Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ready yourself for the Citizen's Army

255 replies

ChedderGorgeous · 24/01/2024 22:12

Is the head of the army being sensationalist to highlight lack of army funding or is the reality of a citizen's army in the UK a step towards a new era of conscription? Both parties would play anything like this down in an election year.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
newnamethanks · 31/01/2024 21:44

Does anyone on this thread seriously think another country's army would invade UK? Get a map. A few missiles would take care of it and it would look like Gaza in no time at all. A 'citizens army' would serve no purpose in preventing this.

Livinginanotherworld · 31/01/2024 01:01

HeWhoMustNotBeNamed · 25/01/2024 08:36

...you're being facetious, right?
I know that none of our voting options are fantastic but I think the party responsible for the Holocaust would very much be a lot worse...

Well both our main parties support a potential genocide and have taken our young men to illegal wars looking for WMD, so they are no better imo.

Alwaysanotherwine · 30/01/2024 23:15

people wouldn’t be doing it for the government through!

if this came in we would indeed be in shit street and people will choose to do it to save their families

JenniferBooth · 29/01/2024 19:07

lol the way the Government allow people to be treated in this country , its no wonder people wouldnt jump for joy to do this

BarryfromWatford · 27/01/2024 18:02

BarryfromWatford · 27/01/2024 18:01

Absolutely
Quite agree
Its just you said ‘ I think it went up to’ …so I thought , I’d note it was in fact higher.

Ps because the age did change ie rise….as war progressed.

ChedderGorgeous · 27/01/2024 18:02

BarryfromWatford · 27/01/2024 18:01

Absolutely
Quite agree
Its just you said ‘ I think it went up to’ …so I thought , I’d note it was in fact higher.

Yes fair enough. It went up to 41 when war started was what I meant.

OP posts:
BarryfromWatford · 27/01/2024 18:01

ChedderGorgeous · 27/01/2024 17:57

Yes but it started at 41 when the war started. If people are comparing then to now, then would make sense to consider this age, Alex.

Absolutely
Quite agree
Its just you said ‘ I think it went up to’ …so I thought , I’d note it was in fact higher.

ChedderGorgeous · 27/01/2024 17:57

BarryfromWatford · 27/01/2024 17:50

In 1942 and after it was all males between 18 and 51. For WW2.

Yes but it started at 41 when the war started. If people are comparing then to now, then would make sense to consider this age, Alex.

OP posts:
BarryfromWatford · 27/01/2024 17:50

ChedderGorgeous · 27/01/2024 17:45

I just checked and looked like it went up to 41 in ww2

In 1942 and after it was all males between 18 and 51. For WW2.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 27/01/2024 17:46

Hopefully pacifists would not be labelled as cowards nowadays.

ChedderGorgeous · 27/01/2024 17:45

BarryfromWatford · 27/01/2024 17:44

😳 not me!

( ps….it went up to 50 I believe )

I just checked and looked like it went up to 41 in ww2

OP posts:
BarryfromWatford · 27/01/2024 17:44

ChedderGorgeous · 24/01/2024 22:21

Yes I agree. It's not Barry from Watford suggesting it though, it's the current head of the army, so worth debating.

I think the obesity levels in the UK would only permit conscription of 18- 25 year olds practically, as apposed to WWII where I think it went up to 40 yrs

😳 not me!

( ps….it went up to 50 I believe )

Hagbard · 27/01/2024 14:39

Crikey, somebody's rubbing their thighs

KnickerlessParsons · 27/01/2024 14:03

They can throw me and my sons in prison before any of us would fight in a war

How close would the bombs and fighting have to get to your front door before you changed your mind?

If you were in Ukraine now,say, and houses, schools, factories, hospitals in your town were being bombed, would you stay on your sofa with your arms folded? You probably couldn't watch TV or use the Internet because comms works have been destroyed too.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 27/01/2024 13:56

They can throw me and my sons in prison before any of us would fight in a war.

your sons might not share your opinion if the UK was attacked or invaded.

Barbadossunset · 27/01/2024 13:47

They can throw me and my sons in prison before any of us would fight in a war.

Fair enough bluefrog as regards a war fought overseas, but would you or your sons fight if UK was invaded?

bluefrog11 · 27/01/2024 08:49

@Alwaysanotherwine I agree totally. I would never have said this would be a thing until covid. Biggest restriction of our freedom since 1940 on very little evidence and people went along with it with knobs on! And then bad mouthed those people who questioned it.

The same will happen here. The young ones will be posting pics of their “ sign up papers” to get likes & comments on social media. I can see it now. Until they get their head blown off or repeatedly raped in a bunker and then it’ll be their poor parents turn to pick up the pieces.

They can throw me and my sons in prison before any of us would fight in a war.

1dayatatime · 26/01/2024 11:45

@MrsSkylerWhite

"Good luck to anyone trying to impose such a scheme."

+++

I think it is clear that such a conscription scheme is never going to happen and if it ever did need to happen then it would be too late to be of any use.

So it is very much a hypothetical debate but at the same time reading the views on this thread a very interesting hypothetical debate.

MrsSkylerWhite · 26/01/2024 10:59

ssd
**
“The present UK government has done so little for the young people of this country they'd have a nerve expecting them to line up for duty eg. Get killed for “

This subject came up on Question Time last night and your post seemed very much the consensus among the (mainly Tory voting) audience.

Good luck to anyone trying to impose such a scheme.

1dayatatime · 25/01/2024 22:14

@ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming

"I think you will find that quite a lot of young rich men also die in wars. Maybe do a bit of research."

+++

During the worst of WW1 the average life expectancy of a junior officer in the trenches was 6 weeks.

TheSeasonalNameChange · 25/01/2024 21:54

RH1234 · 25/01/2024 12:38

My discharge papers from the MOD say 6 years if that helps to clarify.

Interesting, my husbands don't! Did you do the full 24 years?

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 25/01/2024 21:49

Fourfurrymonsters · 25/01/2024 14:06

War is rich men sending poor men to die, and always has been.
As my 20-year old son said earlier today “if the people of the UK are being brought together to fight, you’d hope it would be to overthrow the shit government that dragged us into this, not going to fight some other poor saps in another country”

I think you will find that quite a lot of young rich men also die in wars. Maybe do a bit of research.

lola8345 · 25/01/2024 20:18

1dayatatime · 25/01/2024 17:21

@lola8345

"I'm sure those in Ukraine, thought it would never happen. I don't think anything is beyond the realms of possibility. Sadly."

+++

I meant that the prospect of conscription is hypothetical whereas an attack on the UK particularly a grey zone attack is, as you say, not beyond the realms of possibility.

@1dayatatime
Actually I was referring to conscription. They had been at peace for years.
I doubt they thought it would happen.

It would have been hypothetical to think of 50 year old men being forced to enlist. 😢

beccaskylar · 25/01/2024 19:35

YoullHaveSomeonesEyeOutWithThat · 24/01/2024 22:50

Such a shame that if there was a need, there isn’t some sort of wider club of European nations who could join their armies together for the common good, isn’t it? Oh…

But then, I expect all those fit young men who voted for Brexit to avoid the creation of a putative EU army will be the first to volunteer to protect old Blighty if the need arises, so it’ll all be fine.

Send in the politicians first...

Barbadossunset · 25/01/2024 19:27

I remember during the anti-nuclear protests one popular slogan was ‘better red than dead’.
Perhaps, but break a rule and working in a Siberian salt mine or rotting in a Soviet jail wouldn’t have been much fun.
Though maybe all those who believed in the slogan would’ve been model Soviet citizens, denouncing their friends and neighbours etc.