Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?

561 replies

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 12:59

My child is in year 8 and in their school
has “Humanities” which is history and geography combined rather than taught separately- not great in my view but ok. However, this year they are being taught by a music teacher. No doubt a very talented musician but according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography.

I do understand there are teacher shortages and sometimes some teachers will have to cover for others but this seems to be a permanent arrangement at least for this year.

Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?

Grateful for advice from anyone who knows the law / regulations here as want to approach the school about it and want to be clear what’s reasonable to expect and what they should in fact be doing according to govt policy.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Zonder · 24/01/2024 19:55

I'd want the teacher to have a degree to teach at A level. Up to GCSE I would be happy if they had an A level in it.

CaptainMyCaptain · 24/01/2024 19:54

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 17:38

It’s a completely different system here.

We have far fewer private schools because we have Catholic and non denominational state schools. We also don’t have selective state schools. So the assumption is that most kids will go to a school run by the local authority.
In many local authorities; you apply for the supply list, or permanent cover pool. Supply work is almost always within your own subject and you could be offered anywhere in the local authority.Permanent cover means you are paid a normal teachers salary but can be moved school to cover in event of a longer absence/maternity cover/vacancy.

Many local authorities can fill roles only using their own staffing banks.

I did permanent supply for a while.

You are simply not allowed to be timetabled to teach a class without being qualified to do so.

Teaching in Scotland is significantly less awful than I’d imagine teaching in England is; we are far better paid too so there isn’t the same recruitment crisis. It’s seen as a profession, and fairly well respected.

I believe you. I know of teachers from England who have moved to Scotland because of the better conditions.

DisabledDemon · 24/01/2024 19:35

You are not being unreasonable to want your child's teacher to have a degree in the subject they teach - in an ideal world, we would all probably like that. However, as others have stated, it is unreasonable to expect every teacher to have the relevant degree because of the chronic shortage of teachers.

This is a situation that has been developing for years and there are many factors that have contributed to it. It certainly true that in a great many cases, teaching is a thankless job (sometimes dangerous, often ridiculed), not well paid for the hours required, and often suffers from lack of support from the SLT or parents. Don't even mention OFSTED.

Before I became a teacher, I worked as a Cover Supervisor (I have a degree in English Literature) and could find myself covering absolutely anything from French to PE - and I certainly wasn't qualified to help anyone with Maths! There were so many absences, some because of training courses but most because of illness, that I got to see some classes more often than their actual teachers.

NorthernGirlie · 24/01/2024 19:33

I don't have a degree in my subject - my degree is in Primary Education (so I have QTS) I teach a GCSE subject and have done for 2 decades.

My students get excellent results, I get excellent observations. Nobody would know I don't have a degree in the subject if I didn't tell them!

Wisenotboring · 24/01/2024 19:32

This is what it's like unfortunately. Not everywhere, not all the time but too often. Teaching isn't valued, the workload is illness inducing under the regime of some heads and the pay is mediocre for the level of education and hours put in. Schools will be focusing their best and most qualified staff on core subjects and exam groups. I just want to cry at what we are doing to young people with how we educate them. Also for the teachers who are holding the system together. This is not what a life enhancing, inspirational and positive school experience is meant to look like.

Crackoncrackerjack · 24/01/2024 19:29

I don’t even have a GCSE in a subject I’ve taught for 25 years

pollymere · 24/01/2024 19:27

Oh and it annoyed me greatly that our Head of English didn't have a degree in English so I do feel your pain!

pollymere · 24/01/2024 19:26

Many music and PE teachers will have trained in another subject because they don't have enough students to fill a full timetable. It's possible that the music teacher is also a trained history teacher. Where I've worked ours have taught various other subjects including Maths and English.

MystyLuna · 24/01/2024 19:03

No you do not have to have a degree in a particular subject in order to teach that subject.
I did a 4 year bachelor of education degree. I am qualified to teach all ages and all subjects from 4 to 16 but I had to chose a particular age group and subject to specialise in.
I specialised in maths so at secondary school level I would be more like to get a job teaching maths but I am not limited to just maths.
During my 4 year degree I only had 3 lessons on how to teach geography but would still be expected to be able to teach it.

Fjruejejrnrnrbbbbb · 24/01/2024 18:56

It’s a fact that many teachers don’t make it to the 5 year mark. I worked with a guy who left for a job at Aldi head office… it’s disgraceful that teachers aren’t supported in what could be a lifelong career, especially since the majority of them really love teaching and really love kids. The profession is in a sorry state and it’s the kids who suffer the most.

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 18:56

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 18:49

Yes - not sure why you have so many question marks after the words “land mass” - do you want me to explain what it means?
Yes, Scotland has a different system. A better one. One England could do too; if it chose to properly invest in education.

It is sad that standards have dropped so far that you don’t think teachers being paid more would allow better better candidates to be recruited.

Says a lot about your country and it’s priorities if you don’t think that is possible. Why is it not possible?

Oh, bore off. I’ve had enough of you now. PLEASE don’t reply.

Notateacheranymore · 24/01/2024 18:55

Look at my username.

I was a secondary Science teacher, and left the profession 10 years ago last month. You couldn’t get me to go back into teaching now for a HT salary much less a classroom teacher.

The school I spent most of my career at employed me to do art for a year to start with. I’m left handed and I can’t even draw a good looking flower similar to what a toddler or Reception class child might draw. But I was a living breathing body. And that was enough for them, even back in 2000.

twistyizzy · 24/01/2024 18:52

Hetty2507 · 24/01/2024 18:49

Ha good luck 😂 even private schools don't have specialist teachers anymore. Big recruitment crisis if you haven't heard.

They do at DDs school. Every teacher is a subject specialist with QTS.

celticprincess · 24/01/2024 18:51

So In some schools they hire specialists who aren’t qualified teachers. I know quite a few musicians who teach music in schools. They don’t have a teaching degree but do have a music degree or grades in music and music theory. Usually primary but sometimes secondary too.

At my daughter’s school the music teacher has taught reading lessons and also food tech. I’m guessing some subjects in some schools are hard to get people to apply for so they make do with someone who at least has an interest and can follow a scheme. I think her drama teacher also taught computing.

Hetty2507 · 24/01/2024 18:49

Ha good luck 😂 even private schools don't have specialist teachers anymore. Big recruitment crisis if you haven't heard.

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 18:49

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 18:43

Land mass?? FFS. You make a point then throw in stuff about Scotland which has a different system. No, it’s not in the least SAD that I think it’s cloud cuckoo stuff to expect it to be the same in England.

Yes - not sure why you have so many question marks after the words “land mass” - do you want me to explain what it means?
Yes, Scotland has a different system. A better one. One England could do too; if it chose to properly invest in education.

It is sad that standards have dropped so far that you don’t think teachers being paid more would allow better better candidates to be recruited.

Says a lot about your country and it’s priorities if you don’t think that is possible. Why is it not possible?

Runnerduck34 · 24/01/2024 18:48

For GCSE / Alevel I think it's really important for a teacher to have a degree or specialise in their subject.
Years 7 and 8 I think its much better if they are subject specific teachers as they will hopefully have enthusiasm for what they are teaching which will engage children more.
Does your school have specific history and geography teachers for exam years?

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 18:43

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 18:23

It really isn’t. In Scotland; spend per pupil is 18% more than in England.
A teacher earns £48.5k within 5 years.
We don’t have a retention crisis.
We don’t have a recruitment crisis.
All children are taught by a subject specialist.
It is really sad that you think this is cloud cuckoo land stuff. It’s not. It’s happening on the same land mass as you.

Edited

Land mass?? FFS. You make a point then throw in stuff about Scotland which has a different system. No, it’s not in the least SAD that I think it’s cloud cuckoo stuff to expect it to be the same in England.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/01/2024 18:36

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 18:20

Cloud cuckoo land.

To be fair, it's not so long ago in England that this was at least somewhat the norm.

I went to school in the 00s, and in my secondary school I had:

-Specialist subject teachers for KS3 and KS4, tbf I don't know what their degrees were, but every subject was taught by someone who specialised in that subject.
-At KS4, I had a biology, chemistry and a physics specialist teaching me throughout my GCSEs.
-If maternity cover was needed, the school was able to recruit a teacher with knowledge and experience of that subject.

My school was a "bog standard" comp, not an especially desirable place to work.

The school itself hasn't changed, but I work in the same area now, and (like most schools locally) the school struggles to fill vacancies, and can't offer subject specialists in lots of areas.

So what's changed?

-House prices have increased faster than wages. A family with a teacher as a higher earner would now struggle to afford a house in that town/area/
-More teachers leaving due to excessive workload and stress
-Teaching is a less attractive career as wages have been eroded.
-Apparently, at that school in particular (but at many schools, to be honest) behaviour has deteriorated massively.

If society could fix even one of these things, it would help- and I don't believe that's impossible.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/01/2024 18:26

CharlotteBog · 24/01/2024 10:31

I don't know why, but this made me a bit tearful. My son's school experience (like so many others) has been such a mess.
Year 6 was hard lockdown - so no end of Primary school things and hideous remote learning (primary schools really were not set up for this), no residential etc.
Year 7 was spent socially distancing with masks in school. Year 8 was partly the same. No football, no enjoyable lunches and playtimes.
Year 9 was spent reading how wonderful it was that the school was fully open and how the new yr 7s and 8s could do all the fun stuff.
Strikes meant only the exam year students went in. Year 9s stayed at home.
I was hopeful things would improve in yr 10; that the resources would be directed towards yr10 and yr11.
He has had one trip since year 5 - a day at Thorpe Park.

He is happy enough at school, but education wise, he is disengaged with so many subjects. Supply teachers come in and tell them to 'get on with your work' or 'do page 7-11 in your work book' ie there is no actual teaching.
The correlation in his effort, behaviour and attainment between subjects with stable subject teachers and those with a string of supply teachers is very, very clear.

I do not blame the school or the teachers.

Sorry, I didn't mean to upset you! Although in many ways the state of education in England is upsetting!

I think up until very recently, schools tried their very best to protect exam year groups and give them opportunities. I know schools who partially redid their timetables to ensure every student got specialist teachers for e.g. science and maths in Y10 and 11. But then they still couldn't recruit enough staff, and it's got to the point where even exam year groups can't be protected enough.

If a science teacher leaves mid year around here, it's pretty much accepted you can't replace them until the following September- which means potentially two full terms of supply for some students.

Trips are really difficult- I'd love our students to get more trips BUT if I take my Y10s on a trip, I know my Y11s or 13s will be left essentially to self teach- and I worry I can't afford to miss too many days with them. There's also the issue of paying for coaches- the school can't afford this (we are in deficit this year) so we have to charge parents, but a lot of parents can't afford to pay either. Because it's a rural school, we also have the pressure of getting back for the busses which limits where we go.

We do run a trip for Y10 in the summer term, after our exam groups have left, so maybe he will get more chances then?

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 18:23

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 18:20

Cloud cuckoo land.

It really isn’t. In Scotland; spend per pupil is 18% more than in England.
A teacher earns £48.5k within 5 years.
We don’t have a retention crisis.
We don’t have a recruitment crisis.
All children are taught by a subject specialist.
It is really sad that you think this is cloud cuckoo land stuff. It’s not. It’s happening on the same land mass as you.

ilovechocolate07 · 24/01/2024 18:21

In an ideal world they'd have a degree. When I trained you could teach it if you had an a level in the subject but now they're so thin on the ground. I'm not sure how schools are still running. My child told me their maths teacher who isn't a lead boasted that they're on more than 60k so I'm guessing they're paying to keep people on as a friend of mine was head of department in another area and on nowhere near this salary. I'm primary trained but exiting and no amount of money would be enough for me to teach secondary from what I hear from my own children. It sounds dire

Ilovecleaning · 24/01/2024 18:20

0rangeCrush · 24/01/2024 18:17

It could work that every child is timetabled to be taught - for each subject - by a teacher who is both:

a) educated to degree level in that subject
b) a fully qualified teacher

”low standards” mean anything other than the above.

The answer, of course, is paying teachers more.

Cloud cuckoo land.

Usernamechange1234 · 24/01/2024 18:19

I agree! But speak to the government and their absolutely rubbish response to the crisis of teacher retention and recruitment!

TBH you’re lucky they’re a qualified teacher!

JussathoB · 24/01/2024 18:18

@C1N1C it really depends on the subject, and the level you would be teaching at. However most schools would be concerned about whether you know what you are getting into. The PGCE or other teacher training involves getting familiar with ideas about how to teach children of different abilities and experience of managing different classes and behaviour. If you haven’t had any of this they would certainly expect you to demonstrate you have experience of working with children/young people etc.
Ask yourself whether a 13 year old whose parents don’t care about education and who ‘hates’ science would be very interested in your PHD in Physics. For example.