Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?

561 replies

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 12:59

My child is in year 8 and in their school
has “Humanities” which is history and geography combined rather than taught separately- not great in my view but ok. However, this year they are being taught by a music teacher. No doubt a very talented musician but according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography.

I do understand there are teacher shortages and sometimes some teachers will have to cover for others but this seems to be a permanent arrangement at least for this year.

Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?

Grateful for advice from anyone who knows the law / regulations here as want to approach the school about it and want to be clear what’s reasonable to expect and what they should in fact be doing according to govt policy.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 18:17

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 18:13

I don’t know what your point is. What couldn’t also work in England? What do you mean by low standards?
Sounds like you possibly have no idea how state schools struggle to meet timetable demands and make sure that all classes have a teacher.

It could work that every child is timetabled to be taught - for each subject - by a teacher who is both:

a) educated to degree level in that subject
b) a fully qualified teacher

”low standards” mean anything other than the above.

The answer, of course, is paying teachers more.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/01/2024 18:16

ThanksItHasPockets · 23/01/2024 23:07

Independent schools are leaving the teachers’ pension scheme in their droves, making the remuneration package much less appealing. The independent sector is rapidly losing its cushion against the national staffing crisis.

A few of my friends have recently moved to teaching in the independent sector, and their pay is much higher than the state sector for comparable experience (think about M6/UPS1 for a science teacher who might only be on M2/3 in a state school). At the moment, around here, private schools are recruiting successfully by offering higher pay, but at some point increasing that pay further will likely become unsustainable OR it will have to be passed on to parents via higher fees. In science, as well, they offer the chance to only teach your specialism e.g. teacher of chemistry, not teacher of science, which is quite appealing to some people.

I agree that leaving TPS instantly makes a school less attractive to teachers (especially experienced teachers with a lot of contributions, as well).

I still know of a few private schools who are really struggling to attract science teachers- especially physics teachers. It's nowhere near as bad as for state schools around here, but I do know of a private school who simply couldn't recruit for a maternity cover recently. It's a popular school, and I would have thought someone would have gone for it as a "foot in the door" type thing, but perhaps given wider economic uncertainty, people are reluctant to give up permanent posts?

Mere1 · 24/01/2024 18:15

Maths and science at GCSE and A level require a specialist teacher, as do all subjects at that level. These subjects aren’t more difficult than others.

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 18:13

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 18:08

My point is that there is no reason why it couldn’t also work in England. Don’t accept low standards.

I don’t know what your point is. What couldn’t also work in England? What do you mean by low standards?
Sounds like you possibly have no idea how state schools struggle to meet timetable demands and make sure that all classes have a teacher.

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 18:08

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 18:06

Well, obviously I was talking about England.

My point is that there is no reason why it couldn’t also work in England. Don’t accept low standards.

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 18:06

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 17:59

Except it does; just not in England apparently.

Well, obviously I was talking about England.

Casperroonie · 24/01/2024 18:04

Welcome to the recruitment crisis. Teachers will always rather teach their subjects but can be forced into teaching just about anything else as no-one else is around to do so. If steps were taken to lessen workload and have less abuse towards teachers perhaps this could change. Until then.....

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 18:01

CantFindMyMarbles · 24/01/2024 17:54

You can have all the qualifications in the world but it doesn’t make you good or efficient in that area

No, it doesn’t.

Meeting the bare minimum entry requirements for teacher training doesn’t make you a good teacher.

However, that doesn’t mean we just erode standards. Keep standards high; pay teachers accordingly; and then you stop the recruitment and retention crisis.

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 17:59

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 17:55

It simply does not work like this in state schools. I’ve had 40+ years of experience in teaching. I have ‘helped out’ in subjects that I am only qualified to O Level. I have taught History, RE and French to Year 7 and 8 and I had to learn the content then teach it.
Fortunately, I have the brains and confidence to manage. This is the norm in state schools which are struggling to recruit.
Your insistence on a teacher having at least A level in the subject is laughable to be honest. You have no idea how schools struggle to keep things afloat.

Except it does; just not in England apparently.

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 17:56

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 17:55

It simply does not work like this in state schools. I’ve had 40+ years of experience in teaching. I have ‘helped out’ in subjects that I am only qualified to O Level. I have taught History, RE and French to Year 7 and 8 and I had to learn the content then teach it.
Fortunately, I have the brains and confidence to manage. This is the norm in state schools which are struggling to recruit.
Your insistence on a teacher having at least A level in the subject is laughable to be honest. You have no idea how schools struggle to keep things afloat.

Sorry - …your insistence on a teacher having a degree… ( not A level)

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 17:55

It simply does not work like this in state schools. I’ve had 40+ years of experience in teaching. I have ‘helped out’ in subjects that I am only qualified to O Level. I have taught History, RE and French to Year 7 and 8 and I had to learn the content then teach it.
Fortunately, I have the brains and confidence to manage. This is the norm in state schools which are struggling to recruit.
Your insistence on a teacher having at least A level in the subject is laughable to be honest. You have no idea how schools struggle to keep things afloat.

CantFindMyMarbles · 24/01/2024 17:54

You can have all the qualifications in the world but it doesn’t make you good or efficient in that area

Island35 · 24/01/2024 17:46

Just about summed up my teaching career. I qualified as a secondary music teacher and then you are a pot of hours. There wasn't enough music so I taught English and media too.
Moving on I taught outreach in primary and a special school then took over a post 16 careers programme. Moved school to teach just music and now work in a primary special school.

The teacher would have been provided schemes of work and will need to plan their lessons. We are expected to teach outside of our first subject area

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 17:40

CaptainMyCaptain · 24/01/2024 17:23

When I left school in 1973 you needed English and Maths O levels to do any teacher training course.

In Scotland you need higher English and standard grade/n5 maths to be accepted.

A higher is like an A level and a standard grade/n5 is an o level/gcse; I believe

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 17:38

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 24/01/2024 17:02

As a teacher myself (primary trained, now working in a secondary), I completely agree that there should be a teacher who is an 'expert' in the subject teaching it, and I live and work in Scotland where this simply wouldn't be allowed.

How do you not allow it if you cannot recruit a teacher though? What could the school do, other than put a non-subject specialist in front of the class?

It’s a completely different system here.

We have far fewer private schools because we have Catholic and non denominational state schools. We also don’t have selective state schools. So the assumption is that most kids will go to a school run by the local authority.
In many local authorities; you apply for the supply list, or permanent cover pool. Supply work is almost always within your own subject and you could be offered anywhere in the local authority.Permanent cover means you are paid a normal teachers salary but can be moved school to cover in event of a longer absence/maternity cover/vacancy.

Many local authorities can fill roles only using their own staffing banks.

I did permanent supply for a while.

You are simply not allowed to be timetabled to teach a class without being qualified to do so.

Teaching in Scotland is significantly less awful than I’d imagine teaching in England is; we are far better paid too so there isn’t the same recruitment crisis. It’s seen as a profession, and fairly well respected.

CaptainMyCaptain · 24/01/2024 17:23

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 16:10

@Sooz817 I take the point about English but why does a History teacher need GCSE (O level for us oldies) in math(s)?

When I left school in 1973 you needed English and Maths O levels to do any teacher training course.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 24/01/2024 17:02

As a teacher myself (primary trained, now working in a secondary), I completely agree that there should be a teacher who is an 'expert' in the subject teaching it, and I live and work in Scotland where this simply wouldn't be allowed.

How do you not allow it if you cannot recruit a teacher though? What could the school do, other than put a non-subject specialist in front of the class?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 24/01/2024 16:46

Power point clicking is bad teaching. Passive learning.

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 16:22

MummyLK · 24/01/2024 14:57

As a teacher myself (primary trained, now working in a secondary), I completely agree that there should be a teacher who is an 'expert' in the subject teaching it, and I live and work in Scotland where this simply wouldn't be allowed. On the point of history and geography being taught together, I'm okay with. In Scotland in the first few years of secondary school, they're called social subjects and are all taught together. The different disciplines all interlink pretty closely and, if taught by a subject teacher, being taught together could increase understanding of the subject 🙂

Scottish geography teacher here.

I do not teach anything other than geography; and that is my hill to die on. It’s most certainly not the norm to do it the way your schools do - normally; classes do a 6/8 week block of each of the three social subjects, taught by a subject specialist, and then rotate to the next.
An alternative model is to do one period per week of each subject (again, taught by a subject specialist) all year.
Some schools do what we call “single teacher delivery” - there is two models for this. The first one is when they complete something like an IDL project - for example, maybe on climate change - with elements of all the subjects included. However, when doing this, subject specialists would still plan and assess their own subject area. Alternatively (and this is absolutely the worst option!) They do a unit of each subject - I only know one school who do this in our area.

Speak to any humanities/social subject teacher and they will ALL agree that single subject delivery is far, far better. Especially for geographers - geography is the least literacy based of the subjects; and many history and modern studies teachers really struggle to teach the geographical skills effectively.

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 16:12

Stressedoutforever · 24/01/2024 10:06

Yes I could and do- it's mostly just PowerPoint clicking! A good teacher can stand in front of a class and teach (that's why we all do cover..)

I have an economics degree but teach maths, only up to GCSE as we don't have a sixth form. I'm due to return from maternity leave soon and since September my classes have all been taught by whoever is avaliable. One class of year 7s has 5 different teachers over the two week timetable including PE, art and science but not a single maths teacher.

If you are just PowerPoint clicking then you aren’t a good teacher.

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 16:10

@Sooz817 I take the point about English but why does a History teacher need GCSE (O level for us oldies) in math(s)?

Sooz817 · 24/01/2024 16:05

There is a teacher shortage, it is likely the case that your child is being taught my a few teachers without degrees in the subject.

there are no rules at all about teachers teaching outside of their specialism, once a teacher is qualified and has QTS that they can be directed to teach whatever subjects the school want them to (whether the teacher likes it or not)

You might also be shocked to learn that there are a huge number of unqualified teachers working in schools who have not yet completed teacher training, and even quite a few teaching who don’t have a degree at all and are still working towards those.

It isn’t unusual in schools to have TAs teaching (some of whom may not even hold GCSEs in English and Math)

the recruitment and retention crisis in schools is so hugely underestimated by the public because it isn’t widely reported on. I urge people to remember this at the polls later this year…..

Aidyl5891 · 24/01/2024 16:03

I expect the poor teacher is a) doing their absolute best and b) doesn't want to be teaching a subject that isn't their specialism but has no choice. All the lesson plans and resources will have been created by a subject specialist.

twoshedsjackson · 24/01/2024 15:52

Filling timetables can be a desperate business; a friend of mine, Music graduate hired to teach Music, found himself picking up parts of the RE timetable as well, on the tenuous grounds that he was also a church organist (Christianity by osmosis, I guess, hence knowledgeable about world faiths in general......)
I once bluffed my way through covering a lesson (primary but private sector) when the specialist teacher of Mandarin required cover - but I was a familiar face to the pupils at least.

Skodacool · 24/01/2024 15:35

There are no requirements for subject degrees. I did supply teaching and, to be quite honest, if you had ‘o’ level in a subject you could manage. What’s more important is the ability and enthusiasm of the teacher.