Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not let him dress like a girl?

413 replies

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 22:37

Lo is 11 and has ASD (not sure if that's relevant). He's told me he is trans, wants me to buy him dresses, make up, hair extensions etc. This is the first time he has come out and said it although he has made comments about girls clothing being better etc over the past year so I had a feeling this was coming. Not sure how to approach this. My worry is if I do allow him to dress like a girl he will get picked on, he already struggles socially and has been bullied in the past. Also if this is just a phase and he changes his mind, people will not forget and he will have to live with that. Also he will be starting secondary school in September which will be a really tough transition for him. With his ASD he tends to become fixated/obsessed with a topic for months but then it's forgotten about and hes onto the next thing so wondering is this just the latest obsession. Just wondering what others would do if their 11 year old told them they where trans or if anyone else has been in this situation? Aibu to not let him dress as a girl?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Diverze · 24/01/2024 08:58

You have the protection of the new government guidance released in December that you can hide behind. This effectively says, no pronoun changes at primary and only in exceptional circumstances at secondary, no access to sports (at secondary) or spaces for the non-bio sex, third spaces can be offered.

I would not make a big deal of him buying and wearing a few items, or having room decor.

My own autistic son went through similar aged about 15. We bought him a pink t shirt and a T shirt with an anime girl on, he had a plain raspberry pink bedding set, he occasionally wore a small girly hair slide in his long hair. He's 20 now and happy to be a not-stereotypically-masculine guy, he still has long hair but doesn't wear anything "girly" and his pink bedding is just part of the regular rotation in his room, it's not special to him now.

Idontwantavaluablelimelesson · 24/01/2024 08:57

OP, Aibu mumsnet is the WOrSRT place to post for advice on this topic. (Minus the FWR board)

I agree AIBU can be a spiteful and biased place sometimes but in this case I think the advice is pretty good and the arguments mostly balanced. Any extreme views are being challenged

Ohnoooooooo · 24/01/2024 08:55

I think also regardless of what sex he was born some of the stuff like hair extensions are not age appropriate so say you are too young but you can have X at X age.
I do worry with autistic children that if they feel they don’t fit in they assume it’s because they are confused about their gender. They may be of course but they may not be too. It’s difficult for all teens at that age.

SloaneStreetVandal · 24/01/2024 08:55

AStrangeStateofMatter · 24/01/2024 08:29

I have a 10 year old son with asd. He goes through phases of wearing makeup, wanting high heels, having manicures, dying his (extremely long) hair pink etc.

He isn’t, and doesn’t think of himself as in any way trans, or girly or feminine.

I’ve always dealt with it by very clearly explaining that all things are for all people- there is no ‘for girls’ or ‘for boys’, there is only affordable, comfortable, appropriate (ie a coat in the rain, no high heels for 9 year olds) and whether he likes it.

He wears clothes from the boys or girls or women’s section as he likes- although he hasn’t ever shown interest in wearing skirts/dresses.

Have you explained that wanting to wear these clothes doesn’t make him trans or a girl- just a boy who likes what he likes? That is the important message.

I somewhat agree with this.
Gender questions are prevelant in the ASD community. Its incredibly difficult though for a clinician, never mind a parent, to determine (or even attempt to determine, whilst navigating the tedious 'you're a TERF' brigade) if its actually part of the condition, rather than an aspect of identity.

ComeAlongPeggy · 24/01/2024 08:55

Argh, I know a girl living as a boy! Not the other way around….

Tandora · 24/01/2024 08:54

HowDoTheyGetThroughLife · 23/01/2024 23:04

Correct. HE is a BOY, and should be encouraged to behave as a boy

should be encouraged to behave as a boy

what does this mean??

ComeAlongPeggy · 24/01/2024 08:53

@Cccc412 what is “dressing like a girl”? When I was an 11 year old girl I wore jeans and T-shirts. I didn’t own make up, my hair was tied back and my main hobbies were cooking, guides, reading, tennis and cycling around with my friends.

I’d remind your son that there are many ways to be a boy and he can be whatever kind of boy he wants. But he is a boy. I’d also talk about gender stereotypes and point out people in his life who don’t fit them (I’m sure there are plenty!).

Almost every child and adult I know irl who is trans is also ASD. It’s no coincidence. I think it’s so damaging to gas light children by saying “yes, you can be a girl if you want to” when they can’t. So much kinder to help them accept their bodies and express themselves however they like.

I would say that although I don’t think it’s a big deal for an 11 year old boy to wear dresses etc, it will stay with him and children will remember as they grow up. And whichever poster suggested getting him girls pants - I think that’s a bit weird. Really weird actually. And gives a secretive air to it all.

I know a boy who has been living as a girl for a few years now (primary age). It’s going to be SO hard for her to stop “being a boy” if she wants to. But puberty is looming and she’s going to look less like a boy each year!

Anyway. I just think it’s ok to be honest and vital to reiterate that girls are not one homogenous mass of make up wearing, high heel tottering, long haired people. Especially at 11!

Tandora · 24/01/2024 08:53

OP, Aibu mumsnet is the WOrSRT place to post for advice on this topic. (Minus the FWR board) .

anyolddinosaur · 24/01/2024 08:53

Forgot to say that my young relative is autistic, not sure about their partner. Until my relative transitioned I knew very little about this subject. I then researched it carefully and I am sad that they fell into the hands of the Tavistock. Time to Think is a good exploration of a medical scandal.

HollyKnight · 24/01/2024 08:51

Caliope27 · 24/01/2024 08:46

What ever happened to cross dressing? A desire to take on the appearance of opposite sex doesn't mean that the individual 'he' should start to be called a 'she' or vice versa.
That first reply - it says everything that's wrong for me at the moment. Of course nurture difference and choices, but don't immediately jump in making assumptions that could change a child's life.
My best friends are a couple who, from what she says, have a 'full' life together. Two children. He's a cross dresser and comfortably hints at that in his everyday appearance. He is not gay though, and he doesn't claim to be a woman.

Cross dressing is a fetish though. It's about getting a (sexual) thrill from dressing as the opposite sex. It is not the same as thinking you are the opposite sex.

DuckinEl · 24/01/2024 08:50

Agree with first poster.

My child with autism (F to M) let me know aged 10 they were trans, we explored what that meant, he could wear clothes that were 'boy clothes' and do any thing a boy could, he didnt need to be one. He was adamant that he didn't want to be one, he WAS one and his outside body didn't match.
After a year of doing nothing apart from talking, he was still adamant. He showed all 'signs' expected with trans growing up (only male friends from an early age, saying he was a boy from very young, as a few examples)
He's 16 now and he's so much a boy, if anyone meets him they never know he was born female.. He has struggled a little in school but 99% of his peers have been accepting and he has a very large friendship group (after not having one and struggling in primary).

No matter what we would have done it would not have changed how he felt or his decision changing his gender as an adult. And I know I'd prefer a trans child rather then a dead one (and I say this as a mother of a child with a life limiting condition who will die young)

As a side note - there seems to be a connection with autism and being trans, a high percent of autistic people are trans.
To my son it made no difference when I told him this ~ he still explained that even if it was his autism making him trans it was still making him feel the way he felt.

Needanewnamebeingwatched · 24/01/2024 08:48

My son would wear Disney dress up all the time, two older sisters that was fine.

My grandson (9) says he wants to be a girl, I've said he can dress up and wear dresses, wigs, but he will be a boy doing these things and that's ok.

He said when he is older he can get boobs, I said he can, but he will still be a boy with boobs.

I think let him wear what he wants, but reiterate he will always be a boy, no matter what he wears or what his does to himself.

DeeLusional · 24/01/2024 08:47

Scutterbug · 23/01/2024 22:53

I agree with @trippily. Also, what pronouns do they want to use? As your parent you are their closest ally and they need your support but this is mumsnet and most will disagree although they are apparently not transphobic.

If not wanting to poison, sterilise and mutilate children makes me transphobic then yes, I am.

Caliope27 · 24/01/2024 08:46

What ever happened to cross dressing? A desire to take on the appearance of opposite sex doesn't mean that the individual 'he' should start to be called a 'she' or vice versa.
That first reply - it says everything that's wrong for me at the moment. Of course nurture difference and choices, but don't immediately jump in making assumptions that could change a child's life.
My best friends are a couple who, from what she says, have a 'full' life together. Two children. He's a cross dresser and comfortably hints at that in his everyday appearance. He is not gay though, and he doesn't claim to be a woman.

diddl · 24/01/2024 08:45

So he doesn't really want to be a girl-just thinks that as he doesn't enjoy stereotypical boy things then he isn't a boy?

I wish that being a woman automatically made you a good cook!

wossgoinon · 24/01/2024 08:44

My son went through this ‘stage’ buying wigs off the internet and dressing up. I let him get on with it. It lasted about 6 weeks and all of a sudden it stopped. I tried not to make a big thing of it. Now he is gay man and proud of it it 🥰

falalalalalalalallama · 24/01/2024 08:44

xxSusanMxx · 24/01/2024 08:30

Hey,

just wanted to reach out as I have an 11 year old who is trans. Was male now presenting female. But my child has been talking about this for years and since starting secondary in September is a full time female.
it’s difficult to know what to do when they are still very young but all
advice I received from professionals is to let them be who they want to be and be there for support. There is a lot of help out there for parents and children 😊

Have you read Time To Think by Hannah Barnes?

It shows how many professionals have been captured by ideology and are not promoting evidence based medicine.

Heck, the entire GIDs service is being closed down as it got it so wrong.

I would strongly suggest doing your own research rather than simply trusting professionals in this area. Speak to parent support groups that won't push the idea that being trans is simply an option that children can choose to be "their true selves" as this is not an evidence based approach and can lead to great harm if they end up going down the medical route.

Bayswater Support is an excellent organisation for parents.

https://www.bayswatersupport.org.uk/

Bayswater Support – For Parents with Trans-identified Kids

https://www.bayswatersupport.org.uk

0MammaBear0 · 24/01/2024 08:44

trippily · 23/01/2024 22:42

September is a long way away. You'll only make it more exciting if you forbid it, whilst driving a wedge between you.

She may also, just be trans. In which case it would be very damaging for her for you to deny her gender affirmation.

No doubt everyone will be here in a minute to tell you all trans people are evil calculating rapists (whilst simultaneously reminding you there's no transphobia on mumsnet ofc).

Suicide rates among trans youth is so high. I wouldn't risk it personally if it were my child. If it turns out not to be the thing who cares. Plenty of young people try identities on for size.

Plenty of studies have been done, medical and social "transitions" doesn't decrease suicide rates. Telling parents that if they don't allow their kids to "transition" will kill them is a cruel and dangerous lie

Mstxxx · 24/01/2024 08:43

Honestly this is a really hard situation to be in and know what the best/right thing to do is… my best friend (since 11 years old) is transgender and has been presenting as female since we were 14, on the other hand my brother (16) has autism so I can see it from both perspectives.

In terms of my best friend, her parents tried to stifle it as particularly back then, it was not as acceptable as it is today, and this had horrible effects on my friend, and she made attempts on her life at a very young age because of it. My friend is now in her 30s and had the full surgeries etc and has never looked back, therefore it certainly wasn’t a phase. I knew her as her previous self and her current self and honestly I don’t see her as anything other than a woman.

on the other hand, if my autistic brother were to say this to me I would have reservations as I know he often does/says things that he gets a temporary attachment to and then changes his mind in a few weeks/months. He cycles between being straight/bisexual every few weeks although he has never shown any interest in boys. We just let him know it doesn’t matter to us what he feels he is and we love him either way and it’s ok to change his mind if he feels that way.

I don’t think there is a wrong/right answer.

anyolddinosaur · 24/01/2024 08:43

I have a young trans relative. They are fortunate in that they do have a partner, also trans. They are less fortunate in that their (same sex) partner is unable to work full time and they are also being to suffer health issues from the medication they take. They are both still young, the health problems can only get worse. Both are probably sterile.

Transition damages physical health. If they take puberty blockers there may be a drop in IQ. There is conflicting evidence on the risk of suicide, some that shows those who take puberty blockers have a higher suicide risk. Much of the so called "research" is actually so badly carried out that propaganda is a more accurate description. Always consider carefully who is funding it. Males who take puberty blockers will not grow a large enough penis to make a neo vagina and if they want one will need to have it made from some other body part, often the colon. That will not increase the number of people who will consider sex with them.

Transitioning a child is not something anyone should undertake - or support - lightly, yet fools do. Good advice was offered upthread on where to seek help. I'll quote it.

"I would recommend two places for support - Bayswater Support is for parents of kids who think they're trans, but won't push the narrative that they must transition on you.
https://www.bayswatersupport.org.uk/

Stella O'Malley is a psychotherapist who does some great work in this area. Look her up or contact her and see if she can put you in touch with a therapist near you who will help your son explore what is actually going on here, rather than push a trans identity on him.

Her organisation Genspect has lots of resources for parents:https://genspect.org/support/support-for-parents-and-relatives/

She co-authored a book that came out last year, "When Kids Say They're Trans: A guide for thoughtful parents" that I think you would find useful.

https://amzn.eu/d/hcw2k7I?tag=mumsnet&ascsubtag=mnforum-21 "

Try to find out who is putting these ideas into your son's head as he is being influenced. Watch Masterchef and cook with him. Show him the English football team and talk about how successful they were. Let him grow his hair but tell him no 11 year old should have hair extensions and make up at school, he can try make up at home if he wishes. Explain that life as a girl is not easier, tall about periods, childbirth, sex discrimination, male violence. Ask where he got the idea it would be easier.

DeeLusional · 24/01/2024 08:42

Grimbelina · 23/01/2024 22:42

I am surprised you aren't contacting charities, professionals etc. skilled in this area to help you navigate this, and are instead posting on AIBU (not the SEN board etc...)

Getting involved with some of the "charities" and other organisations "skilled in this area" is the entrance to the rabbit hole. Their raison d'etre is to transition children and any attempt to help children think otherwise they call "aversion therapy".

0MammaBear0 · 24/01/2024 08:42

This is social contagion, probably picked it up on social media if he has a phone or access to youtube/tik tok... Absolutely don't let him, there's plenty of people who are "detransing" and regret to have permanently mutilated their bodies

VaddaABeetch · 24/01/2024 08:42

Have you explained to him the physical reality of being a girl. Periods, pain , fluctuating hormones. The male gaze. That as a woman you’re always too fat or too thin or your beasts are too big or too small.

It’s not about play acting with makeup & ling hair. He can still have those things as a boy.

It doesn’t make him a girl. He can never be a girl.

Isitreallythough · 24/01/2024 08:40

LeavesOnTrees · 23/01/2024 23:12

Also regarding my son I think a lot of the gender stereotypes, you might be trans if you like pink, is a load of bollocks (i've probably just offended half the internet).
I just wanted him to express himself however he wanted without any external influences.

Children like dressing up and experimenting.

Yes. A boy might just like pink, or want to try on a dress or two (like my small boy), and I think it’s a really good idea to let them have flexibility and challenge the stereotypes. There was another thread here suggesting that a boy with long hair was bound to get comments... If we challenged that enough and supported individual children expressing themselves as they liked I think we’d be really doing them a favour.
I don’t doubt some people are trans and I accept and support people who’ve come to that conclusion. But colour and hobby preferences shouldn’t be reasons to think that you can’t possibly be the right sex/gender.

frostyfeet · 24/01/2024 08:38

SoreAndTired1 · 24/01/2024 08:37

Life is 'easier' for girls?! That made me gasp out loud. You really need to nip this in the bud and set him straight. Life is far harder for girls than it is boys. It sounds like he is not actually trans, he is just misogynistic and thinks girls have it easy and he sticks to stereotypes. Like 99% who say they are trans. It's all about misogynistic stereotypes, not truly actually feeling you are a different sex. Please tell him he is not trans, but he can wear dresses around the house if he wants to. But that's all. And please have a long talk and set his misogynistic ideals of girls and women straight, before he has done too much damage to himself and other girls.

He is an autistic child who probably doesn't have huge experience of life - hardly misogynistic!