Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she should look for work?

259 replies

Daisydoodo · 24/01/2024 23:35

my sister is on the migration from tax credits to universal credit. Her husband works and earns around £25k a year and does not aspire to earn anymore she has 6 children 3 over 16 and 3 5-16years she was complaining today that she may be expected to start looking for work when she migrates and how she thinks it’s unfair as she is only just getting her life back now the 5yo is in full time school. AIBU to tell her to get a grip and get a job? I feel awful for saying it but it’s getting on my nerves as I was expected to return after 6 months mat leave. Should the UC system force her to look for work

OP posts:
Winterday1991 · 26/01/2024 07:05

In my experience there is definitely a cohort of women who think working for a living is beneath them, your sister sounds like one of them.

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 07:04

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 07:02

Of course it is. Legality and morality are not the same thing. The whole concept of "entitlement" itself is the problem. Complete lack of personal responsibility, because you're "entitled" to live off everyone else - incredibly selfish, even more so once all 6 kids are at school all day.

Basically though, it's tough shit. It's not your choice no matter how much you don't like it.

Noicant · 26/01/2024 07:04

She’s probably just nervous because she’s been out of work so long.

I don’t get the six kids and stay on UC thing though, if you had 2 you could work towards improving your family circumstances in a 4 person household. 6 kids means you pretty much guarntee that you will never be financially independent and stable. I mean the government can change the rules at anytime and you can find yourself in a bind pretty quickly.

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 07:04

kisstheblarney · 26/01/2024 06:58

@Beezknees it's legal

But it's immoral and greedy, which luckily most on this thread can see!

Imagine if every family carried on like this!

An I'm alright Jack attitude is not helpful.

Anyway, looks like the benefits will stop soon 🤞 and they can start giving instead of taking!

Many things in this life are Immoral and greedy. I think legal tax loopholes are Immoral and greedy, I think landlords are immoral and greedy. It's not my choice though what people do and I don't get to tell them what they can and can't do.

But yes, when they migrate to UC she will have to look for work, so I don't know why everyone is so up in arms. It will happen.

WithACatLikeTread · 26/01/2024 07:02

kisstheblarney · 26/01/2024 06:58

@Beezknees it's legal

But it's immoral and greedy, which luckily most on this thread can see!

Imagine if every family carried on like this!

An I'm alright Jack attitude is not helpful.

Anyway, looks like the benefits will stop soon 🤞 and they can start giving instead of taking!

Superior morals won't feed your family so if you need it and are entitled claim it. We claim it even with both working as we are entitled to it. Why wouldn't you?

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 07:02

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 06:56

It's not "scrounging" to legally claim what you're entitled to, no matter your personal feelings on it.

Of course it is. Legality and morality are not the same thing. The whole concept of "entitlement" itself is the problem. Complete lack of personal responsibility, because you're "entitled" to live off everyone else - incredibly selfish, even more so once all 6 kids are at school all day.

kisstheblarney · 26/01/2024 06:58

@Beezknees it's legal

But it's immoral and greedy, which luckily most on this thread can see!

Imagine if every family carried on like this!

An I'm alright Jack attitude is not helpful.

Anyway, looks like the benefits will stop soon 🤞 and they can start giving instead of taking!

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 06:57

Moreorlessmentallystable · 25/01/2024 21:03

It's more likely for kids from households that were on benefits long term to end up on benefits themselves...you can do a simple Google search for the literature on this.

Their father works, as everyone is conveniently ignoring. Top up benefits are different to a completely unemployed household.

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 06:56

kisstheblarney · 26/01/2024 06:49

Who on this thread said they don't agree with benefits?

It's just the scroungers people don't agree with.

Stop twisting what's been said, it makes for a poor argument.

It's not "scrounging" to legally claim what you're entitled to, no matter your personal feelings on it.

kisstheblarney · 26/01/2024 06:49

AmethystSparkles · 25/01/2024 20:17

Does this mean that almost all of you disagreed with tax credits?

Do you not realise how much easier women’s lives were with tax credits? Why do you all want women’s lives to be hectic and for there to be no effective safety net?

I thank God that my migration letter arrived a couple of weeks before my tax credits ended! And I wish that they still existed for everyone else.

I hope that the people who don’t agree with benefits done become ill or disabled. It could happen to any of you. And there will be no help.

Who on this thread said they don't agree with benefits?

It's just the scroungers people don't agree with.

Stop twisting what's been said, it makes for a poor argument.

kisstheblarney · 26/01/2024 06:30

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 20:42

And actually, as a single parent of one child with a full time job myself, I do not envy any SAHP with 6 children, sounds like my idea of hell. I'd choose my life any day.

But we would assume the DS likes it, no one is forced to have 6 children!

GenevièveSapha · 26/01/2024 04:20

'Pull his finger out...'

Say whaaattt.... you expect him 2pull down 6figures... ???

So rude....

AsIseeit · 25/01/2024 23:47

SaladDays2024 · 25/01/2024 02:13

I dont know how she could work with so many kids at home.
It's not her fault you had to work 6 months after your child birth.

I wish I could choose where my taxes go. I would choose not to spend them on the lifestyle choices of women who don't like the idea of working for a living.
People are entitled to have lots of kids but they shouldn't expect others to pay for their upkeep.

CheerfulYank · 25/01/2024 23:15

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 25/01/2024 09:02

Yes this.

it’s so boring that people completely taking the piss out of the benefit system get supported by ‘but we need people to have kids to look after us when we are old ’

we do not need ANYONE to have 6 kids and especially not to give the example that no one has to actually work or try hard for a
living.

I can’t imagine these kids are ones that would be happy to wipe bums for £11 an hour when benefits are on offer instead.

the birth rate argument is total bullshit tbh. Get a job stop being so bloody lazy.

Hey now, I make over £17 an hour to wipe bums, don’t knock it! 😆

OP, YANBU to feel the way you feel. Of course she should get a job. And just personally, as a former SAHP, I felt I “got my life back” much more when I did get back to work! I truly loved getting to have chats with co-workers, a long lunch break, etc.

I don’t know what you can actually do about it, though. If she’s asking your opinion you could tell her as tactfully as possibly that it’s good for everyone to support themselves as they are able…but I don’t think it would help anything to bring it up and have a fight over it.

Goldbar · 25/01/2024 21:14

Have you suggested to her that it won't be so bad because her husband will naturally step up to do more in the house and share pick-ups, drop-offs and sick days when they are both working?

Daisydoodo · 25/01/2024 21:09

Wow lots of responses! Apologies I have been at work. It just really frustrates me that it’s almost an entitlement that she shouldn’t have to work because tax credits have entitled her to do this for years! I understood when the children were babies but they are in school she could at least try to get a part time job for a few hours a day! Her worry is that she will be expected to work 30 hours minimum (I could only wish to work 30 hours a week I work minimum of 40) and have only 2 children because I can simply not afford to have anymore and we are only just above threshold for receiving any help. The system just seems so broken! I know she is my sister and do support her when I can but I just don’t agree with her stance on this

OP posts:
Moreorlessmentallystable · 25/01/2024 21:03

SaladDays2024 · 25/01/2024 03:32

Her children will end up contributing to society, we need more children for all the expected elderly in care.

It's more likely for kids from households that were on benefits long term to end up on benefits themselves...you can do a simple Google search for the literature on this.

Therealjudgejudy · 25/01/2024 20:50

Yanbu. Having 6 children was a choice. She needs to start taking some responsibility

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 20:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ElevenSeven · 25/01/2024 20:42

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 20:39

No they aren't though. You might not like where the income is coming from, but a SAHP is doing the exact same thing whether it's on benefits or provided for by a partner. In fact, the single SAHP on benefits is doing a far harder and more relentless job as they don't have a partner to help them.

You spelt feckless relentless wrong

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 20:42

And actually, as a single parent of one child with a full time job myself, I do not envy any SAHP with 6 children, sounds like my idea of hell. I'd choose my life any day.

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 20:39

ElevenSeven · 25/01/2024 20:35

No, they’re fundamentally different.

No they aren't though. You might not like where the income is coming from, but a SAHP is doing the exact same thing whether it's on benefits or provided for by a partner. In fact, the single SAHP on benefits is doing a far harder and more relentless job as they don't have a partner to help them.

Babyroobs · 25/01/2024 20:37

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 20:28

Not until their children were 5, and only 16 hours then.

Only 16 hours was required right up until the youngest child left education at 18/ 19 years of age ! Madness. Then again a couple only had to work 24 hours to be topped up by working tax credits !

ElevenSeven · 25/01/2024 20:35

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 20:26

That's not what I said though. Either being a SAHP is lazy, or it isn't, regardless of where the income is from. So if you think she's lazy, you think all SAHPs are lazy too.

No, they’re fundamentally different.

Beezknees · 25/01/2024 20:28

Kalevala · 25/01/2024 20:24

Women who were single parents had to work on TC.

Not until their children were 5, and only 16 hours then.