Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she should look for work?

259 replies

Daisydoodo · 24/01/2024 23:35

my sister is on the migration from tax credits to universal credit. Her husband works and earns around £25k a year and does not aspire to earn anymore she has 6 children 3 over 16 and 3 5-16years she was complaining today that she may be expected to start looking for work when she migrates and how she thinks it’s unfair as she is only just getting her life back now the 5yo is in full time school. AIBU to tell her to get a grip and get a job? I feel awful for saying it but it’s getting on my nerves as I was expected to return after 6 months mat leave. Should the UC system force her to look for work

OP posts:
kisstheblarney · 26/01/2024 13:18

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 07:14

Also, feeding 8 people on £25k plus top up benefits for probably only 2 or 3 kids? That sounds miserable as heck. The envy is just ridiculous. How many people on this thread would actually want that life? It's just another thing to moan about.

Yeah miserable as heck, boring low value food! But that's what they chose for their children, a lifestyle choice of their own making.

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 12:56

LadyBird1973 · 26/01/2024 12:50

We've hopefully moved on from what was normal 100 years ago though.

Yes we have. And thank goodness we have. But it is still irresponsible, and she should still need to get a job.

LadyBird1973 · 26/01/2024 12:50

We've hopefully moved on from what was normal 100 years ago though.

Kalevala · 26/01/2024 12:49

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 12:07

100, 200 years ago a family of 8 on less below average income would have lived in abject poverty. And the mum would have worked in some capacity throughout. People have always been free to have as many children as they want, it's only in very recent history that those children have been provided for by other people. It's not mean to think parents ought not to have more children than they can provide for.

Only 80 years ago my grandmother and siblings had the rugs off the floor on the beds. I don't know about her mother but her eldest brother worked before school in the mornings.

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 12:07

LadyBird1973 · 26/01/2024 11:42

That's fair @OutsideLookingOut
I wasn't really think about material purchases though, just choices over family size and whether one parent should be able to sah to parent. If wealthy parents can make that decision because it's what they want for their family, it seems mean that a family with one ft worker can't also have that choice.

I do think there's a difference between families where one person is working full time but not earning much and families where neither parent is making any effort to financially support their children.

100, 200 years ago a family of 8 on less below average income would have lived in abject poverty. And the mum would have worked in some capacity throughout. People have always been free to have as many children as they want, it's only in very recent history that those children have been provided for by other people. It's not mean to think parents ought not to have more children than they can provide for.

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/01/2024 11:57

@SisterSabotage

What's wrong with being a copywriter or a community lead or a housing worker? Why only servitude on the lowest rung?

Someone with six children who has never worked (or not for many years) is never going to get a job as a community organiser or copywriter. Not in a million years.

I agree that this woman should not be complaining about being encouraged off benefits but you are being absurd if you think she can re-enter the workforce in a graduate level job. A degree of realism is needed.

LadyBird1973 · 26/01/2024 11:42

That's fair @OutsideLookingOut
I wasn't really think about material purchases though, just choices over family size and whether one parent should be able to sah to parent. If wealthy parents can make that decision because it's what they want for their family, it seems mean that a family with one ft worker can't also have that choice.

I do think there's a difference between families where one person is working full time but not earning much and families where neither parent is making any effort to financially support their children.

RampantIvy · 26/01/2024 11:26

Sd1960 · 26/01/2024 11:23

What makes you think £25k isn’t a full time wage? Some posters on here have no idea of the reality of most people’s lives.

I agree. There are loads of mumsnetters who think that earning a 6 figure salary is normal. It isn't for most people.

Sd1960 · 26/01/2024 11:23

What makes you think £25k isn’t a full time wage? Some posters on here have no idea of the reality of most people’s lives.

OutsideLookingOut · 26/01/2024 10:05

LadyBird1973 · 26/01/2024 09:29

You're missing my point there @OutsideLookingOut
Obviously if you don't have lots of money, you end up making different choices that if you did have millions, but being rich or not is largely down to luck for many people. I'm just raising the thought that maybe it's not right to morally condemn someone because their family isn't fortunate enough to be wealthy, if you wouldn't condemn the lucky rich family for the same thing.
This is a family where the husband is working full time - I think the main problem is that wages in this country don't allow a person to support their families and have to be topped up with tax revenue. Really, the husband's employer should have to pay an actual living wage, or housing/utilities costs should be brought down so that normal people can afford them.

Agree with you that wages are low and of course having money may not make one more deserving but I think your conclusion from this is false.

Like with the mansion, if I could get tax payers to buy it for me that would be right because you wouldn't condemn a rich person for buying one?

ElevenSeven · 26/01/2024 09:34

LadyBird1973 · 26/01/2024 09:29

You're missing my point there @OutsideLookingOut
Obviously if you don't have lots of money, you end up making different choices that if you did have millions, but being rich or not is largely down to luck for many people. I'm just raising the thought that maybe it's not right to morally condemn someone because their family isn't fortunate enough to be wealthy, if you wouldn't condemn the lucky rich family for the same thing.
This is a family where the husband is working full time - I think the main problem is that wages in this country don't allow a person to support their families and have to be topped up with tax revenue. Really, the husband's employer should have to pay an actual living wage, or housing/utilities costs should be brought down so that normal people can afford them.

Not many people’s wages stretch to supporting 6 children and a SAHP on a single wage. And nor should they, particularly.

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 09:32

LadyBird1973 · 26/01/2024 09:29

You're missing my point there @OutsideLookingOut
Obviously if you don't have lots of money, you end up making different choices that if you did have millions, but being rich or not is largely down to luck for many people. I'm just raising the thought that maybe it's not right to morally condemn someone because their family isn't fortunate enough to be wealthy, if you wouldn't condemn the lucky rich family for the same thing.
This is a family where the husband is working full time - I think the main problem is that wages in this country don't allow a person to support their families and have to be topped up with tax revenue. Really, the husband's employer should have to pay an actual living wage, or housing/utilities costs should be brought down so that normal people can afford them.

Wage suppression is a real issue, that's true. But it's never been realistic to expect to properly support a family of 8 on one below average wage.

LadyBird1973 · 26/01/2024 09:29

You're missing my point there @OutsideLookingOut
Obviously if you don't have lots of money, you end up making different choices that if you did have millions, but being rich or not is largely down to luck for many people. I'm just raising the thought that maybe it's not right to morally condemn someone because their family isn't fortunate enough to be wealthy, if you wouldn't condemn the lucky rich family for the same thing.
This is a family where the husband is working full time - I think the main problem is that wages in this country don't allow a person to support their families and have to be topped up with tax revenue. Really, the husband's employer should have to pay an actual living wage, or housing/utilities costs should be brought down so that normal people can afford them.

OutsideLookingOut · 26/01/2024 09:21

Kendodd · 26/01/2024 09:06

Except this family isn't workless. They actually have a very traditional, even model, set up with dad going to work and mum staying home to look after the children.

Sadly if you rely on others to support you that support can be taken away. If the man could sup[port his family without benefits they would have the choice to continue that way.

OutsideLookingOut · 26/01/2024 09:20

LadyBird1973 · 26/01/2024 09:01

Ultimately though, shouldn't poor people be able to make the same life choices as rich ones? No one condemns a rich woman for sah and having 6 kids and generally she isn't more deserving than the poor woman. Shes just fortunate if married to a man who earns enough to support them. Wage rates aren't linked to how hard a person works or how deserving they are as people - it's mostly just luck where you end up working and how much you get paid.

lol yes, I'd love to live in a mansion with an indoor heated pool, I don't know why my lack of millions does not allow me to do so!

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 09:13

Kendodd · 26/01/2024 09:06

Except this family isn't workless. They actually have a very traditional, even model, set up with dad going to work and mum staying home to look after the children.

I think it's ridiculous to suggest that everyone should have the same choices irrespective of their means.

Kendodd · 26/01/2024 09:06

Moreorlessmentallystable · 25/01/2024 21:03

It's more likely for kids from households that were on benefits long term to end up on benefits themselves...you can do a simple Google search for the literature on this.

Except this family isn't workless. They actually have a very traditional, even model, set up with dad going to work and mum staying home to look after the children.

Kendodd · 26/01/2024 09:04

LadyBird1973 · 26/01/2024 09:01

Ultimately though, shouldn't poor people be able to make the same life choices as rich ones? No one condemns a rich woman for sah and having 6 kids and generally she isn't more deserving than the poor woman. Shes just fortunate if married to a man who earns enough to support them. Wage rates aren't linked to how hard a person works or how deserving they are as people - it's mostly just luck where you end up working and how much you get paid.

Actually I think there's plenty of judgement around having lots of children regardless of how rich you are.

LadyBird1973 · 26/01/2024 09:01

Ultimately though, shouldn't poor people be able to make the same life choices as rich ones? No one condemns a rich woman for sah and having 6 kids and generally she isn't more deserving than the poor woman. Shes just fortunate if married to a man who earns enough to support them. Wage rates aren't linked to how hard a person works or how deserving they are as people - it's mostly just luck where you end up working and how much you get paid.

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 07:50

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 07:42

Nah, there's definitely envy there. Look at the amount of posters saying they would like to not work so much.

Envy of the ability to stay at home perhaps. Not of the 6 kids on benefits part.

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 07:42

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 07:20

You're confusing envy with judgement.

Nah, there's definitely envy there. Look at the amount of posters saying they would like to not work so much.

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 07:20

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 07:14

Also, feeding 8 people on £25k plus top up benefits for probably only 2 or 3 kids? That sounds miserable as heck. The envy is just ridiculous. How many people on this thread would actually want that life? It's just another thing to moan about.

You're confusing envy with judgement.

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 07:14

Also, feeding 8 people on £25k plus top up benefits for probably only 2 or 3 kids? That sounds miserable as heck. The envy is just ridiculous. How many people on this thread would actually want that life? It's just another thing to moan about.

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 07:12

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 07:10

Well yeah, but this is mumsnet, not the house of commons. Exchanging opinions is kind of how it works.

Yeah, I'm not sure why people are so pissed off though as she will be having to look for work soon, so problem solved. And she won't be getting anything for the younger kids anyway as they were born after the 2 child benefit cap! So she's not claiming for 6 kids.

Oliotya · 26/01/2024 07:10

Beezknees · 26/01/2024 07:04

Basically though, it's tough shit. It's not your choice no matter how much you don't like it.

Well yeah, but this is mumsnet, not the house of commons. Exchanging opinions is kind of how it works.