Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not let him dress like a girl?

413 replies

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 22:37

Lo is 11 and has ASD (not sure if that's relevant). He's told me he is trans, wants me to buy him dresses, make up, hair extensions etc. This is the first time he has come out and said it although he has made comments about girls clothing being better etc over the past year so I had a feeling this was coming. Not sure how to approach this. My worry is if I do allow him to dress like a girl he will get picked on, he already struggles socially and has been bullied in the past. Also if this is just a phase and he changes his mind, people will not forget and he will have to live with that. Also he will be starting secondary school in September which will be a really tough transition for him. With his ASD he tends to become fixated/obsessed with a topic for months but then it's forgotten about and hes onto the next thing so wondering is this just the latest obsession. Just wondering what others would do if their 11 year old told them they where trans or if anyone else has been in this situation? Aibu to not let him dress as a girl?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Futb0l · 24/01/2024 07:25

He's only 11. I'd wonder where he'd learned the word "trans". I've got a nephew that age and he is completely oblivious to this stuff.

At 11 there doesn't have to be a massive difference between typical boys clothing and girls. Lots of girls wear sports wear very similar to boys.

I'd suggest neutrality and don't play to gender stereotypes. Do not affirm this- this is a pre pubertal, ND child!

Allow/buy some more neutral wardrobe items but really challenge gender stereotypes as to what he thinks females can do/wear that he can't. Gently remind him that the biological side can only be changed cosmetically and his chromosomes will be XY for life.

Idontwantavaluablelimelesson · 24/01/2024 07:23

I wouldn't bat an eyelid if he wants to experiment with clothes etc. It's just clothes and he should be able to express himself as he wishes if it's age appropriate. As pp have said hard no to hair extensions though.

I'd be strongly challenging any claims he's making that certain things are for girls/boys. Introduce him to awesome androgenous celebs eg Pink/David Bowie, to male chefs, to female footballers etc

He's 10. This crap shouldn't even be filling his head. He should be out exploring the world and expressing himself like a child.

Find out whatever platform is making him obsessed with this issue, remove it and spend time with him appreciating what really matters in the world.

maddening · 24/01/2024 07:23

BabyEl · 24/01/2024 07:17

I don’t think the charities are a good place to look.

mermaids? Stonewall? Both scandal ridden…

Transgender trend are.good

ntmdino · 24/01/2024 07:22

ProperOuting · 24/01/2024 07:08

I haven't missed the point at all. I am autistic myself with autistic children. I know what autism feels like. I know what being a child who doesn't fit due to stereotypes is as I lived it. I'd have been so called transed but thankfully in the 90s that wasn't a thing.

I'm of the opinion that there is no good reason for adults to trans a child. 80 percent of children grow out of gender dysphoria and I wouldn't enable an anorexic so why another way to abuse the body. Autistic children need extra time to mature and navigate this because they mature more slowly as well. Absolutely everything about an autistic brain makes them vulnerable and trans is one way of exploiting that vulnerability.

Please don't equate autism with trans and maybe do some actual research on it.

I haven't equated autism with being trans at all, and I haven't said anything about it being good or not. Please read exactly what I said without putting your own spin on it. EDIT: Oh, and in this interests of accuracy, you know what your autism feels like. Not his.

The point is that life is hard for him, he sees people treating girls nicer than he's being treated, and he's drawn the conclusion that life is easier that way, so why not be one? It's nothing to do with being "set straight" on gender politics, it's about him and his experience. So, if OP lets him wear girls' clothes, one of five things will happen:

1 - He discovers that life isn't actually easier when dressing as a girl.

2 - He doesn't like it and stops.

3 - It's one of the temporary fixations OP mentions, and it just naturally goes away as he loses interest.

4 - He is actually trans, and he sticks with it.

5 - Turns out he just likes girls' clothes, and wears them occasionally.

There are few downsides, really - OP needs more information on what's going on in his head, and this is the only reasonable way to get it without external influence.

And yes, I'm diagnosed autistic. I'm making no judgement at all here, on the basis that I know a number of trans autistic people and the misdiagnosis rate is around 50% amongst them.

maddening · 24/01/2024 07:22

Get him therapy,.remove social media look upntrans gender trend they have sjpport for parents and speak the genspect and I think there are other groups for parents that are not trams affirming.

Also meany 11 year old girls do not have makeup and most do not have extensions and most do not wear dresses so he does not need theee to express femininity

fabricstash · 24/01/2024 07:20

I let my 14yo son wear nail varnish, have long hair, pick some girls clothing (t-shirts and shorts) from when he was young. we have has long talks about sex and gender. it is definitely being pushed at school but he knows i think its stupid, regressive, homophobic & sexist

HollyKnight · 24/01/2024 07:19

It might also be worth spending some time explaining and exploring what autism is and how it affects how his brain works. Help him to understand that it makes him think differently than other boys do, but that he also thinks differently than the girls do. Brains aren't binary. They aren't "male" or "female". They are unique to each individual.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 24/01/2024 07:17

From what you’ve said he isn’t trans, he’s a cross dresser. Trans people aren’t simply trans because they like women’s clothes. Lots of male cross dressers who prefer to dress in woman’s clothes and firmly believe they’re still males.

BabyEl · 24/01/2024 07:17

I don’t think the charities are a good place to look.

mermaids? Stonewall? Both scandal ridden…

ProperOuting · 24/01/2024 07:15

Also very sceptical about the solution to autistic traits and not relating to their own body or others seems to be set them down a path that ends in sterilisation.
Sounds like eugenics to me.
No matter how much you paint it up as benign rainbow sparkles.

colourfulchinadolls · 24/01/2024 07:12

I'd get your child off the Internet and get him out of the house.

Hair extensions are not what 11 year old girls wear anyway op.

The incidence of teens claiming they are 'trans' is much higher than average amongst autistic youth.

FluffyFanny · 24/01/2024 07:12

Most 11 year old girls don't dress in particularly stereotypically female clothes. Most wear trainers, leggings or jeans and a hoody in grey and black.

Being trans is just about a clothes fetish in most cases which is why trans women want to wear clothes that make them look like drag queens.

Alwaysalwayscold · 24/01/2024 07:10

I would make it a priority to find out who/what is filling his head with this crap at such a young age and remove that.

Than as others have said, tell him he's a boy and wearing a dress won't change that. Same as if a girl wears his clothes.

Toptotoe · 24/01/2024 07:08

I’d let him wear what he wants within reason. - I think extensions and make up are unsuitable for any 11 year old.
I think this could be a great opportunity to discuss gender stereotypes with your child Explain that he can wear what are stereotypically ‘girls’ clothes whilst still being biologically a boy and that you will support him in that if that is what he wants to do.

ProperOuting · 24/01/2024 07:08

I haven't missed the point at all. I am autistic myself with autistic children. I know what autism feels like. I know what being a child who doesn't fit due to stereotypes is as I lived it. I'd have been so called transed but thankfully in the 90s that wasn't a thing.

I'm of the opinion that there is no good reason for adults to trans a child. 80 percent of children grow out of gender dysphoria and I wouldn't enable an anorexic so why another way to abuse the body. Autistic children need extra time to mature and navigate this because they mature more slowly as well. Absolutely everything about an autistic brain makes them vulnerable and trans is one way of exploiting that vulnerability.

Please don't equate autism with trans and maybe do some actual research on it.

ntmdino · 24/01/2024 07:03

ProperOuting · 23/01/2024 23:16

He said that life is easier for girls

I hope you set him straight.

I think you've entirely missed the point here. He's autistic, which means that life is really hard for him as a baseline before even considering gender - so there's a chance that this is him trying to find a way in which life might be easier.

There's also a chance that this is genuine dysphoria and he's trans.

At this point, there's no real way to tell either way, or if it's the third option (this is just a phase).

I think the earlier suggestion of buying him girls' clothes that are only worn in the house (eg PJs etc) to begin with may help, and see if it's one of his temporary fixations or not.

Utterknowitall · 24/01/2024 07:00

I am really shocked about the YABU/YANBU split. I honestly think in a situation like this, you have to assume your child is trans and it is not phase. It may turn out to be a phase. School will be amazing and will keep a very close eye on bullying. Child doesn't have to go from boy to girl in one fell swoop. Let their hair grow long naturally. Start changing up clothes as they need new ones. Let it unfold organically. Without rush and also without brakes. If you try to stop your child being trans, it will not stop them. It will just make their childhood horrible and probably make them depressed.

Propertylover · 24/01/2024 06:50

If he likes cooking I would encourage him and watch some cooking shows (catch up TV) e.g. GBBO, Great British Menu, Masterchef where there are both men and women who make fantastic creations. GBBO is good as some people follow along and make one of the bakes each week.

Buy him some pink clothes e.g. sweatshirt, shirts etc.

Keep the dialog open.

MrsImtheProbleM · 24/01/2024 06:46

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 22:37

Lo is 11 and has ASD (not sure if that's relevant). He's told me he is trans, wants me to buy him dresses, make up, hair extensions etc. This is the first time he has come out and said it although he has made comments about girls clothing being better etc over the past year so I had a feeling this was coming. Not sure how to approach this. My worry is if I do allow him to dress like a girl he will get picked on, he already struggles socially and has been bullied in the past. Also if this is just a phase and he changes his mind, people will not forget and he will have to live with that. Also he will be starting secondary school in September which will be a really tough transition for him. With his ASD he tends to become fixated/obsessed with a topic for months but then it's forgotten about and hes onto the next thing so wondering is this just the latest obsession. Just wondering what others would do if their 11 year old told them they where trans or if anyone else has been in this situation? Aibu to not let him dress as a girl?

Hi OP - my family went through similar when my ASD child was 11 and nearing secondary school. Girl in this instance and needing to explore their identity. My child was undiagnosed ASD at the time and do think relevant.

I think these children can feel like imposters sometimes in the world they are growing up in, feel like they don’t quite fit and a logical way of exploring why and trying to find an explanation is by thinking they are wrong, so their gender could be wrong.

Any way we didn’t encourage but didn’t didn’t discourage, we listened we supported we followed their lead. We navigated this period by not dismissing but by accepting. I made it clear that all I wanted for them was to be happy, I was clear from the start that they could dress and express them self how they wanted but there would be no hormones medical intervention until they are adult, should that be what they chose. I said this from the get go - the first time they told me they wanted to be a boy. It wasn’t because i didn’t love or support them, but because I said they needed time to understand them self properly. That topic never came up again. I think you need to be very direct with this expectation don’t blur the lines and separate it completely. I also limited social media use, they weren’t allowed TikTok or insta until they were 14/15. They had snap chat at 13 (monitored) - so they could talk to their friends and not feel completely out the loop. But I just felt like the former would have fixated them more and skewed their thinking on their gender, they needed to work it out either way without too much outside influence.

I dealt with it by neutralising their gender, removing she and he and just letting them be. Some would say that ‘s a label in itself but it was very useful and very freeing for my child. They were then free to explore without social restrictions and expectations. They could just be. - they flirted between being really boyish, to then being gender neutral, back to more masculine and then now experimenting with girls clothes and make up again this year. They are have more of an alternative style emo but not full on so it’s been easier in that respect for them to go between. I also noticed if their mental health was poor they would revert more so into the boys clothing think it felt safer for them.

my child is nearing 16 now, I still say they as my brain is programmed now, but they are more of a she. It wasn’t forced by me it happened organically, we never made how they expressed them self a big deal outwardly it was a non issue. Don’t get me wrong I agonised over if I was doing right by my child and had many sleepless night’s. I was scared for their future. However, I would have supported whatever path they choose but it would have been hard for so many reasons.

My advice is go with the flow, remove expectations, reframe your way
of thinking. The best thing I did for us all was when I said to my self “this isn’t about me this is about them” - that removed my hurt. Don’t get me wrong there were times it was hard, but it doesn’t have to be. Just be the amazing mother you are love them unconditionally and you won’t go wrong whatever path they choose. Be their one champion be the person they talk to and open up to and just hold their hand.

I don’t regret for a second how we navigated this period, my husband struggled more and questioned me a lot and was a lot more cautious. When the long hair was cut he tried to stopped it I put my foot down. He tells me now I made the right choices and he thanks me for how I handled it all. Our child is amazing happy and know’s they are loved no matter what. You’ve got this op..

forgotmyusername1 · 24/01/2024 06:45

I am gender critical but have an asd son

I would probably remind him he is a boy but boys can dress and present how they like. Remind him that other kids can be mean but if he wants to choose some clothes then you will take him shopping. If he wants to grow his hair that is fine. He can be a gender non conforming boy but he is still a boy

Soontobe60 · 24/01/2024 06:44

trippily · 23/01/2024 22:42

September is a long way away. You'll only make it more exciting if you forbid it, whilst driving a wedge between you.

She may also, just be trans. In which case it would be very damaging for her for you to deny her gender affirmation.

No doubt everyone will be here in a minute to tell you all trans people are evil calculating rapists (whilst simultaneously reminding you there's no transphobia on mumsnet ofc).

Suicide rates among trans youth is so high. I wouldn't risk it personally if it were my child. If it turns out not to be the thing who cares. Plenty of young people try identities on for size.

What complete and utter rubbish. First of all, the OPs child is male, so why are you referring to him as ‘she’?
Second, statistically people who transition are MORE likely to suffer from associated mental health conditions, not less. Suicide rates amongst ‘trans’ youth is not high, in fact it’s the opposite. I think you’d do well to actually educate yourself rather than regurgitating inflammatory TRA nonsense.

Fjruejejrnrnrbbbbb · 24/01/2024 06:41

I worry about how an 11 year old knows enough about what transgenderism is to decide they want that for themselves. Does he have a lot of access to the internet?

BarbaraWoodlouse1 · 24/01/2024 06:39

He’s still very young. At that age nearly all my daughter’s friends labelled themselves as lesbians. This was a phase.

Winterstormm · 24/01/2024 06:37

I think you need to (if you don't already) put blocks on your WiFi eg Reddit, Tiktok and other websites where you think he may have heard about this. Discuss gendered stereotypes and puberty (boys then girls).

Also tell him that hair extensions and makeup aren't suitable for children - girls and boys. I wouldn't buy him dresses, but if he wants pink t-shirts then that's fine.

babyproblems · 24/01/2024 06:34

I’d stop internet access, let them wear what they want - not hair extensions or make up as these aren’t ok for an 11 year old - and not label clothes as boys or girls. You could just buy neutral clothing and I’d be switching their attention to a hobby or new activity as a distraction from the internal ruminations. A lot can change for an 11 year old in a few months!