Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not let him dress like a girl?

413 replies

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 22:37

Lo is 11 and has ASD (not sure if that's relevant). He's told me he is trans, wants me to buy him dresses, make up, hair extensions etc. This is the first time he has come out and said it although he has made comments about girls clothing being better etc over the past year so I had a feeling this was coming. Not sure how to approach this. My worry is if I do allow him to dress like a girl he will get picked on, he already struggles socially and has been bullied in the past. Also if this is just a phase and he changes his mind, people will not forget and he will have to live with that. Also he will be starting secondary school in September which will be a really tough transition for him. With his ASD he tends to become fixated/obsessed with a topic for months but then it's forgotten about and hes onto the next thing so wondering is this just the latest obsession. Just wondering what others would do if their 11 year old told them they where trans or if anyone else has been in this situation? Aibu to not let him dress as a girl?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Cantthinkofafruit · 24/01/2024 06:30

Correct. HE is a BOY, and should be encouraged to behave as a boy

@HowDoTheyGetThroughLife wtf does this even mean?

You do realise that the concept of "boy behaviour" and "girl behaviour" actually supports transgender beliefs, right?

So long as they are polite and kind, let the kid behave how they chose.

Zanatdy · 24/01/2024 06:27

this might not be the right approach as I have no experience of this but I think sometimes kids see things on Tiktok etc and think how easy it looks. So I’d speak to them about how changing sex is not possible, you’ll always biologically be a boy, but some people have surgery and you don’t suddenly transform with a click of fingers like these videos have kids believe - it’s a lot of surgery and there’s no going back. I’d give a bit of reality to it and also monitor more closely what they are watching. My eldest I strongly believe has ASD but he’s 30 and wasn’t diagnosed as wasn’t as easy to get that kind of assessment like now. But he also had obsessions (still does) but after a few months moved onto the next. When he was 3 he wanted to called Rachel and told the nursery staff they had to call him rachel. He wanted to wear a dress. It didn’t last long.

Ladyj84 · 24/01/2024 06:24

Boggles me so a child yes a child says to a parent I want to be a fireman, are you then going to chuck him/her into a burning fire???

Ggttl · 24/01/2024 06:23

Not many girls his age go in for hair extensions make up and dresses.
Couldn’t he just wear jeans, jumper and grow his hair like most girls. He could have a bit of chipped nail varnish to peel off during lessons, if he wants to get the full look.

rainydaysandwednesdays · 24/01/2024 06:22

inapickle2300 · 24/01/2024 06:16

My DD (16) yr 11 fell for the trans trend for a few years. She’s autistic. In year 7, she had an English teacher who identified as a “demi girl” and would engage with children at lunch and break for special chats. My dd started using he/they for a bit. I refused to play along. The teacher was let go after complaints. My DD is well out the other side now and knows what a woman is. She has a trans friend but she’s also well aware that her trans friend will never be able to change sex.
Be careful who your son is talking to, make sure he gets his info from you.

Oh ffs I absolutely despair. Thank god this woman was removed and all has worked out ok for you.

rainydaysandwednesdays · 24/01/2024 06:20

No YANBU, don't entertain it.

Does he have social media? Where is he getting this from?

AnneValentine · 24/01/2024 06:17

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 23:12

@Mary1234567 thank you. A few of the reasons he gave me for being trans is that he would be better at cooking, he hates football and that boys can't wear pink so I definitely think he is associating these things in strict gender categories. He said that life is easier for girls, girls are treated better than boys and girls clothes are prettier. According to him he is straight as in he likes girls.

He’s not trans. He’s autistic. That’s really clear from this post.

I think start unpacking each point. Pretty isn’t because girl. Pink for both. Book him on a cooking course. Etc.

inapickle2300 · 24/01/2024 06:16

My DD (16) yr 11 fell for the trans trend for a few years. She’s autistic. In year 7, she had an English teacher who identified as a “demi girl” and would engage with children at lunch and break for special chats. My dd started using he/they for a bit. I refused to play along. The teacher was let go after complaints. My DD is well out the other side now and knows what a woman is. She has a trans friend but she’s also well aware that her trans friend will never be able to change sex.
Be careful who your son is talking to, make sure he gets his info from you.

Mary1234567 · 24/01/2024 06:11

I thought this part was interesting too. It would be worth exploring with him what experiences have led him to feel women have it easier. Before jumping to dismiss it with ‘no they don’t !’ Just ask a bit more. For example maybe he’s experienced other boys being rough with him or laughing at him for not being sporty enough, or whatever it may be, or he’s been shamed for crying by a male teacher, and he may have (in his young and autistic mind) coped by thinking ‘this doesn’t happen to the girls’. There has to be some interesting experiences/thought processes behind what’s led him to think life’s easier for girls, so it would be very interesting to ask him more about that too.

Questioffs · 24/01/2024 06:10

Toopolitetoask · 24/01/2024 02:11

@DeeLusional I only have anecdotal evidence but I have worked with approx 10 children over my career who identified as trans, who had made serious attempts on their own lives. The youngest was 7. I don't know if there is a statistical increase but one child trying to kill themselves is one child too many in my book.

Fwiw none were children who were encouraged by families to be trans or were exposed to the level of trans positive stories/media that there is now - this was before tik tok existed.

Fwiw I don't believe in pushing labels on children, rather being neutral and accepting them explore things. There are some lovely accounts on this thread of parents who have done so with their own children where it has worked out really positively.

Surely wanting to be 'trans' shows that the person already has mental health issues (dysphoria at least), which would make them a higher risk anyway. I think 'trans' gets in the way.

Would you encourage an anorexic? Someone with bulimia?

HollyKnight · 24/01/2024 06:10

Mary1234567 · 23/01/2024 23:06

I am an autism specialist and one thing I would say is that autistic people can be very rigid and rule based for example, for them sometimes being trans can be the logical conclusion they come to, after absorbing gender stereotypes and taking them very literally and as very fixed. E.g. ‘ I like caring and I like cooking and art, and those are for girls so I am a girl. I don’t like football so I am not a boy’ or even ‘I want to marry a man not a woman so I am trans’ (when really they may grow up to be gay) basically I think one way you can help your child to explore their identity in a more nuanced way, is by helping them see that boys can wear pink, paint their nails, have long or short hair, etc. I would try to approach gender as something a bit more ‘grey’ than ‘black and white’ and see if they can find somewhere they’re comfortable and discover themselves, without drastic changes but without shaming their possible trans thoughts either. I hope that makes sense.

Yep. This was very much me as a child. I knew there were only two genders. You were either a boy or girl. I was apparently a girl. Except I didn't understand girls. I couldn't play house, or any other make-believe game, or role play games. I didn't like hugging, holding hands, plaiting hair, or any of the other touchy-things "girls" did. I hated skirts and dresses because the wind burned my legs. E.t.c.

My favourite colour was blue. I liked trousers. I liked Lego. I like collecting Pokémon cards, Pogs and small toy cars. I liked being out on my bike and hanging upside-down from trees. All the things I didn't see girls around me doing. I didn't have many friends because of this. I was absolutely 100% certain I was a girl, but with the wrong brain. I thought I must have got a boy's brain by mistake. Because if I didn't think like a girl, by default that meant I must think like a boy. It was that simple.

This was over 30 years ago. Transgenderism wasn't a thing many people would have been aware of. Yet the thought process I had then is the same thought process I keep reading about now from trans kids. Especially autistic ones. Except now there are "experts" telling them that yes your body is wrong but we can fix that. It's terrifying. I am so glad I am not a child in this day and age because this is what would be happening to me.

Now, over 30 years later, I understand my belief was just an autistic/logical mind trying to make sense of why I wasn't like anyone else. At one stage I even wondered if I was an alien lol. My thinking constantly changed as I matured and learned more about myself. It wasn't until I properly learned about autism that it finally click. It was a huge "Ooooh so that's what that was!" moment.

I am very much just a woman with an autistic brain. Not a boy's brain.

And I still hate dresses.

Letsgotitans · 24/01/2024 06:10

Delphinium20 · 24/01/2024 00:06

Could you say to him, "Well, any clothes you wear are boy clothes because you're a boy. Same for a girl. If a girl came and wore your clothes, they become girl clothes because she wears them."

Yes I agree. The people here saying let him wear pick and sparkly things I feel would only reinforce stereotypes. Men can wear pink, women can wear blue and still be a man/ woman. He's obviously already been fed a lot of stereotypical rubbish by the fact he's saying I want to be a girl because I like cooking and don't like football 🙄

Questioffs · 24/01/2024 06:04

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 00:11

How do boys behave? Asking for a friend?

Well, quite. If he can't behave (or be encouraged to behave) like a 'boy' how can he want to behave and change to become a 'girl'. He is what he is and cannot change that. However he behaves, he will always be a boy.

FridayNightSupper · 24/01/2024 06:02

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 23:00

@LeavesOnTrees did he ever wear girls clothes outside and did other kids make fun of him/still make fun of him? This is my biggest worry, kids can be so mean

Is this part of the problem? Have you ever told him he can’t wear something he wanted to, because it’s ‘girls’ clothes?

DS is autistic and occasionally has wanted a top that was in the girls section (a neon pink sparkly t-Rex was the most memorable). But we’ve always told him that saying certain clothes is off limits because of your sex is silly, you like what you like and it doesn’t make you less of a boy. Same for toys, hobbies and who you want to be friends with.

Apart from one incident with his Nan, who persistently tried to shame him, where I ended up dramatically looking at the label in t-shirt and telling her ‘nope, it definitely doesn’t say vaginas only’, no one else gave a toss.

As he has grown older he has his own sense of style but is still very much a boy (then again, we saw the trans madness coming from a mile off so we were very careful to get the message in early that humans can never change sex, and isn’t it silly to say ‘only girls can like this’ or ‘if you do this then you are a boy’ etc. as autistic children can be easily led by a movement that promises belonging).

If you are giving him unsupervised internet access then that needs to stop immediately, I’d be worried he was being groomed.

WandaWonder · 24/01/2024 05:25

Is it because you are worried you will be judged?

Noicant · 24/01/2024 05:25

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 23/01/2024 22:48

Haïr extensions and make up are not suitable or necessary for an eleven year old of either sex.

This, absolutely this, I wouldn’t let my DD have them to be frank.

The problem with being gender affirming is that it’s not a neutral act. It’s difficult, kids these days feel like they have to have an “identity” instead of just being and I think for ASD kids it’s even more complicated. If they don’t feel like they “fit” their perception of the norms for their sex they may then think “ah yes well that must mean I’m x y or z instead”.

I wouldn’t assume he is dysphoric I would talk about why he thinks he’s a girl and what that means.

MerryMarigold · 24/01/2024 05:16

Mary1234567 · 23/01/2024 23:06

I am an autism specialist and one thing I would say is that autistic people can be very rigid and rule based for example, for them sometimes being trans can be the logical conclusion they come to, after absorbing gender stereotypes and taking them very literally and as very fixed. E.g. ‘ I like caring and I like cooking and art, and those are for girls so I am a girl. I don’t like football so I am not a boy’ or even ‘I want to marry a man not a woman so I am trans’ (when really they may grow up to be gay) basically I think one way you can help your child to explore their identity in a more nuanced way, is by helping them see that boys can wear pink, paint their nails, have long or short hair, etc. I would try to approach gender as something a bit more ‘grey’ than ‘black and white’ and see if they can find somewhere they’re comfortable and discover themselves, without drastic changes but without shaming their possible trans thoughts either. I hope that makes sense.

This is fantastic advice, I think.

autienotnaughty · 24/01/2024 05:11

Well there's two things here. Firstly you have a boy who wants to dress like a girl.(I assume this means dressesetc, more feminine clothes) I would (within budget) let him crack on, it may be a phase or it may be a life long thing but right now dont over think it. Do make him aware he may be bullied at school but ultimately it is his choice.

Secondly he wants hair extensions and make up. I wouldn't let a 11 year old child wear these things. Maybe some lip gloss and eye shadow or blusher to wear in the house but not as general use.

NeverAloneNeverAgain · 24/01/2024 04:59

Can only speak from own experience, DS with ASD when he was 15 went through similar. Wanted to be referred to with female pronoun and wear skirts/dresses. For the most part we let him explore it but also took him to GP and spoke to his worker at CAMHS. At the time he was struggling with his social network and GCSEs and all of his friends were expressing they were trans and identifying as opposite sex. For him, he wore skirts intermittently for about 6wks and we didn't pass any comment and it then just stopped. 2yrs later he gets very embarrassed whenever it's mentioned or he sees photos. I wouldn't put too much emphasis on it but access support from health and maybe explore if there are other factors he's struggling with.

badwolf82 · 24/01/2024 04:32

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 23:12

@Mary1234567 thank you. A few of the reasons he gave me for being trans is that he would be better at cooking, he hates football and that boys can't wear pink so I definitely think he is associating these things in strict gender categories. He said that life is easier for girls, girls are treated better than boys and girls clothes are prettier. According to him he is straight as in he likes girls.

I think you need to seriously investigate and monitor his internet usage. The whole “girls/women have it so much better/easier” thing is very much associated with toxic male influencers like Andrew Tate as well as “incel” culture. 11 is far far too young to be consuming that kind of media uncritically.

SisterSabotage · 24/01/2024 04:31

What the hell is dressing like a girl anyway? Jeans, trackies, hoodies, tees, they all wear the same stuff. Do they want to wear dresses? I honestly couldn't give a tinker's cuss about what anyone wears unless it carries abusive slogans

PiersPlowman11 · 24/01/2024 04:27

@Cccc412
"A few of the reasons he gave me for being trans is that he would be better at cooking, he hates football and that boys can't wear pink so I definitely think he is associating these things in strict gender categories."

What an almighty non-sequitur. Nah, not buying this thread.

simplemoments · 24/01/2024 03:38

If it were me I would say ok now you want to be treated like an 11 year old girl ? Ok … no make up and no hair extensions but we can go find a nice unicorn sweatshirt if you like and some joggers .

falalalalalalalallama · 24/01/2024 02:40

Cccc412 my heart goes out to you, this must be so difficult to navigate.

I would recommend two places for support - Bayswater Support is for parents of kids who think they're trans, but won't push the narrative that they must transition on you.
https://www.bayswatersupport.org.uk/

Stella O'Malley is a psychotherapist who does some great work in this area. Look her up or contact her and see if she can put you in touch with a therapist near you who will help your son explore what is actually going on here, rather than push a trans identity on him.

Her organisation Genspect has lots of resources for parents: https://genspect.org/support/support-for-parents-and-relatives/

She co-authored a book that came out last year, "When Kids Say They're Trans: A guide for thoughtful parents" that I think you would find useful.

https://amzn.eu/d/hcw2k7I

Wishing you and your DS all the best.

Bayswater Support – For Parents with Trans-identified Kids

https://www.bayswatersupport.org.uk/

falalalalalalalallama · 24/01/2024 02:29

Grimbelina · 23/01/2024 22:42

I am surprised you aren't contacting charities, professionals etc. skilled in this area to help you navigate this, and are instead posting on AIBU (not the SEN board etc...)

The OP would do well to steer clear of charities such as Mermaids and Stonewall who will happily give advice, but none of of evidence based, and likely to lead her child further down a path of significant harm.

She's doing the right thing by discussing it here as she's likely to get better advice than if she talks to zealots who are pushing a radical agenda on kids, based on ideology not facts.

Swipe left for the next trending thread