.

I doubt anyone has a problem with benefits for truly ill or disabled people. However, having 6 children isn't a disability, is it?

MRSMTO · 25/01/2024 20:20

AmethystSparkles · 25/01/2024 20:17

Does this mean that almost all of you disagreed with tax credits?

Do you not realise how much easier women’s lives were with tax credits? Why do you all want women’s lives to be hectic and for there to be no effective safety net?

I thank God that my migration letter arrived a couple of weeks before my tax credits ended! And I wish that they still existed for everyone else.

I hope that the people who don’t agree with benefits done become ill or disabled. It could happen to any of you. And there will be no help.

You're missing the point. They're not ill or disabled. I'd say 99% of posters here wouldn't begrudge anyone unable to work access to the welfare system, it's what it's for. But I do begrudge people who fund their overactive wombs with benefit payments.

MRSMTO · 25/01/2024 20:17

Caththegreat · 25/01/2024 19:54

Perhaps he can't earn more.mumsnet is so judgemental.

I'm not judgemental about his wages at all. Not one bit. I am massively judgemental about the pair of them and their inability to be responsible about family planning and their sense of entitlement that the benefits system should fund their life choices.

AmethystSparkles · 25/01/2024 20:17

Does this mean that almost all of you disagreed with tax credits?

Do you not realise how much easier women’s lives were with tax credits? Why do you all want women’s lives to be hectic and for there to be no effective safety net?

I thank God that my migration letter arrived a couple of weeks before my tax credits ended! And I wish that they still existed for everyone else.

I hope that the people who don’t agree with benefits done become ill or disabled. It could happen to any of you. And there will be no help.

misssunshine86 · 25/01/2024 20:12

Well yes it is ridiculous, however our mortgage (on our 3 bed just btw) has gone up by 600 quid. I'm pregnant anyway so hey sod it.

daliesque · 25/01/2024 20:02

Her children will end up contributing to society, we need more children for all the expected elderly in care

Well let's hope so, considering all the taxes that future elderly are paying for these kids healthcare, education etc.

I'm one of 5. My mother kept having kids because she didn't want to work. We grew up in a lot of poverty and had generally shit lives. Only my eldest sister and I have actually done something useful with our lives. The rest are all on various benefits with lots of kids. It's looking like a third generation of my family are going to be scrounging off the taxpayer 🤷‍♀️

Cakemum17 · 25/01/2024 19:58

We just changed over, and stopped tax credits instant which I wasn't expecting. I would love to work, I'm not required to as a severally disabled son. But she should be grateful she can go and look for work

Caththegreat · 25/01/2024 19:54

Perhaps he can't earn more.mumsnet is so judgemental.

RoxieB · 25/01/2024 19:46

So I've selected that I don't think you're being unreasonable and I mean that in the sense of your opinion, thoughts and feelings on the situation but I don't think you should confront your sister with it. As a society we constantly make women feel bad for their choices in regards to work, children, home life and the balance of it all. Remember it wasn't that long ago that her partner would have earned enough to keep them so she could stay at home with her children and fulfill that housewife/houseparent role. It was actually expected of the women. Now we are expected to fulfill that full time role as well as work on top. Its a big ask and isn't the way of life which suits everyone.
I have worked full time since I finished my GCSE' barring taking an additional (after maternity) year off after having our daughter. At the time we had pammed I would return to work because I earned more but due to losing our first born I needed to take the time with pur daughter. I have then worked full time since she was almost 2. I have always justified it to myself and others that I wad providing for our family but was judged because I didn't do school runs, missed plays, would sometimes be home after bed time etc. I always told myself I wanted to work and it was ok missing these things because it was for work. At the time I felt mum guilt and looking back I now regret not stepping back from work to be able to spend more time with her. We cant win. In regards to your comment about your 6 month maternity I would ask you to reflect on if you have raised this because you feel the same, that girl missing out in some way and see that your sister isn't. Also it was yours and your families choice for you to go back after 6 months as maternity is permitted to be longer. I appreciate this may have been a decision based on cirumstance but if you really wanted to you could have taken longer and woild always make it work because that's what parents do. I'd advise you to share your experience in a sensitive way to show your sister she's lucky to have had the time she has had and then try to be positive and supportive about her looking for work.

wronginalltherightways · 25/01/2024 19:46

I don't care if she works or not. I just hope the taxpayers aren't having to pick up the bill for this lunacy.

6 children she can't afford and now wants 'her life back' when her imagined life doesn't include supporting her own children like the rest of us.

WithACatLikeTread · 25/01/2024 19:45

LunarLover · 25/01/2024 19:43

No my husband works full time.

Then you shouldn't be pushed too hard. You should be in the light touch group because of his earnings.

WithACatLikeTread · 25/01/2024 19:44

misssunshine86 · 25/01/2024 19:37

Absolutely ridiculous!

I have agonized for 5 years about having a second child due to the cost of living, and our combined income is around 130K.

I would dream of dropping ONE day to go down to 4 but we need me FT for our mortgage and bills as I earn very slightly more.

That said, I would just ignore her comments and leave her to it. She doesn't live in the real world.

I would say it is absolutely ridiculous that you think you can't afford a second child on £130k. 🙄

LunarLover · 25/01/2024 19:43

No my husband works full time.

greengreengrass25 · 25/01/2024 19:41

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 08:27

It's funny how when people get benefits as a SAHP they are "lazy" but the SAHPs not claiming anything are told they are doing the hardest job, their DH should be helping more, etc. The double standards are hilarious to me.

Yes because she's receiving benefits and now needs to get a job or stop claiming

Fair enough you can be a SAHP if you don't need to depend on the state

A slightly different scenario

misssunshine86 · 25/01/2024 19:37

Absolutely ridiculous!

I have agonized for 5 years about having a second child due to the cost of living, and our combined income is around 130K.

I would dream of dropping ONE day to go down to 4 but we need me FT for our mortgage and bills as I earn very slightly more.

That said, I would just ignore her comments and leave her to it. She doesn't live in the real world.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 25/01/2024 19:35

Shes just getting her life back? I cant wait to get mine back but after 35 years of work, I am no where near being able to retire. She needs to work. Sponger.

Babyroobs · 25/01/2024 19:26

LunarLover · 25/01/2024 19:25

As someone who has been registered on UC for the last 5 years since having my 1st child, I am only being expected to look for work now that my youngest is turning 3. Once they are in school you have a commitment to be either making a minimum of £750 pm or working the equivalent in hours which is roughly 20hrs PW (this has recently increased from being a minimum of 16hrs PW).
Essentially she won't have it easy and will be pressured into finding work as she has multiple almost adult children to look after.

Are you a lone parent though as the rules seem to be significantly tougher for lone parents ?

LunarLover · 25/01/2024 19:25

As someone who has been registered on UC for the last 5 years since having my 1st child, I am only being expected to look for work now that my youngest is turning 3. Once they are in school you have a commitment to be either making a minimum of £750 pm or working the equivalent in hours which is roughly 20hrs PW (this has recently increased from being a minimum of 16hrs PW).
Essentially she won't have it easy and will be pressured into finding work as she has multiple almost adult children to look after.

Babyroobs · 25/01/2024 19:24

chickenriceorspud · 25/01/2024 17:52

People should be turfed out to work when their own children reach school age. If not paid work they should be forced to do community work. There is always someone to contribute to society in exchange for benefits. Makes me mad when i see lazy friggers not working / playing the system when they are more than capable! For some reason it annoys me more when I see herds of them hitting the local Asda for a fry up after the kids are farmed out to school.

. I mean I can see my 12 hour days far enough many days!

I know people who in the twenty years I've known them since our kids were at pre-school have honestly never done a days work. I wonder if their partners/ husbands ever tell them to get a job. My dh doesn't even like it that I work one day less than him, can't imagine what he would think if I just said I wasn't going to work ever !

CagneyAndLazy · 25/01/2024 18:33

Goldbar · 25/01/2024 17:52

There isn't a problem with people having too many children.

Just saying that doesn't make it a fact.

Fluorescentgem · 25/01/2024 18:03

She's a lazy urchin. Six kids is ridiculous in this day and age unless you're very wealthy and can support them. 'Get her life back' - what an absolute joke to those of us who work day in and day out.

Oliotya · 25/01/2024 17:56

Goldbar · 25/01/2024 17:52

There isn't a problem with people having too many children.

If a few had less, there'd be more support for everyone else to have a couple. If those who had loads, had less, those who have a coiple would have to worry less about the state of the planet.
You're massively underestiming the carbon footprint and benefits bill of a family of 8.