Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Changing the name of an adopted child

62 replies

Lospecesenelrio · 23/01/2024 15:46

It's not about me, but because I am going to adopt my sd, I have been on lots of adoption forums. There's one thread that really caught my attention. 2 white American who adopted a little girl from the DR of the Congo and were complaining that her name was too "exotic" (their word not mine) and wanted to change it. The name is... Prospère!

But what shock me the most is that the child is 9yo. Am I completely oblvious or is this some type of abuse?

OP posts:
Toddlerteaplease · 23/01/2024 17:31

I remember two brothers at school who were adopted and they changed their first names.

Lospecesenelrio · 23/01/2024 17:28

nohopehere · 23/01/2024 17:13

Nothing to do with adoption but ...

A friend is Congolese. Her name is Esperance which is Swahili for Hope. She calls herself Hope in the UK.

A young lad I know has a name that would be perceived to be very Congolese and difficult to pronounce in the UK. It has been shortened to Mo (which are the first two letters of it).

It's a shame not to keep their heritage alive. I think people should be making an effort to pronounce more unusual names!

Esperance is not swahili but French. It is common in -both- Congo to use french adjectives as names.

OP posts:
PicaK · 23/01/2024 17:23

Don't take any adoption advice from Americans. I'd steer clear because it's so different to UK good practice. Glibly denying the children their sense of self and reinforcing a negative opinion of their background is a prime example.

Saytheyhear · 23/01/2024 17:22

In some cultures it's common, particularly for girls to choose their own name from aged 6-9. Whilst their family often names them at birth (often a family name or the same as their mum) children often choose a name that they feel suits them more.
It's not that out of the ordinary for this age group to start using shortened versions of their birth name anyway so, not much difference in name changes.

PicklesAndTequila · 23/01/2024 17:20

I'm adopted at birth, my name was changed, but they kept my first name as a middle name.

nohopehere · 23/01/2024 17:13

Nothing to do with adoption but ...

A friend is Congolese. Her name is Esperance which is Swahili for Hope. She calls herself Hope in the UK.

A young lad I know has a name that would be perceived to be very Congolese and difficult to pronounce in the UK. It has been shortened to Mo (which are the first two letters of it).

It's a shame not to keep their heritage alive. I think people should be making an effort to pronounce more unusual names!

NeedToChangeName · 23/01/2024 17:07

BrieAndChilli · 23/01/2024 17:04

no the original birth name wasnt that unusual i just think they didnt like it. They did adopt my other sister at the same time me and my other sister were adopted and kept hername the same (she was about 6 months old and at the time they split babies away from siblings as easier to adopt so me and my 3 year old sister went to 1 foster home and the baby went to another. They ended up adopting her and then another sister when my birth mother had another one.
They do live in the same city as our birth family but as they didnt change the other sisters name I dont think that was a consideration. This was the 80s though so things were different.

Very interesting, thanks for replying. I hope life turned out well for you all

fightingthedogforadonut · 23/01/2024 17:05

Her name is all she has, poor kid....

NeedToChangeName · 23/01/2024 17:04

Nellieinthebarn · 23/01/2024 16:42

This happened to a friend of mine, and she didn't find out until the day she sat her O levels, (yes it was a long time ago!) and the register had a different christian name on it.

When she questioned the teacher, she was told that this was her official name and that for her exams to count she had to use that name. She told me that she always knew she was adopted, not least because both her parents are white and she describes herself as a bit more than tinted, but to find out they had changed her name was a huge issue. She felt like they had stolen the only thing she had that was hers.

As soon as she was 18 she started to use her original name, and went through a lot of therapy helping her come to terms with her adoption and identity battles.

I thought that this type of thing had gone away a long time ago tbh. And yes, I think it borders on abuse.

@Nellieinthebarn in the past, choosing a new name for an adopted child was common, and marked the child joining the new family. Your friend's parents were wrong to keep it secret though

Now, it's highly unusual, as the name is regarded as an important part of the child's family, and a link to birth family

2024NewyearNewme · 23/01/2024 17:04

Regardless of the child's age, her name is her identity, her parents chose it and gave it to her, I find it disrespectful to change it on adoption.
Your adopting her for who she is. So I suggest keep the name, it's part of her heritage, her lineage, her history.
It seems you think you can polish her up and start fresh. Real adopted humans always long to know who they are and where they are from.

BrieAndChilli · 23/01/2024 17:04

NeedToChangeName · 23/01/2024 16:39

@BrieAndChilli it's unusual to change a name, even for a baby. Was the original name very unusual / identifiable on social media? Or was the baby living very close to birth family?

no the original birth name wasnt that unusual i just think they didnt like it. They did adopt my other sister at the same time me and my other sister were adopted and kept hername the same (she was about 6 months old and at the time they split babies away from siblings as easier to adopt so me and my 3 year old sister went to 1 foster home and the baby went to another. They ended up adopting her and then another sister when my birth mother had another one.
They do live in the same city as our birth family but as they didnt change the other sisters name I dont think that was a consideration. This was the 80s though so things were different.

Delphinium20 · 23/01/2024 17:02

I live in a state which has a higher percentage of white people than other states and still, my kids go to school with children whose names include Sophie, DeMaras, Juan, Ngoc, Sherwa, Finn, Anwar, Sundus, Keelie, Solveig, Boris, Fiana, Houa, D'Shawn etc.

Delphinium20 · 23/01/2024 16:57

I'm an American and frankly, the family who think that name is exotic and she should have an American name seem unAmerican - please don't be offended, but they sound far more British as I notice UK people have a lot of conversations about naming children (is it posh, is it classic, etc.) where here in the US, we assume a name just reflects whatever culture you come from and we have a lot of cultures. If you adopted a child from another country and she's 9 and you decide to rename her an Anglo name like Emma or Katherine, most people would think you were an asshole and a racist.

bimbimbap · 23/01/2024 16:57

I wonder if they’ve considered keeping her name and using a nickname like Perrie

ComtesseDeSpair · 23/01/2024 16:56

mathanxiety · 23/01/2024 16:51

Though actually, adoptions of older children now require the maintenance of contact between the children and their bio parents in the US, so changing names isn't possible, and unless terrible abuse has been proven, contact must be maintained, so the adoptive parents have to stay in the same state as the parents, or even the same area, as a practical choice to avoid long travel times across big states.

This is really interesting. Even if a child has “only” been neglected by their birth parents, I’d have assumed that continued contact would both be a continuation of their trauma and an impediment to them bonding properly with their adoptive parents.

thecatsthecats · 23/01/2024 16:54

Blimey, I wouldn't even change the names of my adopted cats.

mathanxiety · 23/01/2024 16:51

Though actually, adoptions of older children now require the maintenance of contact between the children and their bio parents in the US, so changing names isn't possible, and unless terrible abuse has been proven, contact must be maintained, so the adoptive parents have to stay in the same state as the parents, or even the same area, as a practical choice to avoid long travel times across big states.

mathanxiety · 23/01/2024 16:47

@CountTo10
Yes, the possibility of children being traced by abusers or their extended families can be a good reason to give a new name. I know people who moved to the other end of the US because the children they adopted were spotted by extended family members. Luckily they became aware of an attempt to contact the children.

mathanxiety · 23/01/2024 16:44

Darkenergy · 23/01/2024 15:56

It's indicative of a certain mentality amongst some adopters (particularly in the US I've noticed) that when a child comes to live with you, their past to date can be erased and they can waltz into the sunset in this fairytale new life with you like the first 9 (or however many) years never happened. White saviour syndrome plays a part here too. It is almost never that simple at any age and certainly not at 9 years old.

Sadly, I think this is true.

I've seen it in the community where I live (US) - children from Guatemala given names like Liam and Kevin, children from Russia whose names weren't Anglo enough (Igor, Oleg, Vitaly) all called Alex, and girls whose names were Svetlana, Oksana, or Lyudmila all given names like Elena, Sophia, or Anastasia - names you can find in Russia so preserving a part of the Russian heritage but not the specific name the child came with. To be fair, the adoption process from Russia (adoptions have stopped now) involved the Russian officials erasing the patronymic from the child's paperwork, but still...

This practice was part of the Russian government's objections to adoptions of Russian children (as well as serious and often heinous abuse suffered by many Russian children at the hands of their adoptive parents). It was all part of a very negative picture.

Children from China, Korea, Thailand, and Vietnam are often given their original names as middle names around here.

Nellieinthebarn · 23/01/2024 16:42

This happened to a friend of mine, and she didn't find out until the day she sat her O levels, (yes it was a long time ago!) and the register had a different christian name on it.

When she questioned the teacher, she was told that this was her official name and that for her exams to count she had to use that name. She told me that she always knew she was adopted, not least because both her parents are white and she describes herself as a bit more than tinted, but to find out they had changed her name was a huge issue. She felt like they had stolen the only thing she had that was hers.

As soon as she was 18 she started to use her original name, and went through a lot of therapy helping her come to terms with her adoption and identity battles.

I thought that this type of thing had gone away a long time ago tbh. And yes, I think it borders on abuse.

NeedToChangeName · 23/01/2024 16:39

BrieAndChilli · 23/01/2024 16:15

i was adopted when I was 7 - my name was slightly changed so it now ends in E and not A as original. My sisters name remained the same. We had other sisters who were adopted by other people, one of them was adopted as a new born and her name was changed.

@BrieAndChilli it's unusual to change a name, even for a baby. Was the original name very unusual / identifiable on social media? Or was the baby living very close to birth family?

Summerishere123 · 23/01/2024 16:35

It depends on the circumstances of the adoption. I have heard of people changing names if they are unusual and would identify them to the birth family. They must have a way of communicating with the child or they wouldn't have been able to take them home considering they wouldn't be able to meet her needs.

CountTo10 · 23/01/2024 16:27

I wouldn't say it was abusive but at 9 it's just wrong and unfair. I would also be concerned about the mindset of adoptive parents about accepting and promoting the adoptive daughter cultural heritage. Huge red flag going forward.

A friend of mine was actually a divided to change the name of her adopted new born baby as it was a ridiculous made up name and they thought it would be too easy for family members to possibly track him down before he was 18 and cause problems. Friend did keep it as a middle name (birth mother had requested adoption at birth. It wasn't forced) as she felt it fair to the birth mother as she had choosen it made it up for her son very bravely gave him up for a better life.

ComtesseDeSpair · 23/01/2024 16:15

Lospecesenelrio · 23/01/2024 16:10

@ComtesseDeSpair The child is not a baby. Does not speak English. It sounds quite abusive to me. So, once you're adopted you say Sayonara to your entire past? Prosperité is hardly an unknown word, the English equivalent is nearly identic. I could understand changing it to Prosperity.

Is it Prospère or Prosperité? Depending on where in the US they live, the latter could be quite challenging for pronunciation integration wise. A small town in e.g. Montana is very different to NYC.

Equally, they presumably know more about the child’s background than they’ve chosen to share on SM. Prospère / Prosperité could simply be a name given by an orphanage rather than the name the child has always had.

BrieAndChilli · 23/01/2024 16:15

i was adopted when I was 7 - my name was slightly changed so it now ends in E and not A as original. My sisters name remained the same. We had other sisters who were adopted by other people, one of them was adopted as a new born and her name was changed.