Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Higher earner should pay more of the bills?

117 replies

TTM123 · 24/01/2024 22:47

What are peoples opinion on this? If your partner earned more than you, would you expect them to pay more towards the bills?

OP posts:
Heatherbell1978 · 25/01/2024 08:01

We put both our salaries into the same joint account. All bills, mortgage etc are paid from this account. What is left is split between savings and our individual 'spending money'. Which is equal. I really don't understand these complex arrangements where something pays 61% of this and 42% of that. Just pool your money.

JustMarriedBecca · 25/01/2024 07:55

Pre kids whilst living together in our earlier 20s, we split 50:50.
Post kids, I went PT for a few years. All money was paid into the same pot. It still is "family money" although I'm now back to being the higher earner.

MarnieMarnie · 25/01/2024 07:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

AlwaysFreezing · 25/01/2024 07:46

This reads like a journo trying to get story fodder.

Badgerandfox227 · 25/01/2024 07:43

Yes, we do all money in joint account, joint savings and then each have our own ‘spend pot’ and had this since we bought our first house in our early twenties. Back then DH earned more than me, now I earn 3 x his wage and we still do the same. We’re a family, I can’t imagine being in a committed relationship without equality, especially now we have kids.

CormorantStrikesBack · 25/01/2024 07:43

You have to find something which works for you but I do agree that the overall thing of the person who earns more should pay more. Otherwise you have one person who is skint and one person with lots of disposable income left.

In the past dh earned more and paid all the bills, direct debit type bills. I paid for food shopping and clothes for dd. I worked pt because of dd so it wasn't my fault I earned less.

We now earn the same and have carried on with the same arrangement but our direct debits are only £700 a month I spend probably around 400 a month a food. I also tend to be the person who buys stuff for the house, new front door, new carpets, etc. So it evens out.

We've always kept separate accounts and a joint bills account. But I guess if the relationship is newer, or there aren't kids, not married then maybe the higher earner would feel the low earner isn't their responsibility???? But would they be happier with a lower standard of living if that's all the lower earner can afford?

DeedlessIndeed · 25/01/2024 07:39

First moved in together - split everything 50/50.

Living together, before kids - work out how much a typical month costs and split it according to take home pay (33/66) etc. Separate "main" accounts and separate savings.

Once married or after children - everything in a pot - each take out equal "fun money" - everything else is family money for bills, children's expenses, holidays and savings.

Sususudio · 25/01/2024 07:39

Dh earns way more than me. We have a joint pot which pays for everything, and we have equal spending money. We consult on large purchases. We are both pretty frugal, so don't buy much and only spend on holidays. We don;t argue about money, usually.

I would never consent to having a lower standard of living than him.

SecondUsername4me · 25/01/2024 07:39

Imo, in an ideal world a newly moving in together couple should have living costs that the lower earner can comfortably afford to pay half of, and that should be how it starts. Both working full time.

Once kids/marriage is on the table, the joint account with identical "fun money" is the best approach. It covers the woman taking mat leave off, covers for if either partner reduces their hours to mind children, and sees all money as everyone's.

Trulyme · 25/01/2024 07:38

As PPs have said it also depends on why one person is a low earner.

One OP was working FT and paying the bills whilst her bf worked a handful of hours a week and didn’t contribute, simply because he couldn’t be bothered (no kids or disabilities).

Allfur · 25/01/2024 07:37

You should both have the same disposable income if you're raising a family together

Trulyme · 25/01/2024 07:36

I think each person should have their own account and money and then a joint account.

In the joint account each person should put a percentage of their wage in E.g both put 50% or 80% of their wages into it depending on costs.
And then all shared costs like bills, food shopping, childcare etc all come out from the shared pot.

The lower earner will be contributing less but they’ll also have less in their personal account, so it’s fair.

LuciferRising · 25/01/2024 07:34

I'm the higher earner. We don't have a pot. We split bills and I tend to pay for food and holidays.

midgetastic · 25/01/2024 07:33

Provided one party hasn't deliberately and without agreement deprived themselves

Then "same spare cash" or "proportionate to earnings " are both reasonable

SD1978 · 25/01/2024 07:27

I fyoure not sharing all finances equally i to a joint account then i do beleive it should be proportional, unless one party is choosing to work less and expecting financial benefits from that and assuming the other partner will pay a higher contribution. So all being equal, bills split proportional to income

Alainlechat · 25/01/2024 07:24

I'm the only earner. All wages into the joint account.

I can't see how relationships can be fair if one partner has significantly more disposable income?

Toooldtoworry · 25/01/2024 07:21

We're married. Mid 40s. We both have children from previous relationships that are not yet adult.

DH has previously been in a DMP and burns through money.

We did have one joint account for bills and a sole one each for spending but when he got made redundant I switched to earnings and bills from my sole. That way I can make sure I save more. He's since found a job but it's a 50% decrease so we're keeping it that way.

Sofabum · 25/01/2024 07:10

In our house the pot pays for the bills. We put money in the same pot and then the bill is paid. We've never split it by % and as my dh doesn't bother with shopping for anything then I, as the lower earner, probably spend a lot more of the pot but we just don't see it has separate and he would never quiz me on how I spent it. We do consult on large purchases.

bluebeach · 25/01/2024 07:07

In our family I earn 4 times as much as my partner. I pay all the mortgage and house bills and house maintenance/furniture etc. I also pay for holidays and meals out. His income is used for food and petrol and he is able to save some too. He does more childcare and household chores than me. We are both happy with this.

Stubbedtoes · 25/01/2024 07:03

We do the account each and a joint account for bills. Husband earns more than me so puts more in. We're both left with same amount of personal spends.

The reason my salary is lower is because I took lower paid jobs to work around the kids when they were younger that don't really translate to career progression - childminding, working shifts etc. Husband obviously benefited from this as I did all school runs, school holidays etc so he could crack on and progress his career.

Now mine are older I'm trying to get on a bit in my career to maximise my earnings but it takes time.

I would be unimpressed if my husband expected me to have a lower standard of living than him. Luckily he doesn't!

heartofglass23 · 25/01/2024 06:53

When women earn more they pay more when men earn more they don't.

Straightomyhead · 25/01/2024 06:49

We put in a percentage of our earnings into our joint account. So currently my partner earns more so I think it's around 36% that I put in and he puts in 64%. This seems the fairest way and neither of us feel hard done by.

(He's seems the opposite to some men on here though and at a recent pay rise was excited to see the change!)

hellsBells246 · 25/01/2024 06:45

Spudina · 24/01/2024 23:00

My husband earns more than twice than me. We both put 50% of our wage into the joint account for bills. Percentage seems fair to me.

Why? He has twice as much money just for him than you do.

GreenWalls22 · 24/01/2024 23:26

Seems I'm in the minority, but just to give a different perspective.

We have separate finances. Married with 2 kids. Both employed full time and both juggle the usual childcare and household responsibilities.

Our salaries go into our own personal bank accounts. We then transfer a set amount each month into a joint account to cover joint bills like mortgage, utilities, kids clubs, groceries etc.

Everything else is individual money. So our own clothes, shoes, cars, phone, Indurance, gym & golf membership etc.

I earn more that DH. It I'm also a saver, so we now have a very decent savings pot for rainy day / emergencies. Plus we use my savings for big purchases like replacement freezer, new oven, most holidays etc. So really 'my' savings are family money.

Works for us.

If we only had joint accounts I think it'd burn a hole in my DH pocket! He's not good with money.

2chocolateoranges · 24/01/2024 23:14

We are a one pot family.

ever since we got engaged money all goes into the family pot , so to speak.

until recently dh has always been the higher earner, he paid all bills and my wages were for holidays, treats, general day to day spending.

even although we roughly earn the same, it still works the same way. It’s worked well for us for the last 25 years.