Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?

561 replies

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 12:59

My child is in year 8 and in their school
has “Humanities” which is history and geography combined rather than taught separately- not great in my view but ok. However, this year they are being taught by a music teacher. No doubt a very talented musician but according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography.

I do understand there are teacher shortages and sometimes some teachers will have to cover for others but this seems to be a permanent arrangement at least for this year.

Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?

Grateful for advice from anyone who knows the law / regulations here as want to approach the school about it and want to be clear what’s reasonable to expect and what they should in fact be doing according to govt policy.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
noblegiraffe · 26/01/2024 20:55

henrysugar12 · 26/01/2024 20:18

^
Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?^

If it's an academy then the teachers don't need to be qualified at all!

And you don't need to have a degree in the subject to train in it either. If you have a totally unrelated degree but say, maths A-level, you can do a subject knowledge enhancement course and train to be a maths teacher.

Zonder · 26/01/2024 20:54

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 18:31

Yep, I’m only passionate about the subject I did a degree in. I enjoyed English, biology and psychology too.
The others I did merely to get the qualifications I needed to do the course I wanted to do.
This is the case for many, many kids. They have to pick x amount of subjects; they probably choose their favourite subject(s); a few they like; and then the rest are whatever ones they hate the least. It would be very unusual for someone to be “passionate” about multiple of their school subjects.
Let’s not pretend that anything taught in school is anything other than basic knowledge. It’s not until uni that you really scratch the surface. Often (in geography in Scotland anyway) the difficulty is the exact same at N5 as it is at Higher; there is just far more of it.
If you don’t need a degree in the relevant subject; why do you need a degree at all?

You need a degree to show that you're educated to a certain level. It is also needed for teaching A level in a subject so that again you have studied further than your students in the subject.

So you studied subjects you weren't passionate about. What if someone has a degree in a subject but isn't passionate about it - they just did it to get a qualification? Does that mean they shouldn't teach it either?

Viamar · 26/01/2024 20:44

Teaching involves skills that are not subject specific. Teachers have a degree in education.

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 20:32

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 20:27

Well, yes. Given that the whole context of this post is about whether teachers should have a degree which is relevant to the subject they teach. Additionally; my earlier post stated that I would want my child to be taught by someone with a passion for the subject they are teaching, rather than something that they just fall into, and studying something at the age of 16 does not signify a “passion”

Thank you for that clarification.

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 20:27

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 20:14

It is possible to be “passionate” about anything; I guess. However, we were speaking in terms of using your passion to teach others.

Were we? You gave me a definition of ‘passion’ as ‘The definition of passion (in reference to hobbies and interests) is “feeling so excited by a hobby or interest that you devote hours of your free time to it”’. I responded within the terms of your definition and I think I was very clear that I claim no expertise to be able to teach the domains that I mentioned.

Well, yes. Given that the whole context of this post is about whether teachers should have a degree which is relevant to the subject they teach. Additionally; my earlier post stated that I would want my child to be taught by someone with a passion for the subject they are teaching, rather than something that they just fall into, and studying something at the age of 16 does not signify a “passion”

henrysugar12 · 26/01/2024 20:18

^
Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?^

If it's an academy then the teachers don't need to be qualified at all!

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 20:14

It is possible to be “passionate” about anything; I guess. However, we were speaking in terms of using your passion to teach others.

Were we? You gave me a definition of ‘passion’ as ‘The definition of passion (in reference to hobbies and interests) is “feeling so excited by a hobby or interest that you devote hours of your free time to it”’. I responded within the terms of your definition and I think I was very clear that I claim no expertise to be able to teach the domains that I mentioned.

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 20:07

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 19:23

We can only claim to be passionate about massive topics if we have mastered them fully? Is it not possible to be passionate about an art form as a consumer rather than a practitioner? Do you therefore claim to have full mastery of the entire field of geography in all its forms, physical and human, as a science and as a humanity? You should probably be on the telly if so.

I am not sure what competition you think you are in but it seems very important to you that you win it.

It is possible to be “passionate” about anything; I guess. However, we were speaking in terms of using your passion to teach others. I am pretty interested in music, in that I attend live music shows several times a month and listen to music for hours each day at home. However; this would not give me adequate mastery to teach it. I also wouldn’t say it was a “passion” since I know little about it; I just enjoy it! In no way could I teach others. I’d suggest your stance on music may be similar to mine?

Obviously I have not “mastered” geography - and I could not successfully teach most areas of geography. Which is exactly my point - if I can’t do it; as someone with a first class honours with distinction in the discipline; then it would be very surprising if a music teacher who isn’t even interested enough to choose it as their degree was able to.

Now obviously I know the school curriculum inside out. But I teach geography up to advanced higher level; which is the equivalent of first year of university.

Point in hand; I think your degree should be related to the subject you teach, rather than something you learned about when you were 16.

Im not even saying it has to be the exact same; it doesn’t need to be the exact same in Scotland either. For example; you can probably teach maths with an economics degree. I can actually teach biology too; kind of by accident as I did part of a biochemistry degree before my geography degree; and then there were enough credits in the rest of my geography degree (like marine ecosystems). However; I’d be pretty shit at it as I have no passion in it.

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 19:23

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 19:15

No, you claimed “passion” for them. You also stated that you actually can only speak a few languages; and can’t really perform music or create art.

Let me guess; you think that geography is just naming places on maps; don’t you?

We can only claim to be passionate about massive topics if we have mastered them fully? Is it not possible to be passionate about an art form as a consumer rather than a practitioner? Do you therefore claim to have full mastery of the entire field of geography in all its forms, physical and human, as a science and as a humanity? You should probably be on the telly if so.

I am not sure what competition you think you are in but it seems very important to you that you win it.

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 19:15

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 19:09

You think that geography as a subject is broader than combining the entire history of the world, all textile and fibre arts, the entire canon of music and visual arts and all extinct and extant human languages? (Obviously I am not claiming expertise in all these, only interest).

No, you claimed “passion” for them. You also stated that you actually can only speak a few languages; and can’t really perform music or create art.

Let me guess; you think that geography is just naming places on maps; don’t you?

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 19:09

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 19:03

There is quite a lot of crossover between those subjects though - geography as a subject is probably broader than all of those interests combined.

You think that geography as a subject is broader than combining the entire history of the world, all textile and fibre arts, the entire canon of music and visual arts and all extinct and extant human languages? (Obviously I am not claiming expertise in all these, only interest).

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 19:03

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 19:00

Probably about four or five, in addition to my specialism in English language and literature.

Languages - I speak a couple and make sure they don’t go rusty
Textiles
History
Music and art - albeit only as an enthusiastic consumer rather than as a practitioner!

There is quite a lot of crossover between those subjects though - geography as a subject is probably broader than all of those interests combined.

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 19:00

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 18:55

No it isn’t.

I have lots of other interests and passions; just not things that I studied at school.

The definition of passion (in reference to hobbies and interests) is “feeling so excited by a hobby or interest that you devote hours of your free time to it” - how many subjects which you studied at school are you “passionate” about?

Probably about four or five, in addition to my specialism in English language and literature.

Languages - I speak a couple and make sure they don’t go rusty
Textiles
History
Music and art - albeit only as an enthusiastic consumer rather than as a practitioner!

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 18:55

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 18:43

Yep, I’m only passionate about the subject I did a degree in.

That’s a shame.

No it isn’t.

I have lots of other interests and passions; just not things that I studied at school.

The definition of passion (in reference to hobbies and interests) is “feeling so excited by a hobby or interest that you devote hours of your free time to it” - how many subjects which you studied at school are you “passionate” about?

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 18:43

Yep, I’m only passionate about the subject I did a degree in.

That’s a shame.

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 18:31

Zonder · 26/01/2024 17:58

Are you only passionate about the subject you did a degree in? I have other subjects I'm also very interested in and would be happy to teach.

Having an A level is deeper knowledge than GCSE!

Yep, I’m only passionate about the subject I did a degree in. I enjoyed English, biology and psychology too.
The others I did merely to get the qualifications I needed to do the course I wanted to do.
This is the case for many, many kids. They have to pick x amount of subjects; they probably choose their favourite subject(s); a few they like; and then the rest are whatever ones they hate the least. It would be very unusual for someone to be “passionate” about multiple of their school subjects.
Let’s not pretend that anything taught in school is anything other than basic knowledge. It’s not until uni that you really scratch the surface. Often (in geography in Scotland anyway) the difficulty is the exact same at N5 as it is at Higher; there is just far more of it.
If you don’t need a degree in the relevant subject; why do you need a degree at all?

Zonder · 26/01/2024 17:58

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 17:08

They absolutely will not.

I want my kid taught by someone who is passionate enough to study the subject at university, for starters. I don’t want someone to teach my kid who hasn’t even learned within the subject themselves beyond high school level.

You also need a deeper knowledge of something to be able to explain it effectively.

It’s just so alien to anyone outside England that this would even be a possibility.

Pay teachers properly and then you can get people who actually like the subject to teach it. Wild.

Are you only passionate about the subject you did a degree in? I have other subjects I'm also very interested in and would be happy to teach.

Having an A level is deeper knowledge than GCSE!

DrFosterWentToGloucester23 · 26/01/2024 17:26

Apart from my PGCE in Secondary English, my highest qualification in the subject is two A grades at A level. I’ve been teaching English in state secondary schools for over 15 years now - GCSE and A Level - and students regularly get the highest grades.

I wouldn’t do it if I felt I wasn’t good at it. I don’t feel students are being let down by having me as their teacher in any way and it has never been mentioned by any HoD I’ve ever had.

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 17:11

MistressIggi · 26/01/2024 15:00

When I read stuff like this I'm so glad I work in (and my children are educated in) Scotland, where university credits are expected in a subject for exam level teaching.
I got an A-level in Maths back in the 80s, would you think it was ok for me to teach that now?

Apparently I can now teach Maths, English, Chemistry, Biology, Geography, Psychology, and Home Economics. Oh, and I think I technically could teach computing too - I got a D for that.

Haha that is genuinely terrifying. Poor children. I hate most of those subjects, with the exception of maybe English and biology - I’m most certainly not good enough to teach them though; but apparently if I move to England I can.

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 17:08

Zonder · 26/01/2024 14:47

And someone with Geography A level will have more than enough knowledge to teach geography GCSE.

They absolutely will not.

I want my kid taught by someone who is passionate enough to study the subject at university, for starters. I don’t want someone to teach my kid who hasn’t even learned within the subject themselves beyond high school level.

You also need a deeper knowledge of something to be able to explain it effectively.

It’s just so alien to anyone outside England that this would even be a possibility.

Pay teachers properly and then you can get people who actually like the subject to teach it. Wild.

MistressIggi · 26/01/2024 15:00

Zonder · 26/01/2024 14:47

And someone with Geography A level will have more than enough knowledge to teach geography GCSE.

When I read stuff like this I'm so glad I work in (and my children are educated in) Scotland, where university credits are expected in a subject for exam level teaching.
I got an A-level in Maths back in the 80s, would you think it was ok for me to teach that now?

Zonder · 26/01/2024 14:47

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 14:02

A geography teacher will (most likely) have a decent understanding of maths, as often geography degrees require you to study statistics.

A maths degree is unlikely to cover something like soil profiling.

And someone with Geography A level will have more than enough knowledge to teach geography GCSE.

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 14:02

Zonder · 26/01/2024 07:44

You really don't. My neighbour just had very positive comments from Ofsted about her teaching of maths. Her degree was in Geography. She has maths A level. You don't need more than A level to teach KS3 or KS4.

A geography teacher will (most likely) have a decent understanding of maths, as often geography degrees require you to study statistics.

A maths degree is unlikely to cover something like soil profiling.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 26/01/2024 12:49

Workworkandmoreworknow · 26/01/2024 10:43

stick me in a room with a bunch of kids and a bunch of instruments and look at the work that has been left for me - the kids have to design a poster

one very real issue some kids face is a day full of supply teachers and a day full of poster designing.

I used to be an art/Dt teacher. This used to drive me fucking mental.

’Design a poster about the murder of Thomas a Beckett’

🤮.

Workworkandmoreworknow · 26/01/2024 10:43

stick me in a room with a bunch of kids and a bunch of instruments and look at the work that has been left for me - the kids have to design a poster

one very real issue some kids face is a day full of supply teachers and a day full of poster designing.