Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not let him dress like a girl?

413 replies

Cccc412 · 23/01/2024 22:37

Lo is 11 and has ASD (not sure if that's relevant). He's told me he is trans, wants me to buy him dresses, make up, hair extensions etc. This is the first time he has come out and said it although he has made comments about girls clothing being better etc over the past year so I had a feeling this was coming. Not sure how to approach this. My worry is if I do allow him to dress like a girl he will get picked on, he already struggles socially and has been bullied in the past. Also if this is just a phase and he changes his mind, people will not forget and he will have to live with that. Also he will be starting secondary school in September which will be a really tough transition for him. With his ASD he tends to become fixated/obsessed with a topic for months but then it's forgotten about and hes onto the next thing so wondering is this just the latest obsession. Just wondering what others would do if their 11 year old told them they where trans or if anyone else has been in this situation? Aibu to not let him dress as a girl?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
11
YouJustDoYou · 25/01/2024 13:07

MovedByFanciesThatAreCurled · 25/01/2024 05:54

What absolute scaremongering nonesense

It's all scaremongering bollocks isn't it? I hate how they trot out the "you won't have a kid" bullshit line.

"Michael Biggs analysed the Tavistock GIDS and national suicide figures and found that suicide amongst young children in England and Wales is, thankfully, vanishingly rare and there is no evidence that there is a high rate among trans-identified children. In teenagers there are other conditions that carry a higher suicide risk, including anorexia, depression and autism.11 The Samaritans reported this year that suicides among teenage girls and young women between the ages of 10 and 24 have almost doubled in seven years, increasing by 94 per cent since 2012.12 All of these factors may be significant when considering the adolescents who are being referred to the Tavistock GIDS"

zingally · 25/01/2024 09:36

"Hey child, hair extensions and make-up aren't appropriate for a child of 11. Girl or boy. But if you want to grow your hair out long, that's fine. And if you want to come clothes shopping with me with the summer stuff is out and chose some things, that's fine as well."

I wouldn't blanket say no. As other posters have said, the forbidden just becomes even more exciting.

Caliope27 · 25/01/2024 09:02

0nceMoreUntoTheBreach · 24/01/2024 22:16

Is is possible for boys to dress like girls without having to want to be one?

I have been wearing men's clothes for years and nobody bats and eyelid.

Yes definitely. In the old days it was just called cross dressing, and there are still plenty of perfectly happy males who enjoy it.

MovedByFanciesThatAreCurled · 25/01/2024 05:54

Lexblip · 24/01/2024 11:16

I am going to keep this short if you do not support your child you will not have a son you will not have a daughter you will have no one. The best case is they run away but more likely they will join one of the 400 or so trans people to die per year. start by doing the little things like using her correct pronouns. help her find gender-affirming healthcare fyi puberty blockers are 100% reversible and HRT is extremely reusable puberty is not and I have to live with the damage from going through male puberty for the rest of my life. FYI I have specialist mental health training for gender diverse people I am also a trans MTF myself.

What absolute scaremongering nonesense

AnneValentine · 25/01/2024 05:49

Calliopespa · 24/01/2024 23:09

She clearly means in this context without question around their gender. What does a definition help with exactly?

Well that’s the point isn’t it. Her nephew being male is not the same as her niece thinking she is male.

SandandSky · 25/01/2024 00:17

My DS went through a stage of wearing a school dress from the lost property box at school! Kept choosing it when he got mucky outside and needed a change of clothes.

honestly? No one ever even blinked - the only people that ever commented were other parents (in a nice “he is so sweet” way) and the teachers who kept telling me he chose that himself. they kept asking if he was ok/comfortable/wanted to change

I worried about the same things as you and I can honestly say the person who made the biggest deal about it was me in my head.

I would go with the flow and do what other PPs suggested- some small changes that let your DC have a little play with what they like to wear without going too crazy and keep a close eye on things without making a fuss

SloaneStreetVandal · 24/01/2024 23:28

0nceMoreUntoTheBreach · 24/01/2024 22:16

Is is possible for boys to dress like girls without having to want to be one?

I have been wearing men's clothes for years and nobody bats and eyelid.

People probably have noticed, and not given it a thought, let alone say anything to you - why would they? I have younger male cousins who've worn narrow jeans and polo shirts designed for women 🤷‍♀️
If however you were to wear something from the men's department that was designed for a 6.5 foot, broad shouldered bloke, you would look ridiculous. In the same way a 6.5 foot broad shouldered bloke looks ridiculous in hot pants and a tank top.

Its perfectly reasonable to want to rip up the rule book on all this stuff, but it would seem the majority don't want to. The majority are happy with the differences. Personally I like how my husband looks in clothes cut for a man, and he does too. Its just about aesthetics (and a little bit of fashion); reasons that are really quite dull and unremarkable.

Calliopespa · 24/01/2024 23:09

AnneValentine · 24/01/2024 22:50

Define male?

She clearly means in this context without question around their gender. What does a definition help with exactly?

OldCrone · 24/01/2024 22:55

Pre the radical grooming of children in this area, you might have the odd trans kid, but the radical surge in this movement certainly isn't a coincidence.

There are no trans kids. It's all down to grooming. Trans kids were invented as a human shield for men who discovered their inner woman later in life, usually in middle age after marrying a woman and fathering her children. In order for the rest of the world not to see these men as a joke or as perverts or fetishists, they needed to be able to point at children and say 'look, I was just like that as a child', because people are obviously sympathetic towards a confused child.

Middle aged men with AGP are nothing like these confused children who are being fed gender bullshit online and even at school. And it's disgusting that these men are getting away with encouraging children down a path leading to sterility and poor health, just to protect those men from criticism of their chosen lifestyle.

AnneValentine · 24/01/2024 22:50

Name5 · 24/01/2024 19:15

@AnneValentine i wasn't suggesting ND people are all dragged into this. My Nephew is ASD and absolutely male. Ditto my ASD great nephew.
I am trying not to scare the OP but this is a very difficult situation to be in. I don't want to derail the thread but I would suggest reading other MN threads on trans children.

Define male?

IdleAnimations · 24/01/2024 22:42

0nceMoreUntoTheBreach · 24/01/2024 22:16

Is is possible for boys to dress like girls without having to want to be one?

I have been wearing men's clothes for years and nobody bats and eyelid.

Same, mens hoodies, jumpers and t shirts are far more comfortable IMO especially if you don’t want form fitting clothes.

I can’t stand how regressive all this is. Men used to wear tights and heels, in some countries men wear robes, kilts in Scotland etc. I thought we’d really come far when you looked at how boundaries were pushed in the 80/90s especially in music and media.

Clothes have no gender unless made for a certain body part eg a bra for breasts (yes I know men can wear them but they’re predominantly made for females, especially useful for pain management when growing breasts or nursing) and certain boxers/briefs to keep male genitalia in place which again could be considered comfort/pain management.

0nceMoreUntoTheBreach · 24/01/2024 22:16

Is is possible for boys to dress like girls without having to want to be one?

I have been wearing men's clothes for years and nobody bats and eyelid.

PollyPut · 24/01/2024 21:50

He's at primary school. I'd say makeup and hair extensions are out purely for that reason alone. If he wants to grow his hair, let him.

SidewaysOtter · 24/01/2024 21:46

BusyMummyWrites01 · 24/01/2024 21:07

Utter rubbish. In 2023, 320 trans people died globally - most of them were black, and a large number were sexworkers and reports suggest that their deaths were due to those factors not their trans status.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamiewareham/2023/11/13/beaten-stabbed-and-shot-320-trans-people-murdered-in-2023/?sh=417108461646

In fact, more people are killed each year by being trampled by Rhinos or elephants.

In an ideal world, a little boy should be able to wear a dress without it being a loaded act. Clothes should not be gendered and the fact that they are is cultural - the OPs son, for example, could live in many other countries of the world and very acceptably wear skirts/dresses (Greek and Turkish national dress, Japanese robes, etc). It would be easy to simply buy him some of these for messing about in at home. However, as OP has already commented, she probably needs to explore why her DS perceives being a girl/female is an easier option with an impartial therapist (and there are loads out there).

Against an average of 66,000 woman killed globally each year.

(Source: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Femicide )

DeeLusional · 24/01/2024 21:27

BusyMummyWrites01 · 24/01/2024 21:07

Utter rubbish. In 2023, 320 trans people died globally - most of them were black, and a large number were sexworkers and reports suggest that their deaths were due to those factors not their trans status.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamiewareham/2023/11/13/beaten-stabbed-and-shot-320-trans-people-murdered-in-2023/?sh=417108461646

In fact, more people are killed each year by being trampled by Rhinos or elephants.

In an ideal world, a little boy should be able to wear a dress without it being a loaded act. Clothes should not be gendered and the fact that they are is cultural - the OPs son, for example, could live in many other countries of the world and very acceptably wear skirts/dresses (Greek and Turkish national dress, Japanese robes, etc). It would be easy to simply buy him some of these for messing about in at home. However, as OP has already commented, she probably needs to explore why her DS perceives being a girl/female is an easier option with an impartial therapist (and there are loads out there).

Kilts. you missed kilts 😊

BusyMummyWrites01 · 24/01/2024 21:07

Lexblip · 24/01/2024 11:16

I am going to keep this short if you do not support your child you will not have a son you will not have a daughter you will have no one. The best case is they run away but more likely they will join one of the 400 or so trans people to die per year. start by doing the little things like using her correct pronouns. help her find gender-affirming healthcare fyi puberty blockers are 100% reversible and HRT is extremely reusable puberty is not and I have to live with the damage from going through male puberty for the rest of my life. FYI I have specialist mental health training for gender diverse people I am also a trans MTF myself.

Utter rubbish. In 2023, 320 trans people died globally - most of them were black, and a large number were sexworkers and reports suggest that their deaths were due to those factors not their trans status.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamiewareham/2023/11/13/beaten-stabbed-and-shot-320-trans-people-murdered-in-2023/?sh=417108461646

In fact, more people are killed each year by being trampled by Rhinos or elephants.

In an ideal world, a little boy should be able to wear a dress without it being a loaded act. Clothes should not be gendered and the fact that they are is cultural - the OPs son, for example, could live in many other countries of the world and very acceptably wear skirts/dresses (Greek and Turkish national dress, Japanese robes, etc). It would be easy to simply buy him some of these for messing about in at home. However, as OP has already commented, she probably needs to explore why her DS perceives being a girl/female is an easier option with an impartial therapist (and there are loads out there).

Beaten, Stabbed And Shot: 320 Trans People Killed In 2023 - New Monitoring Report

The vast majority of those killed (94%) were trans women. The Trans Murder Monitoring report also found most victims were black and many were sex workers.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamiewareham/2023/11/13/beaten-stabbed-and-shot-320-trans-people-murdered-in-2023/?sh=417108461646

Whoiam · 24/01/2024 21:07

In my boy's class, a mixture of 3-4 year olds, they were reading my shadow is pink. It seems innocent enough, but once I looked into the book, it was about a little boy who wanted to wear a dress. I asked my four year old about the book and his take was 'he wore a dress to school and everyone wanted to be his friends'. Why are 3 and 4 year olds having this seed planted. Why is it hidden under the guise of acceptance when there is a million other books about acceptance which don't promote gender fluidity. Pre the radical grooming of children in this area, you might have the odd trans kid, but the radical surge in this movement certainly isn't a coincidence.

porridgeisbae · 24/01/2024 20:59

Lexblip · 24/01/2024 11:16

I am going to keep this short if you do not support your child you will not have a son you will not have a daughter you will have no one. The best case is they run away but more likely they will join one of the 400 or so trans people to die per year. start by doing the little things like using her correct pronouns. help her find gender-affirming healthcare fyi puberty blockers are 100% reversible and HRT is extremely reusable puberty is not and I have to live with the damage from going through male puberty for the rest of my life. FYI I have specialist mental health training for gender diverse people I am also a trans MTF myself.

Interesting first post. Welcome to Mumsnet. What brings you to the site? Grin

Payfrozen · 24/01/2024 20:34

I've read all OPs posts and most of the others. Just wanted to share what I said to my gender nonconforming, as it turns out, gay DS.

"Gender is a social construct based on stereotypes that are harmful to women and men.
Liking football and short hair does not make you a boy.
Liking dancing and glitter does not make you a girl.
Like what you like.
Wear what you want.
Love who you love.
You cannot be born in the wrong body.
You are perfect as you are."

We tried to embrace flamboyant because that suited my DS's interests. Lots of examples - Harry Styles, Joe Lycett. Plenty of frilly blouses, sparkly t shirts and fur coats in the menswear and womenswear sections.

When my kids were born I never expected to need to have goals of getting them to adulthood able to experience sexual pleasure and fertile.

I think your DS may not be being misogynistic, or at least no more so than anyone else socialised into sexism. He may be scared of changing as people have said and feels unsure about how to be a stereotypical man so feels something is amiss = trans in his mind.

Good luck OP. It’s tough parenting ND older kids.

Mumof2NDers · 24/01/2024 20:23

I’d seek professional advice. Following advice on here for/against allowing him to follow his wishes could be damaging to his MH.

Bpickle1 · 24/01/2024 20:16

maybe don't gender clothing - wearing a dress or nail polish does not a woman make

Prinnymio · 24/01/2024 20:08

its very very common in young people with Asd to be trans or gay or bi or any other sexual preference. a lot of it is because they are already confused about who they are they know they aren't the same as everyone else and once puberty starts its so much worse, there's all these extra hormones and its stressful and a lot of people with Asd find they feel comfortable in the opposite sex or attracted to the same gender. its very common, kids are more accepting of stuff nowadays, how about you have a girly day with your child, discuss what they want the transition to look like how they expect people to act, and look at some clothes and makeup, if you prevent it it'll just happen behind your back anyways kids get sneaky especially when they feel suppressed.

DonnaBanana · 24/01/2024 20:08

Putting the trans stuff to one side, there is no dressing "like a girl" or "like a boy." Unless something actually requires genitals to operate, it is unisex, and plenty of men wear skirts (see Scotland) and plenty of women wear trousers. Let him do what he wants.

porridgeisbae · 24/01/2024 20:06

@Cccc412 As a PP says, be very careful because most therapists have had training to be gender affirming. So they will encourage it. I would sound the therapist out about their views on it and if you don't feel comfortable with their responses, change his therapist.

porridgeisbae · 24/01/2024 20:04

HalliwellManor · 24/01/2024 13:51

Completely agree with you,it's as if they purposely plant the seed of doubt into kids heads as to whether they are a boy or a girl!,it's so normalised and dare I say encouraged for kids to question their identity and I bet a pound to a penny if this shit wasn't put in their heads they would never have questioned their 'identity' in the first place!.
The world has gone mad,it really has!

It's even quite recent for most people to have a 'gender identity' at all. 15 years ago or so, people would've had to have the idea explained to them before they knew what the question was. Yes some people thought they were trans but apart from extreme cases of gender dysphoria etc, most people hadn't even thought about their 'gender identity' and didn't know what that was.

Swipe left for the next trending thread