Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Higher earner should pay more of the bills?

117 replies

TTM123 · 24/01/2024 22:47

What are peoples opinion on this? If your partner earned more than you, would you expect them to pay more towards the bills?

OP posts:
hellsBells246 · 25/01/2024 11:54

redheadsaregreat · 25/01/2024 11:34

@hellsBells246
My husband earns more than twice than me. We both put 50% of our wage into the joint account for bills. Percentage seems fair to me.

Why? He has twice as much money just for him than you do.

Because the dh already puts more into the joint account. Get put in 50% of what they earn. He earns more do his 50% is twice as much as her 50%

Isn't that enough sharing?

As long as both are equally responsible for domestic stuff then I don't think it's unfair

You're totally right. I misread that as they paid 50% of bills equally. Sorry!

BarrelOfOtters · 25/01/2024 11:48

Yes. My DH does. He also pays out more to his grown up children (help with rent etc) and they will inherit more of the house as he paid the deposit.

Definitelynotem · 25/01/2024 11:46

I am the high earner in my marriage. I pay a bit more to bills but not proportional. My DH has a career he could progress in but chooses not to as he doesn’t want extra responsibility and likes to clock in and clock off. Absolutely fine with me and I wouldn’t force him into a huge mortgage anything, but I’m also not giving up my hard earned money which requires me to have a lot of responsibility! He has plenty of spending money left for him (£400 after bills, food and petrol), if he didn’t I would contribute more. I do pay for our holidays, pay all mortgage overpayments and savings on my own and will pay for big purchases like furniture, so I guess I contribute in other ways. I like this to be my choice though!

edit to say that we don’t have and don’t want DC. If we did and he was doing childcare then I would definitely make things more equal!

redheadsaregreat · 25/01/2024 11:36

Stubbedtoes · 25/01/2024 07:03

We do the account each and a joint account for bills. Husband earns more than me so puts more in. We're both left with same amount of personal spends.

The reason my salary is lower is because I took lower paid jobs to work around the kids when they were younger that don't really translate to career progression - childminding, working shifts etc. Husband obviously benefited from this as I did all school runs, school holidays etc so he could crack on and progress his career.

Now mine are older I'm trying to get on a bit in my career to maximise my earnings but it takes time.

I would be unimpressed if my husband expected me to have a lower standard of living than him. Luckily he doesn't!

In your situation your arrangement is fair. Because your earning potential took a hit to enable his to thrive. Its only fair that ongoing his higher income is seen as down to both of your contribution

redheadsaregreat · 25/01/2024 11:34

heartofglass23 · 25/01/2024 06:53

When women earn more they pay more when men earn more they don't.

Weird generalisation here. And not accurate by any means. Some do. Some don't.

redheadsaregreat · 25/01/2024 11:34

@hellsBells246
My husband earns more than twice than me. We both put 50% of our wage into the joint account for bills. Percentage seems fair to me.

Why? He has twice as much money just for him than you do.

Because the dh already puts more into the joint account. Get put in 50% of what they earn. He earns more do his 50% is twice as much as her 50%

Isn't that enough sharing?

As long as both are equally responsible for domestic stuff then I don't think it's unfair

Sususudio · 25/01/2024 11:33

I used to think that @RadiatorHead but now I have realised how many different circumstances there are and how different spending habits are.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/01/2024 11:33

JadziaD · 25/01/2024 11:26

Fair enough and as I said, it seems to work for you both so that's the main thing.

I think that's a fairly specific example though and relatively unusual. In my experience, it's usually extremes - either one person is the high earner and the other one is just an all round slacker ie works less/ makes no effort/ doesn't pick up enough of the household stuff (SIL's situation) OR, one person is the high earner but as a partnership it works as things are split and the higher earner/more hours person gets support with fewer other tasks (like with me and DH and many of my friends and family) so that works too.

I agree that it's relatively unusual, largely because it is less likely for the woman to be the higher earner.

If it is the other way around, the lower earner tends to go part time or become a SAHM and like I said in my first comment, in that case I would agree that the higher earner would need to contribute the most financially.

XmaswasbadNYisworse · 25/01/2024 11:33

There's a lot of variables.

Married, I kind of agree with treating it as family/shared money, because that's the (lifetime) commitment there, even if it often doesn't actually work out that way in practice.

Earlier, pre-kids relationships: could be 50/50, could be by proportional earnings, kind of depends how you see the relationship going/lasting.

Later life relationships, it gets complicated: do you have kids, does he, how much time do each set of kids spend with you both, how is the split of "family" responsibilities for children, housework, mental load etc?

I think both parties' contributions to the relationship should be equal, but that isn't necessarily the same thing as equal financial contributions, and it depends a lot on the individual situation.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/01/2024 11:31

RadiatorHead · 25/01/2024 11:23

This is so boring on MN. Why can’t people just have a joint account, put all the money in it and then take out an equal amount of personal spends?

All this complicated ‘you pay 31.43% and you pay 68.57%’ of the bills doesn’t make it sound like a proper partnership. It makes couples sound more like flatmates who may or may not shag from time to time 🤷‍♀️

Because relationships are different and different things work for different couples?

I'd never be in a relationship with someone or marry someone who expected all money in a joint account.

JadziaD · 25/01/2024 11:26

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/01/2024 11:20

Hours are similar, we actually work for the same company. The difference is that I have more responsibility and more stress. He is more than capable of progressing if he wants to and he has, he's just reached a level that he's happy with whereas I want to continue to progress.

He does pull his weight at home but then so do I. There's no doubt that he works hard, we both do but if he wants more money, he's more than capable of earning it himself and that's what I'd expect.

Fair enough and as I said, it seems to work for you both so that's the main thing.

I think that's a fairly specific example though and relatively unusual. In my experience, it's usually extremes - either one person is the high earner and the other one is just an all round slacker ie works less/ makes no effort/ doesn't pick up enough of the household stuff (SIL's situation) OR, one person is the high earner but as a partnership it works as things are split and the higher earner/more hours person gets support with fewer other tasks (like with me and DH and many of my friends and family) so that works too.

Haydenn · 25/01/2024 11:26

shipsahoyy · 25/01/2024 11:06

Should one be penalised in the relationship? I think that's actually difficult to answer. My ex did a job that he LOVED, same hours as me, had to work hard, but working with his absolute passion. I on the other hand have my passions, but didn't work in that industry because WE couldn't afford to have both of us earning under £25k a year.

As it was I earned 4 times as much as him, in a job that I didn't particularly enjoy (don't hate it my any stretch of the imagination though). As it was we had the nice house, holidays, lots of meals out all in the main paid for by me. He had lots of disposable income and we were very equal in that way. But what wasn't equal was contribution and effort.

And you know what it is draining, to see someone that supposedly loves you take it all and happily watch you work 45-50 hours a week in a mundane job, whilst they swan around indulging their passions. They could choose to relieve the burden, do a job that they don't love quite so much to bring home a little more money, but they choose not to.

So for me this thread is very focused on equality of outcomes rather than equality of input. I think if one of you is working fewer hours but picking up more at home, then fine. If you both choose to work in less well paying jobs, because you love them fine. Split according to income.

But if one of you has decided to work part time to spend more time on hobbies, or give up well paid work to follow a dream role then I don't think the obligation is on another adult to support you.

I think the last part here is key. It’s about the respective efforts you put in contributing to family life. If you are both working hard- whether it be in the home or in a job then proportional to earnings might be fine. If one of you is working part time to have more leisure time or in an easier role for a quiet life it isn’t fair to expect someone else to subsidise your bills.

I couldn’t bear to see someone I care about working harder than me to pay for my lifestyle.

My ex dropped to part time without telling me because I was paying most of the bills as we were paying % to income. With his “disposable cash/fun money” he looked at how much he had and calculated he could drop 2 days a week because he felt he didn’t need so much disposable money! When he’d been single he had to work full time- with a muppet to pick up his bills all of a sudden he didn’t need to earn so much. No discussion about finding a nicer house, putting money into savings…

RadiatorHead · 25/01/2024 11:23

This is so boring on MN. Why can’t people just have a joint account, put all the money in it and then take out an equal amount of personal spends?

All this complicated ‘you pay 31.43% and you pay 68.57%’ of the bills doesn’t make it sound like a proper partnership. It makes couples sound more like flatmates who may or may not shag from time to time 🤷‍♀️

Mnetcurious · 25/01/2024 11:20

paintingvenice · 25/01/2024 10:27

I am single and find that not only do I earn more than most men I come across, but also because of my age many men of a comparable age already have kids and are paying maintenance.

By the logic on this thread if any of these relationships were to get serious I should start subsidising these men. I then start to question is it me they like or the lifestyle. Shack up with Paintingvenice and my living expenses don’t get slashed in half they get cut by 70 or 80 percent.

having been taken for a ride by a cocklodger once before, I have always struggled to trust since. The prevailing thinking and assumptions on this thread don’t help.

It depends on the circumstances though doesn’t it? A guy pissing about just doing bits and bobs of work here and there, having an easy life while you subsidise him - not ok, but why would you be with someone like that anyway? (The same would be true here if the male/female were the other way round). A man earning a lower wage in a job that’s essential to society and he works really hard at, eg nurse, teacher then why shouldn’t you both share all your money with each other if you’re in a loving, mutually supportive relationship? Or at least pay proportionally so that he’s not left with nothing after paying his 50% while you have loads to spare?

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/01/2024 11:20

JadziaD · 25/01/2024 10:49

Does he work similar hours? And does he pull his weight at home? Obviously, it clearly works for you, but I'm always a bit hesitant about this sort of set up. It's the old nurse/teacher vs doctor/CEO issue - both can work hard, similar hours etc, but one is going to get paid more. Does that mean that one should be penalised in a relationship?

Hours are similar, we actually work for the same company. The difference is that I have more responsibility and more stress. He is more than capable of progressing if he wants to and he has, he's just reached a level that he's happy with whereas I want to continue to progress.

He does pull his weight at home but then so do I. There's no doubt that he works hard, we both do but if he wants more money, he's more than capable of earning it himself and that's what I'd expect.

JadziaD · 25/01/2024 11:19

shipsahoyy · 25/01/2024 11:06

Should one be penalised in the relationship? I think that's actually difficult to answer. My ex did a job that he LOVED, same hours as me, had to work hard, but working with his absolute passion. I on the other hand have my passions, but didn't work in that industry because WE couldn't afford to have both of us earning under £25k a year.

As it was I earned 4 times as much as him, in a job that I didn't particularly enjoy (don't hate it my any stretch of the imagination though). As it was we had the nice house, holidays, lots of meals out all in the main paid for by me. He had lots of disposable income and we were very equal in that way. But what wasn't equal was contribution and effort.

And you know what it is draining, to see someone that supposedly loves you take it all and happily watch you work 45-50 hours a week in a mundane job, whilst they swan around indulging their passions. They could choose to relieve the burden, do a job that they don't love quite so much to bring home a little more money, but they choose not to.

So for me this thread is very focused on equality of outcomes rather than equality of input. I think if one of you is working fewer hours but picking up more at home, then fine. If you both choose to work in less well paying jobs, because you love them fine. Split according to income.

But if one of you has decided to work part time to spend more time on hobbies, or give up well paid work to follow a dream role then I don't think the obligation is on another adult to support you.

I agree with this to a large extent. My teacher/nurse vs lawyer/doctor/CEO example was based on assuming both like their jobs and both work hard etc. And also that the other burdens are ALSO split. Or, in the case of one working less than the other, the person working more gets the support of the person working less in terms of housework/childcare etc.

But I couldn't agree more with the point that one person expecting the other person to take on the heavy lifting is not okay. In our case, I outearn DH by a huge amount. But doing so is made possible because he is picking up the slack elsewhere, including being a SAHD when the DC were little and I had a job working long hours in the City.

SIL, on the other hand, was with a man who constantly worked less and less but never ever stepped up anywhere else. At one point he was doing just 20 hours a week because "childcare" but their DC were at school and she was still paying for after school club 4 days a week.... And no, he never did a load of washing, ran the hoover round or did any of the cooking/cleaning.

RatatouillePie · 25/01/2024 11:13

If you both work full time (no kids) and earn different amounts then yes, the higher earner should be paying more.

If one works part time and looks after kids then yes the higher earner should pay more and you should have roughly equal amounts left over.

The only exception would be if one of a couple was deliberately not earning as much as they could, then I think I'd begrudge paying more!

DH earns twice what I do. I work part time and do most the childcare. He pays far more into the joint account, but as his hobbies are more expensive than mine he has more left over too which I'm fine with.

Sususudio · 25/01/2024 11:12

A friend who is a massive spender has married a man who is massively frugal, and the tension! He earns more, I think, but not sure. She is planning to quit her job for a more creative and less well paid job, and I think shit is going to hit the fan.

mindutopia · 25/01/2024 11:11

Yes, of course. Dh earns probably twice as much as I do - he's self-employed, so it's variable, but on average, probably about twice as much plus fewer expenses as he can put his work-related costs through the business, while I have to pay for mine. He pays 2/3 and I pay 1/3 into our joint account for each month. We then each have the remainder for personal spending. Obviously, if ever there is an emergency though, either of us could transfer money to the other to cover any additional costs, but generally yes, he earns more so he pays more. I'm not a fan of one joint account for everything though as I like having my own money and not needing to discuss between us how we chose to use our personal spending.

Drosera · 25/01/2024 11:08

I think joint account is the way to go.

Some men are defo tight but I can also see how some feel resentment when the wife doesn't want to go back to FT work and they're enabling it with their higher salary. We see plenty of cases where husband wants to reduce hours but wife won't step up and contribute evenly.

shipsahoyy · 25/01/2024 11:06

JadziaD · 25/01/2024 10:49

Does he work similar hours? And does he pull his weight at home? Obviously, it clearly works for you, but I'm always a bit hesitant about this sort of set up. It's the old nurse/teacher vs doctor/CEO issue - both can work hard, similar hours etc, but one is going to get paid more. Does that mean that one should be penalised in a relationship?

Should one be penalised in the relationship? I think that's actually difficult to answer. My ex did a job that he LOVED, same hours as me, had to work hard, but working with his absolute passion. I on the other hand have my passions, but didn't work in that industry because WE couldn't afford to have both of us earning under £25k a year.

As it was I earned 4 times as much as him, in a job that I didn't particularly enjoy (don't hate it my any stretch of the imagination though). As it was we had the nice house, holidays, lots of meals out all in the main paid for by me. He had lots of disposable income and we were very equal in that way. But what wasn't equal was contribution and effort.

And you know what it is draining, to see someone that supposedly loves you take it all and happily watch you work 45-50 hours a week in a mundane job, whilst they swan around indulging their passions. They could choose to relieve the burden, do a job that they don't love quite so much to bring home a little more money, but they choose not to.

So for me this thread is very focused on equality of outcomes rather than equality of input. I think if one of you is working fewer hours but picking up more at home, then fine. If you both choose to work in less well paying jobs, because you love them fine. Split according to income.

But if one of you has decided to work part time to spend more time on hobbies, or give up well paid work to follow a dream role then I don't think the obligation is on another adult to support you.

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/01/2024 11:00

Before children, we split proportionately to earnings. He also usually paid for nights out/takeaways/holidays because my salary wouldn’t stretch to that.

SapphOhNo · 25/01/2024 10:58

If not in one pot, definitely proportionate to salary.

But this discussion should take place prior to moving in not after.

JadziaD · 25/01/2024 10:49

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/01/2024 10:15

I earn more than DH, we have separate finances and pay 50% of joint bills such as the mortgage and nursery fees.

DH works FT just like me so he hasn't sacrificed any earnings for childcare reasons etc he simply doesn't want as much responsibility as I have which is absolutely fine but that also means that he has less money left over than me for 'fun' spending. I'm not funding that and thankfully, he'd never expect me to.

I do think it is different if someone has sacrificed their earning potential such as going part time to take on childcare responsibilities. In that case, I do believe the higher earner should pay more towards the bills.

Does he work similar hours? And does he pull his weight at home? Obviously, it clearly works for you, but I'm always a bit hesitant about this sort of set up. It's the old nurse/teacher vs doctor/CEO issue - both can work hard, similar hours etc, but one is going to get paid more. Does that mean that one should be penalised in a relationship?

Sususudio · 25/01/2024 10:30

I suppose it's different in a long marriage. I do more of the housework and cooking. Ideally, I would have preferred that both of us earn the same, but it hasn't worked out like that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread