Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not let him dress like a girl?

413 replies

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 22:37

Lo is 11 and has ASD (not sure if that's relevant). He's told me he is trans, wants me to buy him dresses, make up, hair extensions etc. This is the first time he has come out and said it although he has made comments about girls clothing being better etc over the past year so I had a feeling this was coming. Not sure how to approach this. My worry is if I do allow him to dress like a girl he will get picked on, he already struggles socially and has been bullied in the past. Also if this is just a phase and he changes his mind, people will not forget and he will have to live with that. Also he will be starting secondary school in September which will be a really tough transition for him. With his ASD he tends to become fixated/obsessed with a topic for months but then it's forgotten about and hes onto the next thing so wondering is this just the latest obsession. Just wondering what others would do if their 11 year old told them they where trans or if anyone else has been in this situation? Aibu to not let him dress as a girl?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Giraffapuses · 24/01/2024 11:34

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Isitreallythough · 24/01/2024 11:33

OldCrone · 24/01/2024 10:07

What do you mean by some people are trans? Born in the wrong body? Nobody is born in the wrong body.

Some people have gender dysphoria, which seems to mainly be a negative reaction to gender stereotyping. Some of those people are repelled by their bodies and feel the need to remove or alter body parts. This is similar to a condition called body identity integrity disorder in which people desire the removal of one or more limbs.

I don't think we should be equating a child who likes the fashions for the opposite sex, or thinks it might be quite nice to be the opposite sex, with people who feel they need to radically alter their bodies.

No child is transsexual.

‘I don't think we should be equating a child who likes the fashions for the opposite sex, or thinks it might be quite nice to be the opposite sex, with people who feel they need to radically alter their bodies.’
That was precisely part of my point. A child can like the fashions of opposite sex and have non typical tastes without their gender being an issue and I don’t think there should be any assumption that ‘feminine’ tastes mean a child is not really a boy.

Where we differ is that I am not going to tell someone they are wrong if they have at length reached the conclusion that their assigned gender was never who they really were. I’ll accept the identity they present. I don’t understand that experience and I’m not an authority on their identity. So I don’t share the view that anyone who identifies as something other than their biological sex is mistaken.

SidewaysOtter · 24/01/2024 11:31

Lexblip · 24/01/2024 11:16

I am going to keep this short if you do not support your child you will not have a son you will not have a daughter you will have no one. The best case is they run away but more likely they will join one of the 400 or so trans people to die per year. start by doing the little things like using her correct pronouns. help her find gender-affirming healthcare fyi puberty blockers are 100% reversible and HRT is extremely reusable puberty is not and I have to live with the damage from going through male puberty for the rest of my life. FYI I have specialist mental health training for gender diverse people I am also a trans MTF myself.

This is incredibly dangerous advice. Do you want to quote a reliable statistic for your “400 trans suicides” statistics?

HagoftheNorth · 24/01/2024 11:30

Oh, and to balance Lexblip’s doom laden post, when teenagers declaring a trans identity are not affirmed more that 80% of them desist. I’ve never seen any data which shows kids who aren't affirmed have a higher suicide rate than their cohort.

Lexblip if you have studies to back up your claims please do link; otherwise stop trying to terrify Cccc412

midgetastic · 24/01/2024 11:29

Lexblip · 24/01/2024 11:16

I am going to keep this short if you do not support your child you will not have a son you will not have a daughter you will have no one. The best case is they run away but more likely they will join one of the 400 or so trans people to die per year. start by doing the little things like using her correct pronouns. help her find gender-affirming healthcare fyi puberty blockers are 100% reversible and HRT is extremely reusable puberty is not and I have to live with the damage from going through male puberty for the rest of my life. FYI I have specialist mental health training for gender diverse people I am also a trans MTF myself.

Scaremongering

Or is this something that should be reported as misinformation?

You don't need to lie to people that they are something they are not, that there is anything wrong or unusual about them for rejecting gender norms

You just need to make sure they know the difference between society rules , societal fashions and real biological differences

Rules - people should not be bullied for what they wear
Fashion - long hair is girls
Biology - girls get pregnant boys don't

HagoftheNorth · 24/01/2024 11:23

I’d agree with pp’s who said you need to explain to him that nobody can change sex, but that doesn’t mean you can’t wear something a bit different from the other boys (although at 11, most of the girls will be wearing tee shirts & joggers/leggings - so quite similar to the boys!)

I’d also agree that you need to put some major controls in place re what he’s looking at on the internet, and check carefully what he’s being taught in school. This whole subject can be very difficult for ASD kids - but focusing on what binary sex actually means (bodies follow one of two developmental pathways etc) can give them some hard facts to hang on to!

Lexblip · 24/01/2024 11:16

I am going to keep this short if you do not support your child you will not have a son you will not have a daughter you will have no one. The best case is they run away but more likely they will join one of the 400 or so trans people to die per year. start by doing the little things like using her correct pronouns. help her find gender-affirming healthcare fyi puberty blockers are 100% reversible and HRT is extremely reusable puberty is not and I have to live with the damage from going through male puberty for the rest of my life. FYI I have specialist mental health training for gender diverse people I am also a trans MTF myself.

Differentstarts · 24/01/2024 11:04

Yanbu he can do whatever he likes at 18

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 24/01/2024 11:00

The problem is real transgenderism is actually so rare! But how do you distinguish from someone who is genuinely transgender from someone who is just confused? If he's never felt like this before... I would say he could be going down a slippery path.. Obviously you know him better than I do.

Mulhollandmagoo · 24/01/2024 11:00

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 23/01/2024 22:48

Haïr extensions and make up are not suitable or necessary for an eleven year old of either sex.

I agree with this, and this is something you should say to your son! I agree with it being much more exciting if you forbid it, and given his obsessions due to his ASD, chances are it will pass.

I would buy him a few bits of clothing that he picks, but no to everything else, based on the fact that they are expensive, and not really 11yo appropriate. Self expression though clothing and fashion is really good for kids I think.

Fimofriend · 24/01/2024 10:56

I would inform him that girls his age do not wear makeup outside of their house and the same rule will apply to him.

SiobhanSharpe · 24/01/2024 10:51

Very gently, OP, I wonder if his feelings may be partly based on his statements that 'girls have it easier, people are nicer to girls' and so on.
There seems to be a bit of sexism in his thinking. I'd start with that -- telling him very firmly that while boys and girls can have a hard time going through puberty and adolescence, it is absolutely not true that girls have it easier. Quite the reverse.
Boys are just not subject to the same amount of unwanted attention from the other sex as girls are, from boys and even grown men -- i think we can see an example of that from the increased numbers of young girls wanting to identify away from their own sex. Social pressures are also a factor and I would argue that these can be more intense for girls too. To be beautiful, nice, compliant, popular and just to conform is so hard.
I can well remember being shocked and highly uncomfortable from the ages of 12 to 13 by inappropriate remarks and attention from men in my father's age bracket. Not just from older teens or men in their early 20s. And I'm sure I'm not alone in that. I can't think boys get the same degree or type of unwanted attention.
I think some men feel that young teenagers, mostly girls, are fair game. Moreover, some men are simply predators. The fear of actual sexual assault is very real.
True, boys may be targeted by paedophiles but men who go after young teenage girls are not generally considered as such, certainly not by other men! (Unless it's their own daughters who are targeted.)
Big conversations about feminism and social pressures may be needed.

Unicorntearsofgin · 24/01/2024 10:48

Could you approach this a slightly different way? Show him non gender conforming males (David Bowie for example) and talk about how everyone is different and individuality is good. I’d find out what appeals to him and explain how boys can love pink, cooking and any other hobbies he has.

YireosDodeAver · 24/01/2024 10:46

Get your terminology right.

Dresses and skirts are not "girls" clothes. They are clothes. If they belong to a boy then they are a boy's clothes.

I would say yes you can wear a skirt, but you have to understand that wearing a skirt doesn't mean you are wearing girls clothes, you are wearing your own clothes and every cell in your body contains DNA that says you are a boy. You do not have to follow any sexist stereotype rules that say boys have to have short hair and wear trousers, you can wear whatever you like and have your hair however you like so long as you are neat and presentable, but you can't change reality.

TheOccupier · 24/01/2024 10:45

mummy21blueeyed · 23/01/2024 23:12

@HowDoTheyGetThroughLife I’m with you!! Sorry I work in a reception class and there’s a book called you need To chill
or something on the shelf for 4/5 year olds to read and it infuriates me. I’m all
for us supporting other Adults if they wish to change although I don’t agree I think a man is a man a woman is a woman. But never mind I don’t hate on them I just say nothing.

however this book on a 4 year olds shelf is practically telling them and teaching them that it’s okay to want to be something else rather than embrace who they are and what gender they are which in my opinion at 4/5 years old thwy should not even be thinking about gender changes.. it’s on the same shelf as a race book to teach about loving everyone as they are but race and transitioning gender are two different things and one should be taught the other shouldn’t.

i would be encouraging everything but allowing him to wear dresses. It’s becoming too normal in my opinion. I understand people don’t feel comfortable etc but why are we broadcasting it to our Children as if it’s normal. My 2 year old will be taught to love herself and be herself and she will be told to ignore books as such but care everyone for who they are no matter what background. But I absolutely do not support supporting or teqxhomf young children about transgender

@mummy21blueeyed please drop that book down the back of the bookshelf ASAP!

OP: there is good information here:
https://www.transgendertrend.com/autism-gender-identity-introduction/

Autism & Gender Identity - Introduction - Transgender Trend

Introduction There is increasing awareness among parents, caregivers, clinicians and therapists that there is a clear link between gender identity issues and Autistic Spectrum Disorder (ASD). We know that currently, 76% of referees to The Tavistock & P...

https://www.transgendertrend.com/autism-gender-identity-introduction

Rosscameasdoody · 24/01/2024 10:45

trippily · 23/01/2024 22:42

September is a long way away. You'll only make it more exciting if you forbid it, whilst driving a wedge between you.

She may also, just be trans. In which case it would be very damaging for her for you to deny her gender affirmation.

No doubt everyone will be here in a minute to tell you all trans people are evil calculating rapists (whilst simultaneously reminding you there's no transphobia on mumsnet ofc).

Suicide rates among trans youth is so high. I wouldn't risk it personally if it were my child. If it turns out not to be the thing who cares. Plenty of young people try identities on for size.

Why are you referring to him as ‘she’ ?

Blueblell · 24/01/2024 10:41

I think ASD probably is relevant and if you have support for that can you talk to them about this development and get some advice.

I don’t envy you and can offer no advice on what is the right course of action. However I would keep in mind that he probably feels different because of his ASD and is probably looking for answers / a solution to this feeling.

SidewaysOtter · 24/01/2024 10:40

Suicide rates among trans youth is so high.

Got a reliable source for that very emotive and hyperbolic statement?

tiredmama23 · 24/01/2024 10:31

@emilysquest quite! Those were just a few off the top of my head 😂

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 24/01/2024 10:31

"Life is easier for girls" 😂scrippsnews.com/stories/man-tweets-about-experience-signing-work-email-as-woman/

emilysquest · 24/01/2024 10:30

tiredmama23 · 24/01/2024 10:25

He said that life is easier for girls

Wait til he hears about periods, hormonal imbalances, pregnancy, childbirth, postpartum recovery, and menopause, then. 😳

Wait till he hears about sexism, harassment, sexual violence, domestic violence, gender pay gaps...

emilysquest · 24/01/2024 10:28

I cant find now, but there is a gif somewhere of a boy saying to his mum "Mummy I think I'm a girl", the mother saying "well you're not" and just getting on with her day. That would be my approach, with a couple of added sentences. Well, you're not a girl. You're a boy. You can wear what you like but some people are going to tease you if you wear dresses to school, so it's best not to do that. You can be behave how you like as long as you are polite and considerate to other people, and you can play whatever sport and games you want and do what you want in your career because there are no activities or jobs that are "for girls" or "for boys". Now, what do you want for supper?

Calliopespa · 24/01/2024 10:26

AStrangeStateofMatter · 24/01/2024 10:23

I don’t think he is trying to look like a woman- he is a man wearing clothes that he likes, so he looks like a man wearing clothes that he likes.

Yes I agree. But most guys would just look as guy-ish as usual ( as you say, a man in women’s clothes), maybe less. I’m not sure how he achieves the more masculine bit. Anyway, he’s still making his point which is fundamentally:why not?

tiredmama23 · 24/01/2024 10:25

He said that life is easier for girls

Wait til he hears about periods, hormonal imbalances, pregnancy, childbirth, postpartum recovery, and menopause, then. 😳

AStrangeStateofMatter · 24/01/2024 10:23

Calliopespa · 24/01/2024 10:08

Funny you should mention Harry Styles! I agree he is great fun in the way he plays with gender stereotypes and I applaud him for it. But what always amuses me is, handsome guy ( very handsome guy) that he is, he nonetheless somehow can’t get it convincing. It’s as if the more feminine the outfit, the more it underlines his basic masculinity. I’m not entirely sure if it is actually half intentional or if he’s really doing his best. Anyway, his best didn’t-quite-pull-it-off-but- how-cool- anyway outfit has to be that boa feather fur coat he wore performing with Lizzo. He looks like Big Bird’s watermelon-hued cousin. But he’s mixing it up and he’s pretty 😎

I don’t think he is trying to look like a woman- he is a man wearing clothes that he likes, so he looks like a man wearing clothes that he likes.