Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Higher earner should pay more of the bills?

117 replies

TTM123 · 24/01/2024 22:47

What are peoples opinion on this? If your partner earned more than you, would you expect them to pay more towards the bills?

OP posts:
paintingvenice · 25/01/2024 10:27

I am single and find that not only do I earn more than most men I come across, but also because of my age many men of a comparable age already have kids and are paying maintenance.

By the logic on this thread if any of these relationships were to get serious I should start subsidising these men. I then start to question is it me they like or the lifestyle. Shack up with Paintingvenice and my living expenses don’t get slashed in half they get cut by 70 or 80 percent.

having been taken for a ride by a cocklodger once before, I have always struggled to trust since. The prevailing thinking and assumptions on this thread don’t help.

Sususudio · 25/01/2024 10:16

Mnetcurious · 25/01/2024 10:05

Personally I think if you’re in a long term relationship you need to have similar views on money (how to spend/save) and put all money in a family pot. If people aren’t willing to share then I’d question their commitment to the relationship. However where this doesn’t happen then yes bills/expenses should be split according to earnings. Like tax, those who have more, contribute more. They’ll still have more spare money than the other person too!

I agree with that. Both ways can work, but both partners have to agree. The reason I don;t earn as much as my Dh is childcare, but also because I moved around for his high earning job. Therefore, would not agree to anything less than joint myself.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/01/2024 10:15

I earn more than DH, we have separate finances and pay 50% of joint bills such as the mortgage and nursery fees.

DH works FT just like me so he hasn't sacrificed any earnings for childcare reasons etc he simply doesn't want as much responsibility as I have which is absolutely fine but that also means that he has less money left over than me for 'fun' spending. I'm not funding that and thankfully, he'd never expect me to.

I do think it is different if someone has sacrificed their earning potential such as going part time to take on childcare responsibilities. In that case, I do believe the higher earner should pay more towards the bills.

Mnetcurious · 25/01/2024 10:05

Personally I think if you’re in a long term relationship you need to have similar views on money (how to spend/save) and put all money in a family pot. If people aren’t willing to share then I’d question their commitment to the relationship. However where this doesn’t happen then yes bills/expenses should be split according to earnings. Like tax, those who have more, contribute more. They’ll still have more spare money than the other person too!

easilydistracted1 · 25/01/2024 09:52

I contribute more to the joint bills than my wife but I'm not sure it's proportionate as I'm completing a further expensive qualification. We're in the same field at different levels. With ex partners who were much lower earnings I did put in a bit more but not loads more. I paid for most of the home improvements and treats on top and had brought most of the equity into the house. The difference was that these (male) ex partners had made a lifestyle choice to do lower level work as it was easier and less stressful. But they still expected me to work long hours in a stressful role even when burning out as we couldn't manage on two low incomes. In this situation I wasn't subsiding their lifestyle choice and they didn't contribute any more or even sometimes as much as me to home chores. It really depends on circumstances and reasons and what's done with any money spare. If it's circumstances rather than choice and you are doing more at home I would say it should be completely proportional

Badburyrings · 25/01/2024 09:45

Wemetatascoutcamp · 25/01/2024 08:44

Thats too vague a question to answer fairly imho. Mumsnet is the land of people who think all money is ours, should be paid into a joint account and shared equally except when the woman earns more than the man then he’s a c**klodger 😂😂

DH and I don’t have a joint account, haven’t sat down and worked out an exact % split of bills by income etc but everything gets paid and neither one of us feels any resentment towards the other re money.

For any relationship to work you need shared values, open communication and a degree of compromise- this applies to everything including finances.

Exactly this. This is what we do. At one time it was something like 64% his salary and 36% of my salary into joint account. I earn more now though and contribute a lot more. I prefer to have my own money as well as the joint account (all house/car/food/bills etc are paid from this) so when I decide to spend money on "stuff" I want no-one can comment about my spending.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 25/01/2024 09:38

I think it depends on loads of factors . For example my DH earns more than me. But he then pays out child maintenance and I get in child maintenance. So we actually split everything 50/50 and I have more left over!

( I actually overpay on the mortgage in addition but I own more of the house so that’s really a bit separate from day to day living)

I would never ask him for money though and he’d probably never ask me either! We use a joint account for bills but neither of us do any other spending from it. We take turns to food shop.

JadziaD · 25/01/2024 09:35

Broadly yes. But there are a lot of variables that would impact exactly how this looks.

I have always earned more than DH.

eg, when DH and I were dating but not living together - I paid a bit more, but not as much or as often.
when we first moved in together, we paid proportionally. So I paid more of the bills but also had more left over every month.
When we got married and bought a house we had a joint account for everything and then separate "allowances" for extra spending. We used the joint for things like clothes, skincare etc, but would usually discuss larger purchases.
Ditto when DH became a SAHD for a while, but by then obviously we had less cash so overall spending came down and we stopped with the personal allowances.
Now DH is working again, all one account. But our income hasn't gone up significantly so we are both careful.

TeeBee · 25/01/2024 09:13

I think it really depends on the relationship/set-up. If you're not married, my feeling is that neither has chosen to have financial responsibility for the other so proportions should be open for discussion since one person would be relying on the goodwill of the other to sub their lifestyle. If the person earning more pushed for a better/more expensive house, they should probably offer more money to the pot. Married with kids, different ballgame...both adults should have equal access to money.

brunettemic · 25/01/2024 09:03

So I’m the higher earner in our house, by a fair distance. We pay the same into a household account that the mortgage, bills, food shop blah blah come out of but I pay for holidays, both cars and most family things. We found it works better that way for us but each to their own.

olderbutwiser · 25/01/2024 09:01

Definitely there are children - children drive lifestyle and you are both their parents so all in one pot
Ideally if you are married, as it reflects the legal realities
Probably if you are living together with no children and have been for a while in a permanent relationship

Its a tricky one to negotiate before moving in together but needs to be done.

myfavouritecolourisnotpink · 25/01/2024 09:00

I know I'm really old fashioned but I get really confused about this... Surely once you get married all money is 'ours' and not 'yours' and 'mine' ??

We have several accounts which we both have access to, I manage the money as I'm the better one with organising online accounts, bills etc... If either of us want something we just buy it, if it's a large purchase we discuss it... (Obviously within our affordability)

Surely if you are a SaHP then surely the other parent covers all the outgoings 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

I think if you keep separate finances then you aren't 'thinking forever'

Just me... don't shoot me down ❤️

DontBeAPrickDarren · 25/01/2024 09:00

Child benefit goes into my account. He retains the equivalent of child benefit from his salary. Everything else goes into the shared pot. Big personal spends come from personal pot. I’m the main earner.

Tempnamechng · 25/01/2024 08:58

Married - shared finances. Unmarried cohabiting with children - shared finances. Unmarried cohabiting - 50/50, although higher earner needs to accept a more economical lifestyle.

ToDamp0rNotToDamp · 25/01/2024 08:58

Sususudio · 25/01/2024 08:13

@ToDamp0rNotToDamp very intrigued by your crisp spending!😂Are they posh crisps?

@Sususudio absolutely not posh crisps, the cheaper the better! Walkers salt and vinegar are my number one (well actually walkers Worcester sauce are #1 but impossible to find in shops nowadays). Pickled onion monster munch is another elite choice. Then pickled onion space invaders and nice n spicy nik naks. Own brand onion ring crisps from supermarkets are also very good but very harsh on the tummy.
If left to my own devices I’d have 20 packets a day - my husband doesn’t need to know that.

KT8282 · 25/01/2024 08:54

My gross salary is 2.5x DH’s. Until we had kids, we split household expenses on a % basis according to take home salary (my idea) less any additional private pension payments (adding private pensions accounted for big differences in our workplace pension schemes). Once we had kids, we just started pooling money.

hanschristmassolo · 25/01/2024 08:48

It's a very personal thing what you are prepared to accept within a marriage that causes the least amount of resentment etc - I was the much higher earner by 3x - I insisted ex DH pay half the mortgage and other house related bills since he'd be entitled to half in a divorce. I paid the whopping childcare bills (twins) and holidays and DIY

He could have earnt more but chose not to. I worked my ass off in my career and work hard in a challenging job. He had zero ambitions and low work ethic. And quite frankly didn't work as hard

I wasn't prepared to top up his spending by taking on a greater proportion of bills.

Wemetatascoutcamp · 25/01/2024 08:44

Thats too vague a question to answer fairly imho. Mumsnet is the land of people who think all money is ours, should be paid into a joint account and shared equally except when the woman earns more than the man then he’s a c**klodger 😂😂

DH and I don’t have a joint account, haven’t sat down and worked out an exact % split of bills by income etc but everything gets paid and neither one of us feels any resentment towards the other re money.

For any relationship to work you need shared values, open communication and a degree of compromise- this applies to everything including finances.

Tiredalwaystired · 25/01/2024 08:42

We have a Joint account and put the same percentage each of our wages in it to cover bills. As my husband earns more he pays more in cash terms. What’s left is our own. In fact, my husband was generously paying 15% more than me when I didn’t earn a lot but I’ve evened it up again recently as things were getting tight and I have less play money now than I used to.

Clearinguptheclutter · 25/01/2024 08:13

minipie · 24/01/2024 22:58

If you’re married I would expect all money to go into one pot and all bills to be paid out of that pot, with equal “fun money” for each of you and the rest (if there is any) saved.

This. We both put 50% of our salaries into the “bills pot” and 20% into a “savings pot”. He earns more so pays more.

Sususudio · 25/01/2024 08:13

@ToDamp0rNotToDamp very intrigued by your crisp spending!😂Are they posh crisps?

HalloumiGeller · 25/01/2024 08:09

I earn more than my partner does, so we split our main bills 50/50 (mortgage, council tax etc) but I pay for food and other treats. He pays for bits too obv, but I do pay more which I think is fair when you live together, especially if you have children.

But then again, it's also fair to split 50/50 equally if you're both adults and childfree (as in one parent isn't restricted to how much they can work).

ToDamp0rNotToDamp · 25/01/2024 08:07

I’m the high earner, I’m also ‘in charge’ of sorting all our finances as I’m much more financially responsible.

Bills are split such that we both have exactly the same amount of money left at the end of the month for ‘fun’ things. That’s also after contributing to a joint account so we have a pool of money for variable costs - grocery bills, items needed for our child, petrol etc. We also have exactly the same amount in savings (though not in pensions).

If one of us individually has a very expensive month, we ask the other for help if needed. More often than not, I may need to give my husband a couple of hundred, or pick up some of his expenses. This doesn’t bother me in the slightest because he does more care for our child - my job is intense and hours can be unforgiving. When we had our baby he took a pay cut to go into a lower paid, but MUCH more stable and 9-5 job, allowing him to cover all pick ups and drop offs if needed.

Neither of us are fussed about pooling all money and having it in one shared account - I don’t necessarily want my husband to see how much money I spend on crisps. I assume he also doesn’t want me to see how much money he spends on coffee.

HalloumiGeller · 25/01/2024 08:07

GreenWalls22 · 24/01/2024 23:26

Seems I'm in the minority, but just to give a different perspective.

We have separate finances. Married with 2 kids. Both employed full time and both juggle the usual childcare and household responsibilities.

Our salaries go into our own personal bank accounts. We then transfer a set amount each month into a joint account to cover joint bills like mortgage, utilities, kids clubs, groceries etc.

Everything else is individual money. So our own clothes, shoes, cars, phone, Indurance, gym & golf membership etc.

I earn more that DH. It I'm also a saver, so we now have a very decent savings pot for rainy day / emergencies. Plus we use my savings for big purchases like replacement freezer, new oven, most holidays etc. So really 'my' savings are family money.

Works for us.

If we only had joint accounts I think it'd burn a hole in my DH pocket! He's not good with money.

We do this too, I honestly hate the idea of pooling our salaries into one account, it's so old fashioned in my opinion!

Cincinnatus · 25/01/2024 08:06

I don’t have an opinion on what other people should do with their finances but our incomes go into the joint account. The stuff we pay for come out of the same pot. We live together and are married with children.