Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will your job exist in the next 10/20 years?

81 replies

LittleRedintheHood · 24/01/2024 23:06

I work in allied medical sector, so my job will exist but with the caveat that AI can increasingly do a lot of diagnosis via scans and decision making from this.

AIBU to ask if you think your job/sector of work will survive in a similar role to now?

Would you recommend a young person to start a career in your sector?

In my job I would say you need to up-skill clinically in extra qualifications and embrace the technology before others to stay ahead of the inevitable changes already coming with AI in the medical field.

OP posts:
babybythesea · 25/01/2024 05:10

TA here.
Will the need be there for TAs? Yup.
To sit in the playground with an anxious child and talk them into school.
To tie shoe laces and cut food and put on plasters.
To help a child say a sentence then write it down.
To say ‘you might find that book scary but I think you’ll love this one.’
To negotiate a myriad of friendship issues in the role of peace negotiator!

Will my job still be here?
Nothing to do with AI and everything to do with the government!
There would be elements that could be done by AI but most of it requires human contact.

NorthernLights5 · 25/01/2024 04:50

Well what if you were well paid and respected as professionals but because you only worked for those who could afford it, while everyone else got the machines..?
I don't understand the point of your post. Machines would never be funded for a start and neither will carers be paid to reflect their work because the majority of people generally but mostly in power don't care about elderly or disabled people.

LightSwerve · 25/01/2024 03:20

I don't think AI will rapidly replace whole jobs in the immediate future, but instead will replace a part of the work, so e.g. a company will only need two people in future to do the work of three currently as the more routine aspects of work can be outsourced to bots. Will this make work more satisfying or more stressful for remaining human employees?

Another big question is will we tax the robots?

HP79 · 25/01/2024 03:07

charabang · 24/01/2024 23:37

I work in HE admin and there's no doubt that I am replaceable. Although the future of HE in it's current form is decidedly uncertain anyway. I've got to last another 11 years before retirement.

Snap! I probably have 15 more years to suffer through before being able to retire, though.

I could easily see my desk job being replaced by AI at some point, but I don’t think the university I work for will be able to fund or organise the software required in the next ten years. Maybe twenty years, though.

nachosandnachis · 25/01/2024 02:48

NorthernLights5 · 25/01/2024 02:43

My job will always exist (carer). I can't imagine people will want to be cared for by machines or whatever even if that technology existed.

Would I advise people to go into it? Nope! I love my job but we are overworked, underpaid and completely disrepected by other professionals and the general public who don't realise what our job is.

Well what if you were well paid and respected as professionals but because you only worked for those who could afford it, while everyone else got the machines..?

NorthernLights5 · 25/01/2024 02:43

My job will always exist (carer). I can't imagine people will want to be cared for by machines or whatever even if that technology existed.

Would I advise people to go into it? Nope! I love my job but we are overworked, underpaid and completely disrepected by other professionals and the general public who don't realise what our job is.

caringcarer · 25/01/2024 01:38

I'm pretty sure Foster Carers will be needed in 10-20 years time. Sadly there are more DC needing a good home to live in safely than there are carers to provide one.

nachosandnachis · 25/01/2024 01:33

LittleRedintheHood · 25/01/2024 00:33

It's very interesting that AI seems to least threaten the creators.
So there's some justification to the Computer Science degree popularity as to future proofing a career.
The white collar jobs that involve routine work threatened seem to be the accountants, insurance? legal?

It may surprise you to know that CompSci graduates have one of the highest unemployment rates. More so now that the media has pushed 'coding coding coding' as a route to getting a cushy, well-paid job leading to a flood of graduates.

There are various reasons but no two 'Computer Science' degrees are the same, not all are rigorous. I've interviewed so many graduates who not only couldn't program but couldn't reason logically when given something unexpected.
Below review might be of interest:
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a8189a5e5274a2e8ab54853/ind-16-5-shadbolt-review-computer-science-graduate-employability.pdf

The reality is that we do a lot of talking to people and research in addition to just writing code at higher levels. We have to deal with complexity, both human and technical. We also have to constantly learn new things, have a lot of patience to deal with problems. 'Writing code' is really the easiest part of the job and I'm quite happy for AI to go ahead and do that! It can never replace the need for people who can manage process, communicate and build relationships.

FYI the majority of devs aren't working on 'AI' (actually you probably need a specialised Master's or PhD to develop the algorithms) just boring old CRUD apps that are the same thing.

JustFrustrated · 25/01/2024 01:30

Meadowfinch · 25/01/2024 01:19

Yes, it will still exist. Producing and managing marketing events. We've already rejected Chat GPT and the like for producing content, which is easy to spot and dull as dust.

I've yet to meet the computer that can physically put a trade stand together, mend a lighting array, assemble a good presentation, talk the speaker out of stage fright and retrieve a DHL shipment that's gone to Rotterdam rather than Rotherham.

This with bells on.

You can spot an AI written post on LI from a thousand yards if you've half a brain for example. Key things are missed, it reads perfectly perhaps, and the content may even be there... but it's too perfect, it misses humanity and humans are exceptionally good at spotting that without realising. And in my experience, they don't like it.

JustFrustrated · 25/01/2024 01:28

Definitely. I'm in sales, business development specifically.

AI can't replace human interaction. It can't build relationships, it can't get in a car and drove 115 miles to go soothe troubles, it can't listen and understand the human emotion behind conversation.

Until we have sentient AI and humans that don't require humans, my role is safe.

In my industry, the only people that aren't safe are the machine feeders. Even the technicians further down the line are safe, until physical technology catches back up with AI.

Meadowfinch · 25/01/2024 01:19

Yes, it will still exist. Producing and managing marketing events. We've already rejected Chat GPT and the like for producing content, which is easy to spot and dull as dust.

I've yet to meet the computer that can physically put a trade stand together, mend a lighting array, assemble a good presentation, talk the speaker out of stage fright and retrieve a DHL shipment that's gone to Rotterdam rather than Rotherham.

MonkeyPuddle · 25/01/2024 01:08

Nah, community nurse, mainly palliative care in the home. Unless the AI can deliver hands on nursing I think I’m safe.

catscalledbeanz · 25/01/2024 01:03

FruitcakeandCheeses · 25/01/2024 00:49

Mine is already on the wain and that is librarianship. People can find out information for themselves now easily compared to when I qualified in the very early 1990’s. Crockfords Clerical Directory anyone? No didn’t think so, you just Google the Church these days. Plus actual book borrowing has decreased with online activity, kindles.

I disagree! In the same ilk as therapy (whereby the advice isn't the goal- a large part of it is human contact)librarianship is for me firmly human alone. A love of firstly reading, of which follows a love of proper research is one that only humans can inspire. Librarians in the main. The AI alternative does not deliver the same, not even a shadow, of the former service.

FartingAgainstThunder · 25/01/2024 01:01

Hopefully opticians will still be in demand.

catscalledbeanz · 25/01/2024 01:00

I'm training for law. Which I think will increasingly be ai in the early stages. Which makes me worry that whilst ai takes over the earlier easier stuff- how will the experts become experts? See also teaching. Or office work- particularly billing and call centre stuff. Hr. Accounting. The early easy stuff can easily be appointed to ai. Whilst the experts deal with the complicated stuff- but then the long view leads to lack of experts.

FruitcakeandCheeses · 25/01/2024 00:49

Mine is already on the wain and that is librarianship. People can find out information for themselves now easily compared to when I qualified in the very early 1990’s. Crockfords Clerical Directory anyone? No didn’t think so, you just Google the Church these days. Plus actual book borrowing has decreased with online activity, kindles.

Diamondshmiamond · 25/01/2024 00:45

Therapist here. There are computerised programmes for manualised therapy, but imo people want to talk to another person, even if that's online or written. I don't think AI could 'bear witness' in the same way, even if it could mimic a human conversation. Hopefully, anyway!

TrixieFatell · 25/01/2024 00:43

I'm a midwife so can see my role still being around in years to come. Whilst we do use technology, it's still our midwifery skills that we use the most and I can't see how AI could replace these.

ErrolTheDragon · 25/01/2024 00:34

Charliecatpaws · 25/01/2024 00:32

Could AI investigate fraud?

Some types, I'd have thought - if it has the relevant data it might be trained to detect dodgy pattens.

LittleRedintheHood · 25/01/2024 00:33

It's very interesting that AI seems to least threaten the creators.
So there's some justification to the Computer Science degree popularity as to future proofing a career.
The white collar jobs that involve routine work threatened seem to be the accountants, insurance? legal?

OP posts:
Charliecatpaws · 25/01/2024 00:32

Could AI investigate fraud?

ErrolTheDragon · 25/01/2024 00:28

Yes. (Well, not mine, I'll be retired!). I write scientific software. When I was at school and we were discussing what we'd do when we grew up, I said I'd do a job that hadn't been invented yet ... I was about right, I was among the first in my area doing this outside of academia, in the mid 80s.

We use machine learning methods now, as well as other more conventional code but on faster machines so we can tackle problems that used to be intractable. The 'AI' is nowhere near knowing what questions to ask; the need for human intelligence in this area is increasing.

mrswinter69 · 24/01/2024 23:53

I'm a prison officer of 30 years. If AI can do my job it can put me out to grass and crack on! 🤔😂

DontGoGran · 24/01/2024 23:51

No way a mental health nurse is being replaced by AI, I don't think!

nachosandnachis · 24/01/2024 23:47

Oh definitely! I'm a software/infra engineer and AI can write code much quicker. It's wrong a lot now, but might not be anymore.
There will be 'less' jobs, not more, but to me the essence of my job is decision making and design. I have good people skills so not really worried about the future.