Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to know what happened? Trigger warning: possible child abuse

33 replies

HairEyebrowsLipsEtc · 23/01/2024 22:47

Name changed as potentially identifying and don’t want this linked to other posts….

I moved to a lovely village last year with DH and DDs - lovely and close knit community, making lots of friends, DDs loving village life, I’ve joined the PTA etc - all very idyllic, but I found out from one of my new friends that one of the other parents in the village was charged by the police with child sexual exploitation a few years ago. Apparently he was arrested (and it was covered by local news at the time) and went to court, but found not guilty - but although I can find media stories about his arrest, I can’t find any information about the trial.

I really want to find out what happened. DD2 is becoming friends with this man’s DD and I don’t know what to do. Everyone in the village seems determined that he’s not guilty because that was the outcome in court, but without knowing why he was found not guilty I can’t trust this - lack of evidence doesn’t equal lack of guilt, and the police had enough confidence at the time he was arrested to publicise it, so they must have been fairly confident of his guilt? I’ve tried asking my friend but she seemed annoyed with me for asking and it’s so difficult because she allows her children to go to his house to play with his daughter, it must seem like I’m judging her decisions by asking more about him. But I can’t let it lie - DD2 is primary age and asking to go over there, and I can’t explain to her the real reason I won’t allow it. I feel so bad for this man’s DD who seems like a lovely girl and who DD2 gets on really well with ☹️

So to get to my AIBU - am I unreasonable to want to see some sort of transcript of this man’s trial, so I can judge whether he could be a risk to DD2? I’ve tried searching and assumed this would be in the public domain but can’t find anything, only the media reports from when he was first arrested. If I’m not being unreasonable to want this information, where can I find it?

OP posts:
HairEyebrowsLipsEtc · 24/01/2024 22:17

Thank you @firstpregnancy1 thats exactly my thinking as well, if there was enough evidence to publicise the arrest and take it to trial, that’s surely a lot of evidence!

Thats why I want to be able to see what actually happened in the trial, so I can make up my own mind about the evidence even if it wasn’t enough to get a conviction. I’m so shocked that it’s not a matter of public record and that someone could get it ‘wiped’ from internet searches.

Youre all right though that I need to protect my DD first and foremost and if I can’t find out what happened at the trial then I just need to keep our distance from this family. I’m so sad that this lovely community that I thought we’d moved to isn’t what I thought it was.

OP posts:
firstpregnancy1 · 24/01/2024 13:11

Sarah's law isn't a catch all. Not entirely sure but I think it only shows convictions. Which this is not.

In our judicial system the burden of proof is 'beyond all reasonable doubt'. This is an extremely high threshold and therefore it is not easy to be found guilty in court. Especially if evidence is one word against another for example. Whilst this is great and fair for the accused, and definitely prevents people being wrongly found guilty, it absolutely unequivocally allows for SO MANY people to be found not guilty despite committing the crime.

In order for a case to even GET to court, the police AND CPS have to decide that there is a 'realistic prospect of conviction'.

Based on this, there is not a chance in hell I'd be letting my kids go there. Ever. People don't like to think ill of others, especially high standing members of the community and it is often 'easier' to believe otherwise, since everyone else is.

Please trust your gut.

from a personal and somewhat professional perspective, I would say that in a lot of cases , if they are charged and it goes to trial, that's a fair chance they're guilty, even if they get found not guilty.

HairEyebrowsLipsEtc · 24/01/2024 12:52

Thank you for the advice about Sarah’s law - would he be told that I’d asked for this information? Everyone here seems so determined that he’s not guilty and I don’t think it would go down well if people found out I was questioning it ☹️

OP posts:
JMPB · 24/01/2024 10:25

As above, do a Sarah’s law request with the police. If they feel your daughter is likely to come to harm they will disclose to you.
For the time being could you invite his child back to your house so your dd still sees her friend?

DecayedStrumpet · 24/01/2024 10:08

There's Sarah's law, which means you can ask the police about the history of someone with close contact with your child... I'm not sure this would count but you could try.

Personally, no way would I be allowing my own child any unsupervised contact with this bloke. And if our kids became friends I'd be having an age appropriate discussion how not everyone who is a parent is always right etc, to open the door for them to speak to me about anything that makes them uncomfortable.

HairEyebrowsLipsEtc · 24/01/2024 10:00

I’ve wondered that as well @InAnotherLifetimeMaybe but my friend is adamant that he was found not guilty, so surely there must have been - but then why can’t I find anything about it?! Is it really possible to have it wiped from the internet @DNLove ? I’ve thought about asking the police but I don’t know if they’d tell me and I’d be worried that they might inform him that I’ve been asking - does anyone know if they would do this?

OP posts:
InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 23/01/2024 23:29

It probably didn't even make it to 'trial'

DNLove · 23/01/2024 22:54

Sounds like he's gotten all of the details wiped from the Internet given he was found not guilty. As I say not guilty, but also not innocent!
Can you talk to local police or ask newspapers for copies of their papers with articles relating to it.
It's your child, trust no one with her.
If you need be honest with your man, if they ask your child over, just say I'm very sorry for your experience but I don't care who I insult, offend or hurt, I cannot risk my daughters safety in the same way you wouldn't. Happy to have your daughter to my house but I understand if you feel you don't know us enough either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread