Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not let him dress like a girl?

413 replies

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 22:37

Lo is 11 and has ASD (not sure if that's relevant). He's told me he is trans, wants me to buy him dresses, make up, hair extensions etc. This is the first time he has come out and said it although he has made comments about girls clothing being better etc over the past year so I had a feeling this was coming. Not sure how to approach this. My worry is if I do allow him to dress like a girl he will get picked on, he already struggles socially and has been bullied in the past. Also if this is just a phase and he changes his mind, people will not forget and he will have to live with that. Also he will be starting secondary school in September which will be a really tough transition for him. With his ASD he tends to become fixated/obsessed with a topic for months but then it's forgotten about and hes onto the next thing so wondering is this just the latest obsession. Just wondering what others would do if their 11 year old told them they where trans or if anyone else has been in this situation? Aibu to not let him dress as a girl?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Winterstormm · 24/01/2024 09:29

steppemum · 24/01/2024 09:24

I've PM'd you.
This is a really difficult topic to discuss on here.
While there can be good advice, some people are just incredibly hurtful.
They forget that real people are behind these posts

It isn't really a difficult topic. Children should be told about gender stereotypes and that it's fine to go against these stereotypes. My brother sometimes dressed as a girl lower down in primary school. He's straight and definitely a man, but likes the odd pink thing.

OP could find pink boxers and pink t-shirts to show her son that it's ok to like pink. She also needs to talk about puberty and how girls don't 'have it easy.'

SuddenlyOld · 24/01/2024 09:27

Well times have changed and this gender experimentation is more acceptable now. My son wanted dolls so he got dolls. My daughter loved to play football but when I bought her a football she complained because it was a boy's toy.

I didn't try to impose gender specific toys or gender social cues at all. But they developed their own. This was in the 80s btw

One of my friends is much younger than me and I respect her parenting above all others. Her son dresses how he wants. He's grown his hair and mainly wears dresses. He doesn't want to be a girl. He has choices. He doesn't get bullied. He has the confidence to be himself.

I don't know the answer but I do have opinions. My opinion is that western gender classification is outdated. In most other cultures it's the men who dress up and wear makeup etc (traditionally I mean, tribesmen etc). Even in the animal kingdom the males have all the colour and flamboyance.

I strongly disagree with giving anyone hormones to change their biology. I also disagree with surgery for the same. (Note, surgery for health conditions where biology is ambiguous, like Turners syndrome, is not the same as 'normal' biology being changed).

YouJustDoYou · 24/01/2024 09:27

anyolddinosaur · 24/01/2024 09:26

@Tandora This is everywhere because trans activists often start such threads. If the OP is not a TRA looking for comments they can quote elsewhere they need help - and not the sort of help that forces gender stereotypes on their child. TRAs want to enforce gender stereotypes. misogyny and homophobia. OP needs signposting to support that will let her child develop their own personality without physically harming them.

This, exactly.

anyolddinosaur · 24/01/2024 09:26

@Tandora This is everywhere because trans activists often start such threads. If the OP is not a TRA looking for comments they can quote elsewhere they need help - and not the sort of help that forces gender stereotypes on their child. TRAs want to enforce gender stereotypes. misogyny and homophobia. OP needs signposting to support that will let her child develop their own personality without physically harming them.

YouJustDoYou · 24/01/2024 09:25

Lying to children is abhorrent. Your son can put on girl-costume, but he will never be a girl.

steppemum · 24/01/2024 09:24

I've PM'd you.
This is a really difficult topic to discuss on here.
While there can be good advice, some people are just incredibly hurtful.
They forget that real people are behind these posts

Potentialmadcatlady · 24/01/2024 09:18

I have asd/adhd adult ds.
When he was little he played with prams- I let him. When he was 7 he wanted to be a train driver. When he was 10 he wanted to be a chef. Now he doesn’t have a clue what he wants to do.
When he was 11 he told me he was gay and I told him not a problem ( massive problem for his father who I am divorced from) but I did advise him to think about it as his life was hard enough due to his various medical conditions. We discussed lifestyle choices as opposed to it being ‘him’ intrinsically.

When he was 17 he brought home his first love- a girl.
When he was young he had his hair right down his back, when he was 12 he saved it to the wood and dyed it green. When he was 19 he grew it long again and now it is somewhere inbetween. When he was young he wouldn’t wear clothes in house, when he was 9 he only would clothes on his top half because ‘bottom’ clothes were uncomfortable. Since he was 10 he has worn various ‘dressing gowns of doom’ in house so he was ‘covered up’ but comfy.
As an adult he has a set wardrobe of black joggers with old trainers and soft T-shirts and will occasionally wear a hoody if he’s cold.
He never wore a tie fully up in school ( had permission) or put his top button in. He also wore trainers to school and on most days plain black joggers.
He is massively sensory seeking and will literally not wear anything he considers uncomfortable.
I let him, I support him but I don’t encourage him when he is focused on something as I know in a few months he will likely swap again.
I didn’t let him have age inappropriate clothing/toys etc.
I wouldn’t have let my ds wear hair extensions at age 11. I wouldn’t have let her wear inappropriate clothing. I wouldn’t have let my ds either but I did listen and work with him to find clothing that was comfortable for him.
There is a lady right now on tic tock who is de transing as she realises, as an adult, that she simply wanted to be more comfortable and she has realised that actually being dressed in gender neutral clothes is all she ever needed. She hasn’t told her family yet as she is worried about the fallout.
What I’m saying is that your son is very young and I believe in treating young kids as young kids. Supporting them but also helping them realise that life with asd can be hard enough. It’s a very tough time for a young teen to grow into and peer pressure is so high at min.

AlphariusOmegron · 24/01/2024 09:14

It is not dangerous to not affirm, it's dangerous to tell them you don't love them however they are. It's also incredibly regressive, and sexist to say that only females can wear dresses and like pink - for example. A male can do all of those things and be happy - gender, if it exists at all (and a majority do not) is entirely cultural and therefore not a rule, just a feel. He can wear whatever he wants, still a boy, girls can wear and do anything. So can boys.

I would really recommend this book:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/When-Kids-Say-Theyre-Trans/dp/1800752644/ref=tmm_pap_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=1706087419&sr=8-1

and this podcast (this specific episode and the rest)

There is a lot more to this than just saying yes - affirmation is not neutral, don;t jump on either side and possibly hurt your child. Please look at the bigger picture and quickly.

My son, at 11, who hates football, said these things to me - he's never done a stereotypically girly thing in his life, but the culture has pointed him at trans as a solution and a label

When Kids Say They're Trans—A Webinar with Sasha Ayad, Stella O'Malley, and Lisa Marchiano

On August 27, 2023 we held a webinar based on our new book: "When Kids Say They're Trans"Here are links to the resources mentioned in the episode:Our Book We...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dJAq9-Nhbcs

SoreAndTired1 · 24/01/2024 09:14

Tandora · 24/01/2024 09:09

Oh yes, those “gender ideologists” who think children should be allowed to express themselves regardless of gender, and don’t think it’s ok to tell a child he has to “behave like a boy”. Such “ideologists” they are .

WTF is a “gender ideologist” anyway? Thats a dog whistle term made up to undermine trans experience.

Anyway I don’t have the time for this today, it’s every bloody day at the minute on mumsnet- several threads, everywhere, not just on the FWR board, but all over AIBU. If you are not trans, close to someone trans, have no really knowledge and understanding of trans issues, how about talking about something else for a bloody change.

Expressing yourself is fine, believing you are actually the other sex, is not. That's the difference.

A Gender Ideologist is one who buys into the religious cult of Gender Ideology. And it is a cult, as Richard Dawkins says.

Yes, there are so many threads because womens and girls rights are being taken away, and we are sick and bloody tired of it! So we won't stop talking about it. We don't need to have knowledge or understanding of this to know that women and girls deserve human rights. Sorry that upsets you, but women say NO and we will NEVER stop fighting for our human rights.

midgetastic · 24/01/2024 09:13

A child who expresses the belief that they are the other sex is highly likely to be peeved at the different treatment of boys and girls and horrified at the changing body

At least that was my personal experience

In the days when fortunately people just let you get on with growing up rather than trying to "treat" you in ways that can lead to the sterilisation of the none conforming

Calliopespa · 24/01/2024 09:13

Tandora · 24/01/2024 09:09

Oh yes, those “gender ideologists” who think children should be allowed to express themselves regardless of gender, and don’t think it’s ok to tell a child he has to “behave like a boy”. Such “ideologists” they are .

WTF is a “gender ideologist” anyway? Thats a dog whistle term made up to undermine trans experience.

Anyway I don’t have the time for this today, it’s every bloody day at the minute on mumsnet- several threads, everywhere, not just on the FWR board, but all over AIBU. If you are not trans, close to someone trans, have no really knowledge and understanding of trans issues, how about talking about something else for a bloody change.

Because it is an issue that is increasingly affecting society at large and everyone has a right to discuss it.
I do agree that there is nothing more irritating that the “ ist” terms. It’s an attempt to dismiss a point of view by making it sound like a pathological issue.

NettleTea · 24/01/2024 09:10

the 'life is easier for girls' trope comes from the incel community. And sadly, if he is surrounded by a bunch of overtly macho posturing boys (dont forget this is year 6, a year of a bit over confident and big for their boots know it alls at that point) then he may be judging from what the most Alpha of this group is saying.
If he is like my son, he will find those boys intimidating.
My son, who is now coming up to 18, has ASD, and hates football. He is a kind, sensitive, quiet boy, who until around year 3 preferred to hang out with the girls because they seemed kinder, wanted to play imaginative games, and were not interested in football - which seemed to be the majority defining element of 'being a boy' at that point - as well as being pretty loud and alot of rough housing.
He struggled when the girls started to not want to play with boys, and was bullied for a while, until he found a couple of boys in the year above (also both a bit individual, but confident enough to withstand being odd) and they bonded over quite a niche computer game they liked, as opposed to Fortnite, and the like, which everyone else played.
He had long hair, and had loved pink at nursery, until he was sharply put in his place about that colour when he went to school. However at year 6 he was confident to just say 'yes Im wierd' and roll with it.
Secondary was even more narrow in the definition of what it was to be a boy or a girl, and he was constantly asked if he was gay, because he wasnt, at 11, asking girls out, interested in them sexually, interested in football, and playing the wrong games. He was bullied again. I changed his school in yr 9 and put him in an idependant small school with a heavy inclusion of creative and performing arts, and he has flourished. Even wore his best Bright Pink shirt to Prom. Incidentally, in that school, where everyone is encouraged to be a confident well rounded child, where individuality is quietly accepted, there are alot of children who are gay, lesbian or bisexual, and its really positive to see that it simply isnt an issue at all. Mixed sex friendgroups are also common, and there are straight girls who are what some would consider 'boyish' and boys who are quite effeminate - it seems to have no bearing on their sexuality. But there are no trans kids.

falalalalalalalallama · 24/01/2024 09:10

Caerulea · 24/01/2024 08:21

@ntmdino @falalalalalalalallama

Out of curiosity, what do you define as social transitioning? Cos it should be changing name & pronouns.

Just wearing clothes whilst retaining your name & accepting your sex isn't social transitioning. No one thinks a girl wearing a hoody & jeans is socially transitioning.

Confining any behaviour to the house, out of sight, creates shame & in this case the shame of doing 'girly' things - the logical extension of that is that being a girl is shameful when you're obviously a boy.

It's far far better to try & instill confidence in their decisions. They want to wear a fitted t-shirt from the girls section? Fine. Someone will point it out, teach them how to deal with that. Prepare them for other people's ignorance but make it clear it's not their responsibility. They want to wear a t-shirt dress to go out, fine. Ppl will look but again, not his problem - theirs.

I would say that understanding the context Is essential, and that to describe social transitioning only as changing name and pronouns is overly simplistic in my opinion.

Transitioning is a process (it's recognised as such in the Equality Act).

A child who wears clothes associated with the other sex, but has no confusion about their sex/gender isn't socially transitioning, of course not. (FWIW, this describes me as a child, I hated "girls" clothes).

But if a child is expressing that they want to be the other sex, then wearing clothes traditionally associated with that sex could very well be the beginning of social transitioning.

I'm not saying they should be prevented from wearing such clothes necessarily. But that saying "crack on, let them wear what they like, nothing bad will happen" is potentially irresponsible / dangerous advice and not a reflection of reality.

For many DC who take this path, it has further developed into a medical transitioning with the significant health risks outlined in previous posts.

If one of my DC was expressing a desire to be the opposite sex, that would be my cue to get them and me appropriate support from an organisation that's not promoting gender ideology, and to explore with them what's going on, and how best to move forward, while making sure they know actually changing sex is impossible.

Whether the best approach for that individual child includes wearing clothes associated with the opposite sex or not depends on that child and what the wearing of such clothes means to them.

Blithely suggesting the child should cross dress within or outside the home and nothing bad could come of it is irresponsible given the huge risks associated with medical transition and the very real pressure from multiple sources online and at school that young gender non confirming DC will be under to "accept" a trans identity.

FWIW, when my DS started secondary he had long hair. He had no question about his gender, but he had to put up with other kids constantly asking if he was trans / a girl / wanted to be a girl. Luckily he falls into the category of DC who are confident and don't care what others think, but let's be honest here, being a pre-teen and teen is a tough time and few posess such confidence in the face of peer pressure. I certainly didn't, but luckily when I dressed "like a boy" it was seen as perfectly normal and no one asked me if I wanted to be one.

Sorry that's so long winded!

TL:DR - this is a complex issue, there's no one-size-fits-all approach. Youth medical transition seriously damages health and anything that could push a child towards it needs to be treated with extreme caution.

Tandora · 24/01/2024 09:09

SoreAndTired1 · 24/01/2024 09:04

No it's the BEST place to post because it is full of wise and sage advice. (Despite the Gender Ideologists trying to muddy the waters)

Oh yes, those “gender ideologists” who think children should be allowed to express themselves regardless of gender, and don’t think it’s ok to tell a child he has to “behave like a boy”. Such “ideologists” they are .

WTF is a “gender ideologist” anyway? Thats a dog whistle term made up to undermine trans experience.

Anyway I don’t have the time for this today, it’s every bloody day at the minute on mumsnet- several threads, everywhere, not just on the FWR board, but all over AIBU. If you are not trans, close to someone trans, have no really knowledge and understanding of trans issues, how about talking about something else for a bloody change.

Ladylalaboo1 · 24/01/2024 09:07

My 9 year old daughter went through this from the age of about 3 until 7. She started off just saying she wanted to be a boy and wearing boys clothes so we just bought her what clothes she felt most comfortable in etc during I'd say year 2&3 at school it peaked. She didn't use the girls bathrooms, and didn't call herself by her female name, opted for a boys name and wanted everyone to call her this in school ( but not at home ) it was a difficult time mainly because I just worried so much about the stigma and how she was being perceived by her peers and their parents. The school were and still are fantastic. The most important thing to us is that she was our child and we wanted to make her feel as safe and happy as possible. The fact your son is able to speak to you and explain his feelings is incredible and shows how brave they are. Some children don't feel they are able to do this. Ultimately towards the end of year 3 she started wanting to be referred to her given name again and didn't mind being called a girl. Now she wears a lot more feminine clothing, calls herself a girl and is proud of that. Who knows if she will explore another identity again, but we just continuously make her aware that she's supported and safe at home and can speak with us about everything. It's such a hard thing to navigate and there isn't really a strict right or wrong way of doing it, just be subtle with the changes and allow them to explore what makes them feel most comfortable. We always asked if our daughter wanted to be called a boy or not ( which was hard for us, it was almost like a grieving of the child you did have ) however she didn't want this just wanted to be nothing specific, no labels. If you don't allow it it will become more of a thing and potentially make it a bigger issue then it ever was going to be. Speak with the school and have a look online for some local charities that can give you support. My dms are always open if you needed a chat xx

Idontwantavaluablelimelesson · 24/01/2024 09:05

Sd1960 · 24/01/2024 08:59

Pink dressing gowns and fluffy pillows. Is that what being a girl is?

Exactly! This is exactly what's wrong with the world and how we're approaching this topic with impressionable kids.

My favourite pjs were my teenage mutant ninja turtles ones at this age, almost certainly from the 'boys' section. I also had thunderbirds and turtles stationary and got a bit teased as they were for 'boys'. I had my hair like a boy for a while too. I'm a married, heterosexual adult now who enjoys being girly and dressing girly but is also very happy to watch football or an action film with my dh. I do wonder if I'd had a histrionic parent who latched on to the fact that I was a tomboy and made a massive thing of it how different my life might be especially in current times.....

Calliopespa · 24/01/2024 09:05

Isitreallythough · 24/01/2024 08:40

Yes. A boy might just like pink, or want to try on a dress or two (like my small boy), and I think it’s a really good idea to let them have flexibility and challenge the stereotypes. There was another thread here suggesting that a boy with long hair was bound to get comments... If we challenged that enough and supported individual children expressing themselves as they liked I think we’d be really doing them a favour.
I don’t doubt some people are trans and I accept and support people who’ve come to that conclusion. But colour and hobby preferences shouldn’t be reasons to think that you can’t possibly be the right sex/gender.

That’s right. It’s about opening his mind to the fact that you can overlay so many aspects of life ( style, colour, hobbies) you like or enjoy onto your own gender and make it part of your gender without the need to abandon it. Some people clearly want to actually change gender; but at 11 I think you have to seriously explore the possibility that he just needs support with the former, and I think it’s important to do that in a way that doesn’t send the message to others that it’s the latter or he may find the momentum to push him in that direction escalates. There are a very few careers and styles of clothing that don’t cross gender well. I’ve seen a few men modelling women’s lingerie which didn’t exactly make me feel like buying that particular bra and which I actually didn’t like because I felt that rather than promoting a breakdown of stereotypes, it ( probably inadvertently) actually took the piss . But broadly speaking , there isn’t that much a male can’t embrace: househusband, fashion designer, florist … I’d let him fully explore ways of embracing what he loves AND his gender before considering too seriously whether it’s the gender itself he has an issue with. And I’m sure a number of people do. Fwiw I don’t think he’s a misogynist as suggested upthread. It’s a bit of pubertal “grass is greener” at most. But I think he probably genuinely quite likes some traditionally girly things. And why not? There are lots of males weaving those threads into their identity and I think he needs to see a bit more of that. I’d try for now, though, to do it in a way that still reaffirms his gender. Brands like super dry make obviously male t shirts, hoodies etc but in glorious shades of pink, coral, watermelon ..,

Tandora · 24/01/2024 09:05

Mary1234567 · 23/01/2024 23:06

I am an autism specialist and one thing I would say is that autistic people can be very rigid and rule based for example, for them sometimes being trans can be the logical conclusion they come to, after absorbing gender stereotypes and taking them very literally and as very fixed. E.g. ‘ I like caring and I like cooking and art, and those are for girls so I am a girl. I don’t like football so I am not a boy’ or even ‘I want to marry a man not a woman so I am trans’ (when really they may grow up to be gay) basically I think one way you can help your child to explore their identity in a more nuanced way, is by helping them see that boys can wear pink, paint their nails, have long or short hair, etc. I would try to approach gender as something a bit more ‘grey’ than ‘black and white’ and see if they can find somewhere they’re comfortable and discover themselves, without drastic changes but without shaming their possible trans thoughts either. I hope that makes sense.

So if gender is based on false stereotypes (which you a sophisticated, neurotypical adult can of course see, but those rigidly thinking autistic children cannot) why does this child need to discover ‘himself’ with moderate rather than “drastic” changes? What does that mean exactly? - Drastic? So a pink hue to his sweater is ok, but a skirt is not? What clothes are acceptable to you in what contexts?
He can have sex with men, but not dress as a girl? Who set the rules? You? And what are they based on?

XMissPlacedX · 24/01/2024 09:04

I feel for you op, the bullying would worry me too. Im not sure how me and dh would feel if ds wanted to wear girls clothes and i can understand why you are worried.

SoreAndTired1 · 24/01/2024 09:04

Tandora · 24/01/2024 08:53

OP, Aibu mumsnet is the WOrSRT place to post for advice on this topic. (Minus the FWR board) .

No it's the BEST place to post because it is full of wise and sage advice. (Despite the Gender Ideologists trying to muddy the waters)

Comedycook · 24/01/2024 09:04

I'd say no to hair extensions and make up....I wouldn't allow any 11 year old to wear extensions and make up.

I'd probably let him wear what he wants at home but tell him that the outside world is cruel and that by wearing traditionally female clothing, he may struggle more to make friends or be a target for teasing. Also, if it is a phase and he eventually forgets about this, he will forever be known for it amongst his peers.

LondonLass91 · 24/01/2024 09:03

Well i'd wonder what social media he was watching and who was grooming him..because a child doesn't think they are trans just because they like 'girlie' things. Tiktok is the main culprit for this, the algorithms are absolutely a nightmare. Just have a watch of some of the videos aimed at kids telling them they must be trans. Heartbreaking. So stop him watching that shit for a start, if you are. Also, tell him that no one is born in the wrong body, he can wear as many sparkly dresses as he likes, he is still a boy.

Sd1960 · 24/01/2024 09:01

Yet considering they are a tiny minority, don’t we hear about them a little too much?

Sd1960 · 24/01/2024 08:59

Pink dressing gowns and fluffy pillows. Is that what being a girl is?

SoreAndTired1 · 24/01/2024 08:58

frostyfeet · 24/01/2024 08:38

He is an autistic child who probably doesn't have huge experience of life - hardly misogynistic!

I'm autistic too. Autistic people are not immune from having misogynistic beliefs. I honestly don't know why you think they are. Though granted he doesn't have huge experience in life, but he is picking up these beliefs from somewhere.