Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about your MILs?

62 replies

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 23/01/2024 22:40

As a Mum of 2 boys, I've been giving a lot of thought to the fact that one day I will likely be a MIL to a younger woman.

Those of you with positive relationships with your MILs, would you please share? Or MILs with positive relationships with your children, in laws, grandchildren?

What can I do to make sure I maintain happy and healthy relationships with my children and their prospective partners/children as time goes on?

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 24/01/2024 09:23

Also op I think it's about trying to connect as two adult women, not the one who knows best and the woman who stole her son away. I treat her with the same respect I treat my mom

Aria2023 · 24/01/2024 07:38

I have a frosty relationship with my mil. I am always polite and civil, but we're not remotely close. Things could have been very different, but the main reasons for the lack of closeness (from my perspective) are that her and my fil have tried to remain the centre of the family instead of de-centering themselves and respecting their son and me (and now dc) as our own, separate family. This inability to ‘let go’ has felt smothering and caused battles where there shouldn't be any. The expectation that Christmas, mother’s / father’s days and birthdays centre around them means I always feel pressured and end up dreading, what should be lovely occasions.

The other big reason is she's never shown any interest in me and getting to know me. Never asks me how I am (even after giving birth to her grandchildren!), doesn't remember any personal details about me eg I'm always told when given gifts, she has ‘no idea’ what I like (maybe ask? Or take some notice?). I on the other hand know about her whole life story. Mostly because I've asked questions in an attempt in the early days to get to know her.

So when (if) I'm a mil to my children, I'll be making sure I give their family unit the space and respect it deserves, not centre myself for special occasions and i'll make an effort to get to know my dil as a person.

Enko · 24/01/2024 07:24

Mil passed 4 years ago and not a day passes where I don't miss her. My own mother passes 9 years ago and its rare I miss her. She was not an active part of my life.

Mil however just loved on her family. Could have 8 grandchildren and feel they all were the best. No favourites. (Mother had favourites)

Only offered advice if asked for it. Or would say would you like my advice? If told no was fine with this. (Dh hated the would you like my advice I loved it)

She was an amazing woman that I'm happy was in mine and my children's life. Dd1 has already said any future dd will be named after Mil

Mummypie21 · 24/01/2024 07:19

I get on with my MIL and she really cares about all of us and tries her best to be supportive. MIL does try to 'mother' me as she always wanted a daughter - which can be a bit too much. However, I'm glad that she is an involved and loving grandparent.

Laurama91 · 24/01/2024 07:14

Love mine. His parents have always been really nice to me. She helped us scrub our house top to bottom when we bought it. She will help out if either of us are ill and always come back to a spotless house from holiday. She's just one of those people who is genuinely nice.

She isn't keen on cats but we have one so she will make an effort to play with him. Never had fish but will try to look after them when we're on holiday.

My mum passed when I was young so I dont know if she puts extra effort in for me because I dont think she is the same with bil and partner

autienotnaughty · 24/01/2024 06:06

My mil is ok but she keeps me at a distance (and by proxy our family) I think she finds me a bit different to them (I'm not that different but I'm not a foodie or a big drinker and I'm not extravagant I'm my spending)

She treats her daughter's children more than she does our kids. She also offers to helps them out a lot more. This irritates me at times.

She will say something nasty if I criticise or even tease dh. For example on Christmas morning he cooked breakfast and (accidentally) didn't save me any. When we saw them the next day the dh, kids and I were joking about me not being fed at breakfast. She got offended and made some comment about dh always having to runaround after me (not true).

She occasionally makes comments about how hard dh life is having to manage me and kids.

I don't have my parents anymore and I would love to have a close relationship with them but I have to accept that they don't want that with me.

I would focus now on building a strong relationship with your sons. When they meet partners welcome them in and take the time to get to know them. Build a relationship with them in their own right (rather than as your son's appendage) support, don't criticise, offer to help but don't be offended. Build a solid relationship way before grandchildren are on the radar.

everygreensock · 24/01/2024 06:03

I love my MIL - we get on brilliantly. Our close relationship started when my mum suggested we should invite her wedding dress shopping before I got married. Sounds mad but I realised then that it was 50% up to me how to frame our relationship and I didn't want it to be negative. Before that point she was quite reserved with me.
We're really different people and there have been some difficult times we've been through but we respect each other and our differences but communicate well and make an effort with each other.
We used to live close to each other but we had to move quite far away. She was heart broken but understood our reasoning. I FaceTime with the kids often, share photos as much as possible and we've always got a date in the diary when we'll see each other next. I'm not organised at all, but she is so I know it means a lot to her to know when and where she'll see the grandkids again. So I make sure she's a priority in our calendar. She also hates hosting Christmas so I always offer as I don't mind.
Basically - it's a 2 way thing. It's important to make the effort. And I'm lucky we like each other as people (despite our differences).

Changedmymind99 · 24/01/2024 05:42

Being a MIL who very much has their own life, their own hobbies and is happy without relying on their children to make them happy.
a MiL who depends on their children to entertain them, bring them places, with expectations etc etc will never end in a happy relationship.
Be your own person then merely enhance your sons life,
don’t take from it.

Noicant · 24/01/2024 05:19

My Mil is lovely (different country) she’s great with my DC, she’s thoughtful and doesn’t interfere or criticise even though we are raising ours very differently from how she would probably like. Only thing that annoys me is that any quality she considers to be “good” is attributed to her family even when clearly it’s not.

Sugargliderwombat · 24/01/2024 05:10

Tell them their babies look like them.

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 24/01/2024 04:41

@Charles11

Yes, I do love my MIL, she can be annoying sometimes but that's family I suppose.

I definitely want to raise respectful, kind men.

OP posts:
ShippingNews · 24/01/2024 00:44

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 23/01/2024 23:25

Let them go. They and their families will want to be around you if you let them go and see the best in them and their choices, including of spouse, when you do see them. You will be someone who only brings positives to their lives.

This. I'm a MIL and I have great relationships with both of my kid's partners. I don't intrude, but I keep in touch and offer to help with anything and everything. Doing child care, helping to move house, solving problems, you name it. Other than that I live my own life. Drop them a loving text every so often .

Charliecatpaws · 24/01/2024 00:43

JohnLapsleyParlabane · 23/01/2024 23:23

I bloody love my mother in law. She makes a huge effort to support and actively praise our parenting (our life is very different to how they raised their boys, in terms of finances and other situations). She has welcomed my widowed Dad into her home as he now only has me, DH and the grandchildren, and accommodated his preferences with grace.
When I was a wreck after DD was born she came up to London every week and gently supported me.
And if DH is being a dickhead, she tells him straight.

She sounds fantastic

Charles11 · 24/01/2024 00:29

Do you have a mil now? What's your relationship like with her now?
Modelling a good mil relationship is a good first step.

Foster a good relationship with your sons. Don't be a martyr and have expectations too. Expect your sons to help out from a young age and not take you for granted. let them know that you have feelings and to consider you as a person in your own right.

So many women do everything for their dc without complaint that often dc grow up barely realising their mum is a person with feelings.
They then never prioritise their mum.

Then it's the relationship with the dil.

Crumpleton · 24/01/2024 00:17

Unfortunately my MIL died some years ago but she was lovely, never interfered but was always there to go to if needed.

I too let my children, mid 30's lead their own lives and follow her suit, helping both where I can.
I've recently become a nana and in all honesty I have no desire to always be right, or use the this is how we done it years ago line.

Tabsysnook · 24/01/2024 00:16

And I should say my MIL has a good relationship with all 4 of her DIL. It’s not just chance, she has fostered good relationships with us. But also her lovely sons have chosen nice women!

Tabsysnook · 24/01/2024 00:14

My MIL has FIVE sons! And I’m the oldest son’s wife. It could have gone one of two ways really, me and her were doing the trial run as her first MIL/DIL relationship. It took us a little while to find our groove, but I still remember the moment when I saw her in real time, clock that I’m a mum, just like her. I know that sounds weird. She’s fab, and I love her to bits. Never offers unsolicited advice, but will help if we need it. Would never get involved in mine and DH’s relationship. She does think the sun shines out of DH’s arse, but frankly she’s done an excellent job of bringing him up, so this is not a problem- I don’t have the “wife work” of negotiating with the in laws like many do, he does it himself. That’s probably the most important thing you can do as a mum of a son - do your best to bring up a decent man!

Rachie1973 · 24/01/2024 00:11

my late MIL was amazing. I miss her so much! I try to model my behaviour as a MIL on hers.

I don’t offer unsolicited advice. I support their opinions. I keep an open door for them to come see us, but don’t demand it of them. I let them know that I think they’re great people.

My DIL’s are lovely, and so is my ex DIL. We have maintained a good relationship with her. She is the mother of one of our grandchildren and is a wonderful mother to her. My sons in law are lovely too.

On the odd occasion that one of them has brought someone we’re not overly taken with we just don’t say anything and stay friendly. It’s not our choice to make.

5foot5 · 24/01/2024 00:11

I got on really well with my late MIL.

They welcomed me in to the family from the start. She was always supportive but never interfered.

I think I probably benefited from the fact that her own MIL was a bit over-bearing and their relationship was a little frosty. So all the things that annoyed her about her own MIL she resolved never to do herself.

I was very lucky really and I miss her now she has gone. She had three DS and always wanted a DD so was absolutely thrilled when we had a DD and was a devoted GP.

saraclara · 24/01/2024 00:10

My late MIL was wonderful. I adored her. I learned everything about being a mother, and then a grandmother, from her.

She was the most loving and accepting of people. She never gave advice. She didn't need to. Her life was all the advice I needed.

Boymum2104 · 24/01/2024 00:08

LocalHobo · 23/01/2024 23:55

Try and not resent DIL for spending more time with her own DM especially if she has children.
I would suggest modelling the opposite of this. If your DS's see that you have a close relationship with your MIL, when the time comes that they become fathers they will see it as normal to spend as much time with you as with the wife's family.
Since having my son I naturally want to spend more time being supported by my mum Thankfully I saw my MIL as equal to my DM in being supportive and involved with my DC, I hope my DS remembers this.

My MIL is lovely and supportive I just want to spend more time with my own mum which I think should be understood and respected

saraclara · 24/01/2024 00:07

Boymum2104 · 23/01/2024 23:40

Try and not resent DIL for spending more time with her own DM especially if she has children. Since having my son I naturally want to spend more time being supported by my mum, I know my MIL isn't very happy about it and it's become awkward

Fine for you to spend more time with your mum. Not fine for MIL to not to be seen as equal to the maternal Grandma though. So your child needs to be able to spend equal time (all practical things like distance being equal) with your MIL. He's just as important to, and loved by her, as he is too and by your mum.

I'm lucky that I have daughters I think. But I'm glad to see that my daughter is positive about and encourages the paternal grandmother's relationship too.

BIinkii · 24/01/2024 00:06

I love my MIL. She doesn't interfere. She's respectful. She will give an opinion when it's asked for. We get along great.

GettingStuffed · 24/01/2024 00:04

My MiL was amazing, she realised that being a parent was stressful and she and DFiL would take the kids for the weekend or on holiday so DH and I could have us time.

She died from complications of Alzheimer's and one day when she was in bed I sat with her and she started telling me about her DIL aka me and how she was a wonderful mother and a great wife to her son. The funny thing was she knew me, but not how I fit into the family, she told the hospital I was her friend.

Words of advice, don't criticise parenting styles. Remember the adults as much as the children.
Don't break any rules the parents have in place.

Aquamarine1029 · 24/01/2024 00:01

Respect the fact that when your adult sons choose their partners, you are no longer the only female influence in their lives. The love they have for you is completely different from the love they have for their partners, as it should be. It's not a competition.

From the start, my MIL would never let me forget that I "stole" her baby boy. That I would never know him as well as she did. My husband was the youngest with two elder sisters. My MIL thought she should be the primary female in her son's life, above all, uncontested.

Luckily for me, my husband has always fully supported me, without exception. I tried for fucking "years* to get this woman to like me. I know now she would have hated any woman in my husband's life.