Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not let him dress like a girl?

413 replies

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 22:37

Lo is 11 and has ASD (not sure if that's relevant). He's told me he is trans, wants me to buy him dresses, make up, hair extensions etc. This is the first time he has come out and said it although he has made comments about girls clothing being better etc over the past year so I had a feeling this was coming. Not sure how to approach this. My worry is if I do allow him to dress like a girl he will get picked on, he already struggles socially and has been bullied in the past. Also if this is just a phase and he changes his mind, people will not forget and he will have to live with that. Also he will be starting secondary school in September which will be a really tough transition for him. With his ASD he tends to become fixated/obsessed with a topic for months but then it's forgotten about and hes onto the next thing so wondering is this just the latest obsession. Just wondering what others would do if their 11 year old told them they where trans or if anyone else has been in this situation? Aibu to not let him dress as a girl?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Zigzagga · 24/01/2024 08:38

Could you let him wear girly clothes etc at home?

SoreAndTired1 · 24/01/2024 08:37

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 23:12

@Mary1234567 thank you. A few of the reasons he gave me for being trans is that he would be better at cooking, he hates football and that boys can't wear pink so I definitely think he is associating these things in strict gender categories. He said that life is easier for girls, girls are treated better than boys and girls clothes are prettier. According to him he is straight as in he likes girls.

Life is 'easier' for girls?! That made me gasp out loud. You really need to nip this in the bud and set him straight. Life is far harder for girls than it is boys. It sounds like he is not actually trans, he is just misogynistic and thinks girls have it easy and he sticks to stereotypes. Like 99% who say they are trans. It's all about misogynistic stereotypes, not truly actually feeling you are a different sex. Please tell him he is not trans, but he can wear dresses around the house if he wants to. But that's all. And please have a long talk and set his misogynistic ideals of girls and women straight, before he has done too much damage to himself and other girls.

AStrangeStateofMatter · 24/01/2024 08:36

@Cccc412 just to say also, my son has never had any negative reactions from his peers- a few questions and quizzical looks, but nothing that has ever upset him. I taught him to smile and say ‘because I like it’ if people ask why he is wearing xyz, and kids generally accept that which is presented to them with confidence and self assurance.

Caerulea · 24/01/2024 08:32

@ntmdino yep, that makes perfect sense to me. I suppose my situation was easier cos the clothes came first at a very young age, so we'd already broken that line of thinking before it even developed.

Emotionalsupportviper · 24/01/2024 08:31

cadburyegg · 23/01/2024 22:51

I would let your child wear what he wants, if it doesn't turn into anything then it doesn't matter. I would draw the line at hair extensions and makeup though because no 11 year olds need that

This.

But don't go down the pronouns rabbit hole.

Viviennemary · 24/01/2024 08:31

No I simply wouldn't allow this. He is a boy not a girl. Children need to be guided by people who hopefully know best. But perhaps allow him to wear a few girly things and hope he grows out of it like others have suggested. On the whole this is not a good thing but how to deal with it is difficult.

QueSyrahSyrah · 24/01/2024 08:31

I'd tell him that he can wear what he wants, enjoy what he wants, like and later love who he wants, but that he's irrefutably a boy.

But it's ok, because boys can enjoy cooking and hate football and wear pink and it doesn't make them not boys.

A family member went through this with her (SEN) son a bit older. Took him to Primark and let him buy a few bits of clothes and make-up to experiment with at home, which he did for a while and then lost interest in. 4 or 5 years later it turns out he's straight, masculine, and thrives working in an industry he loves that leans a bit more to the feminine.

frostyfeet · 24/01/2024 08:30

Mary1234567 · 23/01/2024 23:06

I am an autism specialist and one thing I would say is that autistic people can be very rigid and rule based for example, for them sometimes being trans can be the logical conclusion they come to, after absorbing gender stereotypes and taking them very literally and as very fixed. E.g. ‘ I like caring and I like cooking and art, and those are for girls so I am a girl. I don’t like football so I am not a boy’ or even ‘I want to marry a man not a woman so I am trans’ (when really they may grow up to be gay) basically I think one way you can help your child to explore their identity in a more nuanced way, is by helping them see that boys can wear pink, paint their nails, have long or short hair, etc. I would try to approach gender as something a bit more ‘grey’ than ‘black and white’ and see if they can find somewhere they’re comfortable and discover themselves, without drastic changes but without shaming their possible trans thoughts either. I hope that makes sense.

This, and the rest of @Mary1234567's posts make the most sense here although I wouldn't say rigid - I'd say love categories/classifications, and patterns, and structure. As she says I'd try to broaden his ideas of what girls and boys do, and dress like

xxSusanMxx · 24/01/2024 08:30

Hey,

just wanted to reach out as I have an 11 year old who is trans. Was male now presenting female. But my child has been talking about this for years and since starting secondary in September is a full time female.
it’s difficult to know what to do when they are still very young but all
advice I received from professionals is to let them be who they want to be and be there for support. There is a lot of help out there for parents and children 😊

AStrangeStateofMatter · 24/01/2024 08:29

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 22:49

@Grimbelina just wondering what other parents would do or have done in this situation. I am planning on speaking to the ASD team for advice but it's a bit late in the evening for that

I have a 10 year old son with asd. He goes through phases of wearing makeup, wanting high heels, having manicures, dying his (extremely long) hair pink etc.

He isn’t, and doesn’t think of himself as in any way trans, or girly or feminine.

I’ve always dealt with it by very clearly explaining that all things are for all people- there is no ‘for girls’ or ‘for boys’, there is only affordable, comfortable, appropriate (ie a coat in the rain, no high heels for 9 year olds) and whether he likes it.

He wears clothes from the boys or girls or women’s section as he likes- although he hasn’t ever shown interest in wearing skirts/dresses.

Have you explained that wanting to wear these clothes doesn’t make him trans or a girl- just a boy who likes what he likes? That is the important message.

ntmdino · 24/01/2024 08:29

Caerulea · 24/01/2024 08:21

@ntmdino @falalalalalalalallama

Out of curiosity, what do you define as social transitioning? Cos it should be changing name & pronouns.

Just wearing clothes whilst retaining your name & accepting your sex isn't social transitioning. No one thinks a girl wearing a hoody & jeans is socially transitioning.

Confining any behaviour to the house, out of sight, creates shame & in this case the shame of doing 'girly' things - the logical extension of that is that being a girl is shameful when you're obviously a boy.

It's far far better to try & instill confidence in their decisions. They want to wear a fitted t-shirt from the girls section? Fine. Someone will point it out, teach them how to deal with that. Prepare them for other people's ignorance but make it clear it's not their responsibility. They want to wear a t-shirt dress to go out, fine. Ppl will look but again, not his problem - theirs.

No, I'm totally with you there.

The idea that allowing him to wear PJs designed for girls will destroy his entire life is laughable at best.

I was simply agreeing with that suggestion as a means of gathering information on what to do next - the fact that he's autistic adds a wrinkle to the usual questions, because his thought processes in arriving at this conclusion are not necessarily what would be expected.

My entire point, I guess, is that ascertaining why he wants to do this is the single most important thing to do at this point, rather than just a flat "nope" and projecting personal or political biases onto him.

So...the suggestion of getting him homewear designed for girls is a logical first step in my opinion - not to make it shameful, just a "let's try this, then" in an environment where he won't be subject to other people's influence (positive or negative).

Emotionalsupportviper · 24/01/2024 08:28

Grimbelina · 23/01/2024 22:43

Suicide rates among trans youth is so high

I thought there wasn't good enough research to support this?

There isn't.

SoreAndTired1 · 24/01/2024 08:28

trippily · 23/01/2024 22:42

September is a long way away. You'll only make it more exciting if you forbid it, whilst driving a wedge between you.

She may also, just be trans. In which case it would be very damaging for her for you to deny her gender affirmation.

No doubt everyone will be here in a minute to tell you all trans people are evil calculating rapists (whilst simultaneously reminding you there's no transphobia on mumsnet ofc).

Suicide rates among trans youth is so high. I wouldn't risk it personally if it were my child. If it turns out not to be the thing who cares. Plenty of young people try identities on for size.

@trippily Suicide rates among trans youth is so high.

That is an absolute lie! A myth. Repeated by manipulative trans activists who lie and distort. And it is a very harmful lie that causes a lot of damage. Not least because it actual promotes Suicide Ideation. It is very dangerous of you to promote this lie. Most suicides are actually post-op. Trans youth have low rates of suicide. https://www.transgendertrend.com/the-suicide-myth/

Suicide Facts and Myths - Transgender Trend

The threat that children may commit suicide if parents do not support their social and medical transition is not born out by the facts.

https://www.transgendertrend.com/the-suicide-myth

BagsaMunroe · 24/01/2024 08:24

I expect no one will agree with me, but I doubt he is really wanting to be a girl and this is just a phase pre puberty.

I'd ignore it and say, no, I won't buy you those things.

The number of people who are genuinely trans is minute and the fact he is ASD would make me question his desire to change.

coldbrightmorning · 24/01/2024 08:23

No doubt everyone will be here in a minute to tell you all trans people are evil calculating rapists

You know,m @trippily, when I first stumbled across this debate a decade ago, it was realizing that your side was consistently lying about what the other side was saying, like you are here, that helped to convince me that it was the other side that was right.

Caerulea · 24/01/2024 08:21

@ntmdino @falalalalalalalallama

Out of curiosity, what do you define as social transitioning? Cos it should be changing name & pronouns.

Just wearing clothes whilst retaining your name & accepting your sex isn't social transitioning. No one thinks a girl wearing a hoody & jeans is socially transitioning.

Confining any behaviour to the house, out of sight, creates shame & in this case the shame of doing 'girly' things - the logical extension of that is that being a girl is shameful when you're obviously a boy.

It's far far better to try & instill confidence in their decisions. They want to wear a fitted t-shirt from the girls section? Fine. Someone will point it out, teach them how to deal with that. Prepare them for other people's ignorance but make it clear it's not their responsibility. They want to wear a t-shirt dress to go out, fine. Ppl will look but again, not his problem - theirs.

Calliopespa · 24/01/2024 08:17

midgetastic · 24/01/2024 07:36

When people label long hair as girls and short as boys, and bully them if they don't conform
When people take offence at being called a man if they are a woman

Then the world is putting nonsensical rules around living and making sex to be way more important than it really should be and restricting how people express themselves and their personality

The more we can beak free of those conventions the better for all of us

OP he seems to have a notion that pink is somehow a girls’ colour. Why not take him to some very traditional mens clothing stores ( Jermyn street would go the trick!) and let him see very traditional men’s styles in this colour ( shirts , socks, pullovers etc) . He probably won’t want them ( and if he does they aren’t too controversial) but it might help unlock the gender stereotypes notion around certain colours etc being for girls. Ironically, deep in the heart of traditional conservatism in clothing he may find there is more freedom than he realises!

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 24/01/2024 08:12

midgetastic · 24/01/2024 07:58

Behave like a boy means pee standing up
Anything else anyone ?

Not in some parts of Germany.......may I introduce you to the 'Sitzpinkler'.
Actually, it isn't just Germany but it's apparently more common there.

The term can be used in a derogatory way, to suggest a 'wimp', but also literally means sitting down to pee, and is used in reference to (biological) males.

user1492757084 · 24/01/2024 08:12

Caerulea, yes, it's true that the only thing just for girls are sanitary products and bras.
I was thinking about dressing in the girls' school uniform and going to school as a girl, really, and how that could prove difficult to come back from when he lost interest in being a girl.
Never does dressing like a girl mean weak or less than. Girls are strong. But dressing like a girl (school uniform) does send a message that he is a girl. Nothing wrong with being a girl except when you really are not/don't know/ want to go back to being a boy etc.
I was suggesting to follow school rules for boys.
I actually agree that boys can wear pink etc pink, no kids using hair dye, piercings (under age 16) and that decorative clothing is not an indication of being anything at all.

ntmdino · 24/01/2024 08:10

falalalalalalalallama · 24/01/2024 08:04

Or

  1. He's not actually trans, but after socially transitioning he gets fixated on being trans and goes through with blockers, hormones and medical transition. Ths blockers stunt his intellectual development as well as his sexual development, and he ends up as a sterile adult with multiple health issues including pain and incontinence. He never develops into a sexually mature adult - no sex drive or adult male genitals, instead a surgical wound that he must work to keep open on the off chance that he finds someone who wants to have sex with someone who can derive no or very little sexual pleasure from it.

"Few downsides" is hugely dangerous advice.

Please go read the Cass Report. Social transitioning is not a neutral act.

Edited

I guess you didn't read the whole quote chain, then. At no point did I suggest socially transitioning, I was seconding the idea of buying him the kind of clothes that can only be worn at home, in order to gain more information on what's going on in his head while minimising external influence.

ProperOuting · 24/01/2024 08:08

If he's autistic that will result in burnout. She needs one carefully chosen activity, at his level of social interaction to hyperfix on and take the place of woo.
Most importantly though, you need to see where this is coming from. I would be very surprised if it's not the internet.

ORLt · 24/01/2024 08:06

Urgently overload him with interesting activities, so he would choose a hobby that would consume him. Try maths, physics, chemistry, languages first. Then try gymnastics, hockey, ice hockey, chess, judo, etc. You are bound to find something that he would love. He would also be brilliant at it, if he finds something he really loves. When he will be really busy with his new hobby, he will have no time for idiotic idle thoughts of rivalling God and changing genders. Please please please don't destroy your child by buying him dresses. Basically, if he is so busy and productive, all he would think of is a healthy uninterrupted sleep when he comes home, he would have no energy for nonsense.

Calliopespa · 24/01/2024 08:05

Nestofwalnuts · 23/01/2024 23:26

This is great advice, as are @Mary1234567 other posts on this thread. So wise.

Agree

falalalalalalalallama · 24/01/2024 08:04

ntmdino · 24/01/2024 07:22

I haven't equated autism with being trans at all, and I haven't said anything about it being good or not. Please read exactly what I said without putting your own spin on it. EDIT: Oh, and in this interests of accuracy, you know what your autism feels like. Not his.

The point is that life is hard for him, he sees people treating girls nicer than he's being treated, and he's drawn the conclusion that life is easier that way, so why not be one? It's nothing to do with being "set straight" on gender politics, it's about him and his experience. So, if OP lets him wear girls' clothes, one of five things will happen:

1 - He discovers that life isn't actually easier when dressing as a girl.

2 - He doesn't like it and stops.

3 - It's one of the temporary fixations OP mentions, and it just naturally goes away as he loses interest.

4 - He is actually trans, and he sticks with it.

5 - Turns out he just likes girls' clothes, and wears them occasionally.

There are few downsides, really - OP needs more information on what's going on in his head, and this is the only reasonable way to get it without external influence.

And yes, I'm diagnosed autistic. I'm making no judgement at all here, on the basis that I know a number of trans autistic people and the misdiagnosis rate is around 50% amongst them.

Edited

Or

  1. He's not actually trans, but after socially transitioning he gets fixated on being trans and goes through with blockers, hormones and medical transition. Ths blockers stunt his intellectual development as well as his sexual development, and he ends up as a sterile adult with multiple health issues including pain and incontinence. He never develops into a sexually mature adult - no sex drive or adult male genitals, instead a surgical wound that he must work to keep open on the off chance that he finds someone who wants to have sex with someone who can derive no or very little sexual pleasure from it.

"Few downsides" is hugely dangerous advice.

Please go read the Cass Report. Social transitioning is not a neutral act.

Calliopespa · 24/01/2024 08:02

DNLove · 23/01/2024 23:11

I would work along with him but agree to small steps and explain you want him to be confident with his choices before going all in out in public so suggest starting with girls pj's, knickers, stuff that isn't blatant to others.
Tell him you'll support him but you'd like if both of you could learn that together.

Knickers!!? 😳They might not be well designed for the job! Agree the pjs etc but I think knickers and bikini might be my last items to suggest. ( I do get the under clothes aspect).

Swipe left for the next trending thread