Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ready yourself for the Citizen's Army

255 replies

ChedderGorgeous · 24/01/2024 22:12

Is the head of the army being sensationalist to highlight lack of army funding or is the reality of a citizen's army in the UK a step towards a new era of conscription? Both parties would play anything like this down in an election year.

OP posts:
HeWhoMustNotBeNamed · 25/01/2024 08:36

Livinginanotherworld · 25/01/2024 01:20

I can’t imagine it would be any worse than living under the Tory party we have now, or the so called Labour Party we might expect.
No, let the warmongers play their “ billy big balls” games.
Putin is not interested in going to war with the UK. And we should stop bombing other countries to destabilise them. It’s all about the money, it’s a game and people die, but not the ones who benefit by it, they stay safe in their bunkers.
Oh and yes my father fought in ww2 as well, it was a different time. We are not in the 1930’s now.

...you're being facetious, right?
I know that none of our voting options are fantastic but I think the party responsible for the Holocaust would very much be a lot worse...

justasking111 · 25/01/2024 08:35

GoodLuckLooking · 25/01/2024 07:47

Inaccurate. Very few from London, not SE. Scotland and Wales proportionate. Yorkshire, North West and South West England higher levels of recruitment.

Old statistics

EasternStandard · 25/01/2024 08:28

DewinDwl · 25/01/2024 08:25

Actually I think that people have seen how coy NATO are being with Ukraine.

Anecdote: Putin once said to the shiny new American-Georgian president: Your new friends will not deliver". And he was right. Many people have the unsettling feeling that NATO might not deliver.

And anyway NATO is only an element of the topic of the thread.

Deliver what? What are you expecting

As for Ukraine wanting to join in pp can’t say I blame them. If I had a threat such as Russia and the associated horror they’re seeing as a result then yeah I might ask too

CampsieGlamper · 25/01/2024 08:26

Yes he is touting for extra money.

By the number of "you couldn't possibly conscript or even take women in the front line" I thought I'd strayed onto an Andrew Tate site. Women have been serving in the infantry on the front line, as medics on the front line, in ships on the front line.

The Tories continually decimate the armed forces. Reservists have been cut back as well as regular forces. Restore them and as the current and next conflict will rely on IT, cyber skills and back.office why not a Kings Own Highland Hackers regiment. Natty tartan kilts?

Why not encourage "Serve four years, get your university fees paid by the government/army? "

DewinDwl · 25/01/2024 08:25

EasternStandard · 25/01/2024 07:52

Yes I think NATO has passed some people by

Actually I think that people have seen how coy NATO are being with Ukraine.

Anecdote: Putin once said to the shiny new American-Georgian president: Your new friends will not deliver". And he was right. Many people have the unsettling feeling that NATO might not deliver.

And anyway NATO is only an element of the topic of the thread.

Mambo19866 · 25/01/2024 08:22

Tbf I don’t think Putin actually wants to invade anyone in NATO. If you follow the history NATO has been inching closer and closer every decade until it reached Ukraine that is right next to Russia. Russia told us a million times this was the red line but alas Ukraine was to join NATO. However if Russia was to invade long standing NATO nations then yes we are going to war because we have no choice because we would need to act now while NATO combined force was strong. If say we as a nation refused and Putin could take countries one by one could easily end up with a Nazi Germany war machine again. That being said Russia doesn’t have the resources for this kind of campaign.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 25/01/2024 08:16

We have too many severe mental health problems between those that are 25+ years. Mental health issues disqualify you from joining the army, it would never work. They’d be turning every 4th person away on grounds of mental health, every 3rd person away on the grounds of being unfit too. I’d never be allowed to join, between asd, ocd and agoraphobia they’d have more luck getting my into a psychiatric unit than into the army - which is one hell of a feat considering mental health support in this country is non existent.

Castlerock44 · 25/01/2024 08:10

The world is different place to what it was in previous wars. I can't see any favourable outcome.

It would be disastrous... nuclear weapons would be used rather than any side surrender.

Why go to war when the end result would be "mutual assured destruction" 😳

Madness.

TheFairyCaravan · 25/01/2024 08:09

He’s just saying that the Armed Forces are on their knees and they can’t afford to be cut any further. We all know there’s an election coming, the country is absolutely skint, cutbacks are going to have to be made from some budgets to pay other budgets, so he’s giving the heads up, that this time, it can’t be defence.

LadyBird1973 · 25/01/2024 08:03

America has never really saved us - just agitated in other peoples countries, while making a shit load of money.
Fighting Naziism was to everyone's benefit - America still exploited that with lend lease.

I would defend my own country from invasion, I wouldn't defend America's continued involvement in other peoples countries. Not least because they keep fucking it up and abandoning places like Afghanistan and Iraq, leaving those poor people even more in the shit!

EasternStandard · 25/01/2024 07:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yes I think NATO has passed some people by

TheWayTheLightFalls · 25/01/2024 07:51

I don't have a problem with national service tbh. Countries that do it well have robust programmes that see people finishing with all sorts of skills, and are good at assigning roles appropriately (rather than everyone off to a putative front line). I'm not sure UK implementation would be up to scratch though.

EasternStandard · 25/01/2024 07:51

Vettrianofan · 25/01/2024 07:39

Even more reason to take in the ones that waddle - get these guys and girls fit!

Not for conscription but that would do it

GoodLuckLooking · 25/01/2024 07:50

Oh and not shown here but 1% NI.

Grandmasswag · 25/01/2024 07:50

I would say he’s scaremongering, but given that we probably can’t rely on the USA to save us as Europe usually do maybe he does have a point. If Putin were try to invade an EU country, and I don’t think he will, we would be royally fucked.

GoodLuckLooking · 25/01/2024 07:47

justasking111 · 25/01/2024 00:08

Statistically very few young people from the south east enlist. The forces have relied on the north, Wales and Scotland for that.

I'm not sure that would be the same these days.

Inaccurate. Very few from London, not SE. Scotland and Wales proportionate. Yorkshire, North West and South West England higher levels of recruitment.

Ready yourself for the Citizen's Army
DewinDwl · 25/01/2024 07:46

Come to think of it, a fitness to fight assessment might not be a bad idea. I might finally get an x-ray for my dodgy hip...

<facetious comment. I know the above would be impossible considering current NHS waiting lists. Unless it happened via a government contract made available to the right friend of a minister, for the right price, I guess... >

ACourseInstead · 25/01/2024 07:45

He was making the point that we can’t wish away the threat that Russia poses to Europe and the only alternative to a standing army is a conscripted army.

I used to think people wouldn’t stand for conscription these days but since Covid I’ve changed my mind on that- I think we’re all a lot more malleable than we like to think. I also think that we look back at conscription in the 20th C in an unrealistic way, as if everyone then was unquestioningly happy to die for King and country, whereas the real picture was rather more mixed, as it is now- some were keen to fight, many more had no choice but to comply, and some did not comply.

Vettrianofan · 25/01/2024 07:39

ComtesseDeSpair · 24/01/2024 22:17

Conscription to do what? Half of the U.K. can barely waddle half a mile, let alone take a physical position in the armed forces.

So I’m guessing it’s simply intended to draw attention to lack of funding / shit conditions.

Even more reason to take in the ones that waddle - get these guys and girls fit!

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 25/01/2024 07:37

FloraClover · 25/01/2024 06:03

@ChardonnaysBeastlyCat the PP knows NATO exists…she was being facetious!

That’s how I would have read it, as a sarcastic reply.

It was the unnecessary Brexit dig that made made it fall flat.

Brexit was a stupid mistake, but bringing it up time and time again is rather cheap.

LlynTegid · 25/01/2024 07:18

The Tories have made far more defence cuts ever since the 1958 White Paper than any Labour government.

Just as the so-called party of law and order and the lack of police funding.

MadamWow · 25/01/2024 07:15

Ukrainian citizens found themselves making molotov cocktails and spikes to assist the army in pushing back on Russia.
Not the same as conscription, but when push comes to shove, do you sit back or do you defend your country?

Wanttobeok · 25/01/2024 07:01

The armed forces need funding, that was the guys point.

Conscription will not happen. Even in ww1 and ww2 there were people who refused it. I would rather my son went to prison than to the front line and I imagine a lot of others would feel similar, oh, hang on the prisons are full....

Watercolourpapier · 25/01/2024 06:34

I didn't start this war. Why should i die for it? Send the politicians first.

MyLadyTheKingsMother · 25/01/2024 06:14

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 24/01/2024 22:41

Hopefully conscripting women too this time 🤞🏼

Hopefully?!?!?!