Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not let him dress like a girl?

413 replies

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 22:37

Lo is 11 and has ASD (not sure if that's relevant). He's told me he is trans, wants me to buy him dresses, make up, hair extensions etc. This is the first time he has come out and said it although he has made comments about girls clothing being better etc over the past year so I had a feeling this was coming. Not sure how to approach this. My worry is if I do allow him to dress like a girl he will get picked on, he already struggles socially and has been bullied in the past. Also if this is just a phase and he changes his mind, people will not forget and he will have to live with that. Also he will be starting secondary school in September which will be a really tough transition for him. With his ASD he tends to become fixated/obsessed with a topic for months but then it's forgotten about and hes onto the next thing so wondering is this just the latest obsession. Just wondering what others would do if their 11 year old told them they where trans or if anyone else has been in this situation? Aibu to not let him dress as a girl?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
falalalalalalalallama · 24/01/2024 02:23

She may also, just be trans. In which case it would be very damaging for her for you to deny her gender affirmation

No. This is misinformed nonsense.

Very, very few children fit the profile of those who maintain they are trans throughout puberty and into adulthood, left to their own devices. And most of them start saying they are the other sec much younger than the OP's DS, and even then, the jury is out as to what is actually going on.

The vast majority of kids who think they are trans are caught up in a social contagion. Most are same sex attracted and autistic or have autistic traits. (According to data from GIDS itself. They didn't record much, but there did at least record this).

You mention danger?

The very real danger here is that the OP's child is actually gay / bisexual but struggling to process it, but instead of supporting him to accept his sexuality and flourish as a same-sex attracted adult, a plethora of well meaning idiots like yourself push the trans narrative on him, and he ends up sterile, in pain, incontinent and unable to ever have a functional sex life as an adult. A eunuch, effectively.

Evidence is emerging that puberty blockers can cause a significant drop in IQ. Young people taking them experience this as "brain fog". They also cause brittle bones, and when started young and followed by cross-sex hormones lead not only to sterility but the suppression of sexual function and desire to the extent that many kids on this pathway never mature into sexually functional adults.

In boys this looks like the genitals staying sexually immature - a child's penis as an adult and no sex drive. And if they go for surgery a "neo vagina" would have to be created out of other bits of the body for example a colon, rather than from the penis itself as in the surgery adult man who have never taken blockers can have.

On a young person who has never sexually matured, such a neo-vagina gives them a hole that can allow them to simulate sex with another person "as if" female but at what cost? If they haven't matured sexually, and their "vagina" is made of colon, it's all about aesthetics over function, they have no hope of a fulfilling sexual relationship. Look up Jazz Jennings if you don't believe me. There's a video of him about 18, asking his grandmother to explain what an orgasm is, as he fad no clue.

Ask yourself, what kind of adult waits to have sex with someone who can never hope to feel sexual pleasure from it? I don't like a lot of the answers to that question. Why would you push a child towards this possible future?

The neo-vagina itself is effectively a wound that wants to close, and is prone to infection, and so it must be dilated, a painful process. Many people who have undergone this procedure struggle with incontinence issues.

Even the prostate is moved so they have no hope of having normal gay sex.

It's a fucking tragedy, what a difficult and lonely life we are setting up so many "trans" DC to have, denying them the chance to ever form a relationship as a fully functional sexual adult.

And it's an outcome that can be easily avoided. All the data shows that if they're not medicated, the vast majority of children grow out of being trans if allowed to go through puberty.

The Cass Report has stayed that social transition is not a neutral act, either, as it puts children on a path to medical transition.

Please, please go educate yourself on what you are actually advocating, it's horrific, a medical scandal unfolding in real time. The practice of stunting the sexual and intellectual growth of mostly autistic and same-sex attracted kids will not be looked on kindly in years to come.

Remember, people used to advocate lobotomy, as people they trusted told them it was a good idea. It was all the rage for a while! This is has parallels. Trendy, no evidence base, those unlucky enough to be duped will end up with serious, irreversible damage at the hands of well meaning professionals

Read some actual evidence based information, not the lobbying of organisations with huge bias.

I would suggest starting with the Cass Report, followed by the excellent "Time To Think" about the collapse of the GIDS clinic, written by Newsnight's Hannah Barnes - available here ttps://amzn.eu/d/a7hPqr4

nolongersurprised · 24/01/2024 02:14

I would be VERY wary of what he’s consuming online. Wanting hair extensions and make up is performative hyper-femininity at this age. Like a girl-costume. He’s very unlikely to see girls his age with fake hair and a face full of make up - how and where has he decided that this is what “girl” is?

I agree with most posters. Get him off-line, make it clear that people can’t change sex, let him wear whatever he wants at home but with age-appropriate boundaries re make up.

Toopolitetoask · 24/01/2024 02:11

@DeeLusional I only have anecdotal evidence but I have worked with approx 10 children over my career who identified as trans, who had made serious attempts on their own lives. The youngest was 7. I don't know if there is a statistical increase but one child trying to kill themselves is one child too many in my book.

Fwiw none were children who were encouraged by families to be trans or were exposed to the level of trans positive stories/media that there is now - this was before tik tok existed.

Fwiw I don't believe in pushing labels on children, rather being neutral and accepting them explore things. There are some lovely accounts on this thread of parents who have done so with their own children where it has worked out really positively.

PlantDoctor · 24/01/2024 02:08

Most people who argue against a person being trans usually fall back on "girls can wear boy's clothes and boys can wear girl's clothes. Isn't it silly that clothing is gendered" etc., yet here many are jumping to say that this child should not be allowed to wear the girl's clothes that they would prefer to wear. Quite an interesting double standard.

DeeLusional · 24/01/2024 01:53

trippily · 23/01/2024 22:42

September is a long way away. You'll only make it more exciting if you forbid it, whilst driving a wedge between you.

She may also, just be trans. In which case it would be very damaging for her for you to deny her gender affirmation.

No doubt everyone will be here in a minute to tell you all trans people are evil calculating rapists (whilst simultaneously reminding you there's no transphobia on mumsnet ofc).

Suicide rates among trans youth is so high. I wouldn't risk it personally if it were my child. If it turns out not to be the thing who cares. Plenty of young people try identities on for size.

High suicide rates among so-called trans youth is a fabrication by the trans lobby to panic parents into "affirming" their children.

MariaVT65 · 24/01/2024 01:51

Agree with PP’s points that he is too young for hair extensions and make up.

I would have a talk with him about gender stereotypes eg it’s also normal for girls to have short hair and not wear dresses and not wear lots of pink and not wear makeup. And men do cooking - would he be interested in watching something like masterchef? Especially the professionals season - they are mostly men.

I would most certainly explain to him how females’ lives are harder, not easier. Tell him about periods, gender pay gap, not feeling safe to walk alone at night etc.

Ask him where he is getting these ideas from.

Allow nail polish if he would like it, no one will be allowed that at school though.

Maybe take him shopping for a pink tshirt in the boys’ section?

Forgottenmypasswordagain · 24/01/2024 01:36

I'm not sure, maybe out of school. But no 11 year old child of mine regardless of gender, sex ect. would be allowed make-up and hair extensions. Too young.

SingleMum11 · 24/01/2024 01:24

I would get some good advice, there is a high % of autistic kids who seek medical transitioning and/or trans identity and there are questions about this, questions about what is the right support as a parent that we haven't had answered.

Personally, speaking as a parents of kids with SEN I would be quite concerned that at age 11 my DS had such definite wishes and I would wonder where the influence was coming from. Especially as your child hasn't reached secondary school and is only just navigating social life, and probably only just having an awareness of what being a boy and girl are at a very unformed stage in cognitive and emotional development.

NotInvolved · 24/01/2024 01:16

I have no personal experience but the DD of a friend of mine who also has ASD declared that she was trans in her early teens. I think it was a similar thing. She was seeing a lot of other girls her age adopting very stereotypical "feminine" behaviours and appearances - long hair, make up, short skirts, dropping out of sport and so on - and she didn't relate to it. So as she didn't feel she belonged with the girls she decided she must be a boy. I suspect that the discomfort that of course many girls feel with their changing bodies around puberty also played a part. She did cut her hair very short and adopt a different name for a while but is now away at University studying engineering and fully accepting that she is a girl, just not a stereotypical one.
My friend certainly found it a difficult line to walk, not wanting to encourage her DD to believe that she was a boy but at the same time not wanting to alienate her. I think the advice she would give is to keep lines of communication with your child open and seek expert help if you are worried. I guess you need to try encourage him to develop his own style and interests whilst stressing that those things don't define you as male or female?

PartridgeInAPearShape · 24/01/2024 01:14

My autistic child decided they wanted to be referred to as they/them for several months, wanted to have blue nail polish, grew hair into a mop, tried a bit of eyeliner. We were fine with it (it mostly happened over the summer holidays). By October they were over it and that was fine as well.
Be supportive and chilled; let them be where they are and love them. Your safe love means the world as they start to explore who they are

Marcipex · 24/01/2024 01:10

Could he join a dance class? Or a drama group? An outside activity that isn’t sport.

Take him to a shopping mall to see what girls are actually wearing. Around here it’s baggy jeans and black puffa jackets, not heels and flouncy dresses.

Encourage cooking and sewing, because they are life skills, not girl skills. Could he design a few things for his room, for instance make a cushion cover for a start. That’s not difficult, mine could do that at 11. Let him design a collage and sew on sequins. He might enjoy a creative outlet.

HollyKnight · 24/01/2024 00:58

It's too cold for dresses. Buy him jeans and t-shirts like what the other girls wear. I wouldn't care about the make-up, but he's too young at 11 for anything other than lip balm.

lemmein · 24/01/2024 00:55

Id let him dress however he wants, but I'd also remind him he's a boy in a dress - he's not a girl, girls aren't just bodies in dresses!

If he was saying he wanted to be a dog you wouldn't start calling him Rover and taking him for a walk around the park on a lead. I'm all for people wearing what they want, however, facts are facts, he's a boy - no amount of wishing/meds/surgery will change that.

I wouldn't allow extensions for an 11 year old no matter their sex.

Fraaahnces · 24/01/2024 00:54

That’s such a tough one to navigate… One of my friends is a psychiatrist. She said that kids who identify as trans fit tend to be either ASD or they have tendencies that will likely fit into the Personality Disorder Spectrum. Kids with ASD don’t tend to feel at home in their bodies or with kids their own age. Add hormones and media and it’s a time in life with extra pressure. They are also vulnerable to obsessions and to the perceived approval of their peers. I don’t know if your child understands that having ASD leaves them vulnerable and so does identifying “differently”… I would be very clear about cooking - show them that most chefs are indeed men, that boys can wear pink - it’s an outdated way to show that your baby is a boy or a girl because otherwise babies all look the same, etc, without pushing for or against their idea that they are trans. What I would also suggest is that you nurture other interests until they are old enough to fully grasp their identity and sexuality without negativity surrounding your child’s current belief that they are trans.

Caerulea · 24/01/2024 00:53

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 23:12

@Mary1234567 thank you. A few of the reasons he gave me for being trans is that he would be better at cooking, he hates football and that boys can't wear pink so I definitely think he is associating these things in strict gender categories. He said that life is easier for girls, girls are treated better than boys and girls clothes are prettier. According to him he is straight as in he likes girls.

I would dearly love to know where he got the idea that life is easier for girls lol. Yikes! Though he's a bit young to truly explain why that's not the case.

Anyway - given this update (I didn't see it prior to my response, 😬) I think you definitely need to work on the ideas of pink & cooking being girl things. Why that's actually very backwards. He is right on girls clothes being more fun, cos they are! Boys clothes are generally dull AF. But it doesn't have to mean floaty dresses - look at practical stuff that surf/skate brands do. Boden used to have very strong designs for girls that avoided flowers & fairies etc.

porridgeisbae · 24/01/2024 00:45

he has ASD and feels awkward already. He thinks this will make him feel 'right' because that's what's being promised to him online.

This makes sense @Cccc412 . He's looking for The Answer. I've been there years ago due to my bipolar and stuff. The Answer doesn't lie in anything except directly addressing the problem. It doesn't lie in clutching on to a random thing he might think is the solution. For instance he might feel better through various therapies and/or medications to address the consequences of his ASD or mental health.

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 24/01/2024 00:42

i've read that it is more difficult for children/people with asd to understand the nuance of being male and female, and with the onset of puberty 11 it not an easy stage for a boy or a girl.
this being said i'm a firm believer in biology and i would simply say you were born a boy. highlight any and all special boy features; larger heart and lungs, heavier bones and totally different hormones.
in my household this would be a no go, so far all my children and grandchildren appear to embrace their natal sex.

CheeseFiend40 · 24/01/2024 00:41

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 23:12

@Mary1234567 thank you. A few of the reasons he gave me for being trans is that he would be better at cooking, he hates football and that boys can't wear pink so I definitely think he is associating these things in strict gender categories. He said that life is easier for girls, girls are treated better than boys and girls clothes are prettier. According to him he is straight as in he likes girls.

I obviously don’t know how his ASD is affecting his thinking on this topic, but I would definitely debate him on this and get him thinking logically about what he’s actually saying here.
I would explain to him that his current perception of what women/girls are is narrow minded. He’s lumping half of the population into a homogenous group of people that all love cooking, don’t like football and like to wear pink. He needs to realise how utterly ridiculous that is.
If he wants to wear pink, great do it. If he wants to wear a dress, cool do that. But that doesn’t change the fact that he’s a boy.
I never wear dresses or the colour pink and I hate cooking, am I suddenly a man?!! No, I’m a woman with my own individual personality traits.

Caerulea · 24/01/2024 00:41

So, from the pov of someone whose son wore a skirt to primary from about 5 & loved dresses that he wore often (though I went with what I'd buy a daughter so nothing frilly or excessively pink etc) who then, around your sons age, declared (hysterically & out of the blue) that he was trans...

This against a background of total acceptance of 'clothing rights' - ie, you can wear whatever you like cos they are just clothes, they don't mean anything. We prepared him for the comments he would get & he was super confident & unbothered. Often his reply would be along the lines of 'but it's ok for a girl to wear trousers?'

It took some unpicking but essentially, he was being coached into the idea by his wellmeaning friends cos the idea was already there that a boy in a skirt = transgirl. We chatted & talked about the need to get to know his body as it is & we'd see what happens. That he was to young to even know himself as he was before wanting to change it.

He continued with his clothing choices though I drew the line at a skirt for secondary on the basis I'd also refuse a skirt for a daughter (on the grounds of it limits movement & makes you to aware of how your sitting, walking etc etc etc) (and no fucking pockets!).

Anyway! He's just a plain ole gay boy. It's that simple. Other people put the idea onto him cos it's just so unacceptable, ultimately, that a boy could lower himself to dress 'like a girl' without there being mental illness involved.

Where we are now - he's 'openly' gay (stupid phrase but I mean he's not ashamed & hasn't hidden it or anything). Mostly grown out of the wearing dresses etc (probably to do with being 6ft 1 & too tall for all my dresses & shoes). We've spoken about what happened a couple of times & he laughs at the idea that's what he thought & is thankful for how I dealt with it. Ie - I didn't just start him on a pathway...

We're also about to get him assessed, I think, cos it's becoming increasingly obvs he's not wired in the same way most others are, at all.

So yeah! Let him wear what he wants & impress upon him that it's actually fine for a man to do that, it doesn't change who he is, it's just pieces of fabric. There's a much higher chance that he's gay than trans & likely higher again that he's having confused thoughts & isn't sure how to process them due to his ASD which makes him far more vulnerable to ideas that might not apply to him.

If you wouldn't let a daughter his age have extensions, then don't let him. I certainly wouldn't. Things like make-up & nails are fine too, just not for school & not to 'beautify' & sculpt, but to be creative. Again, the same rules as you would for a daughter.

To be brutally honest - my son (nearly 15) has become incredibly sceptical of the whole movement now after his experience (which happened thru kindness!) & watching what's happening around him. That's not to say his doesn't believe in gender dysphoria, just that young ppl are getting swept up in it).

I have tried to present everything as neutrally as possible so he (& his brothers) find their own way rather than me coach them.

OShoey · 24/01/2024 00:40

Clothes are clothes. They don't make you a boy or a girl. And I'd make sure my child understood that. Wear whatever makes you happy, son.

Dontblameitonsunshine · 24/01/2024 00:40

Don’t make any decisions until you get this book,When Kids Say They're Trans: A Guide for Thoughtful Parents
https://amzn.eu/d/8rwTh3d
In the meantime get him off the internet

Fionaville · 24/01/2024 00:39

It really bothers me that it seems to be mostly kids with ASD who are getting drawn into this.
Honestly, I'd get him off the Internet and whatever is influencing him. Because that's what's happening. He's being influenced and he's more susceptible to it because he has ASD and feels awkward already. He thinks this will make him feel 'right' because that's what's being promised to him online.
If he truly is trans, then he'll still feel that way in 5 years time. There's no need to start dressing like a caricature of a 16 year old girl from the 90s. My DD is the same age as him and I wouldn't have her walking round in make up and hair extensions! Her and most of her friends wear leggings, jogging bottoms, cargo pants and jeans, with long sleeved t shirts or hoodies. They all dress pretty unisex most of the time anyway.

BarbieDangerous · 24/01/2024 00:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You’re not going to engage further yet you’re the one that @‘d me completely unprovoked?🤣 okay then.

I have nothing futher to add to the thread hence why I’ve thanked a lot of posters comments as I agree with what’s already been said. Do you want me to copy and paste the majority of comments on here?

There’s 4 fucking pages of advice. If I want to ask a poster why they’re calling a boy, ‘she’ and ‘her’ then I will. You’re very strange and I wish MN would let you block posters on here

kisstheblarney · 24/01/2024 00:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You've already derailed it sweetie!

I'll comment on POs, if I think it's relevant!

Assuming a she/her pronoun was ludicrous and I'll say so!

HTH!

CocoC · 24/01/2024 00:28

LeavesOnTrees · 23/01/2024 22:55

I'd get him some dresses and let him wear them around the house and out with you without any comment. I'd probably discourage for school (does he have a uniform?).
I'd tell him he's too young for make up and extensions.
Overall I'd treat it like it's no big deal.

This. Let him have a couple of girl things, and he can wear these at home or in whatever place he will not run into anyone he knows. Not at school. Also, veto anything you wouldn't let an 11 yr old girl wear (ie anything excessively sexualised/feminised, like hair extensions, false nails heels etc).
Show him that 10 year old girls wear similar things to 10 year old boys! (most girls especially nowadays are wearing baggy jeans and grey sweatshirts with black puffas, not twirling about in pink dresses!). He can be a girl who dresses like a real life girl - not the ridiculous trans look which is actually not what girls or women actually look like.
I would definitely hugely downplay it, and interest will wane.

Swipe left for the next trending thread